TE
TechEcho
Home24h TopNewestBestAskShowJobs
GitHubTwitter
Home

TechEcho

A tech news platform built with Next.js, providing global tech news and discussions.

GitHubTwitter

Home

HomeNewestBestAskShowJobs

Resources

HackerNews APIOriginal HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 TechEcho. All rights reserved.

Why I'm switching back to Firefox

928 pointsby dave1010ukabout 12 years ago

93 comments

stroboskopabout 12 years ago
The post is spot on. Firefox is a great browser, but reading the OP's last paragraphs, users rarely choose software for quality <i>alone</i>.<p>The most popular alternatives to Firefox are Google's Chrome and Microsoft's Internet Explorer. I doubt these alternative browsers would exist if they were not useful for Google's and Microsofts main businesses. These companies produce web browsers to support their main products/services. The rationale behind AOL Explorer (<a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AOL_Browser" rel="nofollow">https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AOL_Browser</a>) was similar. In settings like those privacy and other interests of web users are easily sacrificed.<p>Out of all the big browsers, Mozilla Firefox comes closest to being a web browser for the sake of web browsing.
评论 #5355872 未加载
评论 #5355880 未加载
评论 #5356141 未加载
评论 #5356179 未加载
评论 #5357735 未加载
评论 #5356431 未加载
评论 #5357077 未加载
bobsyabout 12 years ago
I feel Chrome is becoming the new IE. Firefox always works. I keep finding obscure bugs in Chrome. I report them. They are confirmed by 3+ people. 9 months later issues remain unfixed. It feels like all development is targeted at new features instead of rounding off and fixing existing functionality.<p>The two things I dislike about Firefox. The development tools are funky. I am sure many people like them but when you are used to firebug / webkit tools the default Firefox tools are a bit of a shock.<p>The second issue is the lack of tab sand-boxing. A fairly large part of my job is testing for edge cases in our products. Our products are JavaScript heavy. I often find issues which crash the browser... well.. they crash Firefox. In Chrome the tab shows an error in the console and I have the option to close the tab. In Firefox I never get an error in the console. The whole browser freezes and stops responding.<p>It would be fantastic if Firefox sandboxed tabs to stop the entire browser crashing.
评论 #5356109 未加载
评论 #5356250 未加载
评论 #5359180 未加载
评论 #5356087 未加载
评论 #5356249 未加载
Trezoidabout 12 years ago
Firefox really needed the release of chrome to kick it back into gear because it had stagnated to some extent, easy in its "we're better then IE and that's all that really matters" mediocrity, and swapping over to the rapid release schedule has just accelerated things.<p>The fact that mozilla actively fights for internet freedom and user privacy is just the delicious icing on a technically solid browser cake.
评论 #5355662 未加载
评论 #5355767 未加载
ricardobeatabout 12 years ago
Here we go again! This is a sentiment that is spreading in the dev community, Chrome is starting to lose it's edge.<p>I'm currently working on a slightly heavy page, and Chrome is the slowest of the bunch to render, despite having smoother animations in most cases after it has done it's thing. Firefox, Safari and even IE9 are visibly faster by a couple <i>seconds</i>.<p>I feel like it slowly got worse and worse over the years. These days Chrome is the main CPU hog in my machine, uses GBs of memory and is responsible for most system hangs (OSX). The com.google.keystone agent thing even causes the trackpad and keyboard to malfunction every once and a while.
评论 #5355899 未加载
评论 #5355815 未加载
评论 #5358000 未加载
shadowmintabout 12 years ago
Same here, but for a slightly different reason for me:<p>When you're not logged into your google account, typing into the address bar with periodically kill chrome on mountain lion.<p>Not often, but maybe 3 or 4 times a day. Not kill the tab; hard kill chrome, instantly, destroying all the tabs, no recovery, all chrome processes go poof. It happens on all three of my mac devices (and this is on Version 25.0.1364.160).<p>It's not even a choice; that's just unusable.<p>I've also found firefox to be a lot better than I remember. Firebug is still a memory hog though, and as we saw in the other epic thread, the firebug / native developer tools thing is still just idiotic.<p>...but it's pretty good.<p>I honestly didn't expect to be ever returning to firefox because it was <i>more stable</i> than the alternative.
评论 #5355904 未加载
评论 #5356644 未加载
评论 #5355962 未加载
评论 #5357139 未加载
ok_craigabout 12 years ago
Sometimes I wonder how comprehensive these comparisons actually are. This is what I currently have open in Chrome:<p>3 Chrome Beta windows, with 17, 14, and 1 tabs open. 1 Chrome Canary window with 2 tabs<p>A good number of these tabs have not-very-light applications open like Gmail, Google spreadsheets, and some YouTube vids.<p>If you say to yourself, "oh, let me go check out Firefox compared to this," and launch it with one tab, do a quick Google search, and then determine, "hey, this is way faster," well... yeah, I wouldn't be surprised. Not only do you not have multiple windows and tabs open, but if you haven't used it in years you've probably got a pretty small cache not bogging you down.<p>Personally I've never actually noticed Chrome's performance to have any issues. Maybe because I have 12 gigs of RAM and an otherwise decent setup. On a more constrained system perhaps problems start to show themselves more easily. But are you sure that those same problems don't also appear in other browsers, given you're using them as intensely as you've been using Chrome this whole time?<p>I'd really love to see some browser comparison stats that go in-depth on this. Basically the only numbers you ever see these days are javascript rendering scores, and I feel like that's a really poor way to determine a browser's overall speed and efficiency. It doesn't account for how long it takes to open a new tab (like .01 seconds vs .3 seconds, which IMO is a big difference), scroll lag, startup time, etc, and it certainly doesn't account for how and if browsers become bogged down by real-world use.<p>I fear that users may be making similar snap judgments by comparing on the basis of quick open-and-go tests, instead of actual in-depth testing. First impressions are everything. You may find yourself five years from now using a browser that is actually slower than you were using previously, but you maintain your use of it because one time five years ago you opened it and loaded a page and it was faster than the encumbered incumbent.
评论 #5356557 未加载
评论 #5355780 未加载
评论 #5355981 未加载
评论 #5355777 未加载
mherdegabout 12 years ago
We've just passed the four-year anniversary of the bug that made me abandon Firefox on Mac: <a href="https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=476541" rel="nofollow">https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=476541</a><p>If you are an extremely fast typer, pretty much any time you use Firefox on OS X to "Save As" you will hit this incarnation of a bug that hangs every tab in your browser and forces you to kill it and start from scratch: <a href="https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=528149" rel="nofollow">https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=528149</a><p>Total bummer, I love Firefox but I'm not gonna train myself to type slower to keep from breaking it. This is no Therac-25.
评论 #5356786 未加载
Mahnabout 12 years ago
I have no idea what the article and some of you guys are talking about. I'm a very heavy user of Chrome, usually I have around 3 windows and 50-60 tabs in total; with this is setting I feel it's running pretty snappy, animations runs very smooth compared to the choppy experience I get with a single window and a single tab using Firefox. And don't get me started about Firebug; it's still so slow and clumsy compared to the chrome dev tools, every time I have to debug something Firefox specific the mere thought of being forced to use it gives me pain. Don't get me wrong, I'm not trying to discourage Mozilla, I have a huge appreciation for what they are doing. But when it comes to day-to-day usage, and as a developer tool, Chrome still wins in my book.
评论 #5356563 未加载
评论 #5356171 未加载
评论 #5356961 未加载
评论 #5363080 未加载
评论 #5360317 未加载
ams6110about 12 years ago
IIRC when Google released Chrome they said (I'm paraphrasing) they were doing it to raise the bar by which web browsers were measured. They needed to do this so that their other products (gmail, google docs) were viable replacements to their desktop competitors. They weren't really interested in developing a browser for its own sake.<p>If Firefox is now seen as being as good as or even better than Chrome, it looks like Google have succeeded.
评论 #5356274 未加载
shocksabout 12 years ago
I get where everyone is coming from when they say Firefox is getting better, but I really don't see Chrome getting worse and I certainly don't see Firefox surpassing Chrome.<p>Firefox dev tools in Nightly are much better, but still don't beat Chrome's. Firefox is still ugly. Firefox still won't let me open Nightly <i>and</i> Aurora. Firefox's Javascript performance is getting faster and memory usage is getting better, but when running tight loops in Javascript doing lots of calculations (specifically rendering fractal flames) Firefox becomes unresponsive and unusable, where as Chrome is fine and I can still browse normally while it runs in the background. Chrome might use a but more RAM but that's not a problem for me. I have buckets of RAM. Firefox needs restarting all the time when I change extensions or get updates.<p>I'll stick with Chrome for now. :)
评论 #5356246 未加载
评论 #5357047 未加载
评论 #5366200 未加载
eumenides1about 12 years ago
I also switched back for similiar reasons. FF has really stepped up their memory management and patching IMO. Also, i went back because of plugins.<p>Say what you will about chrome, but tab plugins are king in firefox. Tree style tabs on the left hand side and tab grouping what really sank it for me. I even merged the the search box and address bar in FF to give me that chrome omnibar feeling.<p>I think the most important takeaway is this: FF is still competitive among technical people and so is chrome. There even might be room for IE. We as a community, would need to keep voting with our feet and we can make sure the "browser wars" never end.
jacquesmabout 12 years ago
I never switched to Chrome for the silly and simple reason that I prefer a less corporate internet over a more corporate one. On top of that I am not sure that Chrome is or is not spyware but I'd like to err on the side of caution with stuff like this.
ebbvabout 12 years ago
I develop on Chrome all day every day and I cannot relate at all to these people saying it is full of bugs and crashing all the time. Nor do I find that Firefox is faster.<p>Chrome dev tools are still the best in the business, and Chrome just works.<p>Also I did a memory usage comparison on Chrome and Firefox 2 months ago and Firefox was using more memory by quite a bit (and got worse the more tabs you had open.) And this was Firefox with NO Flash and Chrome with Flash.
评论 #5356922 未加载
评论 #5357614 未加载
评论 #5357814 未加载
siamoreabout 12 years ago
I too have switched Firefox as my main browser, so far I like the better addons,<p>* ad block is much better<p>* addons work in private mode by default,<p>* an addon to use keepaas as my password manager<p>* many addons that allow me to customize youtube which i could not do in chrome (force 240p etc..),<p>* I missed Instant search but Firefox already searches bookmarks better and with the instantFox addon i can also search any site ala google instant and ddg<p>Better in chrome<p>* Addons by HNers (HN in chrome is great with a few addons like tldr.io, HNbox)<p>* Firefox seems unable to do multiple downloads as well as chrome (I'm unable to download multiple videos at once from coursera when using firefox)<p>* some chrome store apps<p>* Developer tools (which I don't really need)<p>I don't see much of a performance difference (maybe Firefox is better now or it may be hardware accelerated as I'm using Windows)
评论 #5356571 未加载
评论 #5355958 未加载
评论 #5359104 未加载
pioulabout 12 years ago
I switched from Firefox to Chrome at about the same time as op.<p>But I can't relate to how he feels:<p>- Chrome still has better dev tools than Firefox<p>- Chrome doesn't freeze at all (while Firefox does when handling a lot of tabs)<p>- Chrome doesn't require to restart when installing an extension (even if Firefox starts moving to this too)<p>- I still prefer Chrome's UI<p>- Even though I didn't try syncing with Firefox, Chrome does that very nicely
评论 #5356046 未加载
nhebbabout 12 years ago
For me the big difference wasn't the browser itself; it has been excessive javascript that's slowing the browsers. Many media sites are loading 20-30 external scripts, and I found that switching back to Firefox with NoScript has made a huge difference in load times and memory usage. The other issue with Chrome was releasing memory. I can close a tab in FF and the memory is recovered.
评论 #5355833 未加载
评论 #5355824 未加载
评论 #5361277 未加载
reidracabout 12 years ago
Firefox is great, but I think is a unfair comparison Chrome vs Firefox as he's talking about freedom and Chrome is not free software[1]. He may want to try Chromium instead.<p>I know is supposed to be the same source code, but it gives me some peace of mind that a 3rd party I trust (Linux distro) had access to the source code and built the actual binary I'm using.<p>[1] <a href="http://www.google.co.uk/chrome/intl/en/eula_text.html" rel="nofollow">http://www.google.co.uk/chrome/intl/en/eula_text.html</a><p>EDIT: formatting
vidyeshabout 12 years ago
Spot on, OP. Spot on. Firefox is a great browser and its truly open.<p>Unlike you I always been a Firefox user mostly because I still can't the basic addons for Chrome which I use on Firefox. And privacy concerns. I still use Chrome for cross-browser checks.<p>The one thing that Chrome was been said to be better than Firefox was the memory management. Over the past years, Firefox's memory leak issue has almost diminished and Chrome's has started.<p>Mozilla was and always is making Firefox for web browsing, they never pulled in any other feature/add-on/plug-in which would side track their motto.
Newkyabout 12 years ago
I have returned to firefox for the following reasons: 1) It feels more stable. Almost never crashes. 2) Can run separate profiles at the same time in a nicer way than chrome. I use this to have a work and personal browser in work. 3) I use vimperator now which I find works best on firefox. 4) I get that happy feeling that I am using software which actually values some of the open source philosophy that I value.
forgotAgainabout 12 years ago
I've been using Firefox more myself.<p>It's the consistent tic- tic-tic of disk access by Chrome. I have all extensions and plug-ins disabled. All caching disabled. And yet when I try to concentrate on something I'm reading in Chrome I'm continuously distracted by the tic-tic-tic of chrome accessing the hard disk every second or two.<p>Right now this window I'm writing in is the only Chrome window open. Yet there are three Chrome processes running. One of which is writing 7k per second to a temp file.<p>Chrome is not the sleek beast it once was. It's living off its reputation at this point.
mcoveyabout 12 years ago
I've been a lifelong Opera user and given the current situation (it's dying), I am considering Firefox the only viable alternative. I've never even liked having chrome on my computer, and in fact I would not be surprised if Google simply dropped chrome as a product, leaving it to the hands of the open source community anyway. They've abandoned many good products and dropping chrome wouldn't surprise me. Then again, maybe I am bitter, I thought Opera would be around forever.
评论 #5357002 未加载
评论 #5356302 未加载
kammeabout 12 years ago
I'm sticking with firefox for most of the same reasons as the author notes, but I do wish the mozilla team used some common sense when they think of new features.<p>A good example of the lack of common sense (imho) is the addon bar. Why do I want an extra bar with 2 or 3 icons? Most people will probably remember the status bar in browsers and they ditched that because it was not needed and you lost valuable screen estate. What was the best solution mozilla could come up with to handle the extension icons? An extra bar in the bottom of your browser. Just implement an omnibar already and put those things there...<p>If anyone from mozilla is reading this: you've done a great (GREAT!) job at making firefox faster and use less memory, and if you're ever in the neighbourhood I'll buy you a beer. Now please also start thinking about those little things that just don't make any sense.
评论 #5356136 未加载
评论 #5356426 未加载
评论 #5356198 未加载
mbestoabout 12 years ago
<i>I honestly believe Mozilla is committed to freedom and privacy on the web. Google is committed to making money and knowing everything I do.</i><p><i>The majority of the revenues comes from Google Inc., which is the default search engine on Mozilla Firefox.</i>[1]<p>Doesn't Mozilla exist because Google exists?<p>[1]- <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mozilla_Foundation#Mozilla_Corporation" rel="nofollow">http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mozilla_Foundation#Mozilla_Corp...</a>
评论 #5358201 未加载
robotmayabout 12 years ago
I made the same switch about a year ago now. Firefox feels so much better than it did when Chrome first appeared. I also now have an Android tablet, and Firefox on Android has come on leaps and bounds since it was first released; the tab syncing feature it shares with the desktop is fantastic and I haven't even launched Chrome on my tablet since I got it.
bryanwbhabout 12 years ago
Switched to Firefox from Chrome due to the following: - I dislike Google tracking everything that I am doing - Chrome with one tab starts out smoothly but with more tabs, its memory usage increases at a faster rate compared to Firefox - A browser that puts an advertisement in a blank page (chromebook anyone?) is a total turn-off
chensterabout 12 years ago
My biggest complain with Chrome right now is it freezes up and take over the entire CPU for 10 to 30 seconds every now and then. It's the case on both Windows 7 and Mac (10.8 Mountain Lion). Usually when that happens, I take a mini-break. Before it was lightning fast. I tried to switch back to Firefox but it's still IMO considerably slower in general but admittedly much more stable and doesn't freeze up for no good reason. Chrome seems to be slowly slipping to where Firefox was before as author ranted.
cabbeerabout 12 years ago
If you're on windows, the difference in font rendering between firefox and chrome is huge.
评论 #5357132 未加载
评论 #5356344 未加载
评论 #5356334 未加载
评论 #5359622 未加载
评论 #5359272 未加载
runeksabout 12 years ago
I recently switched back to <i>Chrome</i> because I felt Firefox was too slow. Strange how we experience the exact opposite :\.<p>Also, the feature I most appreciate with Chrome is the synchronization of tabs across all my devices (PC, laptop and phone). Firefox also has this but it never really worked for me (it was slow to update the tab list of my PC so I could access it from my phone, or it didn't update it at all "Ubuntu 12.04 - 4 days ago").
评论 #5357066 未加载
tanepiperabout 12 years ago
I've recently switched back as well and I find that it's back to a much better experience. Firefox was horrible for a while, but I think the team have been doing an excellent job of optimising it.<p>My only annoyance is the development tools - Chrome still whips FF here - and they are still no where as good as Firebug, which continues to be the most required extension - but I believe work is being done there too.
评论 #5356394 未加载
fafnerabout 12 years ago
I use both Firefox and Chrome. But I prefer Firefox. Better addons and extensibility were already mentioned. But one thing that seems to be commonly overlooked is the superior typography of Firefox. Firefox even does stuff like ligatures. That makes reading longer text much more pleasant.<p>Firefox is also capable of handling large amounts of tabs. In Chrome the tab bar is of fixed length (length of the window) and thus the maximum number of tabs is limited by my screen width. In Firefox the tab bar can extend to the sides or even better you can use the TreeStyleTabs addon to organize tabs in a tree view.<p>I think the biggest problem for Firefox was the long wait before FF4 was released. That was the exact time many people moved to Chrome. FF3.6 wasn't bad but was clearly slower than Chrome and had a huge memory appetite. Later versions improved this dramatically and Firefox now feels lighter/faster than Chrome. But every time FF vs. Chrome there are people claiming otherwise who have stopped using FF at version 3.6...
nodataabout 12 years ago
At the least, we desperately need Firefox as competition for Webkit.
dictumabout 12 years ago
I'm currently using an early 2006 iMac with Core Duo and 2GB of memory, running OS X 10.6.8, while my main computer is being repaired. For two years I thought it was dead (or on its last gasp), after some futile attempts to revive it with an external HDD. Finally I managed to boot it with an USB flash drive and later transferred its contents to an external USB hard drive.<p>Firefox is the only browser that runs comfortably on it. I'm using a lot of extensions, including ABP with multiple filter lists. After disabling caching on hard drive, I'm keeping around 25 tabs, sometimes 30 or more, and there's still RAM to spare, and the CPU isn't getting pounded.<p>Of course, browsers should be optimized for current use cases and computers, but what I've experienced for the past two weeks really changed my impression of Firefox as a bloated and slow browser that was only fast in comparison to old IE.
sdfjklabout 12 years ago
I've switched back to Firefox recently too (from Safari). Here's what I had to tweak to get it working like it should: <a href="http://sdfjkl.org/post/2013/03/07/Making-Firefox-behave-on-OS-X" rel="nofollow">http://sdfjkl.org/post/2013/03/07/Making-Firefox-behave-on-O...</a>
jagermoabout 12 years ago
I would love to switch back to Firefox, but, to be honest, the rapid relase cycle really annoys me. I would love to head back, if Mozilla switched to a more stable release cycle - or at least to updates, that don't interupt me everytime I start the browser up.<p>But I'll give it a try.
评论 #5355725 未加载
评论 #5355821 未加载
评论 #5356089 未加载
评论 #5358442 未加载
piyush_soniabout 12 years ago
I've always stuck to Firefox for its customizability and because it has less reasons to collect all my data and become an Apple like walled garden which Chrome is slow turning into.<p>That said, yes, they also have less reasons to be 'answerable' to their users or to fix problems. On Bugzilla, I've mostly seen arrogant and rude contributors who are mostly like, if you can't contribute or fix it yourself, go away! Don't even complain. See the example of this major/critical <i>12 years</i> old bug, which no one wants to fix, and now they don't even want users to express their displeasure on that. There's no resolve, while other browsers have fixed that problem.<p>I've always stuck to Firefox for its customizability and because it has less reasons to collect all my data and become an Apple like walled garden which Chrome is slow turning into.<p>That said, yes, they also have less reasons to be 'answerable' to their users or to fix problems. On Bugzilla, I've mostly seen arrogant and rude contributors who are mostly like, "If you can't contribute or fix it yourself, go away!" Don't even complain. See the example of this major/critical <i>12 years</i> old bug, which no one wants to fix, and now they don't even want users to express their displeasure on that. There's no resolve, while other browsers have fixed that problem. <a href="https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=78414" rel="nofollow">https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=78414</a>
Semaphorabout 12 years ago
Does anyone know of an extension that adds Chromes feature of highlighting results in the scrollbar when searching through a page (Ctrl+F)?<p>It's pretty much the only thing I'm missing whenever I try FF again.
评论 #5355759 未加载
评论 #5358485 未加载
评论 #5359550 未加载
razzmatazabout 12 years ago
Recently, it seems Chrome is saving history online between browsers on different machines. This has freaked me out to the point where I'm moving back to using Firefox.
评论 #5356335 未加载
评论 #5356292 未加载
kaoliniteabout 12 years ago
I switch back on Linux every so often, feel refreshed and stay for a few months. Then I switch to Chrome, feel refreshed and the cycle continues.
afhofabout 12 years ago
What OS? I have noticed that Firefox on Ubuntu (12.04 clean install) looks way worse and feels worse than FF on Windows 7. I feel like Firefox on Windows is still more peppy than Chrome / Firefox on Ubuntu despite my Linux box being way beefier. I feel like the author's post is 1 dimensional (which browser) when it should be a 2 dimensional comparison (browser and OS).
rasmusklabout 12 years ago
I was actually thinking the same thing and am giving it a try.<p>One thing that strikes me as vastly inferior in FF given my use cases is the way private browsing works. I use incognito tabs in Chrome all the time in dev to get a clean tab with no sessions etc. FF only allows for either normal tabs or private tabs, not both. Oh well :-)
评论 #5357208 未加载
评论 #5356918 未加载
评论 #5358179 未加载
_augustabout 12 years ago
Installed Firefox again because of this post.<p>One of the things I tried out was WebGL performance using the recently posted WebGL terrain flyover demo (<a href="http://www.zephyrosanemos.com/windstorm/20130301/live-demo.html" rel="nofollow">http://www.zephyrosanemos.com/windstorm/20130301/live-demo.h...</a>), but I can't get over 30.5 fps in Firefox whereas on Chrome I get 50 - 60. Hardware acceleration seems to be enabled for both, perhaps Firefox is not recognizing the graphics card?<p>One of the things that impressed my about Chrome in the beginning was when they launched Chrome Experiments to show off the performance. There was no comparison at the time between any other browser and Chrome. This may still hold true to a certain extent.<p>However, for general browsing I can't tell a difference with the current iteration.
christogreeffabout 12 years ago
Finding myself using Firefox more often again. Chrome is not as snappy as I once felt it to be.
pnelsonabout 12 years ago
I switched from Firefox to Chrome around the same time as the author. However, I'm having the opposite experience. Chrome is great; everything is blazing fast, even with my ~25 tabs open.<p>I tried Firefox a few weeks ago just to see if I had been missing out on anything. Nope. Opening new tabs in Firefox was sluggish. Page navigation was even worse. I assumed that most browsers would be roughly on par these days but Firefox was not even tolerable after having used Chrome.<p>It pains me because I, too, share the sentiment that Mozilla is committed to freedom and privacy on the internet. I guess I am just willing to give that up in exchange for a better internet experience for the time being.
评论 #5359632 未加载
fiendsanabout 12 years ago
I use firefox, always have even when it was buggy as hell, mostly because i needed all the web dev tools and was confortable with it, but i also use chrome for watching youtube and quick browsing (unfortunately firefox till this day is damn slow to open and become responsive).<p>Thats why im looking forward to opera's webkit version (so i can ditch google chrome for opera), i think google chrome is getting more and more creepy and has made some decisions that are more in google's interest than the users (like posting links on the speed dial or all the extensions that are nothing more thank links and all the extensions that are not links but behave like links, its weird).
qooabout 12 years ago
Firefox's killer features:<p>1. Option "Don't load tabs until selected"<p>2. Firefox Sync<p>3. Aurora releases
评论 #5356395 未加载
YPetrovabout 12 years ago
I used to be a Firefox user a couple of years ago and then when I switched to Chrome I noticed a BIG difference in the performance. Chrome was faster and more stable.<p>Now, similar to the OP I keep having issues with Chrome, the biggest of which is its memory usage.<p>"Memory usage is off the charts and I frequently have tabs become completely unresponsive."<p>In my case, it not only eats 2GB of my RAM, but also takes a bit proportion of my hard-disk. I did a quick experiment yesterday and measured my FREE HDD space before closing Chrome and after that.<p>Before: 800 MB free. After: 10.9 GB free :)<p>It's true I keep a lot of tabs open (&#62;70), but 10GB.. I think that's too much. Now, I'm considering switching back to Firefox, too.
tekahsabout 12 years ago
Firefox is great for his philosophy, but for my part, Chrome is better for dev., performance, memory, etc. (And recently, I'm having a weird bug with text while scrolling with Firefox).<p>Anyway, I think everyone here using Firefox AND chrome.
leleleabout 12 years ago
&#62; The post is spot on. Firefox is a great browser, but reading the OP's last paragraphs, users rarely choose software for quality alone.<p>Quality is not the same for everyone. I have switched to Chrome, and it feels like it's build much better than Firefox. Maybe Firefox is actually built better, but as an user, I perceive Chrome to be better, starting with rare crashes instead of Firefox's frequent ones. Yes, Firefox's crashes may be because of its plugins, but that's a moot point, because without any plugins, Firefox is too basic a browser.
cciesquareabout 12 years ago
Firefox is still slow as heck for me. Not sure what performance you guys are talking about. I unfortunately have to use Firefox heavily at work. When I can I use something else, sometimes even IE.
评论 #5358508 未加载
评论 #5358888 未加载
srgsegabout 12 years ago
Great timing - I just posted a Show HN about my new extension to save 95% memory in Google Chrome<p><a href="http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5356823" rel="nofollow">http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5356823</a>
0mbreabout 12 years ago
Surf with Chrome and use Firefox for dev
DrinkWaterabout 12 years ago
I switched my main browser Chrome to Canary some time ago. And recently i have been using Firefox Nightly. And all i can say is that Chrome now lacks the quality it used to have (yes, even in the canary build) and Firefox has gained a lot in terms of stability, memory consumption and Dev-features.<p>The bad thing is: hardly anyone knows about this, because Google is investing tons and tons of money for Chrome marketing purposes (and developer evangelisation; a point you also have to consider).<p>Only thing i like more about Chrome: the dev tools
seferphierabout 12 years ago
Chrome lags a lot when dealing with HTML5 and hogs a lot of memory
johnwardabout 12 years ago
I still prefer firebug over the firefox dev tools. The built in tools look pretty but they aren't that useful to me. I just figured out how to show the style window, but there doesn't seem to be any javascript tools. Where is the console?<p>edit: After I posted this I figured I should dig deeper before I get all kinds of negative comments. I found the console and also some other useful tools that I didn't know existed. Things like the responsive view and scratch pad are pretty cool.
andybakabout 12 years ago
Due to issues with memory usage on Chrome I recently tried switching back but page rendering and UI response felt noticeably slower. I am also so fluent with web inspector that the burden of re-learning Firebug or the built-in tools was a drag.<p>So I decided that the easiest way to reduce Chrome's memory usage was to curb my slightly irrational usage patterns - keeping dozens of tabs open that I rarely ever get around to going back to.
writebufferedabout 12 years ago
The exact reason I jumped out of Chrome to back Firefox. Privacy. I will never trust Google with my information and it seems they do collect it without me knowing as well. I have scoured over Chrome's source code to see if they are doing anything nefarious as tracking my url visits but still I never felt safe in that platform. I moved to duckduckgo, Firefox and I am happy.
zhangtaiabout 12 years ago
I have tried several times to switch back to firefox, but without success. I have to use different computers almost everyday, chrome does the sync work so well besides other functions, when I install firefox on a different pc, the sync configuration is so conplex for me... but there are some excelent addons on firefox I will miss, e.g. pantadactyl
the_gipsyabout 12 years ago
How about doing actual benchmarks? How about pin pointing how exactly google tracks you more or better with chrome than with ff?
评论 #5355965 未加载
tn13about 12 years ago
Switching between Firefox and chrome will happen often for at least few years to come. Chrome was a good thing because it brought some real competition in the Market.<p>Webkit is supported by Apple as well as Google which happen to be worlds largest companies. Firefox on other other had is open, non profit organization giving a tough fight to both of them.
scotty79about 12 years ago
I'm switching back from Chrome to Firefox because Chrome doesn't work for me with basic Google services, like search, maps, gmail.<p><a href="http://productforums.google.com/forum/#!topic/chrome/hsW8ls9XhQE" rel="nofollow">http://productforums.google.com/forum/#!topic/chrome/hsW8ls9...</a><p>It goes on and off. When I have this problem I switch back to Firefox for a while.
Tenokeabout 12 years ago
This post seems weird to me as I recently switched back to Chrome for Firefox precisely because Chrome is faster than ff. It is visibly faster for me and most recent articles I could find after I googled 'Chrome versus Firefox' showed exactly that - that Chrome is faster than Firefox on the more important metrics right now.
评论 #5359370 未加载
e40about 12 years ago
<i>I frequently have tabs become completely unresponsive</i><p>This started happening to me a few months ago, and yesterday I had about 5 tabs do this. I even cleared the cache and restarted, and it happened again.<p>I've been having the same thoughts as the OP, and having fled FF around the same time frame, perhaps I should give it another try.
_pferreir_about 12 years ago
&#62; Now it’s five years later and things aren’t so great. More than ever I’m having issues with general slowness in the browser.<p>Check.<p>&#62; Memory usage is off the charts and I frequently have tabs become completely unresponsive.<p>Check.<p>&#62; JavaScript errors occasionally disappear into the void instead of logging to the console.<p>Check.<p>Oh, my! I'm so glad I'm not the only one!
rthabout 12 years ago
First of all Firebug and million other addons are good reason to stick to Firefox ;) Welcome back!
INTPenisabout 12 years ago
My story is similar but goes further back, I tried Chrome shortly but soon learned that its only two noscript-options were flawed in various ways, mainly they loaded all the javascript once before they blocked it.<p>So the only reason I use firefox today is due to noscript.
gokfarabout 12 years ago
Pentadactyl alone did it for me.
评论 #5358449 未加载
pavankyabout 12 years ago
&#62; Chrome greets me with… sigh… Chrome greets me with a fucking advertisement for a Chromebook.<p>I have always used Chromium as opposed to Chrome. I am not sure why people would go for the Chrome version if they really care about freedom.
评论 #5357677 未加载
qwertaabout 12 years ago
I tried to switch to Firefox while ago, but there are two problems which holds me back:<p>- Firefox is horrible with inversive color theme (light text on dark background). With Chrome it just works on 99% websites<p>- KDE Firefox integration is horrible.
评论 #5356042 未加载
p6v53asabout 12 years ago
The ultimate parameter for me is speed. As much as I love Mozilla's open source policy, I just can't use it because it is slower. RAM is not a problem to anyone, so I prefer more RAM used than slower performance.
rishimokoabout 12 years ago
There must be some shifting in the geekforce. I just switched back to Firefox a couple of weeks ago on OSX 10.7. Flawless, which is more than I can say for Chrome or Safari.
debian69about 12 years ago
Til people are snobbish and only use one browser , personally i use whatever is avail i have no allegiance to one or the other just the one that works first.
mariusmgabout 12 years ago
See you there. Most of us already made the switch (back).
评论 #5356822 未加载
jpulecabout 12 years ago
Unfortunately, in my experience, Chrome's WebGL performance is several times better than Firefox's. Upon several benchmarks, there is just no comparison.
dgesangabout 12 years ago
Reading blog posts like this makes me wonder if the author even considered using Opera at any point in his painful journey with Firefox and Chrome.
Kurtz79about 12 years ago
Like many, I also switched to Chrome when it came out, after many years of Firefox.<p>Are there reviews/benchmarks that substantiate the article's claims ?
rkwzabout 12 years ago
&#62;The “disable cache” checkbox in the developer tools seems to do nothing<p>I've the same issue. It works sometimes and other times it doesn't.
评论 #5355942 未加载
sibilsalimabout 12 years ago
I've noticed Google Analytics tab in Google Chrome crashing often. Google Analytics eats lot of memory in Google Chrome.
tommaxwellabout 12 years ago
I actually use Chrome because it syncs my settings between Chrome for Desktop and Chrome for Android quite nicely.
webwanderingsabout 12 years ago
&#62; Chrome greets me with a fucking advertisement for a Chromebook<p>My solution for now is to use about:blank as a homepage.
3doabout 12 years ago
Built-in syncing service is still not user friendly. Persona may fix it in future
babyabout 12 years ago
And firefox has Tree Style Tab. Makes it superior to any other browsers.
qooabout 12 years ago
Why was this post showing as [deleted] a few hours ago?
prisonguardabout 12 years ago
Does the op know that the Mozilla foundation is almost entirely funded by Google?<p><a href="http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mozilla_Foundation" rel="nofollow">http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mozilla_Foundation</a>
ghjmabout 12 years ago
Well, with both Chrome and Firefox on rapid mandatory release schedules, all I can say is: Get comfortable supporting IE for large enterprise customers forever.
评论 #5356817 未加载
评论 #5356515 未加载
g3orgeabout 12 years ago
Chromium doesn't greet you with an ad. ;-)
评论 #5356313 未加载
brooksbpabout 12 years ago
I use Chrome because of the UI.
dmccunneyabout 12 years ago
Speaking personally, I never <i>left</i> Firefox.<p>I've been using Mozilla code since the Netscape 7.X days (and tried to use NS6, but it was way too buggy.) I progressed from MS7 to the Mozilla Suite to Firefox, and have stayed there.<p>I have Chrome (and Opera, Safari, Midori, Konqueror, K-Meleon, D+, and a few other things including IE installed, but mostly to keep up on what others are doing. Firefox is what I use in production, and I currently run Aurora (which will be the next release when it gets out of beta.)<p>FF isn't the smallest or fastest browser on the machine I'm on at the moment (and old netbook) but is the most capable. FF, like other current browsers, makes assumptions about what you will run it on, and assumes a reasonably current machine with a reasonable CPU, GPU, and amount of RAM. I have another old machine I don't even <i>try</i> to run FF on.<p>My reasons are tied up in the architecture. FF uses the Gecko engine, like everything else Mozilla puts out. Aside from HTML, CSS, and JavaScript, Gecko interprets and renders XUL, an XML language for designing user interfaces. The look and feel of FF is determined by XUL, CSS, and widgets, and the browser is simply an instance of something Gecko renders.<p>This makes it possible to create themes that change what FF looks like, and extensions that modify and extend what it does, and that power is why I use it. My RSS reader, IRC client and several other things that would ordinarily be external programs are implemented in FF as extensions. Since the browser is always running when I'm at the computer, this make things very convenient.<p>Other browsers like Chrome added an extension capability, but they are pure JavaScript and limited by what the device API will let you do in JavaScript. Half of what I do in FF isn't <i>possible</i> in Chrome.<p>Chrome is a worthy browser, and I'm glad it's there, but it's not what I use. It invokes somewhat faster than FF, but page rendering is equivalent, and memory usage rises rapidly as you add extensions, so there's little difference between FF and Chrome in use. Faster invocation is a non-issue here: I start the browser when I sit down at the machine and simply leave it running, so a few extra seconds to invoke it isn't a concern. Too many people have the bad habit learned from IE of hopping in and out of the browser, and I just tell such folks "You're doing it wrong".<p>On my desktop booted into Windows, I run FF from a RAMdisk. The desktop still runs XP and has 4GB RAM, but 32 bit Windows can only use 3.2GB of it. I found a RAMdisk driver that can use the rest and have a 768MBR ramdrive seen as Z:. Firefox, its cache, and its profile all live there and FF is run from there. It's <i>quick</i>. (Batch files populate the ramdisk on start up, and store the contents back to HD on shutdown.) I don't believe I can <i>do</i> that with Chrome.
kinnthabout 12 years ago
really refreshing!
wilfraabout 12 years ago
It's getting better and it's now overtaken Safari as my default when I need a second browser. However I'll never consider switching back until they completely eliminate popups of any kind. I never want to be asked to restart the browser or update my plugins or anything. I don't care if Mozilla is filing for bankruptcy and they are turning it over to Kim Jong-un - I don't want a fucking popup announcing it.<p>Edit: immediately after making this post I realized there might be a way to disable all popups and notifications. Is there? If so, I might give it a spin for a week.
评论 #5358425 未加载
fakeerabout 12 years ago
Earlier it used to be ...-Firefox-Chrome-Firefox-... every 2/3 months but fot that 1 year or so it's been just Firefox, happily.<p>I switched back to Firefox sometime ago. It got back its speed and crashes less and fries my Mac less than other browsers. Well, on crashing part and getting stuck part Safari is better than all others on a Mac(at least) but for other purpose(for my usage) it's a pretty pretty useless browser. Safari uses more RAM in Mac than Firefox/Chrome and for less tabs it uses more RAM than both combined, it just does that in a different helper process.<p>Quick releases ensures FF gets thinks out and fixed faster.<p>Their mobile browser is not still there. I hope it becomes better so that I can replace Chrome on my Android too.<p>There are things I wish were there in Firefox. Like manage tabs separately. Like in Chrome. Visual tools/API(seems it's not that open, not sure) like Chrome. I really liked Cortex extension of Chrome in Firefox(it was my favourite).<p>And of course I love those people at Mozilla for always standing against those privacy-killers and keep telling them to suck it up their -----.
评论 #5360819 未加载
martincedabout 12 years ago
People trading security (sandboxing) for performance (lower memory usage and faster speed in Firefox) deserve to be a) owned and b) have their whole browser crash when one tab crashes.<p>I'd be using Firefox if they started to sandbox all the tabs. To me the argument that it's faster and use less memory because it's not sandboxed is a <i>very</i> poor one.<p>Actually that argument shows what is wrong with the mindset of many people in our field.<p>You should never trade security for a bit more perfs.
评论 #5357269 未加载
Nuxabout 12 years ago
Welcome back! :)
marvwhereabout 12 years ago
1) Firefox is the new IE7/8 - i having more and more issues with standard css settings, which are f<i></i><i></i>* up in the ff, but are nice and shiny in all other brothers (yes even in ie)<p>2) "I honestly believe Mozilla is committed to freedom and privacy on the web." - haha thats funny :D you know about chromium right? :D its free, you can code on it too if you want too, sure there are might be 1-2 functions in the chrome, which belongs to google, but all in all you can know the code. and google did there learnings after the first versions where they sending stuff to there servers.<p>and in the end, all browser are logging the same shit, where are we clicking, what are we doing, where we enter this and that. why? because they want to make there money too, and collect a big big big database, which they can sell to other companies. and learn stuff out of it. i guess on this view all brothers are the same crap<p>3) memory management - yes its true chrome get stuck more and more often, and eating the memory, and it is annoying. but for me, firefox still is worse. everytime i start firefox for debugging some website or whatever, i'm totally pissed, because this stupid software still needs like forever for the initialised start. and when you keep it open for 2 days, you done :D in my opinion even photoshop has a better memory management then firefox.<p>=<p>i hope for the chrome too, that the switch from opera to webkit, give them a little ass kick, because that is that what all browser companies needed, an ass kick.<p>first there was an IE everybody used it, so why should they update it? then there was the firefox, ie was screwed, everybody used ff now, so why should they update it? then there was the chrome, ff was screwed, everybody used chrome now, so why should they update it?<p>and everybody took there lesson out of it, IE is getting better, FF starts updating there browser after sitting on 3.6 like forever... and thats ok, people now having like 3-4 good brothers and can choose.
评论 #5355897 未加载
评论 #5355800 未加载
评论 #5355786 未加载
评论 #5355829 未加载