TE
科技回声
首页24小时热榜最新最佳问答展示工作
GitHubTwitter
首页

科技回声

基于 Next.js 构建的科技新闻平台,提供全球科技新闻和讨论内容。

GitHubTwitter

首页

首页最新最佳问答展示工作

资源链接

HackerNews API原版 HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 科技回声. 版权所有。

High-Tech Solution to Disaster Response May Be Too Good to Be True

51 点作者 127001brewer将近 6 年前

9 条评论

arkades将近 6 年前
&gt; Our mission is not to make money only,” Mr. Wani said, later adding, “We’re trying to save the world.”<p>People should probably watch Silicon Valley before giving interviews. Repeating satire verbatim isn’t a good look.
评论 #20657599 未加载
评论 #20656962 未加载
评论 #20656530 未加载
127001brewer将近 6 年前
<i>“We really think we can enable a disaster-free future.”</i><p>That statement gave me pause since it&#x27;s quite the unrealistic claim to make.
评论 #20656520 未加载
评论 #20655837 未加载
评论 #20655865 未加载
40acres将近 6 年前
For one, it’s great to see startups tackling hard problems like this: generally I believe there is huge benefit and opportunity for startups in providing government services like this. It certainly helps to dispel the feeling that our brightest minds are working on ads.<p>Secondly, this really seems like the initial phases of product development and fit — agencies would be foolish to simply rely on a startup like this to coordinate 100% of disaster response, I’m sure FEMA has similar models. With startups, especially ones tackling more “serious” domains (for lack of a better word) I’m willing to have a longer leash and proceed with caution.
评论 #20658306 未加载
neilv将近 6 年前
Quote from article:<p>&gt; <i>Ivan Porto Carrero, who oversaw a team of engineers at One Concern, said he was fired in June after speaking out against what he viewed as a company culture of dishonesty. He said the usual start-up attitude of “fail fast and try something new” was inappropriate to apply to disaster response because, “If you fail fast, people die.”</i>
tsss将近 6 年前
I can already see how something like this will further increase inequality due to unaccounted biases in the training data, for example worse no emergency response in black neighborhoods because there is less data about them.<p>The question is whether this bias is better than just relying on government agencies, which we know are absolutely infested with racists and fascists.
6gvONxR4sf7o将近 6 年前
Wow. &quot;AI&quot; and emergencies are such a bad fit. ML is great at probably being almost right. That&#x27;s not how you want to run critical systems.
评论 #20656303 未加载
Dowwie将近 6 年前
My experience with disaster response is a month in Louisiana helping to operate the Rapides Coliseum shelter managed by the American Red Cross after hurricane Katrina in 2005.<p>Those who are resourceful, can solve problems creatively, and take initiative will lead a disaster response while those granted rank and position tend to spin wheels and control a situation they don&#x27;t understand. Disasters aren&#x27;t responded to by staff employees with adequate training. If it&#x27;s a major disaster, people who have never worked together nor acted in such a capacity are loosely organized together and used to channel resources and effort to victims and their families. Technology absolutely plays a vital role in disaster response but at times it can be a major hindrance. I recall when agents of FEMA came to the coliseum, they asked where the computers and network were. The location did have them, unlike others, but over time they went down and no one has available to maintain them. I explained to the agents that they will have to use forms and manual entry the old fashioned way. They just looked at each other and left. Several days passed. Then, FEMA returned with a mobile command center, featuring computers and satellite communication.<p>The experience didn&#x27;t surprise me but made me realize how dependent people are on technology and how unprepared they are to handle circumstances they haven&#x27;t trained for.
blendo将近 6 年前
&quot;In classes that fall, Mr. Wani and other graduate students turned the problem into a project. Using crowdsourced ground-shaking reports from previous earthquakes, they trained a computer system to predict the areas of greatest impact so that responders would not have to rely on 911 calls.&quot;<p>After a major earthquake, I seriously doubt competent emergency dispatch operators will be proactively sending critically-understaffed ambulances, fire engines, and police to a location identified by old, crowd-sourced cell phone shake data cobbled together for a grad-school project.<p>Not that emergency systems IT is not without challenges: old (often third party) technology, overly stove-piped administrative domains, and just plain old out-of-date technical skills. In other words, there&#x27;s lots of low hanging fruit for bright young programmers looking to serve their community!
jvanderbot将近 6 年前
anyone up for a relevant xkcd?<p><a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;xkcd.com&#x2F;2128&#x2F;" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;xkcd.com&#x2F;2128&#x2F;</a>
评论 #20655933 未加载