TE
科技回声
首页24小时热榜最新最佳问答展示工作
GitHubTwitter
首页

科技回声

基于 Next.js 构建的科技新闻平台,提供全球科技新闻和讨论内容。

GitHubTwitter

首页

首页最新最佳问答展示工作

资源链接

HackerNews API原版 HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 科技回声. 版权所有。

Problems at Singularity University

52 点作者 meri_dian超过 7 年前

9 条评论

loorinm超过 7 年前
Um, did anyone really not see this coming?<p>Their whole deal was “we are going to merge humans and machines”, yet it had zero technical side on how to do that.<p>“It has become a conference and seminar company” .....<p>No, that’s what it was from day 1.
评论 #16390755 未加载
评论 #16398041 未加载
ipsum2超过 7 年前
It&#x27;s not surprising. If anyone&#x27;s been following Singularity University, it&#x27;s obvious that the degree was absolutely worthless, and they let anyone teach. Not sure what anyone gets out of the program.
heracles超过 7 年前
I literary didn&#x27;t know they were actually working towards the singularity in any technical way. Just thought they were like TED, but only lecturing on one theme (singularily focused, one might say).
trhway超过 7 年前
&gt;conferences and executive education (tuition: $14,500 for a weeklong program) will become the bulk of Singularity’s work.<p>looks like they&#x27;ve pivoted straight to pure gold mining. Our VP recently boasted about neural networks [which were briefly mentioned] in his coursework ~25 years ago. I can only imagine the size of his inflation after &quot;executive education from Singularity University&quot; when he gets to it - he probably wouldn&#x27;t be able to fit into his office anymore.
confluence超过 7 年前
Difficult to bring about the singularity without historic levels of technical competency and financial investment. Anything less is simply being contemptuous of the true challenge that must be overcome to achieve even 1&#x2F;10th of what could be possible. A bunch of lectures, or sci-fi-esque stories really aren&#x27;t going to do anything to achieve it past the first batch that really opened it up, but they do have an effect on what people care about, and what motivates them, so they aren&#x27;t totally worthless.<p>Imagine if scientists approached bringing about the Manhattan Project without also demanding 10% of US GDP for five years, multiple state spanning test sites, absolute discretion, and the work output of hundreds of thousands. Same goes for the Apollo project.<p>Achieving the promises of the Singularity - whatever that happens to be exactly - is bigger than all of those nation spanning projects combined.<p>And we will only get there through enormous quantities of technical and organizational blood, sweat and tears spanning decades, and more likely, centuries. The work required is bigger than every research org, every country, and every company, so it looks less like &quot;hard take off&quot; and more like faster plodding.
评论 #16390981 未加载
moomin超过 7 年前
Thing set up by Wadhwa turns out to be problematic. Colour me surprised.
XnoiVeX超过 7 年前
Thanks to SU. People now know what a hype factory looks like.
sorent超过 7 年前
With a startup founded at SU (in 2014), and as a YC company (W2016) I would like to add some color to this discussion.<p>The Bloomberg article has one goal; discredit SU! Statements such as &#x27;Google pulled their funding from GSP&#x27; is just plain wrong. According to SU, THEY decided to pause GSP. Google, therefore, moved their support towards the SU Startup program.<p>The article talks about bad sexual behavior from a former employee back in 2013. When I was at SU in 2014, I thought it was almost cringing to hear how everyone was instructed NOT to engage romanticly with anyone. I was like, c&#x27;mon, we&#x27;re grownups!! To say that they didn&#x27;t learn from the 2013 incident is not true. And.. the &#x27;financial fraud argument&#x27; is ridiculous - any company can experience a bad employee. Fired and out - whats more could they do?<p>Here is my SU experience. In summer 2014 my co-founder and I attended the GSP program:<p>- We were 80 students with different domain expertise from 36 countries. We spent 10 weeks at SU&#x27;s campus at NASA Ames in Mountain View.<p>- We were briefed about a broad range of technologies, so we had a general understanding of which direction tech is moving.<p>- The worlds most pressing problems were presented. Think shortage of food, clean water, energy crisis, access to health, etc.<p>- The &#x27;homework&#x27; was now to come up with moonshots that could impact +1b people positively in 10 years.<p>Was that experience valuable? Yes. Though none of the SU companies have hit the 1b person impact mark, it has seeded a wide range of projects - our own company is one.<p>One of the hype machines of this world is Peter Diamandis, the co-founder of SU. He might be too much of a capitalist for my taste, but his consistent launch of moonshots is wild and he is an extraordinary entrepreneur... Have you guys seen X-prize, Planetary Resources, and Human Longevity? Just yesterday he launched &#x27;Celularity&#x27;, and raised $250m in funding for using &#x27;waste placentas&#x27; to develop new stem cell therapies. SU was founded to create similar moonshots.<p>SU used to be a non-profit but switched to a for-profit model to expand their reach. That&#x27;s how conferences came about. I too ask myself if it&#x27;s sustainable? Maybe. Change is happening quickly, and big corps are used to pay big bucks for the consultants of the world. In that world, SU&#x27;s brand on &#x27;exponential thinking&#x27; is fragile, but they are trying to expand their offering. The risk in their business model is how hard they ride their brand, where articles like this one are straight out poisonous.<p>I would take a look at who is promoting this article. Who would benefit from the SU slandering? There is a lot of money in conferences, and SU just announced $32m to address that market.<p>My thinking on SU is that it&#x27;s an organization educating people on technology development, with a goal of framing it into positive human development. The world needs more of that!<p>At least for us, that thinking helped us frame a solution, with a very large potential for positive impact. Later, YC was the perfect segway into creating a scale-able company.<p>Anyway, wanted to share my two cents..
mathattack超过 7 年前
I’ve heard horror stories from a former employer. But they raised...