TE
科技回声
首页24小时热榜最新最佳问答展示工作
GitHubTwitter
首页

科技回声

基于 Next.js 构建的科技新闻平台,提供全球科技新闻和讨论内容。

GitHubTwitter

首页

首页最新最佳问答展示工作

资源链接

HackerNews API原版 HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 科技回声. 版权所有。

Dan Ariely on why online dating is so unsatisfying

97 点作者 mike将近 15 年前

15 条评论

WilliamLP将近 15 年前
I had my first dating experiences in life online, and then I met a couple of girls "normally". (Relationships are few and far between for me, and I have to work at getting one and it takes a year or two and finding one is by far the hardest problem I've ever had to solve in my life).<p>I'm trying online again, and the contrast is extremely stark. There is nothing in any other experience in life that has made me think of myself as an unwanted commodity item quite so much as this. As a man in my thirties who is below average in height (5'8) I fight against about 25% to 75% numbers, and the women seem almost universally to be working extra carefully to exclude me and almost always come across as extremely entitled, both in written and in unwritten ways. And I can't blame them for it! They just understand the economics of scarcity, apparently. Despite being reasonably successful in life and being in the best physical shape I've ever been (10% bodyfat or so, can barely see my abs, can bench press 185 for 8 reps at bodyweight of 155), I seem completely uninteresting to women in a nearly universal way without much I can do to change this.<p>There are no doubt some men who succeed fantastically in this environment, but it seems that for someone like me to do so, I would need to, very much, be conscious of playing the game and pretty much doing anything <i>but</i> presenting an unashamed and straightforward version of self-expression. Since I consider it to be the core of my character to neither accept or deal out bullshit from anyone, but to seek the direct truth, this is a problem.<p>This is in contrast to where I've actually had success with women in the past - amateur classical singing and opera. There the population is about 75% women, with many of the men being gay. There, I can get a taste of what dating is like for the rest of the world - I didn't have to play some stupid hyper-masculinized pursuer who throws semi-sincere interest at a hundred women until one of them returns a peep, but situations actually can develop somewhat symmetrically and organically. Clearly the answer for me is to get back into a world like that, despite not being very interested anymore for any other reason. (My passion these days is programming and development.)<p>Anyway, this turned into a big rant, but I've been single for a year, face the prospect of a few more, and it does get to me.
评论 #1499522 未加载
评论 #1499587 未加载
评论 #1500057 未加载
评论 #1499656 未加载
评论 #1499551 未加载
评论 #1501384 未加载
评论 #1499650 未加载
评论 #1499768 未加载
评论 #1500008 未加载
评论 #1500359 未加载
rokhayakebe将近 15 年前
I have started to use an online dating site for the first time about 4-6 weeks ago. It is hard work. It's like having a mini part time job.<p>Advice for startups in this space. Cut your features to the following: Like + Email. If I LIKE someone (judging by the looks), then show me the basic info. If I LIKE the basic info, they get a notification and if they LIKE me then that's it. Let us email each other from OUR OWN client. So I email user345@datingsite.com and you route the email a la Craigslist. Simple as that. Let us take it further.<p>Advice to guys. My first 2 weeks I was pinging everyone I was attracted to. That did not work (for me). It's when I just kick back and decide to wait that I realized it's mostly the women who choose in this game. Also if someone contacts the conversation is usually much easier. My 2 newbie cents.
评论 #1499514 未加载
augustflanagan将近 15 年前
I only ever went on one internet date. It was the best date of my life and I ended up marrying her 4 years later.<p>Obviously this a ridiculous statistical outlier, but one of the reasons I always thought it was successful was because we didn't find each other on a huge site like Match.com or Plenty Of Fish. Instead it was through the online dating section of the Seattle Stranger, which sort of guaranteed that we would at least have a few similar interests right off the bat. To anyone in Seattle I highly recommend it.
评论 #1499808 未加载
ambulatorybird将近 15 年前
I agree wiht a lot of his points. I think people do tend to be more superficial or picky when evaluating profiles, because the photos are really the only thing to go on -- you can't get a sense of a person's body language or speaking style online, and textual data only goes so far. And I found the actual "first dates" to be stressful because they're more like interviews for dates rather than real dates -- much of the spontaneity and chemistry of meeting a person for the first time is gone. Finally, as a non-white male, the odds online are somewhat stacked against me, which is discouraging.<p>I'm intrigued by the guy's idea about creating interactive virtual spaces for dating, rather than searching through textual profiles. I.e., put people together in a rich, dynamic environment, let them observe the complexity of each other's interactions, and they can gravitate toward one another on that basis. Heck, it doesn't even have to be virtual -- you could launch something like a matchmaking amusement park.
评论 #1499315 未加载
评论 #1499553 未加载
评论 #1501623 未加载
ajg1977将近 15 年前
Good luck in real world dating if you think a coffee date after 5 hours of surfing the web from the comfort of home is a poor ROI.
评论 #1499232 未加载
评论 #1499581 未加载
billmcneale将近 15 年前
One thing that's positive about online dating is that it takes away a lot of the mysterious parameters.<p>Mysterious parameters: you meet a girl (or guy, but let's say girl) at a party, hit it off, exchange phone numbers, call a few days later a get the cold shoulder. Or you go on one or two dates, things still going well and then you never hear back from that person.<p>What probably happened: she had a hang up, she wasn't ready, she met someone else, she wasn't really looking, she was just interested in a few free meals, she was set up by friends but she wasn't really into it, etc...<p>The advantage of online dating is that people who commit to it are usually a bit more ready to get involved with someone else. I found that there is less playing game and more straight-to-the-point "I'm looking for someone, so are you, let's see if this can work".
kadavy将近 15 年前
Online Dating is Unsatisfying because people suck at communicating.<p>They need to write good profiles by not talking about <i>themselves</i> so much: <a href="http://www.onlinedatingmatchmaker.com/how-to-write-an-online-dating-profile/" rel="nofollow">http://www.onlinedatingmatchmaker.com/how-to-write-an-online...</a><p>They need to write clear and compelling opening messages: <a href="http://www.onlinedatingmatchmaker.com/match-messages/" rel="nofollow">http://www.onlinedatingmatchmaker.com/match-messages/</a><p>They need to speak in specifics to get a conversation flowing: <a href="http://www.onlinedatingmatchmaker.com/conversation-nuggets-in-online-dating/" rel="nofollow">http://www.onlinedatingmatchmaker.com/conversation-nuggets-i...</a>
评论 #1499513 未加载
blizkreeg将近 15 年前
How to approach online dating in a novel way does keep me up long hours as this is something I'm trying to solve in my startup, albeit for a niche segment of the population.<p>[Apologies for this next plug] I am very interested in teaming up with a couple of talented and driven hackers and working together if this area interests you. My startup has some initial traction (slightly north of a thousand users) in the two months since launch.<p>My email is in my bio.
Goladus将近 15 年前
Excellent interview. Yes, he mostly ignores the people who've had success, but I don't think it really detracts much from the overall point. I've had some success with online dating but I agree that it's generally an unsatisfying experience much the way he describes it. (3-6 hours of work per cup of coffee pretty much nails it).<p>The points about sharing experience are accurate, except that I would focus in particular on shared experiences with multiple people at once. A big weakness in online dating is that it's tends to be a series of one-on-one interactions. Unless one of you is really good at seducing strangers, and does it right away, it's going to be hard to sustain those one-on-one interactions long enough to turn into a relationship.<p>At least one person has to take the step to integrate into the other's social network, and it has to happen quickly, or else it's not likely to go anywhere. The way offline dating tends to work is that you meet someone in a social situation. You interact with them for a few moments at a time, with frequent breaks while you each socialize with other people. You have opportunities to observe the person discreetly as well as interact with them. You send each other signals and at some point you find some privacy and get more serious.<p>A dating site that encouraged that sort of thing might be more successful. (okcupid tries to encourage a variety of behaviors but ultimately their design still winds up facilitating the one-on-one chat -&#62; date paradigm)
motters将近 15 年前
Online dating is difficult if, like me, you generally dislike superficiality and find the prospect of turning yourself into a sales &#38; marketing guy or a snake oil salesman terrifying.
amichail将近 15 年前
Maybe social news sites such as reddit could double as online dating sites.<p>The focus would be on intellectual debate, rather than on more superficial things.
评论 #1499408 未加载
markbao将近 15 年前
/ <i>It turns out, women really care about men's height. I’m 5’9”, if I wanted to be as attractive as somebody who’s 5’10”, right, another inch? I would have to make about $35-40,000 more a year.</i><p>From a 5'7": sorry, what!? Link to paper?
评论 #1499239 未加载
评论 #1499322 未加载
评论 #1499292 未加载
jasonlotito将近 15 年前
Choosing PHP over Python, Perl, and ASP.<p>Countless hours on #php.<p>Meeting and talking with a girl I met on #php for hours on end on the phone.<p>"Dating" online.<p>Meeting 2 months after we started "dating".<p>Me moving to another country 3 months after that.<p>Marrying 6 years later.<p>Happily married and expecting our second child later this month. =)
评论 #1500744 未加载
davidedicillo将近 15 年前
I can see his point, but I have very good friends who I'm sure they would say the total opposite. Some found love, some found fun... heck, one even found a Maxim model (and they are still dating).
评论 #1499222 未加载
AaronM将近 15 年前
I stopped reading this after the first paragraph. Who puts their article in a small 5x5 inch box?
评论 #1501874 未加载