TE
科技回声
首页24小时热榜最新最佳问答展示工作
GitHubTwitter
首页

科技回声

基于 Next.js 构建的科技新闻平台,提供全球科技新闻和讨论内容。

GitHubTwitter

首页

首页最新最佳问答展示工作

资源链接

HackerNews API原版 HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 科技回声. 版权所有。

Ask HN: Is it unethical to finish project from a company that never finished it?

41 点作者 casper345超过 6 年前
I worked on a mobile application for a project that I was really invested in but after graduating, different developers with different coding beliefs - the project just fell apart. I still love the idea and put so much time into it. Has a lot of potential I think. Can I just complete it on my own. Do I even have an obligation to ask them if I can do it? When is their idea no longer "thiers". Also did not like the direction they were going with the business.

22 条评论

blihp超过 6 年前
Standard IANAL disclaimer...<p>When you say &#x27;finish&#x27; that implies using code&#x2F;assets the company owns. Unless it was produced under a permissive license (I.e. BSD&#x2F;MIT&#x2F;GPL) you can&#x27;t use it without explicit permission from the copyright owner.<p>As far as taking the <i>idea</i> and running with it, as long as you didn&#x27;t enter into a non-compete&#x2F;NDA agreement, you&#x27;re probably fine. There are examples of this all over the place in business history (with matching lawsuits when they weren&#x27;t careful to respect the rights of &#x2F; agreements with former employers)
评论 #17971310 未加载
Bluestrike2超过 6 年前
There are a lot of unknowns with your post, which makes useful feedback difficult. The answer could range anywhere from &quot;don&#x27;t worry about it&quot; to &quot;hammer out an agreement with the other parties first.&quot; Are you looking to run with the concept, or are you hoping to build off of code already written?<p>In either event, I&#x27;d strongly suggest speaking to a qualified attorney before doing anything. At the very least, you&#x27;ll want them to review any contracts you signed, walk you through your possible exposure, and give you some recommendations for either minimizing or managing it. It&#x27;s not a cheap move by any means, but if you genuinely want to move forward with this project, it&#x27;ll help you avoid possible long-term problems.
cimmanom超过 6 年前
I see nothing unethical about that, but there are legal considerations. (Disclaimer: I am not a lawyer and this is not legal advice.)<p>If you’re using existing code, they may still have a stake in the IP. You may need to make sure they either license it or turn over ownership to you. In the latter case you may want to set up an official bill of sale and pay them something for it, even if it’s only $1 each.<p>AFAIK there’s no legal ownership of the <i>idea</i> if it hasn’t been patented. But your options may also be restricted if you signed a contract that includes a non-compete clause.
评论 #17970367 未加载
deaps超过 6 年前
Unethical, absolutely not, at least in my opinion. Legally speaking - there are so many variables that are unknown to all of us that we cannot possibly begin to tell you what your rights are to finish, release, and&#x2F;or potentially make a profit off of the finished product.
jppope超过 6 年前
Offer to pay for it. They will either say no worries you can have it, or the sum will be nominal. Make sure you get it in writing (email).
评论 #17970047 未加载
coreyp_1超过 6 年前
Indeed, there are a lot of holes to fill in. The problem is that the IP of the existing code and assets (graphics&#x2F;designs) might be contested in court, if your project is successful enough to make money and therefore makes you a desireable target.<p>As a non-lawyer offering non-legal advice, I suggest you rebuild the project from scratch (using a different language if possible&#x2F;feasible, as well as different graphics) so that there can be no question as to whether or not you used code or graphics for which you do not hold the correct license (in the case of code) or copyright (in the case of graphics).
notJim超过 6 年前
I&#x27;d talk to an employment attorney, or at least make a more detailed posted &#x2F;r&#x2F;legaladvice to see if they think you should talk to one. If you&#x27;re going to ask for permission, I would definitely talk to the attorney <i>before</i> doing that, as tipping your hand may set bad things in motion from the company.<p>Ethically, I think you&#x27;re giving them the same or more consideration than they&#x27;d give you. Companies screw over small developers all the time, it&#x27;s just business.
TheOtherHobbes超过 6 年前
Others have covered the legalities, but I&#x27;d wonder - as a useful question to ask in general - if it&#x27;s as good an idea as you think.<p>A lot of the value of any idea comes the execution - which doesn&#x27;t mean the code, it means the marketing, branding, support, networking, customer acquisition, and reputation-building.<p>Unless it&#x27;s a very unusual idea that needs minimal customer interaction - they exist, but are rare - or something that works solo (games, mostly) you should budget time and money for all of these.<p>Many apps are killed by the support process, not the development process. The app sells, bugs appear, customers get various shades of irritated and angry, negative reviews are left, and dealing with all of this can turn into a huge time sink if you&#x27;re not planning for it. This is even more true of projects that have a significant server back end.<p>The app store is full of abandonware left by devs who didn&#x27;t realise how much extra work is involved in turning an idea into a reliable income stream.<p>I&#x27;m not saying it can&#x27;t be done, but I am saying it needs some consideration before you go ahead and spend time (weeks? months?) on a clean-room rebuild of everything you&#x27;ve done so far.
arjunvpaul超过 6 年前
Use &quot;the newspaper test&quot;. If an article appeared in a local newspaper about the decision and action you made, and your family and friends read the article, would you feel good about it? Here is a video of some ol&#x27; man explaining it well - <a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.youtube.com&#x2F;watch?v=wgvBV6kWE54" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.youtube.com&#x2F;watch?v=wgvBV6kWE54</a><p>If you are really invested, have a conversation with the highest decision making authority you know about what you would like to do and what would be a fair way for you to continue with this? Tell him you are broke and then offer him solutions - buyout the codebase for a token sum? future revenue share? have them invest in you? If the guy&#x2F;gal is worth his salt this wont be a waste of time.<p>You would be surprised and what you can get if you just ask.
caseysoftware超过 6 年前
If you mean &quot;finish it&quot; by picking up the code and continuing development, that&#x27;s ugly at best. Someone owns that - you might have a claim! - but you&#x27;ll spend more time and money with attorneys than anything to do it right.<p>If you mean &quot;finish it&quot; by taking the idea and starting fresh, it&#x27;s probably competitive so I&#x27;d double check that you didn&#x27;t sign some sort of non-compete or &quot;won&#x27;t reuse this information&quot; kind of thing.<p>Of course, either you could roll with it and see what happens.. no one is going to pop up to make a claim unless you a) offend them or b) are successful. And even under (a), it&#x27;s unlikely they&#x27;ll hire an attorney to cause you angst.
saluki超过 6 年前
Contact an attorney for advice.<p>But it sounds like you should just take the idea, and start building code from scratch, pick a new name, domain, etc. Just don&#x27;t use any code&#x2F;assets from the original project.
sjg007超过 6 年前
The idea is not theirs per se but any code or digital and physical assets may be. If you need those assets ask them for a release. If there are patents that you can&#x27;t work around then ask for a license. If you don&#x27;t want a release, make sure your NDA has expired and don&#x27;t use or look at the old code in question. You may want to hire a third party to write the code clean for you too. Or proceed as you wish and if you are later successful expect a lawsuit&#x2F;settlement. Consider that the idea tax.
rmena123超过 6 年前
Look failed things happen all the time, no one is going back to each other and asking permission to continue. Do it! Now don&#x27;t go off and use the same exact code of the project, start fresh and try to change things up. Good Luck!<p>And I think another important thing is, be sure you are not apart of the project anymore in anyway. No more being paid from them or working with them sometimes. Be sure you create the business paperwork setup for yourself. Start fresh!<p>If you need help in anyway, let me know, I&#x27;m a nobody fyi. haha
apo超过 6 年前
What documents did you sign prior to working on the app?<p>The main thing to avoid is intellectual property (trademark, copyright, patent, and nondisclosure) infringement.
orev超过 6 年前
Assuming USA and that you had a standard work for hire agreement, then no, you cannot sell it as your own without getting a release and probably having to pay back whatever salary you received when working on it. The work&#x2F;code you produced belongs to whoever paid for it. You could rewrite from scratch if you wanted to though.
megaman8超过 6 年前
People don&#x27;t get in trouble for doing unethical things. they get in trouble for breaking the rules or doing illegal stuff. what you really need to know is, is it legal? or will it have a negative public relations impact? those are the questions you should be asking.
swalsh超过 6 年前
No one owns ideas, you might have signed a non-compete... but those aren&#x27;t usually enforcable depending on what your position is.<p>If you take the code, that&#x27;s unethical. They paid you to write the code, so they own that. But you&#x27;re free to do whatever you want.
评论 #17970236 未加载
评论 #17971106 未加载
pecg超过 6 年前
If you are really attached to such idea and would love to work on it, your best bet is to reimplement it on your own, with a new code base. That is if you didn&#x27;t sign a NDA.
acomjean超过 6 年前
&gt;I worked on a mobile application for a project that I was really invested in but after graduating,<p>sounds like a college project. You should ask them. if not you can start over. nobody owns the idea.<p>IANAL
incadenza超过 6 年前
It’s impossible to know whether you’re legally liable without more details on the arrangements made.<p>Ethically speaking, why not ask them?
评论 #17970699 未加载
maxxxxx超过 6 年前
Definitely don&#x27;t take any of their code. I am not sure what the legal situation is for the idea as such.
fouc超过 6 年前
Did you get paid to work on it? Is there a non-compete?<p>Can you delete all the code, and start from scratch?