TE
TechEcho
Home24h TopNewestBestAskShowJobs
GitHubTwitter
Home

TechEcho

A tech news platform built with Next.js, providing global tech news and discussions.

GitHubTwitter

Home

HomeNewestBestAskShowJobs

Resources

HackerNews APIOriginal HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 TechEcho. All rights reserved.

Ask HN: Friend and I want to start a business

5 pointsby showsoverover 10 years ago
We&#x27;re in Belgium, which determines the main part of our question.<p>My friend and I have an idea that could have a nice future. At the current stage it&#x27;s just that, an idea. My friend wants to go and get a patent in his name (it was his idea), and then start a company together, to THEN build the product.<p>This requires investment much larger than I can contribute (€5k), which would shit the company from a 50-50 split (me being the technical person, he being the one with the idea and money) to something which I think would not be good for me. In Belgium there exists the option to start a BVBA, which takes around €18k, or we can start an NV, which takes ~ €60k.<p>I think it&#x27;s completely crazy to invest all this money without even having a prototype or any non-paying customers. On the other hand, I don&#x27;t know how we could make something that people are willing to pay for without actually charging them and having them pay, without such an investment.<p>My thought would be to first create a prototype, get feedback and non-paying customers, to finally start a company and charge people.<p>I basically have 2 fears: 1) invest money without having 1 customer or even 1 user 2) get shafted (see: jobs &amp; wozniak)<p>So who do I talk to, what do I research?

5 comments

yellow_and_grayover 10 years ago
&gt; he being the one with the idea and money<p>Ideas are worth $0. Nevermind you&#x27;ll switch the idea to something else.<p>And the type of person who wants to a get patent first instead of getting users is precisely the kind of person you shouldn&#x27;t be starting a company with. A patent won&#x27;t get you customers. How many companies can you friend name that lost to another company because of a patent rather than a thousand other reasons?<p>Both your fears are valid. Trust your gut. My suggestion: don&#x27;t start a company with this friend.
评论 #8872649 未加载
phantom_oracleover 10 years ago
You do realize that setting up a company is a waste of time&#x2F;resources, as getting a verified and valid patent is quite expensive too?<p>Take all the resources people are providing you and also try to find a nice lawyer friend who can draft up a type of document where the initial patent is filed under the friends name until a certain point where it is feasible to setup a company.<p>Once the company is setup (51&#x2F;49??), you then transfer the patent to the company, to prevent the patent owner from exploiting any future profits through legal means.<p>Also remember that no VC (even in Silicon Valley) will give you seed money if the patent is not under a corporate name.
charlesdmover 10 years ago
Minimum share capital with two shareholders in a BVBA is €6200, i.e €3100 each. Nothing wrong with setting up an entity, but at the same time, there are alternatives in Belgium (e.g. a VOF), if you&#x27;re strapped for cash.<p>You could set up a &quot;joint ownership&quot; document for the IP rights, which won&#x27;t be worth much, but better than nothing.<p>This said, I would focus on getting customers first. Face it, if this is your first product, you&#x27;ll probably fail. It&#x27;s a cycle everyone goes through. :-)
评论 #8872665 未加载
JSeymourATLover 10 years ago
&gt; So who do I talk to, what do I research?<p>You MUST seek out and talk to the Economic Buyer. That&#x27;s the individual who&#x27;s life will be helped by purchasing your product or service. The more you understand his world, the stronger your idea will be.<p>Incidentally, you CAN sell a concept on a pilot project basis. The customer becomes your first investor.
Vomzorover 10 years ago
If you want local advice, try contacting <a href="http://startups.be/" rel="nofollow">http:&#x2F;&#x2F;startups.be&#x2F;</a>
评论 #8872667 未加载