TE
TechEcho
Home24h TopNewestBestAskShowJobs
GitHubTwitter
Home

TechEcho

A tech news platform built with Next.js, providing global tech news and discussions.

GitHubTwitter

Home

HomeNewestBestAskShowJobs

Resources

HackerNews APIOriginal HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 TechEcho. All rights reserved.

Ask HN : What do you think of our new app design? (plus the history of it)

3 pointsby dan_simabout 16 years ago

3 comments

alexkabout 16 years ago
I am not a professional, but can share my personal experience. (looking at ss5u.png)<p>1. TimmyOnTime has a shadow and the following text - "time tracking..." does not, besides they have different fonts (I understood later that TimmyOnTime is a logo and the following text is an explanation, but at the first time I was confused)<p>2. I would make the header text giving the most important message bigger and cleaner.<p>3. The main picture on the page makes no sense to me. I see 6 different images: Address book? (what does your app do with it?) Adium (I don't know what it is) AOL instant messaging (I am using ICQ, Jabber and Skype) and 3 other images below having no meaning to me. Then 2 minutes later I notice the text explaining that I can use your app with Google talk, MSN and aim.<p>4. It seems to me that text on your button has more space on top then on bottom (is it your intention?)<p>5. Your customer feedback uses the smallest font, gray color on a white background what makes it hard to read and notice, I would value my customers most of all and make their feedback more noticeable.<p>Once again I am not a professional, just a software developer and these are my personal thoughts and impressions.
评论 #572290 未加载
评论 #572295 未加载
pxlpshrabout 16 years ago
With all due respect: developers are not designers, and visa versa. <i>Puts on M$ Monkey Suit</i>, "Delegate, delegate, delegate!" I know you're not a big company, but that doesn't matter — if you're developing a consumer-facing web application, you need to be thinking about UX/UI, branding, etc. The bar is raised, web-app market is ultra-competitive, consumers will ditch a bad looking site.<p>In my humblest opinion, your current website is better structured and more professional looking than ss5u.png, but that's not to say it can't be improved. I too am not a fan of the color scheme (brown, orange, etc.) but from a design standpoint, it's feels like a complete thought while ss5u.png looks and feels like an unfinished wireframe (as a customer, I'd wonder if your product is unfinished too). However, there are elements from ss5u.png that I think you can merge, like the call-to-action button for one, the lighter color scheme, etc.<p>I think people mistakenly believe a designer's job is easy, and quite frankly it's not... it's torture. Reading your blog post, I was happy to see you came to the same conclusion. :) People see a clean and simple design and say, "that's easy, I can do that!" but fail to realize the amount of work and iterations that it took to get to that point. Visual harmony requires balance, and there's a reason why few companies can reproduce Apple's simplistic product design. It's NOT easy.<p>Designers live in a perpetual cycle of NEVER being satisfied because we tend to be obsessive-compulsive. I'm glad you got to experience this, but now I think you should put down the mouse, get back to hacking, and let a professional handle the job. :)
评论 #572333 未加载
raptrexabout 16 years ago
you should make Add timmy@timmyontime.com, Add timmyontime and Add timmyontime@hotmail.com these into links (well i know u can make the one for AIM into a link)<p>and this is a reason to use the app, not a feature: 98% instant messaging VS 2% web Type what you are doing instead of clicking in a cumbersome interface.
评论 #572304 未加载