TE
TechEcho
Home24h TopNewestBestAskShowJobs
GitHubTwitter
Home

TechEcho

A tech news platform built with Next.js, providing global tech news and discussions.

GitHubTwitter

Home

HomeNewestBestAskShowJobs

Resources

HackerNews APIOriginal HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 TechEcho. All rights reserved.

Has the time come to kill the Remember Me checkbox? (2009)

29 pointsby movingaheadover 11 years ago

12 comments

GrinningFoolover 11 years ago
No, it&#x27;s time to kill passwords. If I need to log in, send me two links and&#x2F;or temporary auth codes: a persistent login clearly labeled, and a transient login for use in public places. If you&#x27;re a serious site (banks, utilities, etc), use two-factor auth, don&#x27;t accept anything less and of course, don&#x27;t persist my login.<p>Alternatively, I keep hoping to see user-controlled federated ID gaining traction - you know, a personal &#x27;wallet&#x27; that I maintain myself and store all of my identity in. And when you want to know who I am, you contact my server and it tells if if I approve it. I&#x27;d happily take this extra step every time. However, I&#x27;ve realized that this will never happen - too many people don&#x27;t care, and no major tech companies are willing to push it for fear for backlash.<p>While I&#x27;m wandering further off-subject (but still reasonably tangential): dear people who make marketing email systems, please stop requiring me to log in when I follow your unsubscribe link. One might begin to expect that you add this extra stumbling block to make it harder for me to do what I want - and that&#x27;s certainly no way to get my business. Every time I get an email from you, I&#x27;m reminded that I don&#x27;t want to be receiving them.<p>I suppose it&#x27;s possible that someone has hijacked my email credentials and that they may be fraudulently unsubscribing me. But that&#x27;s a risk I&#x27;m willing to take. You - you hypothetical marketer you - should be too, unless you&#x27;re a bank. A pissed off customer is not one who will do business with you no matter how many mailings you send.<p>edit: typos and correctness
评论 #6341517 未加载
评论 #6341129 未加载
评论 #6341107 未加载
评论 #6341045 未加载
basicallydanover 11 years ago
I don&#x27;t think so. Not in every case, anyway. The number of times I&#x27;ve been in an Internet cafe or hotel using a shared PC, in a rush because my taxi is waiting outside and I need to book a hotel in the next city...<p>It&#x27;s one less thing to worry about. Sure, they could have a keylogger, or a dodgy version of their web browser - but it&#x27;s one less thing to worry about when you&#x27;re already in a rush.
评论 #6341857 未加载
detcaderover 11 years ago
Are people really unable to imagine alternatives to a &quot;yes&#x2F;no&quot; debate? Certain websites should never have Remember Me checkboxes and should log you out when you close the tab, like banking websites (mine does have a Remember Me checkbox, for shame). There should be a convenience cost for security, or else you&#x27;re probably not doing security right. Unless it&#x27;s Reddit or something, there should be no Remember Me and the cookie should expire shortly or on closing the page.
评论 #6341654 未加载
评论 #6341392 未加载
falkflyerover 11 years ago
The biggest argument people seem to have is that &quot;users who are not tech savvy won&#x27;t remember to log out&quot;. Quick wake up call: users who aren&#x27;t tech savvy don&#x27;t know what &quot;remember me&quot; really does, and chances are they see it as a &quot;don&#x27;t make me log in again&quot; option which they will <i>always</i> prefer, even if it&#x27;s not as secure.<p>Typical users don&#x27;t have a concept of security, they only want convenience.
coinover 11 years ago
I&#x27;ve always found the browser&#x27;s password remembering feature annoying. I disable it immediately after installing it.
mathrawkaover 11 years ago
I never trust a Remember Me checkbox.<p>If I want to make sure I am not logged in anymore, I log out.
ollysbover 11 years ago
It seems like it should be a setting on the browser i.e. if it&#x27;s your own personal laptop then you probably want to always be remembered and if it&#x27;s an internet cafe then the browser should never remember your password. Maybe the browser could send a header indicating the preference(it could always be ignored - for bank websites etc).
评论 #6342090 未加载
评论 #6342308 未加载
kleibaover 11 years ago
I&#x27;ve got nothing against &#x27;Remember Me&#x27; checkboxes, if they were always <i>unchecked</i> by default.
评论 #6342093 未加载
dlwiestover 11 years ago
No, because some users share computers, or use school, library, store, etc. computers. Just check it by default. Problem solved.
评论 #6340655 未加载
donniezazenover 11 years ago
The problem is if &quot;Remember Me&quot; button is checked in then once you sign-in your information is already saved and you have to go through settings to remove it.<p>I don&#x27;t even &quot;Remember Me&quot; on my own system. LastPass takes care of it. First thing I do after installing a browser is to uncheck remember password.<p>It is an atrocious setting from nineties.
user2over 11 years ago
+1 for killing &quot;remember me&quot; checkbox
rokushoover 11 years ago
Public computers? Libraries?
评论 #6340854 未加载
评论 #6340662 未加载