TE
TechEcho
Home24h TopNewestBestAskShowJobs
GitHubTwitter
Home

TechEcho

A tech news platform built with Next.js, providing global tech news and discussions.

GitHubTwitter

Home

HomeNewestBestAskShowJobs

Resources

HackerNews APIOriginal HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 TechEcho. All rights reserved.

Samuel Colt's “YC app” for the Summer 1851 batch

277 pointsby blueintegralabout 10 years ago

18 comments

Devthrowaway80about 10 years ago
I don&#x27;t see this being a viable product.<p>1) For a machine shop owner, you can already build such a &quot;multi-shot gun&quot; yourself quite trivially. I have a setup in my barn where I can spot-weld seven rifles together along the length of the barrel. I then use a bunch of loops of baling wire that run from the triggers to the end of the stock so that I can fire the correct rifle without any awkwardness.<p>I haven&#x27;t tried this with pistols but the general approach should be the same.<p>2) My system also has the benefit of me not being tied to one company&#x27;s proprietary standard of &quot;interchangeable&quot; parts. If you buy a Colt, you&#x27;re stuck buying Colt parts forever. With my system, I can weld together any guns I want.<p>3) It does not seem very &quot;viral&quot;.
hedgewabout 10 years ago
Sounds neat, but..<p>- How are you going to scale production to meet demands? Does not look like you could reach the kind of growth YC wants. - Who is this guy and why should I trust his guns? How do I tell how many bullets I have left? - Seems like rearming would be a pain! Reloading just one chamber is already difficult.
评论 #9290720 未加载
评论 #9290792 未加载
评论 #9290520 未加载
tlbabout 10 years ago
That&#x27;s a well-written app. It clearly explains what they&#x27;re doing, why it&#x27;s important, and why they&#x27;re the right team to execute on it.
评论 #9294561 未加载
johngaltabout 10 years ago
Seems like the barrel is a single point of failure. How is this better than simply carrying more than one pistol? Allowing complete fail-over in case of a malfunction.<p>Pretty design, but the proprietary projectiles breaks compatibility with existing arms.
评论 #9291695 未加载
chug2kabout 10 years ago
Pretty funny, but I&#x27;ve been working on this post about the same thing for the Wright Brothers: <a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;news.ycombinator.com&#x2F;item?id=9291316" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;news.ycombinator.com&#x2F;item?id=9291316</a>. Great minds think alike. Maybe if we could put some guns on a plane...
评论 #9291699 未加载
sophaclesabout 10 years ago
Rejected, doesn&#x27;t know the market:<p><pre><code> It&#x27;s much safer and more reliable than flintlock, which is what people are using now. </code></pre> In the enterprise of war, we use percussion caps these days.
评论 #9291970 未加载
prjwabout 10 years ago
Funny idea. Are there more examples of fictional YC applications of historical or modern companies?
评论 #9290473 未加载
评论 #9292459 未加载
sparkzillaabout 10 years ago
Someone just showed us an idea like this right before you guys. We don&#x27;t like it. What else do you have?
lucozadeabout 10 years ago
Rejected. Won&#x27;t move to SV. Takes to long.<p>Now if someone would only hack the isthmus of Panama...Hmmm
tdaltoncabout 10 years ago
I can&#x27;t believe they didn&#x27;t mention their big US navy contract! Cartridged rounds are a big plus at sea!
评论 #9291758 未加载
评论 #9291073 未加载
bluerailabout 10 years ago
Wow, really neat and well executed.<p>I was thinking of doing an similar product but couldn&#x27;t get time for it.. All the best for you guys.<p>BTW, Are you planning for global reach or targeting only local?
hrayrabout 10 years ago
I opened the video link in the background while I read the application. For the first two minutes I thought the drive in my macbook pro was going bad.
EGregabout 10 years ago
I think they have done a great job doing things that don&#x27;f scale. Also they have a lot of paying customers and traction.<p>But I am worried that this might be a solo founder type team. We invest in teams, not just products. You&#x27;d be surprised how many times an idea changes midway through the project, and you will need each other to keep going.
tdaltoncabout 10 years ago
Compared this to apps friends have shown me, this is really concise.
wehadfunabout 10 years ago
So would they get in?
评论 #9290575 未加载
tehchromicabout 10 years ago
tough competition this batch
madaxe_againabout 10 years ago
Ah, they have revenue and users!? This sounds like a feasible business model. Rejected.
tiffanyricksabout 10 years ago
Hilarious!!! I did not like the application. I am glad it was a joke.