TE
科技回声
首页24小时热榜最新最佳问答展示工作
GitHubTwitter
首页

科技回声

基于 Next.js 构建的科技新闻平台,提供全球科技新闻和讨论内容。

GitHubTwitter

首页

首页最新最佳问答展示工作

资源链接

HackerNews API原版 HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 科技回声. 版权所有。

Ask HN: Review my winter break project (statusdot - hosted website status pages)

38 点作者 samdk超过 14 年前
Hi HN!<p>Eli Fox-Epstein (elitheeli here) and I decided that we should build something this week, so we built Statusdot (http://statusdot.com). It's a service to provide status pages for websites (similar to status.github.com or status.37signals.com).<p>https://statusdot.com<p>It's pretty basic right now: You set up a CNAME pointing at statusdot.us for (for your 'status' subdomain), so you can access the site by going to status.yourdomain.com. You give us a URL, we do a GET request every 5, 10, 15, 30, or 90 minutes. If that request doesn't come back with a 200 response or doesn't contain a string you specify, we consider it down. We display that information on a status page, along with your twitter account and status messages you can post. (We also send you an SMS message when your site goes down.)<p>We've got a few more features and a <i>ton</i> more polish left to do, but we wanted to soft-launch to get some feedback, so right now it's free for a couple of weeks. (After that we're planning to start charging monthly.)<p>We'd love any feedback you can give. Would you use it? If not, why not? Is there anything we could add that would make it more useful for you?<p>Thanks!

14 条评论

elitheeli超过 14 年前
I'd also like to thank everyone in advance for feedback. In exchange, here's a clickable link: <a href="http://statusdot.com" rel="nofollow">http://statusdot.com</a>
fookyong超过 14 年前
If you're just doing a GET request then this doesn't solve the problem.<p>Correct me if I'm wrong but you're trying to solve the problem of reliably displaying uptime status to answer the "huh it's down for me, is it down for you?" question that users sometimes have.<p>Just sending a GET doesn't really solve this, as it will only give you the status of the server from the point of view of that node.<p>Anyway, it depends what your intended use-case is.<p>If it's for publicly displaying uptime and therefore taking the reputation of the client company into your own hands, I would make sure that the method of reporting is as accurate as possible. I don't even think multiple nodes is the answer. You basically have to have a daemon installed on the client server.
评论 #2111133 未加载
jackowayed超过 14 年前
Looks good. A few places you could go with it:<p>* It looks like you currently allow custom messages and overriding of the up/down-ness, but only through SMS. A web interface for that would be nice.<p>* An API for that would be nice too. Eg. GitHub's monitoring of the uptime of the git interface could make an API call to tell you when it goes down and comes back up.<p>Why do you have us CNAME to statusdot.us instead of to statusdot.com?<p>I'm also wondering what the best way to handle plans is. I'm using it to monitor my personal site and am highly unlikely to ever pay you for that. But letting me use it for free would make you likely to get some money out of me when I launch a real site.<p>Some ideas:<p>* To use SMS, it costs money<p>* To have multiple sites, it costs money.<p>* To use the API, it costs money (?)<p>* To CNAME, it costs money (?)<p>But it seems like you should offer some basic version for free.
评论 #2110991 未加载
ernestipark超过 14 年前
Looks pretty good so far. I like that I got up and running real quick and it's simple. Two quick suggestions (although some of these might be things you already thought of but just haven't implemented yet: (1) error messages for form mis-entry, and (2) in the change password form, I'd move the old password field to be first. That's how I've seen it everywhere and it feels unintuitive to type the new password first. I messed up the first time I tried to change my password because of it. Best of luck!
pvsnp超过 14 年前
I just put my site here, it looks like a great start. Getting some more data in future would be interesting, like how much time it's taking to load the pages and show that on a graph.
jeffmould超过 14 年前
Looks nice, but what is the selling point here? How do you differentiate yourself from a service like Pingdom? I would put some selling points on the homepage.
dholowiski超过 14 年前
It looks great. The only thing I would be concerned with is that it would be pretty easy for a developer to replicate on their own.<p>Being totally honest, the price would have to be pretty low, or offer X sites (like 10) for the price for me not to just do it myself.<p>That or there would have to be some kick-ass value-add. The simplicity is a nice value-add, but doesn't quite cut it for me.
jessor超过 14 年前
Great idea!<p>In the admin, when one adds his site and there's an error, all fields clear out. Also i tried putting in a german mobile number in various formats and it always said "Sms number must be at most 10 characters long".<p>Best of luck, looking forward to where you'll go with this.
评论 #2111391 未加载
aik超过 14 年前
The landing page seems overly dark and techno. A professional business looking for a client-facing status page you would expect to be lighter and friendlier looking, and the front-page doesn't agree with this. I was a little turned off by it, but the example was great.
评论 #2111000 未加载
llgrrl超过 14 年前
I love your service. Some thing that I'm thinking about now:<p>- Ability to customize the status page (theming) - Embeddable image (just in case someone wants to shove a lot of status for different pages into one page) - API? This, you can charge money for.
评论 #2111004 未加载
grep超过 14 年前
I believe <a href="http://www.stashboard.org/" rel="nofollow">http://www.stashboard.org/</a> does the same and it's free and open source.
obilgic超过 14 年前
Why do not you just integrate micro-blogging system to this ?
评论 #2111195 未加载
kevinburke超过 14 年前
Pretty awesome - puts my winter project(s) to shame :-)
Mithrandir超过 14 年前
Will there be a free version at the end of the beta?