TE
TechEcho
Home24h TopNewestBestAskShowJobs
GitHubTwitter
Home

TechEcho

A tech news platform built with Next.js, providing global tech news and discussions.

GitHubTwitter

Home

HomeNewestBestAskShowJobs

Resources

HackerNews APIOriginal HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 TechEcho. All rights reserved.

Soylent 1.4: a quick review

40 pointsby jmgrosenabout 10 years ago

15 comments

vhost-about 10 years ago
I&#x27;m not going to run-on and on here, but I&#x27;m on 1.4 right now (first time Soylent user) and I&#x27;m pleasantly surprised.<p>I was very skeptical about it at first and got it just to convince myself I didn&#x27;t need it. Immediately I felt pretty good and didn&#x27;t crave the burrito I wanted for lunch.<p>I&#x27;m also very excited that it&#x27;s vegan because that&#x27;s been my diet for over 8 years.
评论 #9265058 未加载
评论 #9265424 未加载
评论 #9265108 未加载
kileywmabout 10 years ago
I&#x27;m almost finished with my first shipment (formula 1.3) and my results have been positive. I use it to replace some, but not all, meals in my diet. I think it especially excels in situations where I am in a hurry or too lazy to cook, because it&#x27;s far more nutritious and cost-effective than the meals I would eat&#x2F;skip otherwise.<p>I currently have my subscription set up so that I receive 2 weeks work of Soylent every month.<p>Breakdown: 500 calories per meal ~$2.33 per meal<p>How I use it:<p>Complete meal&#x2F;snack replacement for breakfast and lunch most days. Rarely have it for dinner.<p>What I&#x27;ve learned so far:<p>Don&#x27;t drink it right after you mix it unless you shake it really really well, otherwise you&#x27;ll encounter clumps. Given at least an hour to soak in water, it reaches a clumpless consistency.<p>The taste is fairly neutral with a slight hint of malty sweetness. Some people rave about using it as a coffee creamer, but I myself have not tried that.<p>The texture is grainy in comparison to a smoothie, but this is to be expected with a powder-based meal.<p>It&#x27;s filling, very easy to drink when chilled, and the bowel movements are regular in frequency (and consistency!) with no notable increase in gas.<p>So far I&#x27;m pretty happy with it. It strikes me as a good deal healthier and ridiculously more convenient than anything else I&#x27;d make for myself, meal-wise, if you can tolerate sacrificing flavor and texture.
kposehnabout 10 years ago
I&#x27;m almost done with my 1.3 and looking forward to 1.4. The big thing for me is the lack of the oil bottle and the sodium (I wasn&#x27;t getting enough before and would get headaches).<p>At this point, my body has fully adjusted and I crave Soylent at some times. I use it for ~1&#x2F;2 my meals and could easily see it taking 2&#x2F;3. I do enjoy regular food a _lot_ so I doubt I&#x27;ll ever go full time, but it definitely has helped to balance out my nutrition fully.<p>I continue to feel that Soylent is the first company that will likely feed the world - literally. Without the oil bottle and the ability to scale manufacturing, it is only a matter of time before we see Soylent as part of humanitarian convoys and&#x2F;or used in medical settings. The possibilities are quite frankly amazing...
评论 #9264918 未加载
评论 #9264897 未加载
评论 #9264898 未加载
评论 #9265145 未加载
mrfusionabout 10 years ago
It still seems very expensive. $12&#x2F;day? Also I wish I could buy a 1 day sample. I&#x27;d hate to be out $85 if I don&#x27;t like it.
评论 #9264982 未加载
评论 #9265030 未加载
评论 #9265091 未加载
评论 #9265110 未加载
评论 #9264994 未加载
评论 #9265009 未加载
FreakyTabout 10 years ago
Glad to see they&#x27;ve integrated the separate oil bottle -- that will make it way more portable.<p>On another note, I hope that the increase in manufacturing capacity will eventually allow Soylet to be purchased through traditional retail channels -- it&#x27;d be nice to just buy it by the package instead of bulk-orders online.
stevebotabout 10 years ago
I like the idea of Soylent, but everything I have read lately on nutrition seems to suggest that gettings vitamins and minerals from real food should be a priority and is against multivitamins. I wonder what is people&#x27;s view on Soylent as a replacement for fruits&#x2F;vegetables? Is the nutritional makeup somehow different from a multi-vitamin? If it isn&#x27;t, then it just seems like an overpriced protein powder alternative. I can&#x27;t seem to find any info on their site.
评论 #9265579 未加载
mrfusionabout 10 years ago
Has anyone lost weight on this? I&#x27;d also be curious if it lowered your blood pressure [1] if it was high, and if it helped with any other health issues.<p>[1] I&#x27;m thinking the high potassium, and low sodium could lower high blood pressure?
评论 #9266121 未加载
评论 #9265053 未加载
mrfusionabout 10 years ago
It seems odd to remove fiber? Does anyone know if it has enough fiber?
评论 #9264976 未加载
评论 #9264884 未加载
DustyDiscoveryabout 10 years ago
You&#x27;ll get more detailed user opinions on the soylent forum.<p>I go through 3 bags a week. I&#x27;m on my second of 1.4:<p>The sugar crashes I would get in previous versions are significantly reduced in 1.4. The artificial vanilla flavor made 1.3 tastier; 1.4 is easier to prep but its blend of oils and lack of grittiness makes it smoother and slimier.<p>Unmodified 1.4 digests slightly better than 1.3 for me. 1.3 digested best for me when I added psyllium husk. I&#x27;ll be adding that again next batch to test.
评论 #9264992 未加载
mrfusionabout 10 years ago
Maybe a dumb question, but how would you use this at work? Do you mix it up at home in the morning and bring it in? Or just mix it at your desk?
评论 #9264950 未加载
评论 #9264997 未加载
rckrdabout 10 years ago
I think the supply shortage of soylent initially helped with their marketing and buzz.<p>I wonder if they are now claiming an artificial shortage to try and continue to sustain the illusion.
weegoabout 10 years ago
You can powderise oils using maltodextrin, it&#x27;s a trick that a lot of gastro-chefs have been using for years. Turns back into oil in the presence of any liquid.
rjurneyabout 10 years ago
Things in plants other than basic nutrients are what keep you alive, well and free of cancer. Soylent is an obviously horrible idea for your health.
评论 #9265266 未加载
评论 #9265129 未加载
评论 #9265106 未加载
评论 #9265132 未加载
mrcwinnabout 10 years ago
Is Soylent on SemVer? Does anyone know if 1.4 is another breaking (wind) change?<p>I would like to apologize to the entire HN community.
mizzaoabout 10 years ago
I wonder what it would be like if some food products were versioned 0.x, like OSS projects :)