TE
TechEcho
Home24h TopNewestBestAskShowJobs
GitHubTwitter
Home

TechEcho

A tech news platform built with Next.js, providing global tech news and discussions.

GitHubTwitter

Home

HomeNewestBestAskShowJobs

Resources

HackerNews APIOriginal HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 TechEcho. All rights reserved.

Why are (male) surgeons still addressed as Mr? (2000)

24 pointsby Tomteabout 14 hours ago

4 comments

OJFordabout 13 hours ago
Seems strange it talks about &#x27;university doctorate: an MD&#x27; when in the UK the vast majority of physicians do <i>not</i> hold doctorates, the qualification is variously MBBS or BMBS - bachelor of medicine and also of surgery - undergraduate degrees.<p>I&#x27;d be surprised if that&#x27;s a more recent change (but I don&#x27;t know it&#x27;s not) but even so you&#x27;d think it would warrant clarifying when you&#x27;re discussing the history of doctor&#x2F;surgeon titles and qualifications.<p>Also apparently published with the typo &#x27;Universy [sic] of Aberdeen&#x27;.
Tsiklonabout 12 hours ago
This article also fails to discuss the historical links between Barbers and Surgeons. In the UK they had their own worshipful company together before the doctors pressured the surgeons to split.
FrostKiwiabout 5 hours ago
AFAIK, in Switzerland you can carry the Dr. title after completing medical school and (relatively) small additional thesis, whereas in Germany you need a full academic dissertation to be able to carry a Dr. title, easily adding a couple of years.<p>It&#x27;s wild how different rules are from country to country, considering historically big pushes for standardization like the bologna process.
ProllyInfamousabout 11 hours ago
TL;DR: it&#x27;s a relic of the 19th century, when the two professions were largely distinct.<p>Today: it&#x27;s a flex by the &quot;gunners&quot; to somehow distinguish themselves as <i>better</i> than &quot;lesser&quot; physicians. A similar thing occurs in the US, it&#x27;s just that some physicians, in addition to a preceding &quot;Dr.&quot;, follow their names with <i>even more letters&#x2F;affiliations</i>.<p>I only attended one year of a US medical school, but the surgeons were <i>at a whole &#x27;nother level (in this competitive exercise of perseverance)</i>...