TE
TechEcho
Home24h TopNewestBestAskShowJobs
GitHubTwitter
Home

TechEcho

A tech news platform built with Next.js, providing global tech news and discussions.

GitHubTwitter

Home

HomeNewestBestAskShowJobs

Resources

HackerNews APIOriginal HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 TechEcho. All rights reserved.

Silicon Valley’s Diversity Problem

15 pointsby sinemetu11over 10 years ago

10 comments

omonraover 10 years ago
So apparently there are &quot;many studies show that companies with gender and ethnic diversity tend to be more creative and more profitable, because varied perspectives help them design products and services that appeal to a diverse, worldwide audience.&quot;<p>Yet somehow this lack of diversity hasn&#x27;t prevented Google, Facebook and Apple from being very profitable and very creative.<p>Let&#x27;s take a stab and see what are these &quot;studies&quot; that show how diversity helps. Here is one (from the article NYT links to):<p>&quot;In a study conducted in 2003, Orlando Richard, a professor of management at the University of Texas at Dallas, and his colleagues surveyed executives at 177 national banks in the U.S., then put together a database comparing financial performance, racial diversity and the emphasis the bank presidents put on innovation. For innovation-focused banks, increases in racial diversity were clearly related to enhanced financial performance.&quot;<p>So we have exhibit A - the three most successful companies in the US that seem to do a-OK without diversity and exhibit B - a survey of bank executives about how they feel about diversity and innovation.<p>Let&#x27;s be honest - diversity has nothing to do with creativity or profitability. It&#x27;s a political construct that the NYT feels needs to be hoisted upon successful American companies. Because diversity.<p>[Edited typos]
评论 #8413069 未加载
vezzy-fnordover 10 years ago
So I quickly looked up the employee demographics for Google, Facebook and Apple (but particularly for the percentage balance of males and females, as that appears to be the hottest topic), and from their official sources the numbers are, respectively: 30% [1], 32% [2] and 30% [3].<p>The number of CS graduates who are women differs in how it&#x27;s gauged, but it&#x27;s roughly 18% [4].<p>Though obviously there are non-technical positions, even accounting only for tech jobs the numbers are still 17%, 15% and 20%, respectively. They all fit around the same range.<p>There&#x27;s certainly room for improvement, but I&#x27;m not sure why the onus should be on tech companies. They seem to be doing well enough with the available resource pool. Having profit-motivated entities be the initiators of social change seems like a clunky band-aid solution to me that won&#x27;t be of any particular efficacy.<p>[1] <a href="http://google.com/diversity/at-google.html" rel="nofollow">http:&#x2F;&#x2F;google.com&#x2F;diversity&#x2F;at-google.html</a><p>[2] <a href="http://newsroom.fb.com/news/2014/06/building-a-more-diverse-facebook/" rel="nofollow">http:&#x2F;&#x2F;newsroom.fb.com&#x2F;news&#x2F;2014&#x2F;06&#x2F;building-a-more-diverse-...</a><p>[3] <a href="https://www.apple.com/diversity/" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.apple.com&#x2F;diversity&#x2F;</a><p>[4] <a href="http://www.ncwit.org/sites/default/files/resources/btn_02282014web.pdf" rel="nofollow">http:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.ncwit.org&#x2F;sites&#x2F;default&#x2F;files&#x2F;resources&#x2F;btn_02282...</a>
评论 #8412530 未加载
评论 #8412606 未加载
jaysonelliotover 10 years ago
Silicon Valley&#x27;s diversity problem is a corollary to its monoculture problem. Every startup mentor, speaker, blogger, etc. has the same advice to budding entrepreneurs: &quot;hire your friends.&quot;<p>We&#x27;re told to hire people who we know, or people that are known and trusted by those we&#x27;ve already hired. One of the first things that will happen if you&#x27;re hired at Facebook or Google is that HR will sit down with you and ask you to make a list of every smart person you&#x27;ve ever worked with, so they can try to recruit them.<p>No one sets out to create a monoculture (we hope), or to build a workforce without diversity. Silicon Valley is filled with intelligent, well-meaning, ambitious people who I believe are truly interested in a meritocracy.<p>But look around. Who&#x27;s founding the companies that get funded? There&#x27;s a reason you get dozens of Snapchat wannabes, &quot;sharing economy&quot; startups, and social apps. VCs are emotional creatures just like anyone else, and they follow the herd, where it&#x27;s safe. That also means they&#x27;re funding founders who live nearby, and come with a warm intro and a recommendation.<p>Companies in the Valley are founded by a relatively homogenous slice of the American demographic, whether you&#x27;re looking at race, age, background, socioeconomic status, or what have you. When you then tell those founders to minimize risk by hiring through personal networks, you create a foundation for a culture that will continue to look homogenous as the company scales and grows.<p>If you&#x27;ve ever been involved in hiring in the Valley, or interviewed with any tech companies here, you&#x27;ve probably heard the words &quot;culture fit.&quot; It&#x27;s an insidious phrase, one that may start with good intentions, but ends up excluding good people, valuable hires who might have brought a much-needed diversity of thought, insight, and perspective to a company.<p>Silicon Valley wants to be a meritocracy, and it&#x27;s not against diversity. But it&#x27;s got a culture that&#x27;s currently designed, albeit unintentionally, to create copies of itself and the people who are already here.
rectangover 10 years ago
The article exhorts the tech industry to tackle the problem of diversity immediately rather than wait for relief from the pipeline. So what are some things we can do as individuals, right now?<p>One thing that has worked for me over the years is choosing to be an &quot;ally&quot; of &quot;outsiders&quot; -- ensure that people get invited to meetings or other functions who otherwise might be left out, make sure that they are consulted for their opinions consistently, make it apparent that you, personally, value diversity through your actions. The effect is to rebalance the ratio of outsiders to insiders so that people don&#x27;t feel surrounded and outnumbered.<p>Other suggestions?<p>Eventually, we&#x27;ll all be &quot;outsiders&quot; thanks to age, so it&#x27;s in everyone&#x27;s interest to mitigate this problem.
lhnzover 10 years ago
Can anybody theorise to me on why asian men are an exception to the lack of diversity?
评论 #8412317 未加载
评论 #8412499 未加载
评论 #8412342 未加载
评论 #8412340 未加载
评论 #8412362 未加载
tzsover 10 years ago
The article they cite to support the claim that diversity promotes creativity cites studies that looked at problem solving and communication in small groups.<p>The interesting thing about those studies is that what they seem to show is that what is important is that there be someone in the group who you perceive as being different in some significant way. It appears that what is going on is that when you see everyone in a group as being the same as you, you expect everyone to think the same, and aren&#x27;t as open to new ideas, and don&#x27;t put as much effort into promoting your ideas.<p>Most of the studies used race as the difference, putting one or two blacks in a group of whites. One used politics, comparing two democrats or two republicans against mixed pairs, and one used groups where the diversity was geographic.<p>That raises some interesting questions. In the following let&#x27;s take as a baseline a small group of white males.<p>Does the degree of difference make a difference? Is adding a black female better than adding a black male to the group, because she differs on both race and gender?<p>What differences besides race, politics, and geography matter? We are all white males in the engineering jobs at my office, but we are split evenly between married with children people and single people. We&#x27;ve also got a nice split between liberals and conservatives. Are these enough differences to max out our creativity?<p>There&#x27;s a lot a more research needed here.
golemotronover 10 years ago
Still, nothing about age in relation to diversity.
评论 #8412403 未加载
1dundundunover 10 years ago
For a long time, the popular belief in SV was that a lack of diversity actually helps an early stage startup.<p>We&#x27;ve probably all heard the story about how Paypal rejected a candidate that aced his engineering tests because he said he &quot;likes to play hoops&quot; in his free time. They decided that a guy who likes to play basketball would not be a good culture fit.<p>So, if that was the thought process that the Paypal Mafia left the nest with, it&#x27;s not hard to see how we ended up in the situation we&#x27;re in regarding diversity.<p>Side note: Like others, I also wonder how age gets left out of this diversity debate. That&#x27;s pretty interesting...
patrickg_zillover 10 years ago
Does anyone seriously believe that this will result in lower costs or improved products and&#x2F;or services?<p>Sorry to say, my view is that it will just lead to a lot more paper-pushing or other make-work jobs.<p>EDIT to add: if it is about money, most would rather take up law.
评论 #8412444 未加载
评论 #8412379 未加载
ausjkeover 10 years ago
I noticed too many black players in NBA and it has a diversity problem, the number&#x2F;ratio of African American players in NBA league should be dramatically limited for diversity.<p>Asian is the _real_ minority(or tinority) in USA, somehow it is not treated as such when we talk about college, IT jobs etc. Maybe it&#x27;s not just about the percentage of population? IT is also a highly skilled profession, similar to NBA players to some extent.<p>I&#x27;m all for diversity everywhere, but it seems the status quo is more likely from nature force&#x2F;choice instead of simple intentional discrimination. To fully better it, we need check the diversity in those who are taking the hard courses in STEM majors, it&#x27;s difficult to hire a non-STEM students for IT jobs.<p>Then we&#x27;re back to round 1, I think it&#x27;s the diversity on STEM major choices from highschool&#x2F;college deciding the end result in SV. For that, there is only so much the government can help.
评论 #8412733 未加载