TE
科技回声
首页24小时热榜最新最佳问答展示工作
GitHubTwitter
首页

科技回声

基于 Next.js 构建的科技新闻平台,提供全球科技新闻和讨论内容。

GitHubTwitter

首页

首页最新最佳问答展示工作

资源链接

HackerNews API原版 HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 科技回声. 版权所有。

Ask HN: How well does unlimited holiday allowance work in practice?

55 点作者 konamicode大约 7 年前
Asking from the point of view of the employee: how many days a year do you actually take as annual leave? Please provide company name or country if possible. Asking for a friend.

43 条评论

decebalus1大约 7 年前
You&#x27;ll most likely not get a definite answer because it can range from very bad to very good depending on both company and team.<p>I don&#x27;t want to mention my current company to keep my anonymity but we currently have unlimited vacation and at least for my team it&#x27;s going great but it&#x27;s mostly because of our direct manager who encourages us to:<p>a) track and document our work so that when someone leaves on vacation the sky doesn&#x27;t fall b) take as much time as needed to unwind<p>I personally took about 6 weeks of vacation (double the amount of policy based vacation I got at my previous company) in the past year and things at work have been stellar. We delivered, kicked ass, whatever you want to call it and with zero guilt. But my company is well known for great work-life balance.<p>However, I can&#x27;t say the same about other teams where peer pressure keeps people in their seats.<p>I am personally very cautious about &#x27;unlimited vacation&#x27; plans because if you do a game matrix you&#x27;ll realize that it&#x27;s skewed against the employee and you&#x27;ll end up in a better place only if the stars align just right. If they don&#x27;t you&#x27;ll end up working way more and either you&#x27;ll never have &#x27;approved&#x27; vacation by your manager or you&#x27;ll never ask for it because passive-aggressively the culture frowns on &#x27;slackers&#x27; who take time off.<p>If vacation time matters to you (and It definitely should) before accepting an offer I would ask the hiring manager for the actual number of business days the team members use for vacation. If he&#x2F;she brushes it off or is handwavy like &#x27;nobody keeps track&#x27; (somebody ALWAYS keeps track) then stay away.
评论 #16768308 未加载
byoung2大约 7 年前
My coworker left to go work at LogicMonitor in Santa Barbara, CA (<a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.logicmonitor.com&#x2F;careers&#x2F;" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.logicmonitor.com&#x2F;careers&#x2F;</a>). Back in 2013 (not sure of the current policy) they offered unlimited vacations, and a $1000 bonus if you took a full week off and did not check email or do any work while you were out. He described it as a dinner buffet...in theory it looks like you could eat 10 steaks and 20 pizzas, but in reality even though it&#x27;s unlimited most people stick to the same portion sizes they would at a regular restaurant because your stomach is still the same size. He said that for him the big 1-2 week vacations were still limited by 1) cost, 2) his wife&#x27;s work schedule, 3) kids&#x27; school schedule. The one difference that having unlimited vacation made is that people didn&#x27;t have to lie about being sick all the time to take 1 or 2 days here and there.
评论 #16767135 未加载
评论 #16767686 未加载
joeld42大约 7 年前
For me it was super stressful and made it really hard to plan. What I did was decide how much leave I wanted if this were a &quot;traditional&quot; system, discussed that with my manager informally (he still wouldn&#x27;t give me a straight answer but I got to a number that he seemed to be okay with), and tracked the vacation and sick time myself in a spreadsheet.<p>One thing I did notice is that it seemed very hard to get more vacation as a more senior employee.<p>I think it&#x27;s less about flexibility for the employee and more so they don&#x27;t have to keep everyone&#x27;s unused vacation on the balance sheet and in the bank. Also they don&#x27;t have to pay out that unused vacation when you leave, so if you&#x27;re tracking it yourself, try not to &quot;accrue&quot; a lot of vacation. The reality of &quot;unlimited vacation&quot; means you will probably take around the same amount as someone at a traditional setup, but it will be more frequent shorter vacations and you&#x27;re less likely to take like a month off for a big summer trip.<p>I&#x27;ve also seen this system (perhaps inadvertently) take advantage of people with workaholic tendencies or people that tend to feel a lot of peer pressure to support the team, and &quot;unlimited vacation&quot; can mean &quot;no vacation&quot; for some folks.
评论 #16767106 未加载
评论 #16772812 未加载
kraftman大约 7 年前
I&#x27;m sure some companies are doing it properly, but I think for the most part it&#x27;s &#x27;unlimited holiday if you get the work done&#x27;, which turns into &#x27;holiday if you get the work done&#x27;, and there will always be enough work that it never gets done.<p>At previous company we switched to the &#x27;unlimited holiday&#x27; policy, I asked my boss what the real limit was and she said if it was anything over 27 days (the previous amount before being &#x27;unlimited&#x27;) then the manager would have to sign off on it, which basically wouldn&#x27;t happen.<p>I&#x27;m experiencing a similar thing at my current job where when I asked what the office hours and lunch hours were I couldn&#x27;t get a straight answer, it&#x27;s kept intentionally vague so that when it gets to 5 you don&#x27;t go &#x27;well I&#x27;m off home, bye!&#x27;
gricardo99大约 7 年前
It sounds like a way for employers to cut benefits&#x2F;costs.<p>If you have PAID vacation, that you accrue, then that&#x27;s something you get, regardless if you take it or not (of course there are usually caps on how much you can accrue). If it&#x27;s &quot;unlimited&quot;, I guess that means there&#x27;s no accrual, and if you take no (or minimal) vacation and leave, your vacation benefits were effectively reduced.<p>I think &quot;unlimited&quot; vacation is a gimmick to sound generous. If you want to offer a generous vacation policy, then stand behind it as an actual paid benefit. Offer it as paid vacation, and if the employee doesn&#x27;t take that much while they work for you, then hopefully they use that banked paid time to take a break between jobs.
评论 #16767727 未加载
评论 #16767354 未加载
noetic_techy大约 7 年前
From what I&#x27;ve heard from people in companies that have implemented it, it basically devolves into &quot;you can take off whenever your want but... we really need you here due to crunch!&quot; Basically it turns into a game of guilting people NOT to take any vacation time. Having guaranteed off time that can be scheduled well in advance and flexible working hours is way more reassuring.<p>In my opinion, why not just be way more generous in how much PTO time employees accrue? If European companies can still function with employees taking up to a month off why is it such a big deal to be generous in this category?
评论 #16767166 未加载
评论 #16770218 未加载
ben1040大约 7 年前
Worked for a (now defunct) Silicon Valley company that did this. My experience also really turned me off to the whole idea.<p>The problem was that it was not clearly defined across the company how much vacation was too much or too little, and even if you hear one thing when you get hired, a reorg can put you under someone with a totally different viewpoint. Meanwhile, in companies I&#x27;ve worked without unlimited vacation, it&#x27;s clearly defined how much vacation is too much, because you can&#x27;t use more than your bucket.<p>My first boss was the one who hired me into the company, and when he called me to present the offer, he told me that as a European he felt people in the US don&#x27;t take enough time off and he wanted us to do 4-5 weeks a year. At one point mid-summer he told me &quot;I don&#x27;t think you&#x27;ve taken enough time off, it&#x27;s slow next week, so go have the week off and take your kid to the pool a lot.&quot;<p>That boss left the company, and I got reorged into a team that was pretty much the remnants of a startup that my employer had acquihired. The company was pushing this team to develop and release a particular new product concept ASAP, but giving minimal staffing to do so, so it was constant lowgrade crunch the whole time. The manager (and former founder of that startup) was also still operating in startup-hustle mode and setting the sort of example that while you technically get time off, you&#x27;d best not be taking a whole lot.<p>I worked under each boss for a year. Under manager 1 I took 4.5 work weeks off in 12 months. Under manager 2 I took 7 days off in 12 months.<p>Not a lawyer but I imagine that companies don&#x27;t provide more guidance on _minimum_ vacation time usage, because maybe that could be construed as a bucket, and would put you back under the idea that in certain jurisdictions (California included) vacation accruals are viewed as compensation duly earned by the employee but not paid out yet. Avoiding having to carry that as a liability on your books and pay out when people separate, as I understand it, is the primary purpose behind unlimited vacation policies in the first place.
nfriedly大约 7 年前
USA. When I was at Sociable Labs, unlimited vacation worked out pretty well for me. I took around 4-5 weeks most years. Typically a week or less at a time, although I&#x27;d do a 2 weeks around Christmas and I think I took one 2-week trip during the summer.<p>Some of my colleagues weren&#x27;t very proactive about it, so after a couple of years, the manager started assigning folks a week off here and there if they hadn&#x27;t taken much vacation recently. I think something like this is a good idea.<p>I&#x27;m now at Tanium, and they have unlimited &#x2F; self-directed vacation, but I&#x27;ve only been around for a few months, so I&#x27;ve only taken a day or two off.<p>They told me that most folks take 4~5 weeks a year here also, and I have seen a couple colleagues take vacations where they were wholly unreachable for a week or more.<p>My first job out of high school did <i>not</i> have unlimited vacation, but I took the month of August off (unpaid) my second year there - that was nice.
评论 #16767016 未加载
JBReefer大约 7 年前
It works OK, but there&#x27;s two situations where it can go bad:<p>1. (Uncommon) People take off during crunch time<p>2. (Very common IME) People take off en masse during lulls, leaving a skeleton crew to handle blowups.<p>3. No vacation payout during layoffs<p>If you do 1 just to get out of work, you&#x27;re a crappy coworker. People do 2, to be team players, but it can result in large waves of low staffing. 3 is a natural result, which is a major financial downside - the upside, of course, is that you can take much more vacation, and many do.<p>Even with the above, I like it. You can take mental health days and deal with family issues without that feeling of &quot;begging for forgiveness&quot;
评论 #16767218 未加载
评论 #16767379 未加载
lhorie大约 7 年前
In my company, in practice it means around 4 weeks with standard accrual. Had a coworker that wanted to go to Japan for 3 months, and the condition for approval was that the other 2 months would be unpaid sabbatical. IIRC, he ended getting part time pay for a some of that time due to on-call duties. I took my vacations in chunks and went a bit over by a few days. Vacation approval is at the discretion of the manager, and mine is pretty lax about accrual, as long as work is getting done overall. I hear in some teams, people need to be told to take _more_ vacations than they do (workaholic younguns, I guess).<p>We disable publishing to production during end-of-year holidays to minimize risks of outages (though of course you can break the glass in case something does break)<p>I work at Uber, in San Francisco.
jcadam大约 7 年前
My current workplace has &quot;unlimited&quot; vacation. You have to request days off in advance, which your supervisor can approve&#x2F;disapprove.<p>However, once you reach 4 weeks (160 Vacation hours) you have to get VP-level approval to take any additional time off. And the vacation hours tracker resets at the end of the Fiscal Year.<p>So, basically, unlimited means 4 weeks per year tops, and you have to get it approved in advance. I don&#x27;t really care for it.
评论 #16767082 未加载
评论 #16767208 未加载
Symbiote大约 7 年前
This is mostly disappointing. I&#x27;d assumed this was a very special benefit, and meant 8-10 weeks off per year!<p>My contract gives me 6 weeks, which is pretty standard in Denmark, and fairly standard in Europe. I use all 30 days, every year. I spread it around, not more than 2 weeks at once, but others take 3-4 weeks off during the summer.<p>I can only see one comment (praneshp) where more than 30 days has been taken, and many where 4 weeks was the unwritten limit. There&#x27;s no country in Europe with less than 4 weeks holiday entitlement! [1]<p>(If I&#x27;m sick, that&#x27;s separate, and has no effect on my holidays. Except if I&#x27;m sick on holiday, then I get the holidays back to use some other time. I would need a note from my doctor to do this.)<p>Has anyone worked in Europe and then at an American company with the unlimited vacation policy, and taken more holiday than they were previously entitled to in Europe?<p>[1] <a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;en.wikipedia.org&#x2F;wiki&#x2F;List_of_minimum_annual_leave_by_country" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;en.wikipedia.org&#x2F;wiki&#x2F;List_of_minimum_annual_leave_b...</a>
评论 #16812014 未加载
tejasmanohar大约 7 年前
I&#x27;ve worked at Segment.com for the last ~2.5 years. We&#x27;ve had an unlimited vacation policy ever since I joined, and I take 4-6 weeks off annually. Our only policy that I&#x27;m aware of is to keep your team posted and not leave gaping holes while OOO.<p>Frankly, I <i>really</i> like it this way. I would <i>not</i> like to go back to tracking vacation&#x2F;sick days, check-in&#x2F;out times, WFH, etc. I appreciate the mutual trust the team has that people will work hard while in the office and stay away enough to sustainably enjoy life and remain productive.<p>I&#x27;ll add that I only think this sort of arrangement works if there is strong trust and leadership is a top-down role model in taking off time responsibly. I&#x27;ve never been asked to take time off, and I don&#x27;t know that anyone has, but I&#x27;ve also never been asked not to.<p>That said, I can also see this not working if you&#x27;re shy about asking for things that aren&#x27;t explicitly handed to you, then this system may not work as well. I&#x27;d be curious if anyone here has felt that way? :)
评论 #16812031 未加载
harryh大约 7 年前
In general, based on personal experience, I am not in favor of this sort of thing for tech companies beyond a certain size (perhaps 50 or so). I think it creates a situation that is ripe for misunderstandings and bad feelings. I used to think otherwise, but as I worked at companies that grew from tiny to moderately large I have definitely witnesses a threshold beyond which things start to break down.<p>We all know that &quot;unlimited&quot; does not really mean unlimited. No one is randomly taking off for 6 months to go walk the appalachian trail or whatever. So what does it mean? About as many days off as you would have had under a typical plan? Maybe with a few extra? But no one is really quite sure. So different people will inevitably have different interpretations which leads to bad feelings when one person takes 10 days off a year while another takes 25.<p>It also puts managers in an impossible situation when people complain. They have no rules or guidelines to point to in order to enforce any sort of standardization. After all, it says &quot;unlimited.&quot; What are they supposed to say to the person who takes off for an entire month one summer while everyone else is hard at work pushing that new release out? We have enough guilt conscious style management as it is. There is no need to add more.<p>There&#x27;s also the issue that if you aren&#x27;t tracking days then exiting employees don&#x27;t get paid off for unused days. I consider this a real problem as well.<p>I know it screams &quot;we&#x27;re a big company&quot; but just suck it up and acknowledge reality. Past ~50 you are a big company. It&#x27;s high time you act like one.<p>Ultimately paid time off is a form of compensation. Would you accept this sort of loosey-goosey attitude about how much cash or stock you are being paid? Probably not. So what is different about PTO?
praneshp大约 7 年前
My last two jobs have been unlimited PTO, and going forward, it&#x27;s a requirement for me.<p>Last job (Godaddy in sunnyvale, one of the nicest places I&#x27;ve worked in) didn&#x27;t have any tracking. For 3+ days you emailed manager and team. Current job&#x27;s the same, except you enter 3+ days in a software. At both places, I took ~20 days to go to India, and another 20 days at least rest of the year. More importantly, my manager can expect me to take a day off after a long night of pages.<p>At previous jobs, the 20 day India trip had to be reduced, or some unspoken agreement with manager, because I had 15 or so vacation days. I&#x27;m too spoilt now to handle that shit again. I haven&#x27;t come across a mandatory minimum, but I take off a healthy amount anyway and I&#x27;m unimportant enough that the team can make do with 10 months of me.
RickS大约 7 年前
USA. It has mostly to do with personality. People who can take 4 weeks in South America and not feel guilty do, and appear to have a great time. I typically take normal holidays (two weeks for xmas, a week here or there ~twice a year).<p>I think the best way to stave this off would be to have a mandatory minimum time. Eg, we have unlimited PTO but you have to take at least 4 weeks this year, or n days a quarter, or something like that.<p>Not sure if it&#x27;s legal to do that.<p>edit: another point that someone else brought up is that you can take sick&#x2F;mental health days often and with ease. This is very true, and is a benefit I&#x27;ve enjoyed a lot.
maximp大约 7 年前
Small but well-known NYC startup. Disliked the policy strongly, and nobody would give me a ballpark of vacation to take when I interviewed and after I joined. There was a huge discrepancy in how much vacation people took, which left some feeling resentful. A couple more senior employees took 4-5 weeks a year; most people did 2 weeks, with some pushing it a little more - 2-3 weeks. Anytime I asked HR, they encouraged me to &quot;take as much time as I need&quot;, but the work was nonstop, and my manager wasn&#x27;t happy anytime I took time off.
RamshackleJ大约 7 年前
Unlimited Vacation is the same as saying Unlimited Salary, its total BS. Without set guidelines in your employment contract of what PTO you get in exchange for working there it creates a drawn out negotiation between you, your manager and your team of how much vacation you actually get.<p>Its just better to know for sure what PTO you are entitled to in your employment contract. Would you accept a job without knowing what the salary was? Keep in mind that vacation days are something that you are EARNING in exchange for your work.
评论 #16768213 未加载
bg4大约 7 年前
In my experience it has a chilling effect on actual vacation taken. The real driver is not having to pay an employee for earned, unused vacation when they leave the company.
评论 #16767287 未加载
leonagano大约 7 年前
Hi, I&#x27;m running <a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;stretchyourannualleave.com" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;stretchyourannualleave.com</a> where people enter the number of days they like to book and the site calculates the maximum number of days off you can have, using public holidays and weekends.<p>What I notice is, people are looking to book 5, 10 and 15 days off and especially at the end of the year.
bsvalley大约 7 年前
It is not part of the employee benefits because it doesn&#x27;t exist. Can I take 2 months off in a row under an unlimited time-off policy? No. Why? Because I would &quot;disrupt&quot; a project or a team. Can I take all my Friday&#x27;s off? Nope... work weeks should be 5 days not 4. That&#x27;s what unlimited holiday means to me. So when a company says we have unlimited time-off policy I usually run away. Liars!
cagey大约 7 年前
One year ago I returned to work at a large&#x27;ish SV company that, in my absence, was acquired and in this transition was converted from &quot;PTO accrued at an annual rate that increased with seniority&quot; to &quot;unlimited vacation [as long as your manager agrees]&quot;.<p>It didn&#x27;t take much thinking to realize that &quot;unlimited vacation [as long as your manager agrees]&quot; is purely a way to screw the employee (who regresses to the mean of however much time they tend to habitually take off per year (having subconsciously ignored that they won&#x27;t be repaid in cash for those lost hours of time off when they leave their company), but now additionally &quot;has to beg&quot; for time off rather than the time off being something they&#x27;ve earned) while also removing the liability of the accum&#x27;d PTO they owe employees from their books.<p>The claimed justification that &quot;tracking PTO is an added accounting cost&quot; rings totally hollow: all employers I&#x27;ve worked for in my 20 year career had automated systems in place to track this info; in my current gig I&#x27;m still required to enter my hours worked per project every week into the same old automated system (into which I used to also enter PTO consumption), so it&#x27;s not like they lack the systems to track this information with minimal effort&#x2F;overhead.<p>As another comment mentioned: this and &quot;open office&quot; go hand in hand: IMO the employers all get together (AEA? etc) and learn about the extra-normal practices of the &quot;edgier&quot; employers, select those that save the employer $$$ (regardless of consequence to employees), and adopt = normalize them (while marketing them internally as modernity incarnate: &quot;this new system is SO MUCH BETTER than the way things used to be back in the bad old days; don&#x27;t you agree?&quot;).
fapjacks大约 7 年前
In <i>most</i> of the companies I&#x27;ve worked in with this policy, it ended up being a net negative. One place I think did it right, but I&#x27;m not sure how much of that was by design. People err on the side of not taking PTO, and everyone is always looking around at what everyone else is doing to see what&#x27;s &quot;normal&quot;, which adds a layer of stress to it. I mean of course it&#x27;s a policy smell where &quot;unlimited vacation&quot; is just a way to get more work out of employees, or if there&#x27;s actually some secret, behind-the-scenes value judgments being made against those rotten slackers for taking time off. But it seems to be one of those small ways that startups turn the screws on employee benefits. But actually at one of the places I worked, the CEO and the CTO took regular PTO. I mean of course the ship wasn&#x27;t rudderless, but I&#x27;d say they took liberal, European amounts of PTO under the no-vacation-policy policy. This was actually a really useful kind of &quot;lead by example&quot; that showed they were trying to actually have a cool &quot;unlimited vacation&quot; policy. Their big thing was that as long as the work was getting done, they didn&#x27;t care about butts-in-seats at all. Incidentally, that&#x27;s now the standard by which I measure all other companies. Anyway, I think it is largely not a good idea, and the only time I would ever say it was a positive thing was as part of a broader pattern of excellent management. Like the &quot;unlimited PTO&quot; policy working out positively to the benefit of everyone was just a side effect of having great management in the first place. If I ever start another company, I&#x27;m just going to hand out 20 days of PTO and be done with it: It&#x27;s sufficiently large that it&#x27;s as impressive as &quot;unlimited vacation&quot; is supposed to be, but without all the hidden baggage that usually comes with it.
sldfjnsdlfk大约 7 年前
Sounds good, doesn&#x27;t work. The fear of taking too much time off makes the conscientious not take enough holiday to maintain a healthy work-life balance. Others take advantage and &quot;are off on vacation again&quot; making the hardworking people bitter and resentful. Unlimited isn&#x27;t the answer, flexible and accommodating, while accountable, is.
handbanana大约 7 年前
Depends on the comnpany. It can mean 15-20 days PTO at some, can mean 30-40 at others. What you must remember is, there will be those who take more PTO than others, and some who take less. Be the person that takes more than the average, make it clear during hiring your PTO expectations. And be sure to take a lengthy amount of time off in the first 6 months of employment. Tell them about this prior to signing on. I have done this twice. It has worked both times. If the company is uncomfortable with the notion of at least 28 PTO days, or you taking 15 PTO days 2 months after getting hired. Then its a red flag IMO (assuming they led you to believe they had splendid PTO)<p>Company I work at doesn&#x27;t seem to notice&#x2F;care if people take off 35-40 PTO days, not including the paid holidays they also provide. Not many do this, though. Most people take 15-25 PTO days. Only one other person I know takes 30+ like I do
评论 #16812134 未加载
rconti大约 7 年前
Only been in my current role for 7 months; due to an acquisition I&#x27;ll never really see how it plays out. Small startup, I was &#x27;told&#x27; 2 weeks&#x2F;year even though it&#x27;s unlimited. Turns out you need a higher level of approval for more than 2 weeks at once which is a buzzkill because I prefer to take 3 week vacations when I travel overseas; that said, I&#x27;ve heard of employers who make using too much accrued PTO at much (eg, more than 2 weeks) difficult. So, IMO, it depends far more on your boss and the culture of the company than whether it&#x27;s &#x27;unlimited&#x27; or accrued PTO.<p>Ultimately I&#x27;ve taken 3 days in 7 months and am trying to swing a 3 week vacation in September.. we&#x27;ll see, I guess. It makes planning a bit difficult any time you need extra approval for &#x27;too many weeks&#x27; in a row. But I&#x27;ve always been a big believer in taking lots of vacation.
cimmanom大约 7 年前
How well? Better than 10 days&#x2F;yr metered PTO. Not as good as 20-25 days&#x2F;yr metered.<p>I probably average 15-20 days&#x2F;yr, with some guilt after the first 10 - which I wouldn&#x27;t have if more PTO were explicitly allocated; but my boss seems fine with the amount I take.<p>Reference: small to medium companies in the US.
66d8kk大约 7 年前
I&#x27;ve never experienced this myself directly. However I used to work at a company who now does this. I still have many silo&#x27;d friend groups at that company (who don&#x27;t even know each other too well - designers&#x2F;devs&#x2F;sales) and the general consensus when I&#x27;m out with each group is that &quot;it&#x27;s a trap&quot;. There appears to be a negative vibe a kind of undertone where people will question others (to them selves not openly) and the hierarchy. Admittedly the trust was never great at this company but from my third party view point I would absolutely not like it. Culture would play a huge part though and unfortunately in this case the unlimited leave was a marketing&#x2F;recruitment angle so was pretty much always set for failure.
wink大约 7 年前
Totally guessing but if we&#x27;re talking about the US, I think the Europeans that have worked in Europe before won&#x27;t have any qualms taking their 24-30 paid vacation days per year whereas the Americans might be inclined to stick to what they know and take their 2 weeks. All based on hearsay, so this might as well totally be wrong :)<p>My point of reference is when I had my first job with &quot;we don&#x27;t count your hours, you just need to do your job&quot; I still kept mental tabs on my hours and it took years until I really didn&#x27;t care anymore and just eyeballed it. (How can you even tell when &quot;your&quot; work is done? Especially if you work in sprints or with a kanban board)
vorpalhex大约 7 年前
United States here. I&#x27;ve worked at two companies that had this kind of unlimited policy.<p>The first one not only did I end up taking less vacation then I would of, I actually had my manager get mad at me for using more than two weeks of leave. I no longer work at said place for a myriad of reasons.<p>The current one is pretty good. I definitely need to be proactive about it, but I&#x27;ve never been denied or guilted. Last year I used a bit over 3 weeks (so about normal for my field), but this year I&#x27;m planning to use a bit more because I have a few different places I&#x27;d like to visit. It definitely took me some mental effort to get past my natural tendency to avoid taking off.
评论 #16767496 未加载
theptip大约 7 年前
The best system I&#x27;ve seen is a well-tracked generous allocation of N days per year, with the option to buy or sell 10 days per year. I think this is the fairest way of doing things; if you don&#x27;t care for vacation then you can increase your salary, and if you want more vacation you can pay to get it.<p>In practice the &quot;unlimited vacation&quot; seems hard to scale beyond a small team, though in that case it can be made to work. It relies on trust, which I&#x27;m skeptical would scale to hundreds of people.<p>That said while you&#x27;re small I think teams can get away with it if management lead by example and actually take good chunks of vacation.
allsunny大约 7 年前
I work for a reasonably large (500+ engineers) software company in San Francisco with &quot;unlimited vacation.&quot; I take between 4-5 weeks off a year (20-25 actual days off). It seems pretty typical amongst my colleagues.
philwelch大约 7 年前
It&#x27;s a mechanism to reduce the amount of bookkeeping HR has to do with vacation hours, with the added benefit of not having to pay out any vacation hours when an employee leaves.
projproj大约 7 年前
I have this with my current employer. The problem I see si that when I ask for time off, it feels like I&#x27;m asking for a favor. Might just be my superiors. I kind of wish it were more like &quot;I have x number of days off left for the year, I&#x27;d like to take some of those in October.&quot; I still get a generous amount of time off each year, but it&#x27;s awkward every time I make the request.<p>edit: Check out mrguyorama&#x27;s comment. They said what I was trying to say in a much better way.
notahacker大约 7 年前
Had vacation limited to 28 days plus national holidays once and struggled to use it due to the demands of the work. But I had a <i>right</i> to arrange it, which in one case meant taking four day weeks for six months. Wouldn&#x27;t have asked for the same thing if holiday was an &quot;unlimited&quot; privilege granted at the whim of line managers.<p>If you want actual unlimited holiday, become a contractor and get used to taking as much <i>unpaid</i> time out as you like, provided you can afford it.
donohoe大约 7 年前
I don&#x27;t think it works any better&#x2F;worse then limited vacation days.<p>The difference IMHO is that companies that paid out unused vacation time when you left no longer need to.
Myrmornis大约 7 年前
USA. I’ve worked under an unlimited vacation policy for 8 years. It’s fantastic, I’ve been able to do lots of trips to places I wanted to visit, and in addition can always see my family at holidays, and can always take time off when people visit me. I’ve never been denied or frowned at for taking time off. But I enjoy my job and my colleagues enjoy theirs, so people work hard without compulsion.
itsmejeff大约 7 年前
The Nash equilibrium for an unlimited vacation policy is no vacation for anyone.<p><a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.amazon.com&#x2F;Algorithms-Live-Computer-Science-Decisions&#x2F;dp&#x2F;1627790365&#x2F;ref=nodl_" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.amazon.com&#x2F;Algorithms-Live-Computer-Science-Deci...</a>
zellyn大约 7 年前
Joining (the Atlanta office of) Square, I was very nervous that “Unlimited Vacation” actually meant “No Vacation”. It hasn&#x27;t turned out that way: our office has a good work-life balance.<p>I would still expect that that is not generally the case.
评论 #16767512 未加载
eip大约 7 年前
If I had unlimited vacation I would pretty much just do 4 day work weeks.
noemit大约 7 年前
I&#x27;ve experienced being denied time off excessively, no vacation payout (even if I didn&#x27;t even take 2 weeks), strict rules about when you can take time off, for how long, etc.<p>Overall bad.
评论 #16767280 未加载
Gustomaximus大约 7 年前
Has anyone used &#x27;unlimited vacation&#x27; to work a 4 day week. Assuming work suitable, I&#x27;d be tempted work a longer Mon-Thur and take Fridays off.
gberger大约 7 年前
Palantir. 28+ days.