TE
科技回声
首页24小时热榜最新最佳问答展示工作
GitHubTwitter
首页

科技回声

基于 Next.js 构建的科技新闻平台,提供全球科技新闻和讨论内容。

GitHubTwitter

首页

首页最新最佳问答展示工作

资源链接

HackerNews API原版 HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 科技回声. 版权所有。

The World's Happiest Countries

26 点作者 gaiusparx超过 14 年前

13 条评论

henrikschroder超过 14 年前
Ah, lies, damn lies, and statistics.<p>It's nice and easy to compare the official numbers and compile lists and rankings, but it's very easy to be clouded by your own preconceptions and belive that the numbers tell the whole story. Not so.<p>For example, Sweden's weakest category was "Social Capital".<p>&#62; The marriage rate is the 77th lowest, globally<p>I was fixing up my profile at LinkedIn today, and under my personal status I could choose between "single" or "married". I got slightly annoyed, because I am neither. I'm "cohabitating" or whatever the awkward English term for it is. Over here, such an arrangement is very common, and even offers some legal protection. There are many couples who live together, raise children, and never marry. There's no difference between these and married couples, except that the latter group shows up in global statistics and the former group show up as singles, even though it's not an accurate view.<p>&#62; while rates of religious attendance are seventh lowest among all countries, suggesting a limited access to familial and religious support networks.<p>The average Swede would consider this being seventh from the top, not seventh from the bottom. There's also no lack of access to religious support, it's that people don't <i>want</i> it.<p>The numbers will tell you that a majority of Swedes are christians, because the number you get is the number of members of various churches, but until recently, membership in the state church was automatic, and a lot of people get married in a church or baptize their children in a church, despite being atheist or agnostic or apathetic to the whole thing.<p>So the official numbers say we are a christian nation where noone goes to church regularly. The truth is that we are a secular nation that uses churches for traditions.
评论 #2124377 未加载
jhancock超过 14 年前
<a href="http://www.prosperity.com/" rel="nofollow">http://www.prosperity.com/</a> is the source of this study. Skip to this to see the list without Forbes' layer of editorial and ads.
评论 #2124096 未加载
评论 #2124142 未加载
smackay超过 14 年前
I don't want to be morose but many of the countries listed also have significant suicide rates. Finland, in particular, has the highest rate in western Europe with Switzerland not far behind. I guess everything comes with a price.
评论 #2124146 未加载
评论 #2124023 未加载
ashbrahma超过 14 年前
I am surprised Bhutan is not on this list. In Bhutan, they measure growth by GNH - Gross National Happiness and not by GDP:)
tici_88超过 14 年前
It is interesting how nearly all of the 10 countries in the top 10 are either in North-Western Europe, or have historically been "sprung" from a country in North-Western Europe (e.g. Canada, Australia, New Zealand who are in the Commonwealth and still technically headed by Queen Elizabeth II).<p>If you look deeper, the top 10 countries that are in North-Western Europe (Norway, Sweeden, Denmark, Finland, the Netherlands) are all under the heavy influence of the Gulf Stream which makes their climate particularly overcast, rainy and dreary - probably the most miserable in the world.<p>So maybe it all comes down to the people of those countries learning ways to "keep themselves happy" over the centuries - an evolutionary technique of psychological survival, so to speak.<p>Just a thought.
axod超过 14 年前
The data lists US as ranked #1 for health???<p>Rubbish. Rather than taking real data such as life expectancy, they seem to be asking population "Are you happy with health".<p>So basically, rather than measuring 'happiness', this is measuring how deluded/subdued the population is.
评论 #2124173 未加载
评论 #2124226 未加载
davidw超过 14 年前
IIRC, The Economist did one of these recently, or reported on it, but also had the good sense to put in some climate data. In other words, I'd rather be here in Italy than in someplace like Finland, even though you'd get no disagreement that the latter 'works' better. The sunnier and warmer (within limits) it is, the happier I am.
pimeys超过 14 年前
If Finland is one of the happiest, the people in other countries should be very, very miserable... Most of the time the sun won't shine and people escape it by drinking heavy loads of booze. It's cold and nothing ever happens. At least when you are a twenty-something it professional :)
评论 #2124082 未加载
hiroprot超过 14 年前
Wowzer...Luxembourg is not even on the overall ranking list?<p>From what I recall, it has been consistently in the top 15 in other studies.
gladimdim超过 14 年前
Why do they split article into 5 pages. I do not read such sites. Is forbes such poor that they increase ads view rate in such way?
评论 #2123914 未加载
iampims超过 14 年前
Why does Forbes try so hard to make the article unreadable?
pedanticfreak超过 14 年前
I find it interesting they make up a bunch of metrics which they claim are related to happiness rather than just asking people whether they are happy.<p>It's as if I said I was happy and someone responded "What? You only make $50,000 per year, your country's GDP to pollution ratio is 4.25, and you had 2.13 medical procedures last year at a 26.7 percent premium over the global average, you CAN'T be happy!"<p>Wouldn't it make more sense to figure out which people actually are happy then figure out the statistical correlations? Although from what I've read there aren't any meaningful correlations. Happiness is defined and continuously redefined by experience.
评论 #2124218 未加载
borism超过 14 年前
The Real World's Happiest Countries, not the utopian world of Forbes and Heritage Foundation:<p><a href="http://www.happyplanetindex.org" rel="nofollow">http://www.happyplanetindex.org</a>
评论 #2124043 未加载
评论 #2124337 未加载