TE
TechEcho
Home24h TopNewestBestAskShowJobs
GitHubTwitter
Home

TechEcho

A tech news platform built with Next.js, providing global tech news and discussions.

GitHubTwitter

Home

HomeNewestBestAskShowJobs

Resources

HackerNews APIOriginal HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 TechEcho. All rights reserved.

Show HN: Premortems, help projects be more successful

6 pointsby _jssalmost 12 years ago

3 comments

bradfordarneralmost 12 years ago
I&#x27;m intrigued by &#x27;premortems&#x27; because the name sounds interesting. However, I find myself very hesitant to pay with my email for a &#x27;free&#x27; signup unless I know what it is. Even with the examples, I have no idea what a &#x27;premortem&#x27; is or what form that takes in your app; its value is still a complete unknown to me even after visiting your site and blog.<p>I don&#x27;t see any unique value proposition that offers me value. For those who understand what a &#x27;premortem&#x27; is they might find it valuable but I cannot even begin to understand it nor do I find it necessary to invest time enough to find out because I don&#x27;t understand its value. In the words of Clayton Christensen, what job is it accomplishing? When I walk by a restaurant that is new, I have no idea what the food might taste like but at least I know what value food offers. In this case, I don&#x27;t even understand the value that &#x27;premortems&#x27; offer.<p>So, I would offer the following suggestions:<p>1. Give a clear, one line explanation of what can be achieved with a &#x27;premortem&#x27; (i.e. what job is getting done; more successful projects doesn&#x27;t count as a tagline because it gives no explanation of what that means. You set X = &#x27;Premortem&#x27; and Y = &#x27;Successful project&#x27; but there is no explanation given of the correlation between X and Y.)<p>2. Give a clear demonstration of that being achieved with an example &#x27;premortem&#x27; (i.e. how the job is done with your site)<p>3. Show pictures&#x2F;screenshots of that being done (There is currently too much reading to be done on the site)<p>Once again the name is interesting enough to get me to write this explanation. Thus, there is at least minimal value in the name. I&#x27;m intrigued but purely by curiosity. The curiosity is simply a vessel waiting to be filled in order to create value.
评论 #6006788 未加载
_jssalmost 12 years ago
The story of building this app is interesting. I discovered the premortems technique the weekend before last, and challenged myself to build an entire app in 3 days with a full infrastructure (monitoring, customer service, marketing plan).
评论 #6006595 未加载
huhtenbergalmost 12 years ago
&gt; <i>even anonymously to avoid political reprisals!</i><p>May want to trim off newrelic and google-analytics snooping scripts from your site then.
评论 #6006614 未加载