TE
科技回声
首页24小时热榜最新最佳问答展示工作
GitHubTwitter
首页

科技回声

基于 Next.js 构建的科技新闻平台,提供全球科技新闻和讨论内容。

GitHubTwitter

首页

首页最新最佳问答展示工作

资源链接

HackerNews API原版 HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 科技回声. 版权所有。

Ask HN: Anyone else not read the questions on SO, only the answers when stuck?

41 点作者 fanpuns大约 7 年前
I don&#x27;t know if I could pinpoint exactly when this started for me, but I realized the other day that I never read the questions when I&#x27;m trying to debug something and SO pops up as part of my Google results. I just read the title, then scroll down to the answers to see if any of the proposed code will work for me. Maybe 1 in 50 I&#x27;ll flip back up to the question to see if a specific variable or setup is mentioned and therefore used in the answer.<p>I have been wondering with the discussion around SO culture and community if maybe this is important. For all the discussion about &quot;good&quot; questions and wanting to archive generally applicable programming advice, would it change the assumptions about the value of either if it turns out that people aren&#x27;t reading the questions anyway?

11 条评论

dvdcxn大约 7 年前
With experience you realise you&#x27;re looking for an answer that matches your question, as opposed to a question that matches your question.
amirathi大约 7 年前
Ditto. I almost never read the question. A well written answer restates the question in some form.
CosmicShadow大约 7 年前
I usually open like 8 tabs of possibly relevant answers from a google result, look for something that looks right, and if I get frustrated why something doesn&#x27;t make sense or seem to work, I scroll up and read the question to find it was super specific or stupid and doesn&#x27;t really match the title.
farnsworthy大约 7 年前
I think you pointed this out yourself: everybody is in fact reading the questions, but in the SERPs, not on SO.<p>(And I&#x27;m sure people are scanning the body of the question there, too, if only subconsciously--I know I do.)
Noumenon72大约 7 年前
I don&#x27;t do this at all. More than half of the questions that seem relevant from Google actually aren&#x27;t my situation -- no point reading the answers. Also, there are lots of good questions that list things I should have tried.<p>I also read the comments on the question and most of the answers to the bottom, so I just read more than most people. I have the gold badge for voting on 600 questions, which only 0.4% of users have. I&#x27;m just too curious for my own good.
评论 #16616158 未加载
hackerfake大约 7 年前
Indeed. I check out the question only if I understood the answer, but need to verify if it solves my problem.
muzani大约 7 年前
Same. I noticed after a while that I stopped upvoting questions when there was a prompt that reminded me.<p>Also noticed that my gold badge questions (the ones with really high views) weren&#x27;t getting a lot of upvotes too. Once a question is prominent enough on Google, people just read the answer.
O_H_E大约 7 年前
I also noticed this in myself, but sometimes Google&#x2F;the question title misleads me to an answer for another situation. I find that this habit sometimes waste my time
xtiansimon大约 7 年前
Read the question first or the answer. A programming problem is not a narrative, it’s a structure. Totally non-linear, man!
hodl大约 7 年前
Why bother reading the question if the answers are lame. It the answers you want after all. Bravo.
potta_coffee大约 7 年前
Yes I do this.