TE
科技回声
首页24小时热榜最新最佳问答展示工作
GitHubTwitter
首页

科技回声

基于 Next.js 构建的科技新闻平台,提供全球科技新闻和讨论内容。

GitHubTwitter

首页

首页最新最佳问答展示工作

资源链接

HackerNews API原版 HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 科技回声. 版权所有。

Why I'm Fed Up with TED

18 点作者 cawel超过 17 年前

16 条评论

mechanical_fish超过 17 年前
Look, I'm all in favor of opening up opportunities to more people, but let's get real: TED excludes people because the concept doesn't scale, not because it's run by elitists.<p>An open admissions policy would turn TED into something the size of Burning Man. Everyone would pile into the Rose Bowl, you'd get to "meet" the celebrities through binoculars, it would rapidly become even more of a scripted mass-market public event than it is now, and it would scare away many of the real celebrities, who would promptly go and invent TED II as a completely private, members-only meeting which we would never hear much about. You know, like Davos.<p>Instead of complaining about how TED isn't completely open, one should be giving thanks that it isn't completely closed.<p>I'm reminded of Richard Feynman's stories about how impossible it was to give a physics seminar after he won the Nobel Prize. If he scheduled a seminar under his own name, half the city would show up, it would get moved to a huge auditorium, and he would have to abandon his plan to discuss the tricky details of quantum electrodynamics with his peers and give a popular talk instead, because he couldn't bear to bore 95% of his audience to death. Feynman experimented with giving talks under a pseudonym, but found that this just made people angry when they found out, later -- there had been a <i>Nobelist</i> in town, and they didn't know, and they hadn't been invited!
评论 #127542 未加载
评论 #127402 未加载
评论 #127554 未加载
iamwil超过 17 年前
Presumably, someone at TED brought up this very point, and the solution was to put the lectures online. Doing that put inspiring lectures in front of more people than possible by expanding the conference.<p>You might talk about the perk of being at Google is eating free food by great chefs, even though the actual reason you work there is because you want to work on great things with great people. In the same way, of course you're are going to twitter about bono and al gore being there, even though the real reason you're there is to see what people on the forefront of technology, entertainment, and design are doing, and do something about it in whatever way you can.<p>It's not that people don't want to talk about why they're actually there, but it's far easier to talk to someone else about perks rather than core reason. That sends the wrong message to those like the writer that feels outcast.
neilk超过 17 年前
I'm fed up with the titles and theme music at the beginning of TED videos. They're almost violently smug. The orchestral crescendo tries to give you a heart attack, like it was the return of Jesus Christ, and then it cuts to some wonk giving a PowerPoint presentation.
评论 #127642 未加载
noonespecial超过 17 年前
I like the TED video where they invited the guy from the completely dirt-poor African village to talk about building a windmill out of scrap bicycle parts... What must he have been thinking while talking to all of those super-rich who could buy his whole village like it was a candy bar from a vending machine as he recounted scrounging enough rusty bicycle parts to pump water and keep villagers from dying of cholera?<p>I'm sure they were thinking this made them all "global" and "in touch" or something. I think they were treating the poor guy like a curious little pet.<p>Here it is: <a href="http://www.ted.com/index.php/talks/view/id/153" rel="nofollow">http://www.ted.com/index.php/talks/view/id/153</a>
wheels超过 17 年前
I personally just dig that they've got some great talks that are up with Creative Commons licenses. I appreciate the conference even if only for the fact that I think they've got some important ideas that are being preserved in an open format.
jcwentz超过 17 年前
What makes TED obnoxious is that they market it so heavily (all those videos) but exclude most people. It's fine to have private conferences, and fine to promote conferences, but it is nasty to do both.
评论 #127519 未加载
ojbyrne超过 17 年前
Sarah Lacey wrote the puff-piece we've all seen on digg, and was quite amenable to leaving founder no. 3 out of the picture. So from my heart, I just want to say... she can go f*ck herself.
danw超过 17 年前
Wasn't it this kind of reaction to FooCamp what lead to BarCamp being created? Don't complain about it, fix it. Sure the celebrity component of TED can't be replicated but there are still lots of smart people who can help figure out how to make the world better.
edw519超过 17 年前
Here's an idea: Watch TED on the internet like the rest of us and give the $6000 to the worthy cause of your choice. Then you would be DOING the message while the others are TALKING about it.
评论 #127461 未加载
cawel超过 17 年前
I was happy to read that one. And see that I was not the only one who's noticed the contradiction in TED: promoting innovation and educational projects (for example in Africa) but limiting its audience to a very few carefully-picked (rich (6k/seat)) VIP's.
jlhamilton超过 17 年前
The BIL conference (<a href="http://bilconference.com" rel="nofollow">http://bilconference.com</a>) is being held in Monterey after TED as a free alternative. They had to cap attendance at 150 though. Some of the scheduled talks look interesting.
Prrometheus超过 17 年前
If only there was a room with infinite seating...<p>Oh wait. There is. It's called "the internet", and TED is there.
ldambra超过 17 年前
Was any Paul around here invited ?
rms超过 17 年前
Can't anyone who pays the $6000/year membership fee get in?
评论 #127660 未加载
motoko超过 17 年前
Elitism? In my America? No...
评论 #127342 未加载
thomasswift超过 17 年前
if i recall the ze frank speech was pretty good, no link sorry.