TE
TechEcho
Home24h TopNewestBestAskShowJobs
GitHubTwitter
Home

TechEcho

A tech news platform built with Next.js, providing global tech news and discussions.

GitHubTwitter

Home

HomeNewestBestAskShowJobs

Resources

HackerNews APIOriginal HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 TechEcho. All rights reserved.

We’re All Nerds Now

29 pointsby eelkeover 10 years ago

13 comments

spindritfover 10 years ago
No, we&#x27;re not, at last not in the original meaning. Nerd used to mean someone obsessed and therefore knowledgeable about something (book nerd, comic nerd, or... The War Nerd[1]). Later geek took over that meaning and nerd moved towards someone socially awkward but smart.<p>Owning a smartwatch, reading a best seller novel, or watching a blockbuster doesn&#x27;t make anyone a nerd. Not any more than wearing aviator sunglasses makes me a pilot. Which is actually what nerd tends to mean now, a style, a fashion fad inspired by the original.<p>Ironically, yet also completely predictably when you think of it, the original demographic is starting to look down on the nerd interests of yesteryear. You can read very dismissive (and downright insulting but that&#x27;s a given) comments about anime and computer gaming on 4chan of all places.<p>[1] <a href="http://exiledonline.com/cat/war-nerd/" rel="nofollow">http:&#x2F;&#x2F;exiledonline.com&#x2F;cat&#x2F;war-nerd&#x2F;</a>
评论 #8315618 未加载
评论 #8315496 未加载
评论 #8315434 未加载
tobyover 10 years ago
Heh, I recently posted this on Facebook:<p>As I spent a sunny Sunday working through Project Euler problems in Haskell, I got a little sad that the word &quot;nerd&quot; has been re-appropriated to people who like video games ($100billion industry) or Star Wars (3rd highest grossing film of all time) or people who like phone apps (everyone in SF).<p>Is there a new word that&#x27;s been invented to take its place?
calvinsover 10 years ago
Being perceived as an intellectual of any type (nerd or otherwise) still mostly excludes one from public office above a certain level (in the USA, at least). Until that changes, it&#x27;s difficult to take the idea seriously.
评论 #8315603 未加载
评论 #8315563 未加载
_random_over 10 years ago
&quot;...the maker of Minecraft and one of the last independent gaming companies...&quot; - LOL, what?<p>&quot;...right now I have three devices — my phone, my Kindle, my iPod...&quot; - worlds most consumer-friendly devices. So nerdy.<p>Reminds me of a South Park classic: <a href="http://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=flippity-floppity-floo" rel="nofollow">http:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.urbandictionary.com&#x2F;define.php?term=flippity-flop...</a>
评论 #8315534 未加载
chiphover 10 years ago
I think there needs to be a distinction (when using the term Nerd) between people who use technology, and those who create it. Users of technology are more commonly called &quot;Customers&quot;. Or &quot;Consumers&quot; in the new parlance. Whereas traditional Nerds are far more deeply involved with the technology, and grok it in it&#x27;s fullness as they combine it into things never before seen.
评论 #8315491 未加载
评论 #8315505 未加载
BendertheRobotover 10 years ago
IMHO, I must respectfully disagree. It is easy for non-nerds to try defining nerds in their own image.<p>This is true especially for journalists. They have a conflict of interest in the matter.<p>Their interest is to sell content online or in the newspapers. To appeal to people&#x27;s self-aggrandizement is a very powerful motivation in this case.<p>Is that what Mr Cohen is doing? At a glance that&#x27;s not certain. However with regard to this opinion piece, reviewing definition of terms and how they are used, looking for logical fallacies, reviewing the background of people being interviewed and some healthy skepticism is warranted.<p>Journalists talking about science and scientists is not equivalent to a thorough understanding of it.
whoisthemachineover 10 years ago
sorry, but everybody * is not * a nerd until they&#x27;re reading articles on beam-forming with wifi antennas with rapt attention.
6d0debc071over 10 years ago
I&#x27;ve read a couple of history books, does that make me a historian now then?<p>What utter bullshit.
pocketheymanover 10 years ago
&gt;An engineering degree is also no longer a requisite to using technology, as seemingly anyone today can install a printer or upload a video.<p>Yikes - does that mean that we all needed engineering degrees to drive cars?
vezzy-fnordover 10 years ago
I&#x27;m not really convinced.<p>The article&#x27;s arguments for &quot;geek culture&quot; (might I add there is no such thing as a homogenous geek culture, but hey) proliferating are:<p>a) The recent popularity of sci-fi and superhero films.<p>b) The mass spread of consumer electronics and social media.<p>c) Computer technology becoming more accessible.<p>d) The information age enabling us to find trivia at a much faster rate than ever before.<p>e) Recent tech company acquisitions. (Twitch, Mojang, Oculus)<p>-------------------------<p>a) is not indicative of any long-term acceptance and popularity of &quot;geekdom&quot;. Sci-fi, superhero and fantasy films have fluctuated in popularity on and off over the past 40 years. We&#x27;re simply at another point where they&#x27;ve picked up again. In fact, the article does mention this quite neatly: &quot;In the past, there have been plenty of pop culture phenomena nerds could get behind — the frenzies surrounding the “Star Wars” and “Lord of the Rings” movie franchises are two potent examples.&quot;<p>This is out, then.<p>b) is a technological inevitability. It has nothing to do with a spike in &quot;geekdom&quot;. It&#x27;s just progress, and in fact, one might make an argument that it is, to some extent, a regression. This is due to the locked down and obscurantist nature of consumer electronics, which discourage hacking and where everything is buried under a smoke screen. Social media? The Web is becoming ever more ubiquitous, so of course social media will as well. Social media has become more practical due to advances in web technology.<p>c) is closely related to b). As I stated, it may actually well serve as an argument against proliferation of &quot;geekdom&quot;.<p>d) This means little, again. People have always been passionate about fiction they&#x27;re invested in, so it&#x27;s only normal that they&#x27;ll memorize factoids and trivia. Honestly, if people think the best thing that came out of the Information Age is being able to look up factoids about television shows, what a miserable failure it is then.<p>e) is just tech giants being tech giants. Hurray?<p>-----------------------<p>Finally, I&#x27;d like to state that <i>The Big Bang Theory</i> has a rather... mixed reception, to put it euphemistically. In addition, installing a printer isn&#x27;t always so simple. CUPS is nowhere near as bad as it used to be, but I still find myself having to reset the printer driver for the UI quite frequently, as it just arbitrarily blocks. I don&#x27;t know.<p>And of course, the irony of taking a jab at that &quot;homogenous, sexist geek culture&quot; while writing about how a very watered down variant of it might be becoming popular.
ProAmover 10 years ago
Just like we are all <i>hackers</i> now too. Just a societal fad in today&#x27;s participation ribbon receiving culture. Overall it&#x27;s a good thing though, helping to push&#x2F;pull people forward.
lazylizardover 10 years ago
i beg to differ. never has the gap between producer and consumer been so wide. what the consumer is seeing is getting more and more dumbed down, while the tech that runs behind the interface is getting more and more complicated.<p>its like (this is really vague, sorry)..once upon a time you interacted with your pc via cli..now you get a in-browser webgl game..<p>or..this certainly is not universal..but those people that have 3 devices often don&#x27;t even know how to add a mail account(whats pop3&#x2F;imap&#x2F;tls?)..
chronidover 10 years ago
People (outside IT) are not interested in <i>knowing</i> more about tech. For them technology is nothing more than magic, and they have no problem with that, nor at work or at home.<p>Having an iPhone in your hand does not make you a &quot;nerd&quot;. It makes you stupid in my eyes, when I discover you use it only for messaging and calls.
评论 #8315263 未加载
评论 #8315247 未加载