TE
TechEcho
Home24h TopNewestBestAskShowJobs
GitHubTwitter
Home

TechEcho

A tech news platform built with Next.js, providing global tech news and discussions.

GitHubTwitter

Home

HomeNewestBestAskShowJobs

Resources

HackerNews APIOriginal HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 TechEcho. All rights reserved.

New Official Facebook Poke iOS Application

67 pointsby remiover 12 years ago

15 comments

gkobergerover 12 years ago
SnapChat cloning aside...<p>I know I'm probably in the minority here, but I really like Facebook's decision to create multiple apps. We aren't good with thinking of apps as having multiple functionalities. Our thought process is more along the lines of "This app is for this, this app is for this, etc."<p>Having one app means a lot of features get lost in the app, and people turn to alternative apps (like Foursquare, Batch or WeChat) for functionality.<p>Edit: To put it another way, what if Google had one app and inside it was GMail, Search, Maps, etc? Facebook sees these as products, not features.
评论 #4954474 未加载
评论 #4954512 未加载
评论 #4954658 未加载
评论 #4954473 未加载
评论 #4954899 未加载
untogover 12 years ago
The level to which this is a clone of Snapchat is kind of astounding. Did FB ever try to buy them, or are they trying to destroy competition before they have to pay big bucks like they did for Instagram?<p>It's all business, so I suppose all's fair, but it hardly paints Facebook as a hub of innovation. I quit a job a few years ago once they gave me the task of basically cloning a competitor from the ground up. There's no excitement or challenge in that, and I can only imagine some very bored Facebook developers have had a less than notable Holiday season so far.
评论 #4954494 未加载
评论 #4954666 未加载
0x0over 12 years ago
How are they implementing the screenshot detection on iOS?<p>I searched and found some stack overflow posts, but they all seem stumped (especially for iOS 6)<p><a href="http://stackoverflow.com/questions/13484516/ios-detection-of-screenshot" rel="nofollow">http://stackoverflow.com/questions/13484516/ios-detection-of...</a> <a href="http://stackoverflow.com/questions/2121970/notification-of-or-detecting-screenshot-being-taken/2122117#2122117" rel="nofollow">http://stackoverflow.com/questions/2121970/notification-of-o...</a>
评论 #4954692 未加载
评论 #4954602 未加载
zaidfover 12 years ago
Can someone explain to me the thinking behind the multiple app strategy for facebook? Personally I find it grossly inconvenient to switch apps when going from chatting with a friend to seeing their Timeline. What am I missing?
评论 #4954386 未加载
评论 #4954502 未加载
评论 #4954597 未加载
mildavwover 12 years ago
Maybe it's because my small social network (my extended family) all have iPhones, but we abandoned Facebook about a year ago in favor of iMessage. Group text, photos, and movies fly back and forth almost every day. And when we want it live, Facetime.<p>I guess Facebook just further validated this mobile multimedia medium.
fratisover 12 years ago
Sure, it's like SnapChat, but isn't that always the dynamic in this industry: the Feature Qua Product (simplicity, focus) vs. Feature Qua Feature (integration)? Some folks, like those who use Buffer, for example, simply prefer tightly-focused, standalone apps while others prefer ones that do more, that integrate many features into a (sometimes) cohesive product a la HootSuite.<p>Personal note: while I'd have been tempted to compare them to Apple or Google in the past, Facebook's turning out to be a lot more like Microsoft for the web, appropriating features or buying companies to Do Everything, even if they're not the best in each vertical.
namankover 12 years ago
And just like that, Poke Wars became a real thing!
atteover 12 years ago
I'm trying to understand what they're going for here. The interesting part is that the "pokes" are ephemeral. Is that special because every other type of electronic message has permanence?
tylermac1over 12 years ago
Nice rip-off of SnapChat functionality.
评论 #4954353 未加载
chromejs10over 12 years ago
Do we really need ANOTHER facebook app? At this rate I'm going to have a dedicated folder of "Facebook crap". It doesn't make life easier to have all these things separate. I understand the camera app, but not things like this app or the messenger app, especially since in the messenger app I end up getting notified of new mail there and in the original facebook app...
评论 #4954590 未加载
lttlrckover 12 years ago
I suppose calling it Poke is a clue for intended use. Though they could have gone for SnatchChat and forgone the ambiguity.
tree_of_itemover 12 years ago
Why would you want your message to expire?
评论 #4954979 未加载
bosky101over 12 years ago
features aside, it must be pretty satisfying for fb employees to know that internal ideas can become separate apps.
dansoover 12 years ago
So has anyone read the TOS yet? Is there a guarantee that the content is deleted from their servers in a reasonable amount of time?
评论 #4954577 未加载
评论 #4958547 未加载
benlowerover 12 years ago
We're saved! This Poke app must be what averted the Mayan disaster.
评论 #4955646 未加载