TE
科技回声
首页24小时热榜最新最佳问答展示工作
GitHubTwitter
首页

科技回声

基于 Next.js 构建的科技新闻平台,提供全球科技新闻和讨论内容。

GitHubTwitter

首页

首页最新最佳问答展示工作

资源链接

HackerNews API原版 HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 科技回声. 版权所有。

“Ily” – a word that qualifies–or adverbs–an adverb

5 点作者 firloop超过 4 年前

8 条评论

SamBam超过 4 年前
The author claim that they&#x27;re not re-inventing adverbs, but rather want a word that modifies another adverb (someone in the comments suggests an &quot;adadverb&quot;). But the example doesn&#x27;t show this:<p>&gt; “He quickly ate the mango in a distracted manner,” I wanted to write, “He distractedily quickly ate the mango,” because, among other reasons, I wanted to be more concise.<p>But in the first sentence, &quot;quickly&quot; and &quot;distracted manner&quot; both modify &quot;ate,&quot; and so they are both simply adverbs.<p>While there could be some merit in trying to suggest a causal relationship between the two adverbs (&quot;Because he was distracted, he ate the mango quickly&quot;), that doesn&#x27;t seem to be what&#x27;s being suggested either.<p>So I can&#x27;t really see the purpose of this. How does &quot;distracted&quot; <i>modify</i> &quot;quickly&quot; in the example? How is &quot;quickly&quot; itself different, now that it&#x27;s been modified? I don&#x27;t think it is, what&#x27;s different is the way the mango is being eaten, so they are both simply adverbs for the same verb.<p>In any case, adverbs can already modify adverbs:<p>&quot;He burped enormously loudly.&quot;
评论 #24309537 未加载
评论 #24309661 未加载
Sharlin超过 4 年前
Um,<p><i>&gt; acceleratingily increasing</i><p>Acceleratingly increasing (without the &quot;i&quot;) is already grammatical English with the desired meaning, right?<p><i>&gt; unconsciousily habitually</i><p>&quot;Unconsciously habitually&quot;<p><i>&gt; endearingily awkwardly</i><p>&quot;Endearingly awkwardly&quot;<p>Drop the &quot;i&quot;s and those are all grammatically correct. That&#x27;s a rather low bar to clear though!
aroundtown超过 4 年前
Those are just adverbs. Poorly written adverbs.
thotsBgone超过 4 年前
If you remove the &#x27;i&#x27; from &quot;ily&quot;, then you get the sentence, &quot;He distractedly quickly ate the mango...,&quot; which seems grammatical to me.<p>In any case, I&#x27;m not sure why some high schooler&#x27;s ill-considered blog post is Hacker News.
评论 #24309577 未加载
Igelau超过 4 年前
The problem is interesting, but the solution is too confusing because an -ily word looks and sounds too much like an adverb with an epenthesis. In speech (YMMV because regional accents) I would just think that the person said &quot;distractedly&quot;, changed their mind, and said &quot;quickly&quot; instead.<p>Makes me wonder if any language existed&#x2F;exists that does have such syntactic sugar for &quot;&lt;adverb&gt; &lt;action&gt; in a &lt;adjective&gt; way&quot;. Seems like something that might have come up.
TeMPOraL超过 4 年前
Oh god what is with those em dashes (—) and spacing? Is &quot;foo—bar baz—quux&quot; correctly spaced? Because it took me a minute to parse the title (and the same line in the article). For a while I was thinking that &quot;qualifies—or&quot; and &quot;adverbs—an&quot; are some advanced concepts from linguistic equivalent of algebra. But it turns out that the sentence is just &quot;qualifies, or adverbs, an adverb&quot;.
评论 #24309551 未加载
saagarjha超过 4 年前
I understand the first example-the awkward way that it’s done is endearing-but the second one seems like a confusing oxymoron. Can someone explain what it’s trying to say?
评论 #24309525 未加载
tingletech超过 4 年前
this is already a thing though, it sounds like he thinks he invented it? <a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;en.wiktionary.org&#x2F;wiki&#x2F;-ily" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;en.wiktionary.org&#x2F;wiki&#x2F;-ily</a>