TE
TechEcho
Home24h TopNewestBestAskShowJobs
GitHubTwitter
Home

TechEcho

A tech news platform built with Next.js, providing global tech news and discussions.

GitHubTwitter

Home

HomeNewestBestAskShowJobs

Resources

HackerNews APIOriginal HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 TechEcho. All rights reserved.

Advice to a Beginning Graduate Student - Manuel Blum (CMU)

56 pointsby chromophoreover 15 years ago

8 comments

anatolyover 15 years ago
There's a lot of filler in there, but one advice that I found interesting was to write right back what you're reading (I take it to refer to technical material and not exposition - e.g. proofs and definitions). Anyone has any experience with trying that?<p>(I've tried this with math books before, but it always felt too tedious to keep up. But I suspect I may have tried to hard, going for a nicely formatted shortened exposition of the entire material; I didn't try to simply jot proofs and formulas down as I was reading them).
评论 #833048 未加载
评论 #833560 未加载
pkruminsover 15 years ago
I found this article extremely insightful and decided to prepare it for the print so that I could read it more carefully and add some notes on the margins.<p>While I was doing it, I realized how awfully true was the fact that science people _can't_ write.<p>No disrespect to Mr. Blum, but really, what is going on with the writing in this article? New line every several words, unconsistent emphasis, various writing styles, quick abbreviations in some places, but not in others, inconsistent division in paragraphs, several misspellings.
simplegeekover 15 years ago
When I was a kid, my father (an EE guy) used to tell me the importance of writing while reading. I mostly ignored that in my career and now a very smart person(Manuel Blum) has validated it. I hope there aren't many things (as told by my father) that I would want other smart people to validate ;(
ytersover 15 years ago
Did not realize this: "the median of n integers can be found with just O(n) comparisons."<p>Must figure this out!
评论 #833948 未加载
bowmanover 15 years ago
"Scrolls must be read like the Torah from one end to the other." - Associating Islam with being outdated can be good for your demographic I guess.
评论 #833586 未加载
TriinTover 15 years ago
I used to love to read these essays on how to be a good and productive grad student... until I came to grad school. Same with phdcomics.
评论 #832873 未加载
评论 #833001 未加载
modelic3over 15 years ago
This is actually quite good advice. It's not overly preachy and it's not overly poetic.
jmtameover 15 years ago
Advice to a beginning graduate student: do a start up instead ;)
评论 #833348 未加载
评论 #832950 未加载