TE
TechEcho
Home24h TopNewestBestAskShowJobs
GitHubTwitter
Home

TechEcho

A tech news platform built with Next.js, providing global tech news and discussions.

GitHubTwitter

Home

HomeNewestBestAskShowJobs

Resources

HackerNews APIOriginal HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 TechEcho. All rights reserved.

Rural residents' DIY 1Gbps fibre project

69 pointsby zantzingeralmost 13 years ago
A community in Lancashire, England, has taken it upon themselves to dig, lay and build a complete 1 Gbps FTTH network. Members of the community have been able to buy shares to finance the project, and then they've mucked in to carry out all the leg-work themselves, with farmers digging trenches and other locals installing the technology. I find it very inspiring: especially given I live in London and still can't get FTTH. Business plan, videos and info on their website: http://b4rn.org.uk<p>EDIT: title changed from "...DIY Google Fiber project" to "...DIY 1Gbps fibre project"

18 comments

nemilaralmost 13 years ago
This may actually be much easier in a rural area, as opposed to urban/suburban.<p>Rural landowners have large tracts of land, and the land is in fewer hands. You need less individuals to buy-in, since a single buy-in on the project can mean miles of line.<p>You don't need a jackhammer to dig up sidewalks and streets, and you (presumably) don't need as many (if any) permits; you don't need to take as much care not to disrupt existing utilities, and you don't need to worry so much about noise and other regulations.
评论 #4347414 未加载
评论 #4341651 未加载
kallebooalmost 13 years ago
Communities like this were a factor in accelerating the broadband buildout in Sweden as well.<p>Here, when we broke up the telco monopoly, instead of splitting it up regionally (like AT&#38;T), they were split into roles. So after the splitup, the ownership of all the POTS copper and related infrastructure (buildings, backhaul etc) ended up as a separate entity[0] who had to treat everyone the same and couldn't favor a single telco.<p>Come DSL. To get DSL, this company obviously has to upgrade the local switches for DSLAM operations, and for this operation they would charge the first telco to request a DSL connection for the upgrade. In the DSL buildout rush at the turn of the century, the big telcos obviously focused on densely populated areas. So people who lived on switches that were too small to be attractive to any big telco would start up a coop like this to save up to pay for the upgrade themselves, and there were several small broadband operators who would take care of the technical, broadband-providing bit. And once your switch was upgraded, suddenly you could get your pick of any of the DSL providers.<p>There were/are also a ton of small, local wireless providers who use directional antennas to service people who live too far away from a DSLAM.<p>[0] <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Skanova" rel="nofollow">http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Skanova</a>
Hoffalmost 13 years ago
B4RN is using burial, which is a great approach for reducing long-term maintenance, but the extra costs of burial may or may not work in other localities.<p>Burying wires in gravel, or burying below the usual furrow depths in farmer's fields is fairly easy, and trenchers are commonly available. (And if you bury your wires outside of the growing season, you won't disrupt the farming.)<p>In an area of the US that I'm familiar with, the granite ledge and glacial erratics (big rocks) would make burial problematic. Nearly all electric and telecommunications distribution wiring is accordingly overhead; on poles. With the problems that brings; ice storms, trees, etc.<p>Rural distribution does have some advantages in terms of not digging up existing infrastructure, and the ability to easily trench connections across the gravel-surface roads, but the cabling distances are usually (much) longer, and the numbers of and densities of houses and potential subscribers are (much) lower than in urban areas.<p>This means that the survival economics of the installation are fully in play; how many subscribers you'll gather, and how much to join, and how much to maintain the (overhead) wiring. This is why many rural areas of the US will tend to have DSL broadband, at best. DSL is cheap(er), and it uses the existing copper.<p>As with the rural electrification and rural telephone efforts that preceded this in the US, the stumbling block for rural broadband is the (large) installation costs; they're not a financially viable undertaking for commercial entities.<p>Incumbent telcos are seeing their business go to cellular, and wireline subscribers are dropping. Some of the telcos have been in and out of bankruptcy. Because of the budgets and the wireline subscriber trends, incumbent telcos also aren't inclined to install wiring ahead of a requirement; dark fiber isn't commonly installed during repairs in this area.<p>Yes, you might hope to see some of the incumbents build out broadband as a way to stay relevant. But in rural areas, that build-out involves greater distances and lower (potential) customer densities, and with higher on-going maintenance costs. And around we go...
评论 #4342347 未加载
EliRiversalmost 13 years ago
Here in the U.S., the local monopoly would have had the law changed to make this illegal :)
评论 #4342102 未加载
评论 #4341801 未加载
sdoeringalmost 13 years ago
What I really like about projects like this is the fact, that local communities organize themselves and get things done, that the bigger entities are not able to tackle.<p>The more I read about such endeavors and the more I think about it, I believe, that local communities in a connected world have more power than<p>a; they thought for a long time, due to the fact, that a lot of things are decided far away. b; a lot of bigger players would like them to have.<p>They might not be as "efficient" or as "moneymaking" but that might be actually a good thing.<p>For example, building this network underground is much more resilient, than on poles. But I also believe, that the bigger players, will try to enforce their role, as such initiatives get more common.<p>The same might happen, as power generation becomes much less centralized or as food production (hopefully) returns to a much more local situation.<p>I really hope to see more such initiatives, not only in Britain, or Europe, but on planet-scale.
geuisalmost 13 years ago
Interesting project, thanks for sharing.<p>The link, <a href="http://b4rn.org.uk" rel="nofollow">http://b4rn.org.uk</a>, should have been directly used when submitting this.<p>This is not digg, nor slashdot, nor reddit. A description of, or commentary about, what you are submitting is not required, as the content should speak for itself.
vitnoalmost 13 years ago
How is this "Google Fiber"? Can't we just call it fiber?<p>edit: title changed, thanks!
评论 #4341339 未加载
johnoharaalmost 13 years ago
I applaud the effort but not the method.<p>The last video on their website shows the trenching, laying and backfill operation. IMO, it's better to lay a 2" or 4" continuous PVC pipe between the access points rather than lay the outdoor fiber directly into the trench.<p>It's better for protection, diagnostics, additional capacity, and if needed, other types of cable (twisted pair, coax) can be run alongside.<p>I think what they are doing is great, but seeing the workers walking all over the fiber while backfilling the trench made me shiver. Isolating and repairing a break is going to be difficult downstream.
评论 #4342886 未加载
kbobalmost 13 years ago
There is some financial trickery going on here. It's buried in Section 6.1.3 of the business plan (pp 23-24).<p>Any resident who invests £1500 or more can nominate a property for free connection and one year's free service. The tax authority gives a tax credit of 30% of that £1500, and the investment can be sold back in year 4 (2016?) at full value.<p>So, pay £1500 (or more) in 2012, get £450 in 2012 tax credit, then sell for £1500 in 2016. That's a 9.2% ROI plus free Gigabit Internet service. Of course, there's risk involved, just like any startup investment.
morphlealmost 13 years ago
We run a couple of startups like B4RN, one in the US, one in Europe en one in South America. We build our own 10 GBps routers.<p>Come join us, we have room for extra founders. info at buurtnet dot org
评论 #4341653 未加载
jiggy2011almost 13 years ago
As someone who grew up in a rural part of the UK, I can empathise with how annoying it is to be limited to a 56k connection with daily timed limits (usually around 3 hours or so) to be connected when all of your city dwelling friends have 1mbps broadband.<p>I wonder if this is as much to do with property values as anything? It must be very difficult to sell a house with no option of fast internet and the modern internet must be basically unusable on 56k.
评论 #4341608 未加载
评论 #4342045 未加载
walrus0almost 13 years ago
If you go active ethernet, not GPON/EPON...<p>This is now particularly economical for two reasons, aside from the cost of the fiber to the home itself (either aerial or buried, which is going to cost more for labor/bucket trucks/trenching than for the fiber itself). Why?<p>1) Inexpensive good quality 24-port 1U switches from Taiwan (Planet.com.tw) with 24 1000Mbps SFP ports, 10gigE uplink.<p>2) Inexpensive $65 1000BaseLX SFPs<p>3) CPE routers like the Mikrotik RB2011Ls which have a SFP port.
alt_almost 13 years ago
I helped build a couple in Finland back in 2003. The lack of bureaucracy and city infrastructure in rural areas likely helped, but the driving force was my uncle - a CS professor/farmer who retired from teaching and had to find something else to occupy his time ;)
webmonkeyukalmost 13 years ago
This is a great initiative. I wonder if there are any plans to bridge sections with WiMax or similar and/or break out from 1G fibre to Copper GigE or wifi in population points to reduce the client-side install and equipment cost.
评论 #4342331 未加载
cheezalmost 13 years ago
Haha, I just got a picture of "There Will Be Blood" 1Gbps version :)
JoshTriplettalmost 13 years ago
One notable thing I don't see mentioned anywhere on the site: where do they plan to get their upstream bandwidth from, and for how much?
评论 #4342364 未加载
评论 #4342383 未加载
ommunistalmost 13 years ago
Thnk you for sharing. The business plan is a very eloquent document, that helps.
cyberdoylealmost 13 years ago
Power to the People!