TE
科技回声
首页24小时热榜最新最佳问答展示工作
GitHubTwitter
首页

科技回声

基于 Next.js 构建的科技新闻平台,提供全球科技新闻和讨论内容。

GitHubTwitter

首页

首页最新最佳问答展示工作

资源链接

HackerNews API原版 HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 科技回声. 版权所有。

We wasted $50K on Google Search Ads and the insights we got on the way

201 点作者 igordebatur超过 6 年前

13 条评论

gk1超过 6 年前
Surprised that keyword selection wasn&#x27;t mentioned. Any time you&#x27;re dealing with programming-related keywords, you&#x27;re going to catch A LOT of people who just want free answers or code samples to copy-paste.<p>They&#x27;re going to click on the first search result automatically, and if that happens to be your ad, then you just wasted $0.50-$5.00.<p>Another issue is keyword match types. If you used the keywords exactly as in the spreadsheet, without any modifiers, then you&#x27;re giving Google way too much leeway in how they interpret and match search queries to your target keywords. For example, your keyword might be UPLOADCARE REVIEW but your ad will show for the search &quot;uploading review&quot; (I&#x27;m just guessing).<p>You might think &quot;well even if our ad shows for an irrelevant keyword, surely the user would see the difference and not click on it!&quot; Wrong. People click the first X results automatically.<p>Case in point: A data science platform company I consult once targeted python programmers. Instead they were getting tons of clicks from snake enthusiasts, before I got involved. Oops.<p>Another company was selling monitoring software for mobile apps but was paying Google (inadvertently) for searchers of free mobile apps. Oops.[1]<p>Anyway, the other lessons mentioned are still valid, but I feel the biggest lesson (mistake?) was overlooked.<p>[1] Quick tip if you&#x27;re running Google Ads now: Go to your Keywords Report and click on the Search Terms tab. You&#x27;ll see the actual search terms people used before they saw your ad. If they vary wildly from your target keywords, you need to fix your keyword targeting.<p>PS - More fun &quot;Oops&quot; stories about Google Ads: <a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.gkogan.co&#x2F;blog&#x2F;selling-software-snake-charmers&#x2F;" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.gkogan.co&#x2F;blog&#x2F;selling-software-snake-charmers&#x2F;</a>
评论 #18905062 未加载
评论 #18905887 未加载
评论 #18906104 未加载
评论 #18905217 未加载
评论 #18909301 未加载
评论 #18910191 未加载
ericabiz超过 6 年前
I manage 6 figures a year of profitable Google Ads spend, and while this article isn&#x27;t bad, it&#x27;s a bit vague. Its strongest point is &quot;don&#x27;t hire an agency to scale.&quot; Its second strongest point should have been keyword selection, but that&#x27;s buried at the bottom of the article.<p>Specifically, the things that have gotten us to profitable ad spend in the 6 figure range are:<p>-- VERY tight campaigns going to tight landing pages. The more specific campaigns you can run, the better. The keywords on your ads AND landing pages need to match the keywords people type in. Most common mistake is driving traffic to a vague landing page. We have 200+ landing pages, all matched to specific keywords. I built out an entire custom framework on top of WordPress to manage this for our company.<p>-- Manage negative keywords. Every 2-3 days, I log in and add negative keywords. Good ones to start out with: free, diy...I have hundreds now. Maybe thousands. It takes a while to scroll through them.<p>-- Track sales back and add more negative keywords. There were some items we were getting a lot of clicks on, but didn&#x27;t make any sales with. I blacklisted a common keyword on one of our campaigns thanks to this insight. Google&#x27;s recommendation algorithm complained that by blacklisting this keyword, I was getting fewer clicks. YUP. Tracked it for a month, 3-4 clicks per day and 1 sale that entire month. Negative keyword!<p>-- Start out with 3 ads per ad group minimum. Every week, log in and pause any ad that&#x27;s not getting good CTR and add a new one. Repeat. After several weeks, you&#x27;ll be in the &quot;holy ____ I didn&#x27;t think that was possible&quot; range of CTRs.<p>It takes a LOT of effort to get to the point where we are now (highly optimized keywords, 12-20% CTR, half the price of most of our competitors.) Still, every couple days I log in and tweak even more things. And I hired a consultant on an hourly basis to get us even better. Totally worth the $ to hire him for a few hours just to see where I could improve!<p>If you are technical and think you can outsource this to an agency, DON&#x27;T. Consistency is key.<p>One of our partners decided to take the campaigns I&#x27;d written and send them to an agency. Their sales dropped 30%. They fired the agency and went back to me. And I&#x27;m the business owner, not an agency. No one cares about your money more than you do.<p>And, being technical, you can do fun things like customizing landing pages based on keywords entered (something most agencies can&#x27;t or won&#x27;t do, even though it boosts sales.)
评论 #18905363 未加载
评论 #18911159 未加载
评论 #18905697 未加载
评论 #18910369 未加载
评论 #18905437 未加载
评论 #18905818 未加载
评论 #18906028 未加载
onpedrof超过 6 年前
This article&#x27;s title and intro makes it look like it&#x27;s mainly Google Ads&#x27; fault, but then actually it was more due to the landing page design + user journey (awareness ladder) + working with an agency that scaled the execution and the costs. Nonetheless, interesting insights, worth reading for any B2B advertising manager.
评论 #18906324 未加载
评论 #18910432 未加载
bambax超过 6 年前
&gt; <i>Uploadcare is an established SaaS product, so we’ve been harvesting the low-hanging fruit from organic and direct traffic for a while now. If you’re in a similar situation, you’ve probably reached the same conclusion: running paid ads is the next logical growth step for customer acquisition.</i><p>I&#x27;m no expert but this strikes me as strange. Organic and direct traffic is not a low-hanging fruit, it&#x27;s the result of a product well adjusted to its target market. One would think advertising <i>is</i> the low-hanging fruit (relatively speaking); it&#x27;s what you do when your offer doesn&#x27;t show up naturally at the top of the results page.<p>If you&#x27;re already winning on SEO it&#x27;s probably harder to improve traffic with ads than when you have nowhere else to go but up.
评论 #18910593 未加载
tedmcory77超过 6 年前
Some key things they didn&#x27;t mention doing:<p>-Retargeting&#x2F;Remarketing - Some of your best ROI campaigns will come from these<p>-Discount Ladders - for customers to nudge over the edge great to use in combination with the retargeting campaigns.<p>-Abandoned cart email follow ups - No mention of these here. Again, these backend flows will really help profitability.<p>Ideally you&#x27;ll break even on those leading awareness&#x2F;acquisition campaigns using the things others here have said and the retargeting campaigns will be nothing but gravy.
评论 #18906648 未加载
评论 #18910612 未加载
bdefore超过 6 年前
May want to rename to the article headline of &#x27;We wasted $50K on Google Ads so you don’t have to&#x27;. As it is, the lack of a comma implies that the insights were also wasted.
评论 #18904881 未加载
simplecomplex超过 6 年前
Some key lessons:<p>- Measure ad effectiveness before continuing to pour money into it (denial is a helluva drug).<p>- Market to your customers, and know who they are. Make sure keywords are targeting the right audience before optimizing click-through.<p>- All steps in the funnel are affected by the first. If you&#x27;re bringing in the wrong audience, it won&#x27;t matter how much traffic you drive and how many ads you place.
评论 #18910708 未加载
jxub超过 6 年前
Still better than the high-schooler guy from my school in Spain (it was news around 2 years ago) who managed to blow up 100k€ or his parents money on youtube ads, and the only lesson there was, was to not give any bank account details to a kid.
vxNsr超过 6 年前
fascinating that an ad campaign worked for them. They appear to be selling a dev product, I always assumed all dev&#x27;s first install was ublock. In facts it was natively installed on all the computers at my university.
评论 #18906665 未加载
评论 #18910645 未加载
8bitsrule超过 6 年前
Maybe they should have considered this:<p>Most people who do searches are probably tightly focussed on the answers. Ads are pretty much unwanted distractions in such an environment.
评论 #18910655 未加载
paulpauper超过 6 年前
Google ads are tough. Very steep learning curve. They work for big brands with deep pockets and want to raise awareness, such as movie studios.
davidwihl超过 6 年前
tl;dr: before spending $50k, spend a few hours learning how to manage campaigns[1] and follow the recommendations<p>[1] <a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;support.google.com&#x2F;google-ads&#x2F;answer&#x2F;7539883?hl=en" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;support.google.com&#x2F;google-ads&#x2F;answer&#x2F;7539883?hl=en</a>
评论 #18910665 未加载
cm2012超过 6 年前
Facebook ads with strong sales follow up would probably work better for them.
评论 #18907052 未加载