TE
TechEcho
Home24h TopNewestBestAskShowJobs
GitHubTwitter
Home

TechEcho

A tech news platform built with Next.js, providing global tech news and discussions.

GitHubTwitter

Home

HomeNewestBestAskShowJobs

Resources

HackerNews APIOriginal HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 TechEcho. All rights reserved.

Constitutional Amendment Petition - Corporations are not people.

13 pointsby nalbyuitesover 11 years ago

5 comments

jasonlfunkover 11 years ago
Which rights exactly are you wanting to take away from corporations?<p>The provision of making corporations people gives them the rights to not be subjected to searches without warrants, to not be spied on by the NSA, to not be punished for speech, to own private land. Are you really in favor of taking these away?<p>By the way, this would not only effect the big evil corporations that you despise but the mom-and-pop shops that you love and all non-profit organizations, PACs, charities, churches, etc.<p>Is their corruption in corporations? Yes. Does that mean we should take away their rights? No. Just as lots of people say really dumb things that we don&#x27;t like, we don&#x27;t take away everyone&#x27;s freedom of speech.<p>This would have much bigger consequences than most people realize.
评论 #6386841 未加载
saosebastiaoover 11 years ago
The problem is...they <i>are</i> people because they are composed of people. The logic you use to defend the idea that groups of people shouldn&#x27;t be able to participate in the electoral process extends just as easily to unions, non-profit political organizations like MADD, and even political parties. The fact that they exist for making money is irrelevant, unless you would like to argue that making money is not a legitimate human interest.
评论 #6385943 未加载
评论 #6385733 未加载
acheronover 11 years ago
Because people have freedom of speech, and freedom of assembly, but FSM forbid they speak <i>while</i> assembled!
Dalkoreover 11 years ago
Corporations should be economic engines only. People can and should be forced to organize independently of a corporation. That preserves the balance in a democracy. I would also add that liability protection for the officers should be recinded. These two changes would have a profoundly postive effect on society.<p>LJ Miehe
DanielBMarkhamover 11 years ago
E-gads. Is this what HN has come to? Regurgitated political tripe of the week?<p>Flagged.<p>Kudos to the other commenters who are trying to un-fuck this. I just don&#x27;t have the time or patience for it.