TE
TechEcho
Home24h TopNewestBestAskShowJobs
GitHubTwitter
Home

TechEcho

A tech news platform built with Next.js, providing global tech news and discussions.

GitHubTwitter

Home

HomeNewestBestAskShowJobs

Resources

HackerNews APIOriginal HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 TechEcho. All rights reserved.

Apple challenges new Woolworths logo

10 pointsby xelferover 15 years ago

7 comments

jballancover 15 years ago
Before everyone jumps on the Apple-hate bandwagon, keep in mind that unlike copyright, which is implicitly granted upon authorship, and patent rights, which are guaranteed upon successful filing, holding a trademark demands a vigorous defense. If Apple were not to lodge complaints like this (and the one against PlaNYC), then they run the risk of becoming the next Xerox or Kleenex.<p>In other words, the goal here is not necessarily to get Woolworths to change their logo, but rather to get it on the record that they were defending their brand.<p>(see for more: <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trademark#Maintaining_trademark_rights" rel="nofollow">http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trademark#Maintaining_trademark...</a>)
cunninglinguistover 15 years ago
Apple: some of the whiniest bitches on the planet. "No, you can't use our trademarked glossy chat bubbles in your $5 iPhone app! We own rounded rectangles with gradients! The ratio of people to cake is enormous!!"<p>Seriously, as a longtime user of trendy/overpriced Apple products, these stories piss me off and "erode confidence" in Apple as an honest and aboveboard company. The more successful they become, the less I like how they comport themself in the marketplace. Nothing wrong with defending your legitimate trademarks, but this sort of shot across the bow really makes Apple seem, on the whole, like a gaggle of paranoid hubristic geek bitchmongers.
评论 #861021 未加载
评论 #861245 未加载
tdm911over 15 years ago
Until I read this I had never even realised that the Woolworths logo was in the shape of an apple, and they are my local supermarket.
评论 #860965 未加载
whatusernameover 15 years ago
To speak in Apple's defence here: I'm not sure this is 100% overreaching. Woolworths (and Coles) are producing a whole lot of branded in-house products.<p>That now includes Mobile Phone SIM cards. (Not handsets that I'm aware of - YET)<p>It might also include stuff like blank CD's, MP3 Players, and whatever other stuff they have down the stationary aisle. (I'll check tonight and reply later) Certainly that logo would look suspicious on a MP3 player. (And also certainly - apple have no complain against a home-brand muesli)<p>Apple might have learnt from their past - think Apple Records and the fact that "Apple computer" weren't in the same business as them..
评论 #861120 未加载
protomythover 15 years ago
Many wish for copyright reform, but I sometimes think trademark reform (taking out the vigorously defend clause) might be needed more.
TomOfTTBover 15 years ago
I await the day when Apple sues Christianity, Islam, Judaism et al. for featuring an Apple with a bite out of it in their origin story which is in clear violation of Apple's established trademarks.
评论 #861051 未加载
aurora72over 15 years ago
As an Apple user, I'm horrified.<p>The way they question the Woolworths logo looks sort of like a huge monster trying to crush a small fly with their iron-covered feet.<p>This has got certainly nothing to do with defending a trademark logo, but more to do with extreme intolerance and total isolation from the world.