TE
TechEcho
Home24h TopNewestBestAskShowJobs
GitHubTwitter
Home

TechEcho

A tech news platform built with Next.js, providing global tech news and discussions.

GitHubTwitter

Home

HomeNewestBestAskShowJobs

Resources

HackerNews APIOriginal HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 TechEcho. All rights reserved.

Wingman: Git + GitHub + OS X

126 pointsby basilover 12 years ago

24 comments

hemancusoover 12 years ago
I'm shocked that an indie Mac app that isn't in the app store is trying to get away with selling a $29 license that has no free trial. To Github developers, of all people. Shenanigans.<p>It'd be one thing if you had an awesome video whereby I could see in this in action. Or tons of awesome reviews from people I respect. Hell, I would pay $5 to try it out.<p>But you want me to pay $30 bucks in hopes that this doesn't suck? There is too much competition in this market to even attempt this. This developer is shooting themselves in the foot.
评论 #4777287 未加载
评论 #4776679 未加载
评论 #4777343 未加载
knowtheoryover 12 years ago
This seems like a cool idea but i'm bewildered by one thing. Why is this a menu item? And does it have hotkeys?<p>Because, for better or worse, my menu bar is essentially full, and I save and manipulate my code and repositories via my keyboard, not my mouse (well that's mostly true. I still browse my git repos using GitX).<p>The workflow ideas seem worth trying, but the interface isn't something I can get with (although i will cop to not having any good ideas on how to improve this. I wonder what a quicksilver-like workflow would be like).
评论 #4775993 未加载
评论 #4775754 未加载
评论 #4776673 未加载
评论 #4776293 未加载
TheTaytayover 12 years ago
Really surprised to see people balk at $29 for a software productivity tool. I mean, I get it if it's not worth it for you, but I happily paid a similar amount for SourceTree (before it was free ;) ), and pay similar amounts for all sorts of development tools. It doesn't take much productivity gain for these sorts of tools to pay for themselves quickly. This is the sort of thing that a dev lead might buy for his team to teach/enforce the git-flow workflow quickly and easily.<p>We happen to use Mercurial around here, so that was my biggest turnoff, but the rest of the value proposition made plenty of sense to me: Solve one problem. Solve it well. Charge real money.<p>I wish these guys success. :)
评论 #4780637 未加载
Hilyinover 12 years ago
I suggest moving your imagery over to a CDN. Chrome network tab clocked your site at taking 30 seconds to load all the images. (I am on a 100mbit connection)
评论 #4775664 未加载
评论 #4775739 未加载
评论 #4775702 未加载
评论 #4775671 未加载
ainsleybover 12 years ago
Seems awesome - like a GUI for git-flow.<p>What is the pricing for this? Seems there's a free download at the top, but the bottom says "Buy for $29.99". Might want to make the pricing structure clearer. :)
评论 #4775810 未加载
harlanlewisover 12 years ago
I'd love to try this, but I'm uncomfortable entering my github username and password - shouldn't apps like this be using oauth instead of basic authentication?<p>Also, the sign in button appears disabled until you actually purchase it (I assume it's not just a bug), which makes the prominent Download link on their site with mostly hidden mention of pricing feel pretty shifty. Behavior like this doesn't instill confidence or trust.
评论 #4776158 未加载
mbustamanteover 12 years ago
SourceTree has something similar: a GUI for git-flow. Mac has the best tools for git and in linux i can't find something with the quality of SourceTree.<p>link: <a href="http://blog.sourcetreeapp.com/2012/08/01/smart-branching-with-sourcetree-and-git-flow/" rel="nofollow">http://blog.sourcetreeapp.com/2012/08/01/smart-branching-wit...</a>
jonpaulover 12 years ago
I'm truly intrigued and curious... my startup Gitpilot (<a href="http://gitpilot.com/" rel="nofollow">http://gitpilot.com/</a>) is trying to solve a similar problem. Was Wingman conceived from any inspiration of Gitpilot? Truly curious, especially because of the airplane naming scheme.
评论 #4776252 未加载
_frogover 12 years ago
Command + Return probably isn't the best key combination for this. Most source code editors on OS X use that key combination to insert a new line below the current one regardless of cursor position.
teddyknoxover 12 years ago
Downloaded it. Ran it. Entered my github credentials... and the login button is disabled.<p>hm.
评论 #4776038 未加载
评论 #4775921 未加载
duanebover 12 years ago
No way I'm dropping $30 without trying it first, especially if it is not on the app store. This isn't exactly a 99 cent flashlight app.
louischatriotover 12 years ago
The page what this brings me on top of Git+Github. Is it just a GUI around Git to avoid having to learn the ~5 everyday commands?
nodesocketover 12 years ago
So I was ready to buy Wingman, but then paused and thought. Why isn't this on the App Store? Am I really going to use it? I am all for productivity tools, and honestly willing to pay for anything that makes my life easier, but I think I just need a trial of Wingman, just to make sure it is what I am envisioning.
tirantover 12 years ago
Alienating developers from git? What's next, hiding them the source code? I do not really see the point of this app.
desireco42over 12 years ago
So this is graphical representation of gitflow... and tied to github... it sounds cool, I am a little suspicious how many people will really need this. From angry comments I see this is not tied to appstore, kudos for that, hope more devs would do it like this.
pdenyaover 12 years ago
Does this work with git-flow already? I wouldn't switch away from an existing git based workflow for this but I'll consider it for future projects.
klrrover 12 years ago
I'm not into these stuff, but this might be an alternative: <a href="http://codejournalapp.com/" rel="nofollow">http://codejournalapp.com/</a>
BillSaysThisover 12 years ago
For all the comments about no trial version, they cover this at the bottom of the page by saying they'll gladly refund if you're unsatisfied.
dmakover 12 years ago
1) I use CMD + Enter for Alfred 2) How is this faster than just going into command line? 3) $30? I'll just stick with command line.
评论 #4777712 未加载
twodayslateover 12 years ago
This looks cool. Is there any similar software for Windows?
shennygover 12 years ago
Are there settings for a --no-ff merge?
cenanozenover 12 years ago
29$ ruined it for me
评论 #4775987 未加载
supercoderover 12 years ago
Ugh, github. No thanks.
btillyover 12 years ago
Tip.<p>A lot of people will see the name and have the response that I did. Which is that this is likely to be an app that aims to help sleazy pickup artists out.<p>Like it or not that is the immediate association that people have with "wingman".
评论 #4776296 未加载
评论 #4776147 未加载
评论 #4777093 未加载
评论 #4777103 未加载