TE
科技回声
首页24小时热榜最新最佳问答展示工作
GitHubTwitter
首页

科技回声

基于 Next.js 构建的科技新闻平台,提供全球科技新闻和讨论内容。

GitHubTwitter

首页

首页最新最佳问答展示工作

资源链接

HackerNews API原版 HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 科技回声. 版权所有。

Ask HN: Are there any regulatory bodies for software developers?

7 点作者 trwhite将近 5 年前
I work for an Accounting firm as a Software Developer. To become an Accountant (in the UK), my understanding is that one has to pass a number of exams in order to attain certain accreditations. Having passed these, one&#x27;s expected to uphold certain quality and ethical standards.<p>As a developer I&#x27;ve witnessed some very questionable decisions and even flagrant abuses of privacy, security and general good practice. Is there any organisation that regulates what we do?

6 条评论

uberman将近 5 年前
The answer to the ultimate question of is there any organization that regulates software developers is:<p><i>&quot;No, there are no industry-wide&#x2F;state-wide &quot;graduate into the field&quot; type awards&#x2F;tests as there are in fields like accounting, actuarial science, engineering, law, medicine...&quot;</i><p>There are however a plethora of pseduo-meaningless (imho) certificates that people can get related to software development.<p>Given that many software developers are self taught this is probably the way many would like to keep things. I personally think that professional certification akin to passing the state bar exam might be a good thing and much more valuable than a pdf saying I was jedi-master of new-company-database-tech or one from cool-bootcamp approving me for emerging-front-end-library.
评论 #24058925 未加载
s1t5将近 5 年前
No, there isn&#x27;t and that&#x27;s a good thing. I can&#x27;t imagine a group of people collectively having the thought &quot;Hmm how can we be more like accountants?&quot;.
评论 #24068240 未加载
评论 #24058930 未加载
happy_path将近 5 年前
I think the question is not if there are any regulatory body for Software Engineering. The question should be: Do regulatory bodies and legal accountability of software engineers would have stopped software projects to fail? i.e. would a regulatory body be useful?<p>Judging from the several cybersecurity incidents of these last days and the Boeing 737 software fiasco, I&#x27;d say yes. However, that should pair a spectacular increase in salary in the accountable software engineers category (because of the insurance they would have to pay). Something similar like doctor&#x27;s medical insurance against litigation.<p>Is the world ready for that? I don&#x27;t think so.
pickle-wizard将近 5 年前
For a while in Texas you could become a Professional Engineer in Software Engineering. I don&#x27;t know anyone who has one it.<p>I just checked and the exam was discontinued in 2019 due to low interest.
Jtsummers将近 5 年前
Not at the individual level. Certain kinds of software have to seek certification before use or deployment (particularly aviation), but the developers themselves don&#x27;t require any kind of certification to work on it.
2rsf将近 5 年前
AFAIK if you want to immigrate on a work visa to Australia as a software engineer you&#x27;ll need to pass an assessment by the AUSTRALIAN COMPUTER SOCIETY
评论 #24068243 未加载