TE
科技回声
首页24小时热榜最新最佳问答展示工作
GitHubTwitter
首页

科技回声

基于 Next.js 构建的科技新闻平台,提供全球科技新闻和讨论内容。

GitHubTwitter

首页

首页最新最佳问答展示工作

资源链接

HackerNews API原版 HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 科技回声. 版权所有。

Losing 100 pounds in 276 days

502 点作者 agrinman将近 7 年前

74 条评论

rburhum将近 7 年前
First of all, congrats - that is amazing and really shows true commitment. As somebody that lost 30+ pounds (I am 5ft 65 and went from 205lbs to 172lbs), I definitely understand can sympathize with the work it takes.<p>For anyone else embarking on the journey, I would add a few things:<p>- When you are in caloric deficit and thus loosing weight, you can choose not to go to the gym, but you will lose muscle mass faster. If you want to <i>maintain</i> muscle mass as much as possible you are better off doing <i>some</i> weight lifting instead of running. You won&#x27;t gain muscle mass, but you&#x27;ll reduce the loss.<p>- Ghrelin is the hormone that you will need to control. It is what makes you hungry and ultimately ruins your diet. Funny enough, you control it by constantly eating low caloric foods. You want to eat a lot of veggies, fats (avocado will be your friend) and protein throughout the day in low amounts. Just stay under your target caloric intake.<p>- The most difficult part is <i>not</i> eating out. Meal preparation is key, and this takes time. When you eat out, you just don&#x27;t know how people prepared the meal you are eating. Sadly, meals that you eat outside have a huge amount of oil and counting calories will be next to impossible most of the time. Even in the cases where a restaurant lists caloric numbers with their plates, you can be certain that the cook is less interested in your caloric intake and more in getting your order out the door. Six tablespoons of olive oil instead of the one you are counting and you are off for the day already. The best you can hope when eating out is maintaining weight.<p>- Your body is designed for homeostasis and will fight you back to get you to regain it (through Ghrelin, mood swings, etc). After loosing the target weight, increase your caloric intake to stabilize it. If you can keep your weight for a year, it will be easy to remain at that weight later on.<p>Good luck!
评论 #17392317 未加载
评论 #17392568 未加载
评论 #17392788 未加载
评论 #17392659 未加载
评论 #17392962 未加载
评论 #17392611 未加载
评论 #17392378 未加载
评论 #17392464 未加载
ericcholis将近 7 年前
I&#x27;ve found that intermittent fasting was easies to implement in 12, 14, 16 hour increments. I do &quot;cheat&quot; just a bit with a coffee in the morning, and 14 hour cheat days on the weekends. Intermittent fasting, allegedly, has numerous benefits. Stem cell regeneration of damaged, old immune system. Improved dopamine levels in the brain. Increased growth hormone production.<p>I personally have found that I do feel &quot;run down&quot; which turned out to be lower blood pressure. I attributed this to low sodium intake. So, I drink two very low sugar (6g) recovery drinks for my first caloric intake around noon.<p>One thing that wasn&#x27;t covered, and likely isn&#x27;t in many of these weight loss recaps, is not just caloric deficit; but also food content. Sugar&#x27;s (and carbs) relationship to fat and our bodies cannot be understated. There&#x27;s plenty of reading on how high sugar diets are detrimental. Here&#x27;s an interesting listen: <a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.foundmyfitness.com&#x2F;episodes&#x2F;refined-sugar" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.foundmyfitness.com&#x2F;episodes&#x2F;refined-sugar</a><p>This image alone scares the snot out of me: <a href="http:&#x2F;&#x2F;reachingutopia.com&#x2F;wp-content&#x2F;uploads&#x2F;2013&#x2F;06&#x2F;sugar-in-drinks.jpg" rel="nofollow">http:&#x2F;&#x2F;reachingutopia.com&#x2F;wp-content&#x2F;uploads&#x2F;2013&#x2F;06&#x2F;sugar-i...</a><p>I think most people are aware of this in principle, but don&#x27;t often associate normal foods as being high in sugar. Orange juice is probably the worst offender. All the sugar, none of the fiber.
评论 #17392668 未加载
评论 #17392837 未加载
评论 #17391979 未加载
评论 #17394090 未加载
评论 #17392850 未加载
feintruled将近 7 年前
I embarked on a similar course as the author - just after Christmas I realised my BMI was well into the overweight category - and the same strategy of calorie counting worked for me. I can especially recommend using an app, this really helped me too. Turns it into a game almost - where can I cut out the unnecessary calories? Whereas before you might help yourself to a biscuit with a coffee now you know it is going to blow your budget right open. Makes it a lot easier to resist.<p>And it was easier than I thought - a piece of fruit for breakfast, a small lunch (single sandwich, down from two with crisps and chocolate bar on top some days), and a normal evening meal. That would come to around 1500 calories or less a day, easily enough to lose a few pounds a week. It becomes easier as time goes on - your body expects less, I guess. And you do gravitate towards healthier food, simply because you can eat so much more of it.<p>I&#x27;ve lost two and a half stone since then (I don&#x27;t follow the diet at weekends so I could have lost more) and am back in the green. Not as much as the article&#x27;s author - his loss was spectacular!<p>Alas I did not take a before and after picture, though others have commented, which feels good.<p>So yeah, great article that I can fully endorse, and encourage others to follow. Just set realistic targets, change will come eventually.
评论 #17391862 未加载
评论 #17392410 未加载
pottspotts将近 7 年前
Really great data! Thank you for sharing.<p>The hard part for me is mindset and willpower. Unfortunately, knowing the physics* behind weight loss doesn&#x27;t make it any easier, and perhaps might make it more stressful. Why can&#x27;t I do this simple thing that logically is as complex as 2+2. Our minds have their own prerogatives.<p>I wonder then what did you tell yourself? How many times did you have a bad day? What was your mood like throughout? I&#x27;d love to know so much more about the psychology. Great article though and thanks again for sharing!<p>* <a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.youtube.com&#x2F;watch?v=vuIlsN32WaE" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.youtube.com&#x2F;watch?v=vuIlsN32WaE</a>
评论 #17391767 未加载
评论 #17391802 未加载
评论 #17392744 未加载
评论 #17398436 未加载
评论 #17398712 未加载
评论 #17391723 未加载
nonbel将近 7 年前
&gt;<i>&quot;The only thing you really need to know is that you should be eating fewer calories than your body burns everyday. If you do this, you will lose weight – it’s science. Nothing else matters for weight loss. The magnitude of the caloric difference will regulate how quickly or slowly you lose the weight. [...] I naturally started eating healthy foods because I could eat more of them. If you eat a chocolate bar, you will still be hungry. For the same amount of calories, you could eat a few bowls of vegetables and be full. [...] Somewhere along the journey I picked up intermittent fasting. I like it but it’s also not necessary. I found that it helped reduce my appetite which means I can eat fewer calories.&quot;</i><p>I don&#x27;t really think this is consistent. Basically yes if you eat less calories than are used you must lose weight, but the ease of doing this depends on what you are eating.
评论 #17391778 未加载
评论 #17391766 未加载
评论 #17391905 未加载
mstaoru将近 7 年前
Great progress and tips! We&#x27;re developing a &quot;MyFitnessPal + UberEats&quot; food delivery service that automatically counts calories and macros here in Shanghai, where ~16 million people order their food instead of cooking or eating out. I wonder why nobody did this in the Bay Area at least? Is it generally lower penetration of food delivery? Or gathering the data is just too much work? It&#x27;s easier here with Chinese food: orders naturally consist of 2-3 dishes at least, and for 2-3 people it can be 5-6 dishes, making it possible for us to pick a right &quot;combo&quot; for the right macros. I think with Western food, most people would stick to one dish with a side, which is much harder to &quot;configure&quot; and meet the right target.<p>Also, of course, even a modest amount of exercise will kick off metabolic processes that speed up weight loss, not mentioning that increasing muscle mass will naturally increase the basal metabolic rate. Weight lifting routines like 5x5 or Greyskull LP can be squeezed into 20-30 minutes every other day, and provide lasting benefits almost immediately.
wukerplank将近 7 年前
&gt; [...] you should be eating fewer calories than your body burns everyday<p>and<p>&gt; I never understood how simple it was before starting this.<p>Sounds so trivial, but sadly true for a lot of things in life. You read and hear something multiple times, but you have to make the experience yourself to get your eyes opened.
评论 #17391765 未加载
评论 #17392017 未加载
评论 #17392332 未加载
评论 #17391992 未加载
评论 #17401468 未加载
评论 #17391806 未加载
评论 #17391733 未加载
jokoon将近 7 年前
You should really exercise, no matter what people tell you, or how difficult it feels.<p>Controlling your diet seems like the easy way, and I don&#x27;t think it&#x27;s really healthy because you will lack energy, and it&#x27;s easy to slip.<p>You should already stop drinking sodas and eating unnecessary snacks, but I&#x27;ll never believe that it&#x27;s the only thing you can do.<p>Remember that exercise gets easier over time, so just hang in there and take the pain. Sweating is good, all your body will be restarting if you exercise. All existing biology reacts to simulation, and dies if it stops moving. Just imagine your cells getting reorganized, cheese particles bring breathed out, and toxins getting filtered out.<p>Exercise will counter the problems created by bad diets but not only vascular. It will rebalance a lot of things. You will also sleep better.<p>There is truth in people living longer because they keep asking their body for more even when they age. All life forms thrived around biological movement. Sedentary lifestyle is the antithesis of living.
seshagiric将近 7 年前
I lost 15 pounds over a period of 3 months. Just want to share the following,<p>a. remove sugar from all diet including coffee etc.<p>b. double protein intake and halve carbs. One way to do is make your dinners protein only. Find Greek yogurt with low sugar content (or its easy to make at home too). This is especially important if you are above 35.<p>c. Read about the difference between fat and carbs. Till the time you reach target weight, eat carbs as little as possible.<p>d. If exercising try things like HIIT or weights that make you &#x27;exert&#x27; yourself. Even if its just 5 minutes per day.<p>Regarding motivation to avoid over eating, make sure your diets includes periodic snacks. There are lot of benefits of eating frequent but light meals (trail mixes with nuts, boiled eggs, green tea, fruits are good examples). Trail mixes with little bit of sugar are ok as they help stop the sugar craving if you have one.
评论 #17393988 未加载
hazz99将近 7 年前
Damn dude, that&#x27;s awesome progress! I love the consistency.<p><pre><code> On average, it takes about 3,500 calories to burn 1 pound of fat. Suppose you eat 1,000 fewer calories than your Basal Metabolic Rate (BMR). After a week your body will burn 7,000 calories or 2 lbs of fat. </code></pre> I&#x27;m almost surprised that the weight curve dropped off linearly -- I always thought weight fell off quickly at the beginning, before plateauing towards the end. Great personal &quot;myth&quot; to have dispelled.<p>Can I also compliment the site design? It&#x27;s very clean, and presented the information well.
评论 #17391780 未加载
评论 #17391742 未加载
评论 #17391748 未加载
评论 #17391758 未加载
评论 #17391754 未加载
nigelk将近 7 年前
I lost 50 pounds in under 200 days, and then another 20 over the next year.<p>Here&#x27;s what worked for me:<p><pre><code> * Calorie counting to work out baselines * Accept the feeling of being hungry and learn to relish it (&quot;I&#x27;m losing weight if I&#x27;m hungry&quot;) * Do light weightlifting at home * Exercise naked in front of a mirror for positive and negative reinforcement</code></pre>
fbnlsr将近 7 年前
I&#x27;ve been struggling with weight problems and my self-image for as long as I can remember. I&#x27;ve tried the Dukan diet ten years ago, which was a total disaster. At my heaviest I was 84kg for 174cm. That&#x27;s a BMI of 27.<p>Two years ago, I had a minor motorcycle crash, and at the hospital the doctor was scared about my heart rate. It was fast and it was loud, around 100 bpm at rest. I always had a heart with a fast beat so I didn&#x27;t really care about it. Then, my son was born. At that moment I decided that I needed to take care of myself and started going to the gym. Alas, being a new parent takes a lot of time and energy, and I had to cancel my membership last year.<p>So I&#x27;ve been experimenting with intermittent fasting since then, and it&#x27;s been the best thing I&#x27;ve done in a long time.<p>I started doing the usual &quot;16&#x2F;8&quot;, that is fast for 16 hours and eat during the following 8 hours window. Basically it meant skipping breakfast and having lunch at around 1pm, which is extremely easy to do.<p>The past two months, I cranked the notch a bit and I&#x27;ve been doing OMAD (One Meal A Day). I eat from 7pm to 9pm and the rest of the time I only drink water or black coffee. It just changed my life.<p>In the past two months I&#x27;ve lost 9kg, so now I&#x27;m at 73kg, and I&#x27;ve never felt so good in my life.<p>My mind feels sharper throughout the day, and I&#x27;ve developed a completely different relationship with food. I now consider it to be fuel, and I&#x27;ve started thinking about the quality of fuel I&#x27;m putting in my body. So now I cook and I try to chose good meat and vegetables, and I&#x27;m trying to cut on sugar and pasta. I still eat lunch sometimes (when I&#x27;m visiting my parents or I&#x27;m having lunch with a client) but I don&#x27;t really care as I know that my weight is going to regulate itself in the few following days.<p>And my heart rate is now normal. At rest, it&#x27;s beating at around 65 bpm.<p>If anyone&#x27;s interested, I highly recommend watching Jason Fung on Youtube. His talks about fasting have been an eye opener for me. His approach on obesity through hormonal regulation is amazing.
Mashimo将近 7 年前
&gt; I tried running – about 30m, every morning, for 3 months.<p>For a few seconds I was confused as to how much running 30 meters would help :D But I guess he means 30 minutes.
评论 #17391781 未加载
bluedino将近 7 年前
I&#x27;m always amazed at the people who can drop a hundred lbs in a year. &quot;I just changed my diet to 1500 calories and bam, the weight fell off.&quot;<p>Not that it isn&#x27;t that simple, because it is. But, because for most people who are 100lbs overweight, they have a very unhealthy relationship with food. They stress eat, binge eat, binge drink, purge...<p>I guess it&#x27;s kind of like the people who can just all of a sudden quit smoking, cold-turkey one day. Maybe they weren&#x27;t addicted to nicotine in the first place?
评论 #17392443 未加载
评论 #17392137 未加载
评论 #17392117 未加载
评论 #17392229 未加载
Bedon292将近 7 年前
I definitely need to lose some weight myself. Unfortunately I can never stick with anything. Including this simple method. I have done MyFitnessPal for weeks, and then fall out of the habit. Just never manage to stick with it, and not sure how to keep myself motivated for it.<p>Of course its always hard, half the time I eat at the salad bar at work, and I may not be able to estimate the amounts right. I always worry about underestimating how much I ate. I have even considered eating pre-packaged meals, but those always leave me hungry, and seem like a less healthy sodium filled alternative.<p>Not sure what my point is, but I guess I am wondering if anyone has managed to keep themselves motivated after years of failing to stay motivated? And if so, how?
评论 #17392790 未加载
评论 #17399422 未加载
weliketocode将近 7 年前
A friend was telling me about her latest date.<p>The guy refused to eat at dinner because he gets his energy from the sun using photosynthesis.<p>As laughable as it sounds, it&#x27;s not out-of-line compared to all the dietary marketing myths and superstitions that somehow persist.
评论 #17392312 未加载
yoda_sl将近 7 年前
Congrats! I have started a similar approach for the last 2 months using LoseIt as my app to count calories, and the goal to loose around 64 pounds by end of the year (going from 244 to 180 pounds).<p>I did join a gym, and this weekend decided to get a personal trainer for a couple months to be sure that I build some muscle mass too: my core is definitely weak, and gaining some muscle will not hurt to strengthen my body: had a few injuries (ankle&#x2F;knee) where having muscles will probably avoid it.<p>So far on track, with almost 20 pounds lost (19.4 as of yesterday), and going to the gym 4 to 5 times a week 45 minutes to 1 hour at a time...
notacoward将近 7 年前
Losing weight is all about triggering the body&#x27;s mechanisms to convert fat into energy, and not triggering its mechanisms to turn food into fat. Counting calories or exercising more are the most basic attempts to do this. If you want to add a bit of nuance you can play around with <i>what</i> you eat, <i>how</i> you exercise, <i>when</i> you do each. But the key thing is this:<p><pre><code> We&#x27;re all different. </code></pre> I&#x27;ve decided to lose weight a couple of times, on the order of 20-40 pounds each time. What has worked <i>for me</i> has been a combination of generally eating&#x2F;drinking less, concentrating almost all of that into a small time window, and a fair bit of running. But the reason it works for me is very specific to what it takes to kick <i>my</i> body into fat-burning mode, how fast and how long <i>my</i> body sustains that, how this affects <i>my</i> energy levels, <i>my</i> physical ability to perform various kinds of exercise or tolerate various kinds of discomfort (e.g. I don&#x27;t mind running on an empty stomach but I hate sleeping that way), and so on.<p>Something vaguely similar to what I do might work for a lot of people, but the devil&#x27;s in the details. My <i>specific</i> formula won&#x27;t work for you. Experiment and find your own. The best thing about the recent IF&#x2F;TRF&#x2F;OMAD&#x2F;whatever fad is not that it provides a specific blueprint but that it encourages people to experiment with different variations to find <i>their own</i> balance points.
jillesvangurp将近 7 年前
Welcome to middle age ;-). I had a stern talking to a few years ago by my doctor and was forced to take measures as well or face the prospect of likely complications.<p>This stuff is hard because we people are not very rational. So, here&#x27;s a few simple practical things.<p>- Get a scale, put it in your bathroom, and use it as often as you can. Step 0 is simply knowing how you are doing. I know down to a few hundred grams what I weigh most of the time and I&#x27;ve learned the impact of my behavior on the scale. A big dinner, excessive drinking, etc. has a measurable impact that peters out over several days before I&#x27;m back to &quot;normal&quot;. Simply knowing, has a moderating effect on what I do.<p>- Make changes in your behavior that you can turn into habits. Starving yourself definitely works short term but you&#x27;ll bounce right back as soon as you resume your old habits. Kind of pointless. Regular fasting is great though because it becomes a habit and you don&#x27;t have to take decisions.<p>- Try not to set your self up for being tempted to eat too much. In my case, going shopping after work when I&#x27;m tired and hungry leads to predictably bad decision making. Make sure you eat before you shop.<p>- Be honest about alcohol. I actually quit drinking completely for a while. Turns out that going for after work beers multiple times per week has a insanely huge caloric impact. I identified it as the single biggest thing that was impacting my weight and duly eliminated it for two years. These days I drink but much less than I used to. In my case I found it easier to not drink than to drink a little. One of the side-effects of alcohol is bad decision making. 1 Beer always leads to more beers. If this is hard for you, that&#x27;s a good sign of being addicted. All the more reason to try to change things.
dalbasal将近 7 年前
Counting calories in&#x2F;out <i>is</i> a way to lose weight that works for a lot of people. It also works well in clinical &amp; research settings, where control mechanisms are strong. That said:<p>&quot;<i>The only thing you really need to know is that you should be eating fewer calories than your body burns everyday. If you do this, you will lose weight – it’s science. Nothing else matters for weight loss</i>&quot;<p>This may be one of the most harmful statements about diet. It&#x27;s mostly true, but in a fairly banal sense. A baby will have a caloric surpluss as it grow. So will a potato. Without the calories, growth will stunt. This is the trivial fact.<p>The growth trajectory of a potato or baby is not trivially <i>determined by</i> caloric surplusses. One big factor is genetics, which tell babies and potatoes to grow. There are environmental factors, many of which are calorie related.<p>&quot;This is a scientific fact&quot; is in the context it&#x27;s used, an empty tautology. Caloric surplusses can be used in exactly the same way to &quot;explain&quot; why an elephant is bigger than a mouse, why there are 6 billion people on the planet, how a bodybuilder got his biceps or why you got fat. This makes it a nonexplanation.<p>A less abstract hint that we&#x27;re dealing with a nonexplanation is apples. Add one apple a day to your diet, and calorie counting will tell you that amounts to 5kg fat per year.<p>We know from experience that people do not gain&#x2F;lose 10 lbs per year by adding an apple a day to their diet. Your apetite or metabolism (these are related) will compensate for the apple.<p>That doesn&#x27;t mean that intentional caloric restriction isn&#x27;t a good method. It works well for some. Other things work well for others. We don&#x27;t have perfect knowledge about what works &quot;in the wild&quot; or even in the lab.
评论 #17391932 未加载
评论 #17391949 未加载
评论 #17391920 未加载
Asooka将近 7 年前
For those who do calorie counting - how do you deal with all the work? E.g. if I want to make a sandwich, the process is<p>1. Find the nutritional information on the back of the bread bag. Enter that into the app.<p>2. Put slice of bread on the scale. Record weight, put into app.<p>3. Zero out scale with slice of bread still on it.<p>4. Put slice of ham on slice of bread, record weight. Enter into app... that brand of ham is not on the app.<p>5. Enter ham nutritional information into app. Enter ham slice weight into app.<p>6. Put a big amount of green salad on the sandwich. We&#x27;re not counting the calories in that, but we need it to zero out the scale.<p>7. Put a second slice of ham on the sandwich, measure its weight, enter into app.<p>8. Put a second slice of bread, measure its weight, enter into app.<p>9. You have now spent 20 minutes making a sandwich and wrestling with an infuriating mobile interface for entering information.<p>And this is the most basic of foods. If I decide to actually cook something, things get super hairy, because I have to first measure the raw ingredients, then measure the weight of the cooked food, then divide the amount of calories in the ingredients by the weight of the cooked food to obtain calories&#x2F;gram, then use that to calculate portion size. The ingredients I use are constrained in variety and quantity by what&#x27;s available in my local stores, so I can&#x27;t even make the exact same thing every time, so I have to repeat this process every day.<p>It also meant I couldn&#x27;t eat out at most restaurants, because there was no nutritional information available, which is the point when I gave up trying to count calories, because having to make everything from scratch myself, while also measuring and entering ingredients in the app means spending 2-3 hours per day on just making food, which is time I don&#x27;t really have.
评论 #17393122 未加载
评论 #17393017 未加载
jsty将近 7 年前
&gt; The only thing you really need to know is that you should be eating fewer calories than your body burns everyday. If you do this, you will lose weight – it’s science. Nothing else matters for weight loss. The magnitude of the caloric difference will regulate how quickly or slowly you lose the weight.<p>One important point to note is that past a certain level, usually around a 500kcal per day deficit, it becomes extremely hard to maintain. Performance physically + mentally will start dropping off quickly. If you do want &#x2F; need a larger deficit, do more low-intensity exercise rather than reducing caloric intake, and make sure you have a reasonably varied diet (or at least take a multivitamin).<p>(I used to do competitive sport with weight classes, and messing up your weight plan was never fun ...). Standard disclaimer: I am not a doctor or nutritionist etc.
评论 #17391808 未加载
edpichler将近 7 年前
I used the same approach explained in the article and it also worked very very fast for me. The most pain to me was using MyFitnesPal, that is really annoying because of its usability. It was a pain to use it. I will try to use pencil and paper, and one time a day, type it all on the app.
评论 #17391755 未加载
评论 #17393075 未加载
pwthornton将近 7 年前
Here is what I recently started doing after fits and starts to get into better shape over the years. Losing weight is relatively easy. Keeping it off long term is hard.<p>So instead of trying to be small, I&#x27;ve started to embrace the fact that I am a larger person whose body wants to be on the larger side. I started lifting really heavy weights, focusing more on adding muscle and gaining strength and a lot less on weight. I&#x27;m doing the Starting Strength program, which is a basic power lifting program.<p>I started in early May at around 240 at 6&#x27;1. I&#x27;m now about 236, so a little bit of gradual weight loss, but I&#x27;ve dropped a lot of fat and added on muscle.<p>I am trying to make sure I eat healthy and clean, but don&#x27;t do calories counting or anything like that.<p>The other benefit of power lifting is that it requires you to take care of yourself in other parts of your life. You must get good sleep. The more, the better. Otherwise, your body can&#x27;t require from all of the stress. You also need to eat good foods to help your body recover from muscle tears and add on new muscle.<p>I can understand the allure of mostly focusing on calorie counting as technically just eating less doesn&#x27;t require additional time, but I have found the 3x 1-1.5 hour lifting sessions well worth it. I feel and look a lot better. Also, the focus and commitment required to do power lifting well spills over to the rest of your life. I&#x27;ll provide an update after six months.
Spoom将近 7 年前
This is great! Congratulations.<p>I recently lost a little less than 50 pounds doing Whole30 (for 30 days, followed by a lighter version with occasional exceptions). I liked it because I didn&#x27;t really need to count calories. Yes, it technically falls into the &quot;fancy diet&quot; category since you&#x27;re eliminating food groups. It had a few advantages that I think straight calorie counting didn&#x27;t, though.<p>Its restriction from any added sugar or sweetener both naturally reduces calorie intake massively <i>and</i> tends to stabilize energy levels throughout the day, while eliminating cravings over time. I&#x27;ve found that I don&#x27;t really want to eat many of the things I used to.<p>The foods that Whole30 eliminates tend to be emptier calories than others. There is some science behind the choices but admittedly it&#x27;s not peer reviewed or anything. That said, again, I don&#x27;t really miss toast, bread, or cereal that much. Dairy was hard at first but easy now (and again, swapping for water eliminates a bunch of calories). I think not drinking Diet Coke helped my health, but I have a harder time identifying why.<p>Also, I don&#x27;t really have to try on this plan. My weight just tends to drop off without thinking about it.<p>I did Weight Watchers before, which kinda worked but left me both hungry fairly constantly and frustrated by the constant food lookups and logging.<p>Some consider Whole30 woo or unhealthy, which is fine, but it works pretty well for me.
pards将近 7 年前
The most critical part of this story is that <i>he was consistent</i>. When it comes to health, diet and exercise consistency is the most important factor.
davidlago将近 7 年前
Nutrition and weight regulation is not as simple as a direct function of calorie intake. The storage of fat in our bodies does not follow the &quot;laws of physics&quot; like someone down in the comments mentioned. This field is actively being studied (and heavily lobbied&#x2F;backed by some food companies).<p>I&#x27;m glad this strategy worked for you, but I hope people don&#x27;t take this as advice that is easily generalized.
评论 #17392346 未加载
htoe8n324nt将近 7 年前
&gt; The second greatest feature is the food database. MyFitnessPal has fairly accurate calorie estimates for almost anything you’d ever eat. I recorded what I ate, every single meal and snack, every single day, and even now I still do it. I’ll probably do it for many years to come. It’s amazingly helpful to stay on track.<p>I did this for about 6 months to a year, and yes, it absolutely works. But it is soooo tedious as to be almost impossible to keep up with.<p>I found that using my fitness tracking watch to measure how many calories I burn while taking daily walks and going to the gym 2x a week was far easier and more rewarding than the calorie counting.<p>I find the calorie counting apps often have a limited database of foods, and if you&#x27;re eating healthy, and not buying packaged foods as much, you have to enter tons more data, and it&#x27;s much less accurate because you don&#x27;t know how much of a given food you&#x27;re eating unless you measure everything before cooking it (which is also tedious). It works, but not without a lot of effort, which is what turns most people off from losing weight.
bad_good_guy将近 7 年前
I would wager that hackernews is probably one of the worst places for misinformation in terms of discussing health&#x2F;fitness&#x2F;weight loss.<p>I am seeing a lot of disregard for exercise and in particular heavy weightlifting which has a ton of benefits to daily life.<p>The original post itself shows a guy who goes for 1000 kcal deficit which is widely known as being twice as much as the healthy maximum.
评论 #17393432 未加载
评论 #17392598 未加载
crazygringo将近 7 年前
&gt; <i>Caloric Deficit == Weight Loss. The only thing you really need to know is that you should be eating fewer calories than your body burns everyday. If you do this, you will lose weight – it’s science. Nothing else matters for weight loss.</i><p>True but completely disingenuous. If you normally eat 3,000 calories&#x2F;day, and cut it to 2,000 calories&#x2F;day, you won&#x27;t necessarily lose weight -- many people&#x27;s metabolisms will simply slow down equivalently.<p>Happy for this guy that it worked, but not all of us are so lucky. Turns out there are a lot of different factors that affect our metabolism, which can be just as important (if not more).<p>Edit: see Gary Taubes&#x27; work on this, extremely detailed stuff on what regulates metabolism and fat storage, there&#x27;s nothing simple about it -- e.g. <a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.amazon.com&#x2F;Good-Calories-Bad-Controversial-Science&#x2F;dp&#x2F;1400033462" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.amazon.com&#x2F;Good-Calories-Bad-Controversial-Scien...</a>
评论 #17393379 未加载
评论 #17393339 未加载
评论 #17393374 未加载
评论 #17393332 未加载
coryfklein将近 7 年前
For anybody interested in accurate monitoring of body weight, I highly recommend checking out a Bod Pod near you. You step in this pod, it vacuum seals, and it uses air displacement to measure your body fat percentage (accuracy usually around 0.5% [1]). Afterwards they print out a sheet that has specific measurements of everything: weight, height, body fat %, non-body fat %, etc.<p>Last I tried, it cost $30 at a local university and took about 30 minutes. Once you know your current body fat % it is much easier to figure exactly how many lbs you need to lose to reach your target %. When going by BMI much of that is guesswork.<p>Locations here: <a href="http:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.cosmed.com&#x2F;en&#x2F;contact-us&#x2F;test-site-locator" rel="nofollow">http:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.cosmed.com&#x2F;en&#x2F;contact-us&#x2F;test-site-locator</a><p>[1] <a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov&#x2F;pubmed&#x2F;10487380" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov&#x2F;pubmed&#x2F;10487380</a>
评论 #17393360 未加载
virtuallynathan将近 7 年前
Many people in this thread are talking about CICO (Calories In&#x2F;Calories Out). While this does &quot;work&quot;, I quite like this paper to explain why it&#x27;s only a proximate cause of weight gain&#x2F;loss.<p>&quot;How calorie-focused thinking about obesity and related diseases may mislead and harm public health. An alternative&quot;<p>&quot;Abstract: Prevailing thinking about obesity and related diseases holds that quantifying calories should be a principal concern and target for intervention. Part of this thinking is that consumed calories – regardless of their sources – are equivalent; i.e. ‘a calorie is a calorie’. The present commentary discusses various problems with the idea that ‘a calorie is a calorie’ and with a primarily quantitative focus on food calories. Instead, the authors argue for a greater qualitative focus on the sources of calories consumed (i.e. a greater focus on types of foods) and on the metabolic changes that result from consuming foods of different types. In particular, the authors consider how calorie-focused thinking is inherently biased against high-fat foods, many of which may be protective against obesity and related diseases, and supportive of starchy and sugary replacements, which are likely detrimental. Shifting the focus to qualitative food distinctions, a central argument of the paper is that obesity and related diseases are problems due largely to food-induced physiology (e.g. neurohormonal pathways) not addressable through arithmetic dieting (i.e. calorie counting). The paper considers potential harms of public health initiatives framed around calorie balance sheets – targeting ‘calories in’ and&#x2F;or ‘calories out’ – that reinforce messages of overeating and inactivity as underlying causes, rather than intermediate effects, of obesity. Finally, the paper concludes that public health should work primarily to support the consumption of whole foods that help protect against obesity-promoting energy imbalance and metabolic dysfunction and not continue to promote calorie directed messages that may create and blame victims and possibly exacerbate epidemics of obesity and related diseases.&quot;<p><a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.cambridge.org&#x2F;core&#x2F;services&#x2F;aop-cambridge-core&#x2F;content&#x2F;view&#x2F;7203F27BFDE14B828C50F20548BCC49C&#x2F;S1368980014002559a.pdf&#x2F;how_caloriefocused_thinking_about_obesity_and_related_diseases_may_mislead_and_harm_public_health_an_alternative.pdf" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.cambridge.org&#x2F;core&#x2F;services&#x2F;aop-cambridge-core&#x2F;c...</a>
spoiler将近 7 年前
I started body weight exercises with a friend who guided me—and is very experienced in the area, and also started being in a slight [1] calories deficit.<p>I&#x27;ve been at it for about 5 months now and I&#x27;ve dropped 30 kg as of a few days ago (from 118kg), which is 66lbs (from 260lbs).<p>The added benefit of exercise is that my energy levels are much more stable throughout the day, and my mood is generally better and more positive.<p>Also, this wasn&#x27;t so much of a diet as a lifestyle change. I always wanted to get into body weight exercises and gymnastics, but got discouraged by injuries and lack of knowledge&#x2F;guidance. So, I&#x27;m very lucky to have met my friend (in more ways than one) who helped set me on the path I wanted to be!<p>[1]: The deficit might not be so slight anymore, given I gained strength and increased my intnesity whilst keeping the calories the same. I&#x27;ve started eating a bit more to compensate for that now, but I&#x27;m still in a net deficit.
tsenkov将近 7 年前
Last year I lost 44 pounds (20kg) by counting calories (I also used MyFitnessPal to count and record everything).<p>My advice to people who want to be successful into this, would be:<p>1. Be realistic with the calories you consume. Use an app to track everything down. Eat more raw vegetables and lean protein-source foods that are easy to account for and will fill you up (so you will not feel hungry all of the time). Measure everything to the gram. Buy a scale and try preparing most of your food yourself.<p>2. Don&#x27;t have cheat-days. Get to your goal and then, you add a few hundred calories a day to equalize intake&#x2F;expenditure (so you stop losing weight), so you will have a few hundred more calories a day to eat - now you can (hopefully) have what you want and would not be cheating.<p>3. Be realistic with the calories you spend. Get an armband to measure your movement throughout the day, measure yourself on the scale every week and if things don&#x27;t add-up - correct for the error.<p>4. Don&#x27;t go for more than 0.5kg loss per week. Having such a huge deficit to make 1kg of fat go away within a week can render you in a very unproductive state where you barely can get anything done during the day (that&#x27;s ~1285 Kcal deficit a day, which is half of your normal calories per day if you are 30 yo male, not gaining or loosing weight and you weigh-in at 220 punds &#x2F; 100kg, you would usually be expending about 2600 Kcal if you have at least some activity during the day like an hour of walking).<p>5. Don&#x27;t listen to people&#x27;s stories about weight loss and &quot;what worked for them&quot;, if they are in their early 20&#x27;s (I am 30 yo). Younger bodies (and minds) are more susceptible to magic.<p>If at the start of your journey you maintain some muscle through training - you will have to continue training during this period of weight loss, or that is the first thing you will lose. Even then, you have to know you will lose some muscle. I personally don&#x27;t care about looks (I run and I train in Boxing) and losing some of that muscle doesn&#x27;t bother me, since at the end I feel lighter, quicker and (compared to my new weight-class) stronger.<p>Good luck!<p>P.S.<p>- Even if you weren&#x27;t training when you started and you are not trying to maintain gained muscle - doing some interval training during the weight loss will help keep your metabolic rate from falling. Your body will (partially) adjust to the weight loss by lowering your metabolism and this will solve part of the hunger, but you will feel sleepy, slow and tired and you will be burning less fat overall. Pushing yourself for just a few minutes a day with some HIIT or something similar, can offset this.
评论 #17392362 未加载
mathw将近 7 年前
So the really hard part is not knowing what to do but managing to do it - willpower, feeling hungry, craving sugars, whatever.<p>I&#x27;ve lost 15kg (so far) following the current (they keep changing it) Weight Watchers plan, which is mostly a series of tricks designed to create a calorific deficit without me feeling hungry and miserable all the time. Works for me. Okay, so I have to pay, but it works and that&#x27;s important (and I can afford it).<p>I don&#x27;t think any one method is going to work for everyone, because so much of effective weight loss is a mental game and you need to find the game that works for you. Research, think, consider yourself and your needs and then go for it. Personally, I tried calorie counting and I just couldn&#x27;t handle the nitpicking nature of it. WW turn everything into much broader units, which are rather crude but it all seems to work out in the end.<p>Although that said I&#x27;m currently stuck 3kg away from my goal weight because having crossed into the &quot;healthy&quot; BMI category and experienced a huge boost in my energy levels, physical fitness and capability my motivation has faded somewhat. I look better (people have commented, which is nice). I can dance more (I&#x27;m a morris dancer, yesterday I danced a solo jig after three other dances in blazing sunshine and I was fine, couldn&#x27;t have done that last year) and I can do much, much better at aikido training (not only do I have more stamina throwing people around, I can also be thrown much better as I can fall better because I&#x27;ve got less excess mass to worry about when I hit the floor - I&#x27;ve been told it&#x27;s much more fun to train with me than it was when I was at my heaviest).<p>So however you do it... it&#x27;s worth it. But it&#x27;s impossible to say there&#x27;s just one method anybody needs, because you have to get over your own mental hurdles first.<p>Which is not just the system btw... I had to change jobs to give me the mental space to pull it off, as I was miserable and depressed and comfort eating constantly.
Tade0将近 7 年前
<i>You don’t have to exercise.</i><p>I tried that last year and lost... 1kg over the course of three months on a decent calorie deficit(or so I thought). Gained that much - and more - in two weeks or so during Christmas. Granted I didn&#x27;t move <i>at all</i>, because I was working remotely and had no incentive to go out.<p>I guess when you&#x27;re obese your diaphragm working to keep you oxygenated is enough &quot;exercise&quot;, so that may be sound advice if you&#x27;re on that end of the scale.<p>I know my last year&#x27;s approach led me to lose a significant amount of muscle mass, so I recommend some light exercise - yoga works well because you only need 2m x 2m of real estate, a mat and thirty minutes of your time daily. At this rate you&#x27;re well within the recommended amount of physical activity.
评论 #17392075 未加载
评论 #17392131 未加载
woodandsteel将近 7 年前
Key paragraph<p>&quot;<p>I naturally started eating healthy foods because I could eat more of them. If you eat a chocolate bar, you will still be hungry. For the same amount of calories, you could eat a few bowls of vegetables and be full. That said, the best part about this overall approach is that you can still eat whatever you want – just count the calories.&quot;<p>That is essential to both taking the weight off and keeping it off. I followed only this rule, which meant avoiding refined carbs and fatty foods,and I didn&#x27;t even count calories and I took off 50 pounds over about three years, and have kept it off.<p>I still don&#x27;t count calories, I eat as much as I want, I just make sure it is mostly high in bulk with a fair amount of protein, and reasonably low in fat.
bscphil将近 7 年前
See also: the hacker&#x27;s diet, which is basically this plan writ large. <a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.fourmilab.ch&#x2F;hackdiet&#x2F;" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.fourmilab.ch&#x2F;hackdiet&#x2F;</a><p>What clicked for me with this plan was that you can <i>automatically</i> adjust your caloric intake on the basis of how well you&#x27;re tracking your goal weight loss rate. You don&#x27;t even have to count calories well: if you&#x27;re undercounting, the system corrects for that by telling you to lower your intake goal.<p>Realizing that it was mathematically impossible not to succeed if I just followed the simple steps was the spark I needed to get started.
bmn__将近 7 年前
<a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;fourmilab.ch&#x2F;hackdiet&#x2F;" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;fourmilab.ch&#x2F;hackdiet&#x2F;</a><p>The Hacker&#x27;s Diet – How to lose weight and hair through stress and poor nutrition<p>first published 1994, also comes with software tools
rcatcher将近 7 年前
You don&#x27;t have to exercise, but keep in mind that way you&#x27;ll go from being fat to being skinny fat. I made that mistake myself and to be honest my body looked better before losing weight.
评论 #17391853 未加载
afpx将近 7 年前
For people who accomplish things like this, I often wonder about how often they tried and failed in the past and what factors changed to make them finally succeed.
评论 #17391797 未加载
评论 #17391978 未加载
评论 #17391838 未加载
评论 #17391796 未加载
iod将近 7 年前
So where does all the fat go?<p>I find the answer rather interesting as for 10 units of fat you burn, you breath out about 8.4 units of carbon dioxide and 1.6 units of water. Applying this to imperial pounds means that:<p>1 lb fat -&gt; 0.84 lbs CO2 and 0.16 lb water.<p>¹<a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.sciencedaily.com&#x2F;releases&#x2F;2014&#x2F;12&#x2F;141216212047.htm" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.sciencedaily.com&#x2F;releases&#x2F;2014&#x2F;12&#x2F;141216212047.h...</a>
nlavezzo将近 7 年前
Does anyone here have any good science they can point to that would help us understand what the short and longer term effects of prolonged Calorie Deficit are on your Basal Metabolic Rate? I&#x27;ve heard a lot about the BMR going down significantly and staying down, after significant calorie deficit weight loss, leading to people gaining back a lot of weight even if they are eating a lot less than they were before.
评论 #17393679 未加载
评论 #17393658 未加载
maerF0x0将近 7 年前
@agrinman On the days where you dipped into really low calories (say &lt;1000) do you recall if that was real consumption or just a lack of tracking?<p>I find my MFP calories are not good data because somedays I say &quot;screw it&quot; and stop counting or don&#x27;t try and track because I really don&#x27;t know how much I&#x27;m eating (is it 6oz, 4oz or 8oz of chicken, not sure because its just a pile)
AJRF将近 7 年前
I feel like there are some parralels between understanding how you lose weight and how you retain money &#x2F; stop yourself living paycheck to paycheck.<p>The Calories in &#x2F; Calories out dichotomy is similar to the double accounting Assets = Liabilities + Capital in that it is so simple, but until you start to pay attention you can make that equation massively unbalanced to the point it starts to hurt you.
bitL将近 7 年前
I have one rule - I eat cake only when I do ~1000kCal aero training on that given day. That&#x27;s like pushing on a bike for an hour for me (hilly terrain with interval sprints). I&#x27;ve noticed that if I don&#x27;t do that, I gain weight, if I do that, I keep the weight and when I do only training, I lose weight, given everything else stays the same.
alistairSH将近 7 年前
1358 kcal&#x2F;day? Is that sustainable&#x2F;healthy for an average sized male? That sounds really low - low enough that I feel like I&#x27;d be missing other components of my diet (vitamins).<p>Simple online BMR calculators put my BMR at &gt;1500 kcal&#x2F;day. Add life on top of that, plus some exercise, and that value needs to be 2000+, sometimes much higher.
评论 #17392193 未加载
评论 #17392247 未加载
评论 #17392249 未加载
评论 #17392872 未加载
评论 #17392186 未加载
brohoolio将近 7 年前
Congrats! This is a great achievement. It’s not easy. Don’t let up! Maintenance of your current weight can be just as tough.
k__将近 7 年前
You don&#x27;t need to exercise, but you&#x27;ll lose more muscle if you don&#x27;t.<p>But yes, diet is much more important than exercise.
评论 #17391768 未加载
dalore将近 7 年前
&gt; Caloric Deficit == Weight Loss<p>&gt; The only thing you really need to know is that you should be eating fewer calories than your body burns everyday. If you do this, you will lose weight – it’s science. Nothing else matters for weight loss. The magnitude of the caloric difference will regulate how quickly or slowly you lose the weight.<p>This is actually not so clear cut. It&#x27;s currently being debated if this model is right or the hormonal model is right. <a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;peterattiamd.com&#x2F;do-calories-matter&#x2F;" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;peterattiamd.com&#x2F;do-calories-matter&#x2F;</a><p>What I suspect with the author was that his caloric deficit was also restricting carbs and once the carbs was restricted his body started to burn fat when there was no more insulin in his blood.<p>Counting carbs and restricting them leads to an easier lifestyle to follow where you don&#x27;t worry about getting hungry and making sure you&#x27;re burning more then you eat (Vs counting calories).
sbr464将近 7 年前
Congrats man! Nice write up. I realize this isn’t a good hn reply but wanted to give support!
AH2mdte8kPnJS将近 7 年前
What about going the other way - gaining weight? Does anyone have tips or reccomendations on how I can gain weight. I&#x27;m 6&#x27;3&quot; and 160lbs and have always wanted to gain weight but I struggle with consistently eating 5 meals a day.
评论 #17393130 未加载
评论 #17392834 未加载
acconrad将近 7 年前
Averaging 1350 calories for an adult male at over 275 lbs is incredible willpower. I cut 22 lbs in 6 months for a bodybuilding show and the lowest I ever got down to was 1750 calories and that was very, very difficult. Amazing work!
roevhat将近 7 年前
Related: <a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;news.ycombinator.com&#x2F;item?id=13413725" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;news.ycombinator.com&#x2F;item?id=13413725</a>. Here using closed-loop feedback for weight loss.
manuw将近 7 年前
congrats!<p>You can find here[0] a lot of progress pics from ppl, who lost a lot of weight with simple cico[1]. I do PSMF[2] sometimes for 1-2 Weeks when I feel to lose 1-4kg.<p>[0] <a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.reddit.com&#x2F;r&#x2F;progresspics&#x2F;" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.reddit.com&#x2F;r&#x2F;progresspics&#x2F;</a> [1] calories in, calories out [2] <a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;en.wikipedia.org&#x2F;wiki&#x2F;Protein-sparing_modified_fast" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;en.wikipedia.org&#x2F;wiki&#x2F;Protein-sparing_modified_fast</a>
npstr将近 7 年前
Exercise isn&#x27;t only great because it burns calories directly. What it does is retain &#x2F; build up muscle, and that in turn increases your base calories burning rate, each day.
评论 #17391816 未加载
nassyweazy将近 7 年前
As someone who lost over 100 pounds (6&quot;2 and from 279 to 169 pounds), I can honestly say that loosing weight is way easier than it seems, provided you have a good work-life balance.<p>I lost the first 45 pounds in 3 weeks by doing the following daily routine:<p>- 4 hours of swimming<p>- 1.5 hours of weights lifting<p>- 3 hours of swimming<p>- 2 hours of table tennis<p>1 BIG lunch, no other meal for the day, TONS of water.<p>Apps, books and all are completely overrated. Just be motivated and listen to your body, stop exercise when you reach your limit, rest, repeat..<p>The other 55+ pounds were lost over 2 years and a half without much exercise, just find the arrangement of fruits, lightweight cheese and vegetables + tuna that you love and eat it as often as possible.
评论 #17392204 未加载
评论 #17392143 未加载
评论 #17392205 未加载
评论 #17392414 未加载
评论 #17392190 未加载
评论 #17394364 未加载
forkLding将近 7 年前
I lost quite some weight in the past, not as drastic as the writer, but I was wondering if the writer had any issues with loose skin after losing weight.
jlebrech将近 7 年前
that&#x27;s a great result.<p>did you find exercise made you hungry? maybe that&#x27;s why going for a run before bed might be beneficial as you can sleep rather than eat.
评论 #17392382 未加载
koreyb将近 7 年前
Slow carb&#x2F;4 Hour Body works really well for weight loss. No counting calories. Just follow a few simple rules. Plus you get a cheat day!
googletron将近 7 年前
Amazing work! I love <a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;gyrosco.pe" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;gyrosco.pe</a> for this type of thing.
throw7将近 7 年前
Congrats on weight loss.<p>Now you should integrate exercising into your life. At least 150 minutes of vigorous exercise per week. Do it.
_up将近 7 年前
Myfitness Pal should publish some data. I would for example like to know if weather&#x2F;temp. has a role in appetite.
coleifer将近 7 年前
Congratulations buddy, I can&#x27;t imagine how hard that must have been. Thanks for sharing what you experienced.
arsenico将近 7 年前
Important to note, that only with metabolism of a young male, it is possible to lose weight without exercise. I am 37 and restricting my calorie intake helps, but not greatly. Exercising daily - helped a lot. Most women of 30+ must exercise to lose weight - metabolism is completely different.
评论 #17391680 未加载
评论 #17391691 未加载
评论 #17391726 未加载
评论 #17391709 未加载
评论 #17391712 未加载
评论 #17391676 未加载
评论 #17391842 未加载
评论 #17391704 未加载
2snakes将近 7 年前
It will be very difficult to gain muscle eating a caloric deficit, but you CAN still gain strength.
gymshoes将近 7 年前
This is inspiring.<p>Don&#x27;t skip logging even if you go over your goal and stay consistent. Very nice points.
exabrial将近 7 年前
All I have to say is WOW and congrats. That takes commitment!
jlebrech将近 7 年前
it would be easier to meal prep a few days in advance rather than recording everything you eat.
weatherlight将近 7 年前
congrats....but is it healthy to lose 100lb in 276 days? what does that do to your liver?
anonu将近 7 年前
&gt; Caloric Deficit == Weight Loss<p>This is generally contested by recent diet and nutrition research, as I understand it.
评论 #17392147 未加载
fapi1974将近 7 年前
I think this is the simplest, most straightforward post on this topic I have read. Congratulations.
scrollaway将近 7 年前
I&#x27;m frustrated reading comments here that repeatedly say &quot;Calories in, calories out&quot;, &quot;law of thermodynamics&quot;, etc.<p>Frustrated because, for one thing, this approach is extremely discouraging to people who want to, or are in the process of, losing weight. &quot;Jesus you&#x27;re so dumb, how can you not understand this one simple thing that you merely have to eat less?&quot;<p>1. What works&#x2F;worked for you&#x2F;your friends&#x2F;whoever you read about on the internet may not work for everyone. That&#x27;s because when talking to each other, neither party has the full picture. Neither party knows exactly the level of activity and food habits of the other.<p>&quot;I simply cut X calories from my diet and it worked!&quot; -- yes, but you also forgot to mention you bike to work and back home every day.<p>2. Calories in != Calories out. CICO is an approximation, a pretty good one in terms of nutrition, but different foods break down very differently in the body. I recommend watching &quot;Sugar: The Bitter Truth&quot;. TLDW: It&#x27;s a long presentation that talks about how glucose and fructose are broken down by the body.<p>Furthermore, CICO is super misleading on two levels:<p>- It completely ignores hunger. Telling someone &quot;Go down to 1400 calories &#x2F; day&quot; can be a horrible idea if they don&#x27;t radically change their diet. It&#x27;s not just about cutting, it&#x27;s about replacing. There&#x27;s high-calorie-budget things you can&#x27;t keep eating&#x2F;drinking, and low-calorie-budget things that make you feel fuller that have to be introduced.<p>- <i>Metabolism matters</i>. As I was saying further down in the thread, depending on your metabolism (influenced both by genetics and overall activity level), two people may burn different amounts of energy, both when they&#x27;re active and even passively by merely existing.<p>So, for all intents and purposes, yes, calories in == calories out. But that&#x27;s <i>not</i> the only thing that matters. Get your diet sorted out, get your exercise plan sorted out, find a strategy that works long term (not just a crash diet) and that is and feels comfortable. Anything that is uncomfortable&#x2F;unpleasant is not something that can be maintained long term.<p>Also, like the post says, get a digital body scale to start recording your weight. I got a Nokia Health smart scale which gives me graphs of my weight automatically. Being able to see the trends is the most critical tool. Can you imagine getting good performance at load on your servers without instrumentation, merely by just running top once in a while?<p>PS, if you&#x27;re downvoting, take the time to leave a comment. All the above is from hard-earned experience.
评论 #17393040 未加载
toomanybeersies将近 7 年前
To prove a point once, I lost a few kg while eating a diet that consisted solely of pizza.<p>Upon saying that, I wouldn&#x27;t recommend it. The best weight management methods are holistic, the different facets of healthy weight management: exercise, meal composition, and serving size, all play into each other.<p>You want to exercise more, eat less, and eat healthier.<p>If you eat healthier; whole grains instead of refined carbs, lots of leafy greens, legumes to replace carbs, and avoid processed foods; then you&#x27;ll feel satiated while eating less, both in calories and in just bulk amount of food.<p>You&#x27;ll have more energy from a diet consisting of whole foods instead of refined carbs, which will allow you to exercise more and exercise harder. There&#x27;s no reason why you can&#x27;t burn 800 calories in an hour of hard exercise with the right diet and motivation. It might be different for other people, but for me, exercising also makes me want to eat healthier.<p>I&#x27;ve found that group classes (crossfit, spin, etc.) are a great motivator to exercise too. If you see the same people every time you go, you form a group and it becomes a social activity. Obviously that&#x27;s not for all of us, but I always struggled with motivation to go to the gym solo. When I started doing functional fitness group sessions, I couldn&#x27;t stop. I went to every session (3 times a week) for 8 months, the only sessions I missed were when I was out of town. Otherwise I&#x27;d turn up no matter how I felt, whether tired, sick, or hungover, I&#x27;d drag my arse out.<p>The big thing is really motivation. Going solo, it&#x27;s really easy to lose motivation. If you have friends who are also eating healthy and working out with you, it really helps. For me, it was other people in my coworking space. The space was really big into healthy lifestyles, so there were a bunch of us who would bring healthy food to work and go to the gym together. Another great tip is to avoid buying any packaged food. Only eat food you&#x27;ve prepared yourself, that way you don&#x27;t accidentally eat a bunch of food you don&#x27;t need to as you need to physically go out of your way to make food to eat. That may include cutting bread out of your diet, it&#x27;s too easy to make a piece of toast if you&#x27;re peckish, it&#x27;s a lot more work to cook a potato.<p>I didn&#x27;t lose as much weight as I wanted to because alcohol was a major food group, but I toned up a whole lot and felt a lot healthier in general. It also had a positive mental health effect.<p>Unfortunately I moved overseas and lost my momentum. It&#x27;s been 8 months since I&#x27;ve gone to a gym and I&#x27;ve managed to pick up most of my old bad habits again. At least I can still run 5 km (3 miles) in 30 minutes, so it&#x27;s not all gone.<p>Anyway, my point is: technically, yes, simply counting calories will work for weight loss. But that&#x27;s the hard way. You&#x27;ll feel like shit, constantly hunger and lacking energy. Take a holistic approach to your health. And if you don&#x27;t exercise and eat healthy food, you might get skinny, but you&#x27;ll still be unfit and unhealthy, you just won&#x27;t get a heart attack at 30.