TE
TechEcho
Home24h TopNewestBestAskShowJobs
GitHubTwitter
Home

TechEcho

A tech news platform built with Next.js, providing global tech news and discussions.

GitHubTwitter

Home

HomeNewestBestAskShowJobs

Resources

HackerNews APIOriginal HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 TechEcho. All rights reserved.

Medium Sucks

129 pointsby gringofyxover 11 years ago

19 comments

derefrover 11 years ago
I don&#x27;t know if Medium <i>cares</i> that much about their own content discovery&#x2F;cliquing&#x2F;etc. Sure, the content has to be accessible from the site in some fashion so web spiders can reach it--but really, as far as I can tell, Medium blogs seem built for the generation of standalone post pages that get shared via their authors self-promoting them on their Twitter feeds and Facebook pages, and then other people putting them up on social bookmarking websites like Reddit and HN. (Or at least, anecdotally, that&#x27;s where <i>I&#x27;ve</i> found all the Medium articles I&#x27;ve ever read.)<p>You don&#x27;t really <i>visit</i> someone&#x27;s Medium blog. I&#x27;ve never seen anyone say, on their profile somewhere else, &quot;here&#x27;s a direct link to my blog; it&#x27;s on Medium.&quot; It looks the same as every other Medium blog, after all; that&#x27;s a strong disincentive to people promoting links their blog root, since they can&#x27;t brand it--and I think that&#x27;s intentional on Medium&#x27;s part.<p>Instead, you just find someone&#x27;s Medium <i>posts</i> shared in your feed on some sharing service, because someone you know linked to them. Which is really what the web has needed for a while, I think: a nice, clean, &quot;here is a long standalone essay&quot; hosting service which is <i>ancillary</i> to your more usual blogging, which occurs on FB&#x2F;G+&#x2F;Twitter&#x2F;Tumblr&#x2F;etc.<p>A geeky comparison, that might explain their value proposition, as I see it: FB&#x2F;G+&#x2F;Twitter&#x2F;Tumblr&#x2F;etc. are like a VM stack: you want to only hold tiny little objects on it, because reading those objects (scrolling past them) takes time and &quot;processing cycles&quot; for the reader. You don&#x27;t want to pass huge ones around, because they&#x27;ll take up a lot of space everywhere they go, and you have to copy them piece by piece (there have been novels written over Twitter, but they&#x27;re a bitch to read or quote or export, etc.)<p>Medium, then, is a VM heap to stick large objects on, and then pass them by reference on the stack (FB&#x2F;G+&#x2F;Twitter&#x2F;Tumblr&#x2F;etc.) In effect, it&#x27;s a pastebin with really nice styling, feed generation, and collaborative editorial features, not a &quot;blogging service&quot; per se. Make sense?
评论 #6243403 未加载
评论 #6243619 未加载
vinceguidryover 11 years ago
Simply looking at the site and its content model, it&#x27;s obvious, to me at least, that it&#x27;s the internet equivalent of a publisher&#x27;s slush file. People have a greater appetite for reading, but are not yet willing to pay for it. So content pieces that wouldn&#x27;t fit into a more serious publication can be shown there.<p>Authors can complain all they want about the platform, how there&#x27;s little money in it, how they can&#x27;t build an audience, and all these complaints do is highlight the author&#x27;s naiveté. These things are set by the market&#x27;s appetite, not your ego. If you want your writing to be taken seriously, then take seriously the craft of writing. Medium doesn&#x27;t suck, you suck. And you&#x27;re on Medium because you suck. It&#x27;s about an efficient a market as you can find, because there&#x27;s exactly zero barriers to entry.
评论 #6244443 未加载
discreteeventover 11 years ago
All I know about medium is that it won&#x27;t render in opera mini which I use on my phone for speed and battery life. I know I have no excuse if I don&#x27;t use a &quot;modern&quot; browser so I can&#x27;t complain. But still, for a site that just displays some text with inline pictures, I wonder why they couldn&#x27;t deliver it with some simpler tech.
评论 #6246074 未加载
评论 #6243833 未加载
评论 #6247380 未加载
nilknover 11 years ago
Am I the only one who doesn&#x27;t think Medium is some horrible, evil thing? It&#x27;s still a solid, pretty, functional, and easy blogging platform for people who just want to get something out there. It doesn&#x27;t do much to allow authors to distinguish themselves from the pack; I think this is left up for the author to do, if they want or even care, via other social media, like Twitter. It seems there&#x27;s a general trend away from a single, all-inclusive social platform like Facebook towards a distributed system of smaller pieces which can fit together.<p>It wouldn&#x27;t be my blogging platform of choice, but I&#x27;m the sort of person who&#x27;d go to all the trouble of hand-crafting a personal website for something like this, just for the fun of it. Medium is obviously for people who want the opposite experience.<p>None of this is to say that Medium doesn&#x27;t have its share of problems, but I think it is at least decent from the blogger&#x27;s perspective and IMHO pretty good from the reader&#x27;s perspective.
foobarbazquxover 11 years ago
The most annoying thing about Medium is that you can&#x27;t discern who an article is written by from the URL. They may as well be pastebin links.
评论 #6244240 未加载
arunodaover 11 years ago
With medium, you simply make traffic for them. Start your own blog, host on your domain.<p>Traffic is all yours. You can do amazing things.
RossDMover 11 years ago
Since we&#x27;re complaining about Medium: the font is too big. We may be in the post Web 2.0 era where huge text is more of a norm, but I feel assaulted every time I load a Medium article. The text is not readable without physically changing one&#x27;s position, or adjusting the browser font size.<p>And why should I have to fiddle with the font size for one site when I don&#x27;t have to think about it elsewhere? Are Medium bloggers so arrogant as to think that their revelations deserve to be shouted in my face at 22px?
评论 #6246821 未加载
scopendoover 11 years ago
I&#x27;ve never thought of Medium as a blogging platform but rather an article publishing platform with tools to encourage conversation and sharing around each article.
k-mcgradyover 11 years ago
&gt;&gt; &quot;Stats are too coarse - There are one or two lovely graphs but it just doesn&#x27;t give me the depth of knowledge I&#x27;d like to know about my audience - even Google Analytics only just makes the bar.&quot;<p>To me at least Medium is meant to appeal to the kind of bloggers who want to post something but don&#x27;t want to maintain a blog. If you want detailed analytics and even Google Analytics are just good enough you don&#x27;t sound like the sort of person Medium is for.<p>As for monetizing I could see Medium offering paid plans. Maybe using them to offer the kind of detailed analytics you want. Or maybe they will charge for mobile apps the way the NYTimes does with it&#x27;s subscriptions. Judging by their focus on nicely laid out content I really doubt they would plaster it with ads.
taudeover 11 years ago
I&#x27;d be interested in hearing some opinions from UX experts on the Medium interface?<p>Specifically:<p>* The rectangular &#x27;M&#x27; in the top-left that hides a menu<p>* The inline hidden&#x2F;comments that animate in on hover.<p>* The weird &quot;suggest a link for further reading&quot; functionality at the bottom of the article.<p>It really seems like a lot of confusing eye-candy to me and my assumption would be that it&#x27;s cool&#x2F;fun for a sophisticated technocrat, but the usability falls apart quickly after that.<p>Personally, I hate the inline commenting ideas. I read an article, and then scan the comments at the bottom. It seems pretty gratuitous to save the effort of &quot;quoting&quot; snippets to discuss.<p>I appreciate them thinking differently about things, though.
jkaunisv1over 11 years ago
Technical and writer&#x27;s issues aside, it&#x27;s the &quot;things that matter&quot; that&#x27;s been sticking in my craw. I was so excited for it to be a browsable collection of thoughtful essays from around the world. Instead one of the first things I read on it was &quot;how to do task X on Windows&quot;. Now it&#x27;s just long-form twitter, which as I type it seems really obvious but I was hoping for the &quot;Things that matter&quot; to actually be a guiding point for Medium.
thehmeover 11 years ago
&quot;80&#x2F;20&quot; sounds good, but if what a blogger is writing is this good, then why not just create your own blog to attract their own audience? As the author said, it is free. Also, I would think that bloggers usually just want to share thoughtful articles and other information with the world and are not actually expecting to make money (I hope). I think a great idea is one that is just great (period) with or without any revenue.
bdzover 11 years ago
Every Medium post: &quot;I made this mistake so don&#x27;t you!&quot; and &quot;this is the way I do it, so you should!&quot;
评论 #6245228 未加载
leokunover 11 years ago
The criticism on the business or social aspects of Medium may be valid, but the technical team at Medium is very impressive. I hope they end up open sourcing some of the work they&#x27;ve done. Right now they are mostly experimenting, but eventually they will create a very awesome product with great technology.
评论 #6243545 未加载
评论 #6243491 未加载
pearjuiceover 11 years ago
Every Medium article I have read via HN (all of which were found on the frontpage) were edgy, self-absorbed and pretentious ramblings. I guess the platform promotes such behaviour by creating this &quot;cool kid bench&quot; and aiding others toward it with a feeling of elitism because they blog on Medium. I wonder when Yahoo (read: Marissa) will buy them!
评论 #6246659 未加载
stevewillowsover 11 years ago
With these writing platforms coming up its starting to feel like the glory days of LiveJournal.<p>I would like to see something that can step in as a social layer to connect a wide variety of blogs over a multitude of platforms. Maybe something that offers standardized categories - - like AllTop with self-discovery.
gringofyxover 11 years ago
I was going to post this on Medium too, but thought it might be in bad taste
评论 #6243585 未加载
qdpbover 11 years ago
There must be a name for a logical construct where you imagine an obscure explanation for a phenomenon, reject this explanation and then extrapolate this rejection to phenomenon itself.
评论 #6243596 未加载
sfardover 11 years ago
throwww.com might be a good alternative. No curation by editors. Recommended articles to come based on algorithms and not circle jerks. Full disclosure: I built it.
评论 #6245089 未加载
评论 #6245746 未加载