TE
科技回声
首页24小时热榜最新最佳问答展示工作
GitHubTwitter
首页

科技回声

基于 Next.js 构建的科技新闻平台,提供全球科技新闻和讨论内容。

GitHubTwitter

首页

首页最新最佳问答展示工作

资源链接

HackerNews API原版 HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 科技回声. 版权所有。

How Not to Die of Botulism (2013)

134 点作者 omilu将近 8 年前

17 条评论

jgrodziski将近 8 年前
Yes, how not to die of botulism: understand home food preservation. That&#x27;s to say: bad bacteria proliferates without oxygen, without salt and without acid, that&#x27;s why garlics in oil is a death recipe, it&#x27;s not only the absence of oxygen but also the high ph and absence of salt.<p>Understand the bacterias ecosystem is also a good way to understand home food preservation, in a salty and no oxygen environment (like salted water) you incentive lactobacillus that will consume sugars to produce lactic acid (and thus lower the ph), hence not a good environment for Clostridium Botulinum and fungi...so yes you can use heat to kill Clostridium Botulinum but you can also use other bacterias and the environment, the problem with heat is that you often kill &quot;all&quot; the bacterias leaving a highway for &quot;pathogen&quot; ones if the heating was not done properly.<p>Lacto-fermentation is a fascinating world: <a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.thespruce.com&#x2F;g00&#x2F;how-lacto-fermentation-works-1327598" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.thespruce.com&#x2F;g00&#x2F;how-lacto-fermentation-works-1...</a><p>And as a french guy, here we know a lot about cheese and lacto-fermentation :-) as all cheese, after coagulation, start from the transformation of lactose (a sugar) to lactic acid thanks to the bacterias (and lot of french cheese use...salted water).<p>UPDATE: the official recommandations to remove the toxin produced by Clostridium Botulinum: boil during 10 minutes, to kill the spore: heat above 120°C during at least 30 minutes, to prevent its proliferation in the first place: water with NaCl at a 15% concentration, OR 2% of acetic acid (vinegar) OR oxygen (but in that case the fungi will gently occupy the place).
评论 #14577941 未加载
评论 #14577572 未加载
dbcurtis将近 8 年前
How not to die of botulism: Understand home food preservation and follow the recipe.<p>The rules are simple: 1. C. Botulinin is everywhere. It <i>is</i> in the food you are preserving. Deal with it. 2. Heat kills C. Botulinin. Propper pressure canning times and temperatures of properly diced foods will kill it. 3. Acidity inhibits C. Botulinun metabolism. Boiling water bath canning of high acid foods like dill pickles is sufficient to keep any remaining microbes from producing toxins. (Botulism toxin is a metabolism byproduct. ) 4. 10 minutes at boiling temperatures before serving will break down botulism toxin. 5. When in doubt, throw it out.<p>Was that hard?<p>The most subtle mistake to make is if the canning recipe says dice into 1&#x2F;4 inch cubes, don&#x27;t use a different size. It changes the convection currents in the jar and it may not reach required temperature&#x2F;times in the core. Also be careful with home made salsa as the acidity can vary wildly depending on numerous factors.
评论 #14576381 未加载
评论 #14576593 未加载
评论 #14577513 未加载
评论 #14576578 未加载
jgrodziski将近 8 年前
Here is a small summary of the different kind of fermentation to better understand the article. The three main type of fermentation are:<p>- Alcoholic fermentation (beer, wine,etc.): without oxygen, yeast produce ethanol from sugar, like when you leave some fruits rotten without too much oxygens...but fruits rotten because fungi proliferates quicker due to the presence of oxygen<p>- lacto-fermentation (cheese, yoghurt, etc.): without oxygen and in a warm environment, lacto-bacillus produce lactic acid from sugar<p>- acetic fermentation (vinegar) : WITH oxygen (seldom one), acetobacter bacterias produce acetic acid from ethanol<p>Louis Pasteur said &quot;Fermentation is Life without oxygen&quot;, so whenever there is oxygen, you&#x27;ll see the usual rot produced by fungi (yes, very crude simplification). So the main aspect of fermentation is to ensure an anaerobic environment, often with water or when you remove oxygen from a recipient by aspiring it.<p>The other types of fermentation are more seldom: propionic fermentation (from lactic acid to propionic acid like in the gruyere cheese), butyric fermentation (like in rancid butter), malolactic fermentation (from malic acid to lactic acid, because the malic acid, found in grappes and apples gives a very acidic taste and is used to lower that acidic taste in some wines).
dghughes将近 8 年前
I&#x27;m surprised the article didn&#x27;t explain outright that the botulinum toxin is the most toxic substance on earth. More than cyanide, sarin, VX, plutonium or anything else man made or natural.<p>Another interesting side note is Napoleon Bonaparte offered a prize to anyone who could preserve food. Armies used to have to eat what they found locally since carrying large amount of food was too tedious. In the late 1700s Nicolas Appert managed to discover heat &quot;pasteurization&quot; (well before Louis Pasteur method in the 1860s). The only problem was Appert used heat that was too high and for too long resulting in mushy food Pasteur&#x27;s method had better results.<p>Interestingly Pasteur was inspired by a relative of Napoleon 1st only this time it was a nephew Napoleon III.
评论 #14578591 未加载
vilhelm_s将近 8 年前
What I wonder is why the bacterium produces such a strong toxin in the first place. Is there any evolutionary advantage to making animals sick, or is just a coincidence?
评论 #14579331 未加载
评论 #14577455 未加载
评论 #14577340 未加载
evanriley将近 8 年前
I assume this was posted because of the Otto Warmbier situation? [1]<p>[1]: <a href="http:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.bbc.com&#x2F;news&#x2F;world-us-canada-40308028" rel="nofollow">http:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.bbc.com&#x2F;news&#x2F;world-us-canada-40308028</a>
评论 #14576391 未加载
评论 #14576426 未加载
评论 #14576362 未加载
presspot将近 8 年前
The open source food safety idea is genius.
pmoriarty将近 8 年前
I wonder why there aren&#x27;t any cheap, simple tests for botulism that people could use to test their home-cooked food. You&#x27;d think something like that would be available by now.
评论 #14576669 未加载
gonvaled将近 8 年前
Please correct me, as this is only my personal understanding of how botulism works.<p>What kills me? Only the toxin. Neither the bacteria nor the spores are directly lethal.<p>How does the toxin get into my body?<p>A) I eat it, from food contaminated with toxin.<p>B) I breath it, from toxin in the air.<p>C) I eat or breath bacteria &#x2F; spores, and they produce the toxin inside my body.<p>How does that happen?<p>A) Badly preserved food. Normal, fresh food, does not contain toxin, but can contain spores &#x2F; bacteria. Over long periods of time (how long?), in the right conditions (low oxygen &#x2F; low salt &#x2F; low acid) bacteria will proliferate (even starting from the very resistant spores), and eventually produce toxin. This can not be seen &#x2F; smelled, and is the source of most toxin poisoning.<p>B) Only in warfare, and not even sure if that&#x27;s been developed. Maybe even forbidden by international conventions &quot;regulating&quot; warfare?<p>C) Only if I am a baby. Adult&#x27;s digestive tract will kill <i>both</i> bacteria and spores, preventing toxin production.<p>How much toxin is lethal?<p>According to the article, a microgram can kill an adult.<p>What is the rate of toxin production by the bacteria? How long do I need to leave toxin-free food exposed to bacteria in order to become dangerously poisoned?<p>At home we usually leave cooked food standing for the next day (sometimes, against my will, <i>outside</i> the fridge) and then we heat it at low temperatures and eat it. Is this safe? Probably yes botulism-wise, but has other problems.
mrob将近 8 年前
Even if there was no risk of botulism, attempting to make alcohol from potatoes and wild microbes sounds like a bad idea in any case. Yeast can&#x27;t ferment starch directly, so you&#x27;d need some other microbe to ferment it to sugars first. Eg. to make sake, rice is fermented by koji (Aspergillus oryzae) to sugars, and then yeast further ferments it to alcohol. You almost certainly have wild yeasts floating about nearby, but it&#x27;s less likely that there&#x27;s something that will convert the starch to sugars effectively. You could easily end up with chunks of rotting potato and no extra alcohol from them.
评论 #14577041 未加载
评论 #14576663 未加载
评论 #14576812 未加载
dom0将近 8 年前
Botulism is incredibly rare in Europe (maybe a handful of cases in each country per year); in which regions is it an issue? The article mentions canned foods which I imagine are not so common in countries with food scarcity.
评论 #14576226 未加载
评论 #14577380 未加载
cmurf将近 8 年前
Botulism spores are also found in honey. It&#x27;s in small enough amounts it&#x27;s not a problem for adults, but this is why you don&#x27;t give babies honey until 1 year old.
notadoc将近 8 年前
Fascinating, I bet the vast majority of the population has no idea regarding the dangers of canning.<p>Wouldn&#x27;t this risk apply to all food preservation?
ge96将近 8 年前
This should be in a hitch-hiker&#x27;s-guide-like guide offline woven into our clothes for the distopian future.
partycoder将近 8 年前
Salmonella and botulism are in part the reasons of why canned food usually come with a layer of Bisphenol A (aka BPA).<p>Botulism is rather infrequent but 2 ways I can think of getting it: 1) giving honey to infants, 2) eating food from dented cans.
评论 #14578818 未加载
Havoc将近 8 年前
&gt;Brazenly, he sampled a few drops of this extract himself<p>Damn that&#x27;s hardcore. Observes that it kills animals so he tries a little himself. wow.
qrbLPHiKpiux将近 8 年前
People inject this into their face. Housewives.
评论 #14577949 未加载