TE
科技回声
首页24小时热榜最新最佳问答展示工作
GitHubTwitter
首页

科技回声

基于 Next.js 构建的科技新闻平台,提供全球科技新闻和讨论内容。

GitHubTwitter

首页

首页最新最佳问答展示工作

资源链接

HackerNews API原版 HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 科技回声. 版权所有。

Ask HN: Why do companies do “remote within the US”?

13 点作者 bhollan超过 6 年前
I&#x27;ve seen a sharp rise in companies that are 100% remote, but have a caveat that you have to be inside the United States. Full disclosure, I&#x27;m an American living in Mexico for the time being. I&#x27;ve had several companies stop the interview&#x2F;hiring process as soon as they find out I&#x27;m outside the US. I&#x27;ve also seen hundreds of job postings say &quot;remote, within the US&quot;.<p>I was even employed part-time with a company that knew I was in Mexico and was OK with it, but then they got bought and I was terminated within months. All my papers are in order, my US Passport is still good, my Mexican visa is fine, and I can&#x27;t honestly think of a reason why they can&#x27;t hire remote globally. Am I missing something? Is there a reason for this I don&#x27;t understand? I have a US bank account, a US Passport, pay US taxes, and am a native English speaker. Is there a blind spot that I can&#x27;t see? Is it just simple &quot;policy&quot; that people made a blanket decision without facts? Am I being unreasonable?<p>It seems like a reasonable thing to be upset over. It feels like discrimination, and it is. It&#x27;s called Geographic Discrimination, and when you&#x27;re talking about being a concierge for a hotel or a janitor or any other physical on-site job, that makes sense. But I don&#x27;t understand why it should be legal to apply it to 100% remote jobs in 100% remote companies.

10 条评论

rosspackard超过 6 年前
International law is complex. Having a full-time employee located in another country can lead to a lot of legal unknowns. At the very least this requires a company to spend the money to understand if they are exposing themselves to any international laws that are unknown to them. I am not a lawyer but have run businesses in the past and legally that would scare the hell out of me. Also, benefits were brought up by the other commenter but it wasn&#x27;t addressed in the legal context. How do ADA and FMLA and other benefits work when the employee is living in another country? These are all questions that are a burden on a company. Why should they legally have to shoulder the burden?<p>Having fully remote employees within the US is a large burden in and of itself. It is very very hard unless a company has resources that can address that. Each employee in a different state or location is basically treated like a separate office. You are basically asking a company to open an office in Mexico.
mchannon超过 6 年前
There are a number of reasons this goes on.<p>First and foremost is why remote is so slow to catch on everywhere. Every manager has to deal with cognitive load, and a limited capability to exceed it. Getting the money to hire somebody at a given rate is hard enough, but then interviewing, weighing how much difficulty will be involved in day-to-day managing this hire, is all factored in, and all adds to the cognitive load.<p>A lot of &quot;100% remote&quot; isn&#x27;t. They want these hires, if for some reason it became necessary, to be able to travel to the main office (and to travel to meet them). They want to be able to pay them without any unanswered questions. They don&#x27;t want a cultural or language barrier. The fact is, even if you have all these bases covered, and you are a US citizen, they have trouble taking you at your word just because &quot;foreign&quot;, and it&#x27;s a load off to just tell you no.<p>If someone emailed me a Mexican phone number, even though it may be as easy as just punching it in, most managers would not want to.<p>Companies are set up to do US taxes, and don&#x27;t want to deal with foreign taxes. Even if Mexico has zero foreign tax filing requirements, the US probably has a form to fill out.<p>A US PO box can cost under $20 per 6 months, and many of the cheapest ones are along the US&#x2F;Mexico border. Take a road trip and use that PO box as the address on your resume. Have a phone number that doesn&#x27;t require international dialing. Don&#x27;t lie about where you&#x27;re from (&quot;my mailing address is in Phoenix&quot;) but if it&#x27;s 100% remote (and you have good internet) it shouldn&#x27;t matter. You&#x27;re a US citizen, and this would fix most of your problems.<p>I&#x27;ve had to deal with discrimination based on where I live, but at least I was showing up to the physical office as agreed. In sum, don&#x27;t make it hard for them to see you as part of the organization they envisioned.
评论 #17824398 未加载
tlb超过 6 年前
Having employees in a country means the company has to obey that country&#x27;s labor laws, pay taxes and social security. While Mexico&#x27;s labor laws aren&#x27;t unreasonable, you basically need a second HR department to ensure compliance with a second set of laws.
评论 #17824380 未加载
chatmasta超过 6 年前
As mentioned by others, it&#x27;s because of compliance headaches with payroll in foreign countries. Next time this happens, I would recommend suggesting to them that you work as a contractor on 1099. In that case, it&#x27;s a way more straightforward process for the employer because they just need to send you money, and you handle all the compliance paperwork on your side. In fact it&#x27;s even easier for them than hiring a US employee.
评论 #17824415 未加载
jklein11超过 6 年前
It might depend on the industry you are working in. I know some grants have language which prohibits data from leaving the continental United States. I think this is done to &quot;protect US jobs.&quot;
评论 #17824434 未加载
jxub超过 6 年前
Just a guess, but probably it&#x27;s because of sharing the same timezone and culture and where it&#x27;s easy to set up payroll, benefits,... for the employee in question.
评论 #17824405 未加载
wprapido超过 6 年前
Try working with startups, smaller companies or take roles where they don&#x27;t care. Also, no need to disclose your actual whereabouts as long as you can get paid, sign contracts, pay taxes, are reachable at the US number, and can travel as needed.
gesman超过 6 年前
To reduce risk.<p>As a manager, besides budget - the risk of delivering (or not) the project is important.<p>The more remote, away from home timezone, less english speaking audience is involved - the bigger the risks.
评论 #17824426 未加载
zerr超过 6 年前
To deal only with people who can be easily sued.
eip超过 6 年前
Where in Mexico? And why tell anyone? Just say you live in the US and travel a lot.
评论 #17824447 未加载