TE
科技回声
首页24小时热榜最新最佳问答展示工作
GitHubTwitter
首页

科技回声

基于 Next.js 构建的科技新闻平台,提供全球科技新闻和讨论内容。

GitHubTwitter

首页

首页最新最佳问答展示工作

资源链接

HackerNews API原版 HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 科技回声. 版权所有。

Facebook Reactions

92 点作者 septerr超过 9 年前

27 条评论

gkoberger超过 9 年前
Why all the negativity here? You can still like things, comment with text, or just not use Facebook. Nobody will ever be forced to use these emoticons, and nobody at Facebook is saying you can only express these 6 emotions while using Facebook.<p>I also don&#x27;t get why everyone feels FB owes them a dislike button. It seems like <i>that</i> would be a bad feature.<p>Personally, I think it&#x27;s a good change. It won&#x27;t change Facebook much, but it certainly won&#x27;t do harm.
评论 #10357378 未加载
评论 #10356888 未加载
评论 #10357036 未加载
camillomiller超过 9 年前
People wanted a dislike button, got a series of redundant emoticons with very little space for actual disagreement. Which is actually good, because it won&#x27;t transform Facebook into a mess of flames and negativity. Wait, maybe it&#x27;s already too late for that...
评论 #10357290 未加载
评论 #10356594 未加载
评论 #10356926 未加载
minimaxir超过 9 年前
Anyone remember YouTube Reactions? Died because no one used them.<p>Hell, even <i>BuzzFeed</i>, the pioneer of reaction culture, implemented Reactions but are slowly depreciating them.
评论 #10356480 未加载
评论 #10356705 未加载
frofroggy超过 9 年前
I wonder if they chose the angry reaction to follow the nonviolent communication pattern: &lt;emotion&gt; due to &lt;specific action leading to emotion&gt; followed by &lt;need hindered by action&gt; followed by &lt;specific request to meet the need&gt;.<p>For example, &quot;I felt angry when you wrote that any realistic web browser has to support Javascript. I have a need for using a text browser to bypass abuses of Javascript on websites with articles, so I would like you to view &lt;specific article&gt; with both w3m and Firefox.&quot;<p>The &quot;dislike&quot; action would not fit the nonviolent communication pattern.
msoad超过 9 年前
I&#x27;ve seen this in a developer phone. The downside is &quot;number of likes&quot; will be lower because those other emotions are not counted as &quot;likes&quot; and there is no indicator of how many total reactions you got. Of course you can add it up but it&#x27;s not calculated by default.
评论 #10356621 未加载
评论 #10356742 未加载
评论 #10356460 未加载
kzhahou超过 9 年前
I&#x27;ve really enjoyed being able to congratulate friends on the birth of their children or their birthdays, with just one click. Super excited to be able to send one-click condolences now!
acheron超过 9 年前
Livejournal&#x27;s &quot;mood icons&quot; were the first thing I thought of.<p>(Though the standing joke with LJ was that they could save space by eliminating all the mood icons except for &quot;angsty&quot;...)
评论 #10357181 未加载
Canada超过 9 年前
Wow I&#x27;m so excited that I can now express myself with a range of Facebook approved emotions!
评论 #10356873 未加载
评论 #10356568 未加载
评论 #10356764 未加载
TazeTSchnitzel超过 9 年前
Reminds me of Slack&#x27;s emoji responses to messages. Alas, we don&#x27;t have quite as much flexibility here. Being able to respond to things with sneks is fun.
crabasa超过 9 年前
And not even a courtesy hat tip to Slack. Tsk tsk.
评论 #10356325 未加载
grovulent超过 9 年前
I&#x27;m genuinely trying to understand how this has any significance at all. They are implementing emoticons - all of which could be expressed in other ways on the platform (in a comment etc).<p>The only thing that changes is that now facebook will be able to explicitly map the emoticon expression to the posted content - something that humans could do already given the contextual clues in the use of an emoticon in a comment.<p>Generally, people &quot;like&quot; the person far more than the like the content (i.e. it&#x27;s various aspects of the person, e.g. status, that are primarily causal with respect to others wanting to click that &#x27;like&#x27; button.) My prediction is that people will be unlikely to use these extra buttons because they confuse this essential signalling game. A &#x27;wow&#x27; emoticon, for example - can often be ambiguous as to whether or not you are aligning with the recipient, or signalling negatively toward them. Thus folks will struggle with the fear of sending the wrong signal.<p>If facebook persists and people do start using them - then the result will be a greater number of signalling failures, increased conflict, and greater user dissatisfaction.
orbifold超过 9 年前
I wonder if one of the new options simply gets adopted as &quot;dislike&quot; by convention, maybe Yay would be a good candidate.
评论 #10356715 未加载
评论 #10356706 未加载
raymondgh超过 9 年前
I liked the insightful&#x2F;interesting&#x2F;informative&#x2F;funny on slashdot, maybe this will work out like that. Anyway, why not test a new feature? I see a lot of cynical comments here. And since when does Zuckerberg announce new features from his fb account? That&#x27;s pretty cool.
myth_buster超过 9 年前
Would just clicking on the &quot;Like&quot; button consider it as like or would the users have to hold press and select &quot;Like&quot;?<p>If someone has already selected &quot;Wow&quot;, &quot;Sad&quot; or something similar, it perhaps would be useful to just click on the icon next to aggregation rather than doing the long-press behavior.<p>I suppose on the desktop site, perhaps mouseover may show the reactions.<p>I think overall it requires more effort on the user&#x27;s part as opposed to just clicking on the like button and moving on. Which perhaps was the reason for the like button&#x27;s initial success.
评论 #10356675 未加载
worldofsofte超过 9 年前
Innovation by some of the world&#x27;s better engineers.
评论 #10356717 未加载
RyanZAG超过 9 年前
They added &#x27;angry&#x27; ? That looks very much the same as &#x27;dislike&#x27; to me. He doesn&#x27;t bring it up in his message either so it was probably a late addition.<p>I have a feeling &#x27;angry&#x27; will be used whenever you don&#x27;t like what someone is saying: it&#x27;s the same thing?
评论 #10357265 未加载
eigenbom超过 9 年前
I look forward to Facebook Actions. Instead of just poking imagine what else you can do..
评论 #10356925 未加载
dang超过 9 年前
Also <a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;news.ycombinator.com&#x2F;item?id=10356539" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;news.ycombinator.com&#x2F;item?id=10356539</a>.
anjc超过 9 年前
My Facebook newsfeed looks very childish with these icons dotted throughout. It&#x27;s horrible, and I don&#x27;t think it could be rolled out.
NoGravitas超过 9 年前
My main gripe with this is they didn&#x27;t include the two main reactions I have to Facebook posts: <i>cringe</i> and <i>gulag</i>.
tdkl超过 9 年前
Is it possible to see the list who reacted with a certain emoji or is this only as it was with likes?
feider超过 9 年前
Could we just agree that &#x2F;P symbolizes a downward thumb. No need for the dislike button.
评论 #10356575 未加载
guelo超过 9 年前
I wonder what this does to the &quot;your friend liked this&quot; advertising.
discardorama超过 9 年前
.... aaaand Facebook&#x27;s MySpacification begins.
redbrick超过 9 年前
Brilliant! The design kept the primary operation to be the like. And, elegantly provides an &#x27;advanced&#x27; secondary operation for those that want a more nuanced expression.
Shish2k超过 9 年前
For disagreement, write a comment explaining &#x2F;why&#x2F; you disagree.<p>(It&#x27;s similar to HN&#x27;s policy* of &quot;prefer discussion to downvotes&quot;)<p>* EDIT: I mean culture; as in I&#x27;ve seen it mentioned a lot by users of the site, though it&#x27;s not in the rules
评论 #10356762 未加载
评论 #10357164 未加载
评论 #10356479 未加载
hockeybias超过 9 年前
Caring...