TE
科技回声
首页24小时热榜最新最佳问答展示工作
GitHubTwitter
首页

科技回声

基于 Next.js 构建的科技新闻平台,提供全球科技新闻和讨论内容。

GitHubTwitter

首页

首页最新最佳问答展示工作

资源链接

HackerNews API原版 HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 科技回声. 版权所有。

Racing to Fill Gaps Left by Google

39 点作者 henry_flower将近 15 年前

18 条评论

mahmud将近 15 年前
meh.<p>I waited for an invitation for 6 weeks and when I finally got it, I was required to login via twitter or facebook. I dropped it right then and there.
评论 #1452491 未加载
评论 #1452575 未加载
评论 #1452461 未加载
评论 #1452459 未加载
ThomPete将近 15 年前
I have been using it for a while now.<p>1) It feels a little like the LinkedIn discussion groups.<p>2) It will most probably be used for self-promotion more than anything else.<p>3) It will have a hard time competing with the quality of HN, SO and the rest of the Stack Exchange network.<p>I don't care about whether they use Twitter and FB for login. In fact that is what I liked about it.
huangm将近 15 年前
What's with all the negativity around here? It's easy to look at a product, have several quick gut reactions, and then simply write it off. For all the open-minded-ness that the HN community prides itself on, it certainly doesn't seem to be showing through in the comments here so far.<p>In my opinion, Quora deserves more careful consideration and suspension of judgment for a variety of reasons:<p>1. Quality of community - Quora has managed to assemble an incredibly high quality set of founders, VCs, angels, hackers as extremely active members of the community. These are probably some of the busiest and hardest to engage and please people, and yet Quora has been able to elicit extremely candid and detailed responses from them about topics unseen anywhere else. The breadth and depth of information in some of these posts dwarf all the random Mixergy, Founders At Work, etc interviews seen here on HN. For one example, search for answers by Reid Hoffman, cofounder of PayPal and LinkedIn.<p>2. Amazing UI/UX design. There are so many clever small details to the user experience that it is impossible to really understand without actually getting your hands dirty and trying the product.<p>3. Pedigree - Cofounders Adam D'Angelo and Charlie Cheever were former CTO/VP Engineering and Head of Connect/Platform at Facebook, respectively. They've managed to secure a massive investment at a huge valuation from a very highly-regarded VC firm - <i>before launch</i>. Regardless of how much confidence you put in these signals, they are meaningful enough to warrant some suspension of judgment.<p>4. No one cares that you won't connect with Facebook or Twitter. Most people aren't like you. And if you really are interested in "building things people want," you're going to have to come to terms with the fact that this is the direction the web is moving in. I don't like Facebook's cavalier attitude toward privacy, but I'm willing to connect to Quora to see a great product and community in action. The potential for learning greatly outweighs any philosophical stance for me.<p>Obviously, there are a lot of unstated assumptions underlying these points, so I'll add the caveat that if none of the above appeals to your sense of curiosity, then maybe Quora really isn't for you. But I just wanted to balance all the negative comments so that someone that would enjoy Quora doesn't get turned off by all the "meh".
评论 #1452624 未加载
评论 #1452840 未加载
评论 #1452631 未加载
aresant将近 15 年前
Interesting site, first time I'd played with it . . .<p>My immediate impression was:<p>a) Brilliantly simple user interface.<p>b) I will likely never go there to use it, but bet I start finding their results via Google.
prat将近 15 年前
If the idea behind linking via facebook/twitter was to make things easier for users - that's a mistake. There are people who already are sensitive about their info on facebook - I bet they wouldn't like to expose it to yet another fledgling website with its own privacy fine print on what it can do with that info. I wonder if this is a surrogate attempt at privacy violation by facebook itself.
bentlegen将近 15 年前
"In March, investors—led by Benchmark Capital—invested $14 million in Quora at a valuation of around $87.5 million, say people familiar with the matter."<p>3 months before going public, already worth ~$87.5 million?
评论 #1452482 未加载
评论 #1452665 未加载
chr15将近 15 年前
Clickable: <a href="http://www.quora.com" rel="nofollow">http://www.quora.com</a><p>Also, the site requires you to have a FB or twitter account. Anyone know if users that don't have either will still be able to access the site?
评论 #1452272 未加载
评论 #1452443 未加载
plinkplonk将近 15 年前
Ok So I've been looking at various questions on Machine Learning and I don't find anything mind blowing or that I can't find elsewhere. (You can read answers without joining up, which is a blessing Damned if I'll sign up with Facebook or Twitter). Nor do I find any otherwise un-encounterable people or opinions.<p>Maybe it works better for non technical stuff like business plans or marketing advice ? Can someone point to a specific "can't find this quality elsewhere" answer? Thanks in advance.
评论 #1452847 未加载
pjhyett将近 15 年前
Does anyone have any experience with old media launches like this?<p>My assumption is you don't get in the WSJ (or any widely-circulated publication for that matter) unless you have a PR company or the right connections. Is it really more than just having something cool to hang on the wall?
评论 #1452423 未加载
评论 #1452391 未加载
patrickryan将近 15 年前
I've been using Quora for a few months and I have found it VERY useful. Mainly due to the quality of answers being far better than anything found in a simple Google Search. Also, the user base is very transparent. There are many influential web users on the site with plenty of good knowledge to share. The fact that you can ask a question to a user without being their friend is also helpful. With the release to the public, I fear that the quality of questions and answers will fall to something similar to that of Yahoo Answers. Let's hope not.
chr15将近 15 年前
For those that want to try it without logging in, go to the login page ( <a href="http://www.quora.com/login/index" rel="nofollow">http://www.quora.com/login/index</a> ) and the search box will be available at the top
RyanMcGreal将近 15 年前
&#62;which have sought to build search-like question and answering services that rely on what people say is important, not just machines.<p>Google's PageRank algorithm is based <i>entirely</i> on what people say is important.
chintan将近 15 年前
No this not a gap left by Google. They tried Google Answers and they shut it down. Its a tough nut to crack.
whakojacko将近 15 年前
It will be interesting to see what happens Re: the community now that it opens up. Right now, Quora's usefullness is somewhat limited (most users are in SF/NY and tech-oriented) but most of the answers are well thought-out and of good quality. User growth is a double-edged sword
acangiano将近 15 年前
A few days ago I declared Quora to be Yahoo! Answers for grown ups. I stand by that definition.
sachinag将近 15 年前
You may need a Facebook or Twitter account to create an account, but you log in with separate Quora credentials. The purpose of the FB and Twitter integrations is so that other users can see the social proof of your credentials and credibility.
评论 #1452360 未加载
maxogden将近 15 年前
<a href="http://www.quora.com/Magnets-How-do-they-work" rel="nofollow">http://www.quora.com/Magnets-How-do-they-work</a>?
bhiggins将近 15 年前
Q&#38;A sites are more a community-building problem instead of a technology problem. Quora's only chance at success will be with building a good community.