TE
科技回声
首页24小时热榜最新最佳问答展示工作
GitHubTwitter
首页

科技回声

基于 Next.js 构建的科技新闻平台,提供全球科技新闻和讨论内容。

GitHubTwitter

首页

首页最新最佳问答展示工作

资源链接

HackerNews API原版 HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 科技回声. 版权所有。

The Irrationality of Alcoholics Anonymous (2015)

93 点作者 iamjeff将近 8 年前

20 条评论

sverige将近 8 年前
My name is sverige and I used to be an &quot;alcoholic.&quot; I have attended at least 2,500 AA meetings in various places since the early &#x27;80s, and probably many more than that. I was fully indoctrinated in their literature and methods, having read every book published by AA more than once, and some many, many times. I am also very familiar with similar and related programs, such as Al-Anon, Narcotics Anonymous, etc. I have also known people who have been involved in even more fringe movements, such as Synanon. I have talked to thousands of people &quot;in recovery&quot; over the years, and I have personally known dozens who died as a direct result of their addictions.<p>The article is a pretty good summary of the sad state of alcohol and drug dependency treatment in the U.S. The prescription is always abstinence, and almost universally any suggestion that moderate drinking might be possible for some is met with scorn and anxiety.<p>My objections to AA have little to do with their mention of God. I am christian, so obviously that is not a problem for me. I will say that AA theology is awful, basically implying that salvation comes from sobriety, but worse is that it actually indoctrinates many with ideas that hinder their ability to recover from addiction. Regardless of whether or not you believe the way I do, I hate to see people needlessly suffering from this illness (or perhaps, this group of related illnesses), yet the conclusion I came to after 25 years of involvement with them is that AA more often than not prolongs suffering.<p>I am not saying that naltrexone or any other drug is the magic bullet, but I am certain that it is well worth investigating alternatives to AA. If you or anyone you are close to needs help, please take the time to explore all the options. There is so much snake oil in this area that it can be difficult to know which way to turn. It is worth the time and effort it takes to find the right treatment, and if it is successful, it is probably even worth the inflated cost of said treatment.
评论 #15059219 未加载
评论 #15058771 未加载
评论 #15059547 未加载
eveningcoffee将近 8 年前
&gt;“Well,” he told me, “it’s 2,000 euros.” That’s about $2,500—a fraction of the cost of inpatient rehab in the United States, which routinely runs in the tens of thousands of dollars for a 28-day stay.<p>&gt;I didn’t mention that some bare-bones facilities charge as much as $40,000 a month and offer no treatment beyond AA sessions led by minimally qualified counselors.
评论 #15059592 未加载
评论 #15058433 未加载
lemonberry将近 8 年前
When I hit bottom a buddy of mine said the worst thing that can happen is that you become &quot;one of those AA assholes&quot;. There&#x27;s truth there. You&#x27;ll never kill a family in your car because you&#x27;ve gone to too many meetings.<p>That said, I&#x27;m an atheist, my buddy is an atheist and here in the northeast the religious part is really watered down, from what I hear, compared to other parts of the country.<p>I go because hearing others stories and talking to others about the being an alcoholic is really helpful.<p>I haven&#x27;t drank in 4 years and AA was a crucial part. But I&#x27;ve never done the steps ( I can&#x27;t even call it a higher power, that&#x27;s lipstick on a pig in my book ). It&#x27;s the talking to others that&#x27;s helpful. People would say things, especially in the beginning, that articulated things I&#x27;d felt but unable to put into words.<p>In addition to speaking with other alcoholics I use philosophy, Eastern thought and stoicism, and the occasional use of lsd and mushrooms to keep me off the sauce. I never say I&#x27;m &quot;sober&quot; because of the latter part, but that was never my goal. I just needed to quit drinking and I couldn&#x27;t.<p>My biggest problem with AA is the religious side. Overall the program seems to help people face their issues and take responsibility for their actions, but the toolkit, in my mind, barely gets them above water. But it is better than drowning. I&#x27;d love to see the organization revamp to catch up to the 21st century. The big book is like reading an anthropology book from the 19th century. It&#x27;s sad how some people cling to it.<p>One feature of AA that I think a number of people fail to remember, though, is that there are meetings everywhere at many different times. For those that haven&#x27;t lost everything you should certainly seek alternatives. But there&#x27;s a large population of people that are so messed up they&#x27;ve lost everything and quite literally wouldn&#x27;t know how to find help in other places.<p>Addiction sucks and is one of the most heartbreaking things for me to see. But not everyone that uses is an addict, whether it&#x27;s alcohol, marijuana, or even cocaine.<p>To anyone wrestling with it: good luck, get help and know there is another side to your life. The rest of it doesn&#x27;t have to be spent feeling the way you do now.
评论 #15059292 未加载
评论 #15059845 未加载
zafka将近 8 年前
There are so many issues with this article, I am not quite sure where to start. I guess at the beginning. The article starts with a title that is leading to say the least. Another thing this author does throughout the article is to insinuate that Alcoholics Anonymous it to blame for the sorry state of how our health care system (U.S) pays for addiction treatment.<p>After stating how hard it is too verify statistics for positive results,the author damns the guess made 50 years ago when Bill Wilson first wrote the book, and most likely had a far better conversion record as they were then dealing with highly motivated quitters. It is almost humorous that this author is complaining about the success rate of this method, when a large number of the pool of candidates are forced into treatment by either the law or parental coercion. Now I would like to say mid- rant that I am biased. I stopped drinking 33 years ago, and while I would not admit to membership in this group in a public forum, I would suggest people who WANT to quit, to give it a try.<p>I would be one of the first to say that there are a lot of hokey parts to the traditions they follow, and I do not agree with a lot of the premises of the literature---- But that being said........It works! One interesting opinion about AA comes from Charlie Munger, Warren Buffets business partner. Charlie writes quite a bit about the psychology of business, and he gives his fairly well thought out opinion of why AA works so well. I wonder whether the AA bashing is just for controversy to better sell the article, or if perhaps the author is helping to market the new version of naltrexone the is being quite heavily promoted to judges recently.
评论 #15060072 未加载
wojt_eu将近 8 年前
One thing I&#x27;ve heard AA does right is asking attendees to talk about each their recent drinking acts and what preceded them. This forces some to realize their patterns and triggers for the first time.
评论 #15058425 未加载
Aloha将近 8 年前
AA is a wonderful tool to get sober - its enough to pull you back from the brink and if you&#x27;re mindful enough reevaluate your life and why you&#x27;re self medicating - it may not however be the tool you need to stay sober.<p>Look at AA as addiction transference - you&#x27;re transferring your addiction from Alcohol to AA - and for some, thats the best they can do, for others its the start of the journey to moderate consumption.
burnerOh2125将近 8 年前
I lost nearly everything in my life: my job, my apartment, my car, and very nearly my life from drugs and alcohol. I used for years with few consequences, but with the help of the dark net markets, got my hands on cheap and power drugs my body and mind could literally not handle. I came to a point in my life where I realized I had lost control over my ability to self-regulate consumption of intoxicating agents, and the consequences were dire.<p>I underwent a pretty radical change getting sober, moved to a different part of the city into a semi-supervised sober house, and started going to AA meetings. What I found there was a diverse group of people, with even more diverse problems (drugs, alcohol, violence, relationships) that had 1) accepted the problem was of their own making and 2) collectively decided that only through their own actions could they make themselves whole again. My AA group is a little unconventional in that we are extremely accepting of different types of addictions, and operate in an inner city area much different than my suburban upbringing. For me, AA is about living a stoic life, accepting what you can control, and disregarding what you cannot control. Seeing these same problems, across race, class, gender and geography was a pretty transcendental moment for me.<p>AA is just one part of what I&#x27;m doing to stay healthy: the other component, which in a lot of ways I trust more, is cognitive behavioral therapy, and group therapy. I think eventually more &#x27;evidence based&#x27; group therapy systems will take over, but you just can&#x27;t beat AA&#x27;s model: people helping people via donated time and services.<p>When a new person walks into &#x27;AA&#x27; with just a &#x27;desire to stop drinking&#x27; their entire experience comes from the individuals, qualified only through their anecdotal experience in sobriety, that they meet. As a data scientist ready to defend AA, it used to be hard for me to rectify the fact that 1) AA is not effective as a prescribed intervention and 2) I&#x27;m in AA, and it works. How can I recommend a treatment when I know doing nothing in some cases is often better? Well, I don&#x27;t know, and for me, AA is about staying sober, statistics be darned, I have something that works.<p>Finally, getting sober, for me, was a long, difficult, and extremely uncomfortable experience. If you are reading this, questioning if &#x27;AA&#x27; is right for you, I would strongly implore you to attend a few different meetings in your area. Raise your hand, introduce yourself, and see what comes forth. AA will not save you, you will save you.
chewz将近 8 年前
I am more then 6 years sober through AA. Before I have tried a professional help and it didn&#x27;t work. My personality is allergic to psychotherapeutics b..t, I cannot stand someone telling my about my flaws. What has worked for me in AA? 1) The possibility to go to a meeting when I was starting feeling bad, lonely, depressed, tense - which previously resulted in getting a drink 2) Hearing the real stories from real people. I cannot stress how much it worked on my, how its had changed my perspective.<p>I am sure AA won&#x27;t work for everyone but it works for certain types of people. In my humble opinion it works exactly because it isn&#x27;t based on hard science but on personal experience. Actually - &quot;this is how it works&quot; is something you hear often at meetings.<p>Now regarding the financial side. 40k$ for bare bone AA meetings is something very American.<p>In Poland AA is self-financing, meetings are open and free. If you can afford you can make a voluntary donation to your group cash-box which is used for coffee and tea. Like 2-3$. Local community or a church is providing place for meetings. Everyone is welcome (if he is not under influence). In . city the size of Warsaw there are meeting going every day and at different hours. So AA is affordable to anyone and at any time while even public healthcare therapy will involve some cost or long wait.
sizzle将近 8 年前
Has anyone tried Naltrexone? I am about to try some after watching the documentary, &quot;one little pill.&quot; by Claudia Christensen. I implore anyone suffering from alcohol addiction to watch the documentary and consider it as a treatment that has helped many yet is not widely discussed as it is unprofitable.
jupiter90000将近 8 年前
That seemed like an overly long article to the point of having an unclear evidence to its argument and seeming biased against AA. I&#x27;d be more interested to see a summary of research about what is proven to be effective in treating the problems than cherry picked study results and anecdotes.
apple4ever超过 7 年前
I read the Big Book, and went to a couple of meetings. As a logical but also religious person, what they said made no sense.<p>First, just &quot;give yourself over to God&quot; means nothing. Sobriety takes work. One falls into a bad pattern, and you need conscious effort to break that pattern. I found the SMART program, which uses Cognitive Behavioral Therapy. That worked for me and made sense for my brain.<p>Also, my religion (Eastern Orthodox Christianity) teaches that God will throw a life raft, but you gotta grab it, hold on, and swim to shore yourself. Again, the same work ethic, not just &quot;turning yourself over&quot;.<p>I really find AA makes it difficult to people to get sober. I&#x27;m sure it does work for some, but I believe it may take longer for them.
YSFEJ4SWJUVU6将近 8 年前
To be fair, also here in Finland some people swear by the “Minnesota Model” (as it is called here) form of treatment – which I&#x27;ve come to understand is very similar to the AA program in the US – almost religiously so, or maybe indeed, so.<p>One way or the other, perhaps the saddest form is the most used – a very short clinic stay coupled with benzodiazepines to help safely stop a prolonged bender. Nothing wrong with that per se, but it&#x27;s not really enough... but it&#x27;s a free world.
ameliaquining将近 8 年前
Here&#x27;s one guy&#x27;s attempt at an actual literature review on the effectiveness of AA: <a href="http:&#x2F;&#x2F;slatestarcodex.com&#x2F;2014&#x2F;10&#x2F;26&#x2F;alcoholics-anonymous-much-more-than-you-wanted-to-know&#x2F;" rel="nofollow">http:&#x2F;&#x2F;slatestarcodex.com&#x2F;2014&#x2F;10&#x2F;26&#x2F;alcoholics-anonymous-mu...</a><p>TL;DR: The science around this is terrible so it&#x27;s hard to know anything with much certainty, but it looks as though AA isn&#x27;t much better or worse than other treatments. Whether it&#x27;s more effective than no treatment at all is an open question.
评论 #15059895 未加载
abrax3141将近 8 年前
I wonder if acamprosate would work for internet addiction?
atomical将近 8 年前
Does Naltrexone work better than AA meetings?
PeachPlum将近 8 年前
<a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;youtu.be&#x2F;uYgdoecq-PE" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;youtu.be&#x2F;uYgdoecq-PE</a><p>Doug Stanhope has some insightful comedy on the subject (nsfw)
dogruck将近 8 年前
One: A scientist told me that AA&#x27;s efficacy cannot be proved.<p>Two: But it worked for my dad.<p>One: Another scientist told me the earth is doomed.<p>Two: That&#x27;s good science. Let&#x27;s get a drink.
评论 #15058617 未加载
aaron695将近 8 年前
&gt; He told me that for years he had drunk to excess, sometimes having as many as 20 drinks at a time<p>Hmmmm that&#x27;s not a lot when your talking problem drinking as an addiction. That&#x27;d be typical in a frat house.<p>There&#x27;s a lot wrong with the article and a lot right. Pick carefully.<p>There&#x27;s no reason you can&#x27;t go to AA and do the Sinclair Method. AA is full of Atheists the god bit is misleading.<p>I&#x27;m not sure why they are putting down AA when AA is not against the Sinclair Method. AA has found their way works for some people. It&#x27;s also cheap councling. Not everyone can afford well paid doctors.<p>If your drinking is that bad you need a pill to stop it wouldn&#x27;t hurt to talk to others about the problem as well. And AA is a meme&#x2F;cult&#x2F;religion that allows that except they don&#x27;t go to war and fight others over oil and resources.
评论 #15058522 未加载
评论 #15059265 未加载
R_haterade将近 8 年前
I wonder what this article is submarining.
canthonytucci将近 8 年前
AA is the Linux of therapies. Free, crowd sourced and rough around the edges but for some people it works well enough to get the job done.<p>edit: maybe linux is a bit strong, php?
评论 #15058469 未加载
评论 #15058889 未加载
评论 #15059978 未加载