TE
TechEcho
Home24h TopNewestBestAskShowJobs
GitHubTwitter
Home

TechEcho

A tech news platform built with Next.js, providing global tech news and discussions.

GitHubTwitter

Home

HomeNewestBestAskShowJobs

Resources

HackerNews APIOriginal HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 TechEcho. All rights reserved.

Ask HN: What is it with this hate and disdain for interns/junior engineers?

23 pointsby colesantiago7 months ago
Some examples of this that I have seen so often:<p>No openings for interns or junior engineers, yet the companies and people I talk with, the senior engineers get sick often, lack drive and take longer PTO and their work isn&#x27;t really that adequate.<p>Blaming interns or junior engineers for simple mistakes, which the senior which also should have seen.<p>Not training interns or junior engineers to become senior and be given more responsibility, I&#x27;m assuming we are all aware of the bus factor here.<p>All the while where some really smart interns or junior engineers come out of prestigious institutions (Oxford, Cambridge, MIT, Stanford, Harvard, etc), with a stunning body of work and can absolutely run rings around engineers that are called &#x27;senior&#x27; in title only and don&#x27;t have a body of work to show when they leave.<p>It is no wonder senior engineers are finding the job market tough now, but it is obviously even worse for juniors, and all the above doesn&#x27;t help.<p>Of course, everyone is different, but I don&#x27;t get the obsession with not giving very bright and talented juniors a chance even though they are more likely to be cheaper than seniors.<p>Background: I am a senior engineering manager looking to take on interns.

15 comments

Etheryte7 months ago
I can&#x27;t help but feel you&#x27;re missing the elephant in the room: this isn&#x27;t about hating interns, it&#x27;s about money. Hiring an intern, even without any pay, costs a company money because it means other people are coaching the intern and thus producing less output than they would be otherwise. Right now there is little money going around in the market so companies have less space to take on interns. When money is cheaper again, expect to see more openings like that.
评论 #41822863 未加载
redprince7 months ago
&gt; lack drive and take longer PTO and their work isn&#x27;t really that adequate.<p>People sometimes come to realize important things when they mature. This may include insights like &quot;there&#x27;s a life happening outside work waiting to be lived&quot;. Or acquiring a better sense where it pays to spend time and energy for maximum effect and where it is wasted.<p>&gt; Blaming interns or junior engineers for simple mistakes, which the senior which also should have seen.<p>Juniors making simple mistakes really doesn&#x27;t rhyme with the rest of what you said. Are they<p>a) Brilliant people, able to replace seniors while being paid a pittance for working their ass off?<p>or<p>b) Actually inexperienced and still have to learn a lot until their output has the required quality?<p>&gt; Not training interns or junior engineers to become senior and be given more responsibility<p>Any junior waiting to be taken by the hand and shown the path to greatness through careful and detailed tutoring by colleagues I can recommend only one thing: Learn to learn by yourself. Fast. Your colleagues are busy with their own work and tutoring you very often has very little bearing on their current goals, compensation or career prospects. It is thus one of these areas where they have learned not to spend much time and energy. (Though some people have strong altruistic tendencies and&#x2F;or find it satisfying to mentor and teach, but that&#x27;s an intrinsic motivation which is either there or it isn&#x27;t. When you run into someone like that: Lucky you!)<p>On a more calculating note: As you have let on that you think juniors are viable replacements for senior while being cheaper, the seniors might not be very motivated to bring their replacements up to speed...<p>&gt; we are all aware of the bus factor here<p>As an employee, that&#x27;s generally not much of a concern.<p>&gt; All the while where some really smart interns or junior engineers come out of prestigious institutions<p>I suggest you attempt to hire them. I wish you the best of luck!<p>&gt; I am a senior engineering manager looking to take on interns.<p>Do it. It&#x27;s going to be a valuable learning opportunity for everyone involved. Including you.
themattmatters7 months ago
Blaming junior engineers and interns is bad engineering culture. I&#x27;m sorry if that&#x27;s the case you are experiencing.<p>As for the stigma against junior engineers, from my personal experience in mostly early start ups programming boot camps really poisoned the well. A lot of us were flooded with very poor candidates that had really flashy portfolios and a ton of marketing and generally some favorable contacts and vcs promoting them. Most of them were terrible, often with extremely little passion for their craft.<p>There were obviously exceptions and I&#x27;ve worked with one that was phenomenal, but the whole schooling systems pitch to me was that it onboarded capable people that just needed an intro to the tech and systems, when in reality most were just folks with money trying to buy their way quickly into an industry that was desperate for more manpower.
dangcompetent7 months ago
Six years ago you were a student applying for your first job and now you&#x27;re a &quot;senior engineering manager&quot;? You barely have enough experience to be a senior engineer. What a joke. Nice post.
评论 #41823296 未加载
forrestthewoods7 months ago
I’ve not personally witnessed a hatred of juniors. But the market is flooded with solid senior talent that it’s put the squeeze on junior roles. Which has some very bad long term consequences.<p>Mentoring and leveling up juniors is expensive and time consuming. And you really need to build a team and work environment that supports them. When teams are under the gun to deliver it’s a very easy thing to drop the ball on.
charles_f7 months ago
I&#x27;m sorry for these bad experiences. I don&#x27;t think I have seen these myself, it&#x27;s either that I have been lucky, or an issue with culture where you are.<p>There is definitely a trend where people get titles because of their age rather than talent, motivation or passion (it&#x27;s what I call having 20y experience vs. having 20x 1y of experience).<p>I don&#x27;t think juniors are all rosy either. There&#x27;s a percentage of bad people in any profession, that as I feel it is relatively stable over the years.<p>When it comes to disdain, I don&#x27;t know what you experienced so its hard to answer in a specific wat. One thing I have verified is that shit rolls down: The higher you are in the hierarchy, the easiest it is to just pass on the stuff you don&#x27;t want to handle or the blame downward. Likely, in larger organizations where politics matter more for your career than skills or accomplishments, it is more important to show yourself up than being helpful down. It&#x27;s kind of like when you&#x27;re in line: you only see other people&#x27;s back. For sure that can fill like disdain, because it is, but I would think it&#x27;s not necessarily targeted at juniors, but more of a &quot;normal&quot; up to down relationship in places that evolved so, where people in power have little incentive to change the game that got them where they are. Best is to stay away from these, unless you are either good at or enjoy this game.<p>So my advice would be that it&#x27;s probably local to where you work, and to find somewhere that isn&#x27;t like that.
Taek7 months ago
I run a startup, we&#x27;re moving fast and growing fast. If you aren&#x27;t already one of the best in the world, we don&#x27;t have time to train you up or guide you.<p>We are all swamped with work, and the team moves together well because we can all depend on our teammates to get things done at a world class level.<p>No space or time for juniors. Stakes are too high.
评论 #41823172 未加载
评论 #41822965 未加载
评论 #41823363 未加载
t8sr7 months ago
You hire juniors on potential, seniors to fix a gap. Right now, 90% of hiring is focused on plugging gaps in the next 6 months - that&#x27;s just where we are in the cycle.<p>As to why we&#x27;re here, I think it&#x27;s obvious at this point that tech massively overhired between 2016 and 2022.<p>Finally, the growth areas haven&#x27;t completely disappeared, they&#x27;ve just shifted. If you&#x27;re a junior right now, you should be getting into ML or something, not webdev. Plenty of entry level roles in ML.
jacknews7 months ago
It sounds like you have a dim view of your seniors.<p>Why not fire them before they leave anyway, and replace them with your cheaper smarter harder-working juniors?
svilen_dobrev7 months ago
you know, in 2014 i did mentor 10 people (newbies, either from college, or switching professions) into software domain, in Ericsson&#x2F;Ireland, for few months. It was great fun, and they are all seniors now - about half still in Ericsson.<p>BUT.. ever since then i have been looking for another gig like that, to no avail.<p>Esp. recently, it seems the &quot;new&quot; idea is that programmers grow on trees anyway. Go figure..
评论 #41823332 未加载
评论 #41823275 未加载
评论 #41823218 未加载
__turbobrew__7 months ago
A lot of times junior engineer positions are simply stepping stones to better positions at other companies. Junior engineers take a lot more time and investment before they become positive EV for the team. In tech especially people job hop frequently, which means that the average EV for a junior engineer can be very low or even negative.
wg07 months ago
Why would it be flagged? Yes I have not seen any junior positions in a long while TBH.<p>Isn&#x27;t it a fair question?
评论 #41824091 未加载
sirspacey7 months ago
I’ve learned that in a job interview if you are too impressive relative to the team they don’t hire you. Seems no one wants to hire their replacement.<p>Starting your own business is hard, but it is the next best option if you haven’t found the right place to work.
评论 #41822761 未加载
评论 #41822692 未加载
评论 #41822757 未加载
评论 #41822845 未加载
perrygeo7 months ago
I haven&#x27;t seen any hatred or disdain for juniors per se, but I&#x27;ve definitely heard flat out &quot;We&#x27;re not interested in hiring any juniors&quot;. Or the juniors that are hired are tossed in the deep end and expected to perform on par with a mature team. The subtext is their business&#x2F;tech is so complex that they can&#x27;t afford to train someone. It&#x27;s incredibly short-sighted and unsustainable but lots of managers don&#x27;t care about investing anything for the long term.
tuckerpo7 months ago
&gt; All the while where some really smart interns or junior engineers come out of prestigious institutions (Oxford, Cambridge, MIT, Stanford, Harvard, etc), with a stunning body of work and can absolutely run rings around engineers that are called &#x27;senior&#x27; in title only and don&#x27;t have a body of work to show when they leave.<p>I&#x27;ve hired interns and juniors at my past three positions, from various educational backgrounds including ivy leagues and ivy-adjacent schools (UCLA, CMU, for instance) over the course of the last ~5 years, and I&#x27;ll give an opposing anecdote.<p>A lot of people who attend elite institutions are able to do so because they&#x27;ve been groomed from a very young age to have a given trajectory in life. Their entire existence and sense of self-worth seem to be predicted by &quot;prestige&quot; and being better than someone else.<p>This typically translates into someone who is very difficult to work with, especially when it comes to interns.<p>The &quot;I&#x27;m clearly better than you because I attend $school&quot; attitude, typically coupled with real-world industry naiveté leads to a real &quot;I&#x27;m gonna change the world because I&#x27;m so special&quot; Spongebob-esque archetype of person. Insufferable to work with, impossible to manage, always off spinning their wheels on something not at all aligned to what the business really needs. Ignore direction, ignore technical architecture, because they assume they know better.<p>I&#x27;ve also found that they don&#x27;t really care all that much about their internships, because in their mind&#x27;s eye, they&#x27;re the &quot;main character&quot; and they&#x27;re surely going to move on to something great because they&#x27;ll be a $school alumnus.<p>They also tend to not be particularly well-rounded individuals. No hobbies, varying degrees of social ineptitude, anti-social competitive behaviors due to where they attend school.<p>I really could not care less about a &quot;body of work&quot;, I care that you have some aptitude, passion, and are bearable to be around for &gt;= 40 hours&#x2F;week.<p>I get your point about senior engineers, a lot of people tend to mentally clock out and settle into their ways, no longer wanting to go above and beyond, typically because they have families, friends, hobbies, and no longer want to participate in a game where there are no winners.<p>But a clocked-out senior engineer who does the bare minimum, but understands how the business works will still be an order of magnitude more valuable than some $school intern.<p>&gt; Of course, everyone is different, but I don&#x27;t get the obsession with not giving very bright and talented juniors a chance even though they are more likely to be cheaper than seniors.<p>Unless you&#x27;re working at some cutting-edge startup, businesses don&#x27;t value merit, really, they care that you understand process, business needs, and the quickest path to execution to ensure continuous revenue.<p>Interns can be great, or horrendous, and I&#x27;ve personally found there to be an inverse correlation to how good the school they attended is to how useful they actually are in real industry terms. It&#x27;s simply a trial period for both parties with the ideal outcome being they become a full-time hire once they finish their degree.<p>When money is tight, as it is now, there&#x27;s simply no point in taking on individuals who will effectively be a burden for potentially months before delivering any real value.<p>Regarding your bus factor comment, businesses hedge that senior+ engineers will not be willing to shoulder the risk of job hopping in a shoddy economy, so there&#x27;s really no concern from that angle of needing to &quot;backfill&quot; with junior engineers who will grow.<p>This will all get better when money begins flowing more freely again. Just a function of time.
评论 #41824534 未加载