TE
科技回声
首页24小时热榜最新最佳问答展示工作
GitHubTwitter
首页

科技回声

基于 Next.js 构建的科技新闻平台,提供全球科技新闻和讨论内容。

GitHubTwitter

首页

首页最新最佳问答展示工作

资源链接

HackerNews API原版 HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 科技回声. 版权所有。

Why are the east of cities usually poorer?

260 点作者 spxdcz将近 15 年前

25 条评论

quant18将近 15 年前
Yep, it's similar over here in Hong Kong too, though a bit more complicated and the directions are different. When you go up north of the Kowloon Peninsula into the mountains, there's a lot of commuter towns built in valleys, where you can find surprisingly cheap housing. Now, the thing about valleys is, wind direction depends on time of day. In the daytime, the sides of the valley get hotter than the centre, so winds blow out of the valley, making the air nice and clean --- but no one's home to enjoy it because they're all off at their jobs in other districts. And at nighttime when the sides of the valley cool faster than the centre, winds blow down into the valley. Just in time for the people coming home to enjoy everyone else's pollution, PLUS whatever they generate locally. Car exhaust is one obvious source, but cooking exhaust is a surprisingly big problem too --- you'd never think of it until you live in a place full of 50-story apartments, closely packed together, where everyone comes home at about the same time and cooks up a stir-fry for dinner.<p>Conversely, the most expensive houses (aside from the ones up on hilltops with nice views) are generally on the south of the main island. You've got mountains to your north and the ocean to your south. So in the summer, when prevailing winds come from the south, you get a clean ocean breeze. In the winter, when prevailing winds come from the north, you get all of mainland China's factory pollution plus all of Hong Kong's car and power plant exhaust blowing in your direction --- but you're protected by the mountains, so most of it goes around you and blows out to sea.
评论 #1391949 未加载
评论 #1395230 未加载
palish将近 15 年前
Short and to the point, lacking any kind of fluff. Very refreshing.<p>Almost every other article of this kind is so incredibly long that it feels like a game of "spot the explanation".
评论 #1391514 未加载
评论 #1393677 未加载
andrewcooke将近 15 年前
In Santiago, Chile, the East side is richer. I thought this was an exception to the rule until I realised that in the Southern hemisphere the winds are Easterlies!
评论 #1392332 未加载
评论 #1392459 未加载
评论 #1392499 未加载
xsive将近 15 年前
In Australia, where the prevailing winds are also westerlies, the opposite is true. i.e. the east of most cities is more prestigious than the west.
评论 #1391746 未加载
评论 #1391512 未加载
评论 #1391485 未加载
mynameishere将近 15 年前
It's better to live in the east since you don't have to look at the sun on your commute.
评论 #1392100 未加载
评论 #1391487 未加载
评论 #1395191 未加载
maukdaddy将近 15 年前
Actually in most of the major US cities, the south side is bad. For example, SE DC, south side Chicago, south-central LA
评论 #1392411 未加载
评论 #1391557 未加载
评论 #1391508 未加载
评论 #1391687 未加载
评论 #1391510 未加载
评论 #1391506 未加载
qq66将近 15 年前
West Philadelphia born and raised?<p>The article would be much stronger if there was some quantitative backing of the assertion that east sides are poorer.
评论 #1392031 未加载
评论 #1391700 未加载
Tombar将近 15 年前
In my country =&#62; Uruguay is the other way round.. east part of the cities is the richest one.. but i believe it's related with the coast line and the ocean :)
评论 #1392504 未加载
评论 #1392118 未加载
hristov将近 15 年前
This is not true for Manhattan. The upper west side has seen quite a renaissance lately, but it is nowhere near the upper east side in terms of price.
subwindow将近 15 年前
Saying 'east' is an oversimplification, but generally the prevailing wind theory seems to hold up. Atlanta, for instance, the wind is SSE, with the richer areas being in the north. It doesn't really explain how the west is poorer than the east, however.
fuzzmeister将近 15 年前
While it's hard to know if the distribution of any given city is the result of this trend, St. Louis is certainly a great example - East St. Louis is tied with Opa-Locka, FL as the most dangerous city in the United States.
评论 #1392110 未加载
tlb将近 15 年前
East-blowing pollution was a huge problem in early industrial London, where many American settlers came from. Whether or not there was a pollution problem where they later built cities, the meme of west=fancy, east=working class was ingrained. Certainly in places like East Palo Alto, the problem is not being downwind of something. It's just that the name "East" is a self-fulfilling prediction of being worse. It only takes a tiny nudge to tip the economic divide towards one side of town or the other.
jff将近 15 年前
Rochester NY, a city with a strong industrial history, is yet another anecdotal counterexample. The very finest houses are in fact directly east from the city center (the Kodak mansion, for example), and in general the nicest neighborhoods are to the east and southeast. To the north and east of the city are the poorer, generally more dangerous areas. Of course as you start to get far enough from the city center to the north and west you'll see the wealthier neighborhoods again.
Dobbs将近 15 年前
Salt lake is a bit different the east bench along the mountains is much more expensive. These areas are also much older. Things get cheaper the further west you go.
moolave将近 15 年前
It seemed true in Washington DC. Northwest DC (Georgetown, tourist spots, etc) was considered better than Southeast DC - albeit recent real estate developments in the past couple years. Same thing with East Palo Alto although there has been some major improvement happening in that area. Can't be true for all though.
seltzered将近 15 年前
This effect seems to be the opposite in Austin. If I'm interpreting the map correctly, the winds blow SW, and most of the affluent/rich areas are out there. The counterpoint is that west austin has more geographical features such as hills, lakes and rivers to offset it.
评论 #1391902 未加载
callmeed将近 15 年前
Are there any maps that plot mean/median income levels across different regions of large cities?
moultano将近 15 年前
I always thought the western side of most cities was poorer as a result of having to look into the sun each way on a commute.
评论 #1393300 未加载
kazuya将近 15 年前
Interesting. It's kinda true for Tokyo too, though probably due to historical reasons, not just polluted winds.
tszming将近 15 年前
In China, the opposite. Coastal cities (in the east) are usually richer.
评论 #1391567 未加载
评论 #1391569 未加载
micaelwidell将近 15 年前
Stockholm (capital of Sweden) seems to be an exception to this.
S_A_P将近 15 年前
this is certainly the case in Houston- the east side is all industrial/chemical/refineries...
lazyant将近 15 年前
counterexample: Louisvile, KY
评论 #1391501 未加载
known将近 15 年前
Sun rises in the East.
ww8520将近 15 年前
Fung Sui