TE
TechEcho
Home24h TopNewestBestAskShowJobs
GitHubTwitter
Home

TechEcho

A tech news platform built with Next.js, providing global tech news and discussions.

GitHubTwitter

Home

HomeNewestBestAskShowJobs

Resources

HackerNews APIOriginal HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 TechEcho. All rights reserved.

The Tyranny of Experts

8 pointsby codexjourneysover 10 years ago

2 comments

thaumaturgyover 10 years ago
&gt; <i>If you’re not recognized as an expert by another team of experts, it’s difficult to reach an audience. This is true even if you really are an expert.</i><p>This can be simplified to, &quot;It&#x27;s difficult to reach an audience.&quot; The meaning is exactly the same.<p>&gt; <i>Leonardo da Vinci</i><p>Was an expert in his fields at the time. He spent many many hours studying anatomy and nature.<p>&gt; <i>Galileo</i><p>Also an expert.<p>&gt; <i>Einstein</i><p>Probably the most over-used and incorrect example used by people who want to trot out the &quot;lone under-appreciated genius&quot; trope. The whole &quot;patent clerk revolutionizes physics&quot; notion is peculiarly attractive to western culture. Unfortunately, the actual truth is, &quot;brilliant man who attended university, diligently studied the hardest mathematics of the day, and took a job while he spent years working on just a couple of problems in one field.&quot;<p>&gt; <i>More often, academics seem to be rewarded for incremental breakthroughs, not out-of-paradigm thinking.</i><p>Subject hobbyists consistently underestimate the value of incremental improvement in science. Most of scientific and technological progress comes in the way of incremental improvements. &quot;Great leaps&quot; usually only happen after a sufficient number of incremental improvements have made them possible.<p>&gt; <i>But ridicule has a higher volume today</i><p>You&#x27;re not likely to be thrown in prison for believing something contrary to the religious faith of the day, like Galileo was. Who cares what happens on social media?<p>&gt; <i>It’s a tough choice: Even if you’re right, you may be ridiculed and discredited</i><p>That&#x27;s why you have to do the work to prove you&#x27;re right, instead of just claiming you are and then being unhappy when other people challenge your notions.<p>There is a real danger in counting yourself among the persecuted and reading only casually about historical heroes of scientific and technological progress. You can end up with a very distorted view of how progress works.
评论 #8814728 未加载
eternalbanover 10 years ago
I certainly treasure my periods of solitude. The closed lipped Oyster produces the Pearl.