TE
科技回声
首页24小时热榜最新最佳问答展示工作
GitHubTwitter
首页

科技回声

基于 Next.js 构建的科技新闻平台,提供全球科技新闻和讨论内容。

GitHubTwitter

首页

首页最新最佳问答展示工作

资源链接

HackerNews API原版 HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 科技回声. 版权所有。

Show HN: Beeper – All Your Chats in One App

962 点作者 erohead超过 4 年前

116 条评论

erohead超过 4 年前
While working on Pebble, we ran into a lot of issues as we tried to enable messaging from the watch. For example, we never figured out how to send an iMessage or WhatsApp reply. While digging around for a solution to that problem, I thought it was odd that no one had built a Adrium&#x2F;Trillian&#x2F;Meebo chat app for modern chat networks. I buried that thought for a while, until I learned about Matrix two years ago.<p>Matrix is the holy grail of chat. It&#x27;s end-to-end encrypted by default, federated and open source. The only problem is that not a single one of my friends or family was on it! Luckily the Matrix folks had already envisioned a solution to this problem - they built an API enabling &#x27;bridges&#x27; between Matrix and other chat networks. This struck a chord with me, maybe we could finally build a single app that I could use to chat with all my friends, regardless of which chat app they used. Through the Matrix community I met Tulir, the most prolific bridge developer and we started working together on what would become Beeper. I&#x27;ve been using it as my primary chat client for almost 2 years now. I could not imagine going back to the hot mess of 12 different chat apps I had before!<p>Beeper is a paid service because I think it aligns interests between us and our users. We make a featureful and secure app, in exchange you pay us money. For those who prefer to self-host, you can run the entire Beeper backend stack on your own server. The vast majority of the code we&#x27;ve written for Beeper is open source on gitlab.com&#x2F;nova. Our desktop client is closed source, but you can use Element (or any open source Matrix client) if you prefer. See our FAQ for more info or I&#x27;d be happy to explain more.
评论 #25851796 未加载
评论 #25861030 未加载
评论 #25848795 未加载
评论 #25849404 未加载
评论 #25849788 未加载
评论 #25850066 未加载
评论 #25849773 未加载
评论 #25849945 未加载
评论 #25853917 未加载
评论 #25848739 未加载
评论 #25852335 未加载
评论 #25868422 未加载
评论 #25848843 未加载
评论 #25855827 未加载
评论 #25854180 未加载
评论 #25852829 未加载
评论 #25851904 未加载
评论 #25850829 未加载
评论 #25864950 未加载
评论 #25851463 未加载
评论 #25849627 未加载
评论 #25856204 未加载
评论 #25853818 未加载
评论 #25848776 未加载
评论 #25852381 未加载
评论 #25856264 未加载
评论 #25852185 未加载
评论 #25851121 未加载
评论 #25851366 未加载
评论 #25851110 未加载
评论 #25848782 未加载
评论 #25850095 未加载
评论 #25853584 未加载
评论 #25853997 未加载
评论 #25867171 未加载
评论 #25850167 未加载
评论 #25850365 未加载
评论 #25856490 未加载
jakelazaroff超过 4 年前
Doesn&#x27;t using this with Discord run a risk of your account getting banned for using a third-party client? That&#x27;s why the Cordless developer shut down the project: <a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;github.com&#x2F;Bios-Marcel&#x2F;cordless" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;github.com&#x2F;Bios-Marcel&#x2F;cordless</a>
评论 #25859006 未加载
评论 #25850948 未加载
评论 #25853295 未加载
评论 #25850272 未加载
评论 #25850427 未加载
npmisdown超过 4 年前
Could someone shed a light on economics of working on such kind of a project?<p>Aren&#x27;t developing third-party client for the entity which you do not control and somehow compete with is typically a futile experience?<p>Doesn&#x27;t it go against most of ToS-es directly (e.g. Discord&#x2F;WhatsApp happily ban accounts using third-party clients) or indirectly (I guess no proprietary chat platform will be exactly happy having third-party clients that compete with their official and controlled app).<p>I mean how people justify building a business on it given that it essentially means that they have to play on the other&#x27;s people playground by the rules which can be changed at any time. Like tomorrow Slack would decide to disallow any third-party apps and you&#x27;re done.
评论 #25871800 未加载
评论 #25850142 未加载
zufallsheld超过 4 年前
I just installed matrix and bridges for telegram, slack and whatsapp using the linked ansible playbook. I used my own domain and a new cheap vps. this took me about an hour. I connected Element on my android phone to my new matrix server and now I have all chats in one app and on desktop. That is totally great and worked far better and easier than I imagined. Well done.
评论 #25861363 未加载
评论 #25853343 未加载
评论 #25862900 未加载
meibo超过 4 年前
&gt; we send each user a Jailbroken iPhone with the Beeper app installed which bridges to iMessage<p>Huh, I wonder how this is sustainable. I assume there is a greater cost than 10 bucks a month for this option? I wouldn&#x27;t want to be the one managing the logistical effort of that!
评论 #25849836 未加载
评论 #25850092 未加载
评论 #25850486 未加载
评论 #25854262 未加载
kevincox超过 4 年前
I love the idea of hosted bridges (in fact I was thinking about starting my own service like this) and I&#x27;m glad that the bridges themselves are open source. However I would much rather that the client was open source as well (It would make it way easier to get all my friends to Matrix with a well polished client).<p>Basically $10 a month for access to bridges that funds bridge development is great however I don&#x27;t want some of that to fund the development of a closed-source client. If the client was opened, or had work upstreamed to an open source client I would be all on board.
评论 #25859816 未加载
AnonHP超过 4 年前
This looks nice, but $10 a month is a tough sell for me (I use only two of the supported platforms everyday, with about 20 messages total in a day, on average).<p>Also, why does the site ask for an email address to get started? An explanation of why along with the on boarding process would be useful.<p>That aside, the Meet Our Team section on the homepage shows “This is some text inside of a div block.” on the right. Is this an oversight or is it some inside joke?
评论 #25852079 未加载
评论 #25849805 未加载
评论 #25849637 未加载
carterschonwald超过 4 年前
I assume some part of the iMessage faq is a joke ?<p>&gt; This was a tough one to figure out! Beeper has two ways of enabling Android, Windows and Linux users to use iMessage: we send each user a Jailbroken iPhone with the Beeper app installed which bridges to iMessage, or if they have a Mac that is always connected to the internet, they can install the Beeper Mac app which acts as a bridge.
评论 #25852938 未加载
评论 #25852964 未加载
usbfingers超过 4 年前
While I think the core focus of Beeper as a cross platform messenger is great, the bigger positive here in my opinion is a matrix client with good UX and design.<p>The user experience portrayed here is much more in line with what is required to get people less technical on one decentralized&#x2F;federated network, such as matrix.<p>I’m currently working towards the same effort, in a very different stage of development, in that regard with <a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;github.com&#x2F;syphon-org&#x2F;syphon" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;github.com&#x2F;syphon-org&#x2F;syphon</a>.<p>Props to Eric, Tulir, and the team for making such a good looking client!
评论 #25852471 未加载
评论 #25859166 未加载
评论 #25849061 未加载
rhacker超过 4 年前
It really sucks that we can&#x27;t go back in time to the days chat apps looked like AIM, ICQ, etc... The current model of making giant React based Electron apps for a chat app is idiotic IMO. Maybe that&#x27;s the price we pay for corporatizing chat?<p>I liked breaking my chats out into different tiny windows I could see everything happening at once.
tylermenezes超过 4 年前
I&#x27;ve been using this for several months now, and it&#x27;s one of the biggest digital quality-of-life improvements I made in 2020. Getting modern chat networks to interact is never something I thought I would see. Congrats to Eric and co!
评论 #25850345 未加载
peteretep超过 4 年前
This looks awesome, only I tried to &quot;get started&quot; and it looks like it&#x27;s just mined a bunch of my contact details into Airtable, which seems suboptimal?
评论 #25855817 未加载
philsnow超过 4 年前
I mentioned bitlbee elsewhere in this thread, but in case people haven&#x27;t heard of it, it&#x27;s a similar beast to Beeper but it bridges chat systems to an IRC client of your choice (you can use an IRC bouncer or whatever else you want to connect to bitlbee). It supports several chat systems <a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;wiki.bitlbee.org&#x2F;" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;wiki.bitlbee.org&#x2F;</a> including apparently Matrix.<p>I mostly mention it as a historical note because bitlbee&#x27;s use of IRC as the bridged protocol means that it&#x27;s of limited usefulness on mobile. It was fantastic for me in the days before smartphones became a thing, but I do at least 50% of my &quot;chat&quot; on my phone these days.
评论 #25852836 未加载
评论 #25853106 未加载
评论 #25854688 未加载
Andrew_nenakhov超过 4 年前
Multiprotocol clients and transports are a dead end.<p>Most walled garden messaging service developers are openly hostile to third-party clients - this goes back to early 00s and ICQ war against QIP and other much better clients. Modern technology and app distribution model has made it far easier for service owners to enforce their rules of using their service.
评论 #25850542 未加载
vini808超过 4 年前
This is really cool however I’m worried about getting banned from discord using for using your service as I believe it’s not authorized on discord to use third party client
评论 #25850302 未加载
yingbo超过 4 年前
Are there already many similar apps? I used two: Rambox <a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;rambox.pro&#x2F;" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;rambox.pro&#x2F;</a> and Franz <a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;meetfranz.com" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;meetfranz.com</a>
评论 #25849783 未加载
评论 #25849952 未加载
评论 #25850670 未加载
arsome超过 4 年前
If I&#x27;m not mistaken, if you&#x27;re using this with Signal you&#x27;d better be running the bridge yourself or your messages are unencrypted on someone else&#x27;s server.
NikolaNovak超过 4 年前
Is this actually active now?<p>The FAQ implies it&#x27;s an available product. Going through the form indicates I may be invited to use at some unspecified point in the future... :-&#x2F;
评论 #25854230 未加载
hansdieter1337超过 4 年前
I guess it’s only a matter of time until Facebook et al fight the bridges in form of lawsuits and API changes. Some years ago Facebook’s chat was accessible via the Jabber protocol. I think they won’t like users switching away from their apps and miss the control and ad revenue.
lc3sim超过 4 年前
Congrats on the launch! My understanding of the space is that there is a great desire for &quot;super powered&quot; messaging - especially over text. Any chance &quot;send later&quot; is a part of your roadmap? Or possible to implement using your API?
评论 #25851276 未加载
el_dev_hell超过 4 年前
Serious question: Is the below a joke or legitimate?<p>How in the world did you get iMessage to work on Android and Windows? This was a tough one to figure out! Beeper has two ways of enabling Android, Windows and Linux users to use iMessage: we send each user a Jailbroken iPhone with the Beeper app installed which bridges to iMessage, or if they have a Mac that is always connected to the internet, they can install the Beeper Mac app which acts as a bridge.
评论 #25855852 未加载
评论 #25855250 未加载
2Gkashmiri超过 4 年前
&gt;This was a tough one to figure out! Beeper has two ways of enabling Android, Windows and Linux users to use iMessage: we send each user a Jailbroken iPhone with the Beeper app installed which bridges to iMessage,<p>is this not a joke?
评论 #25849075 未加载
评论 #25849017 未加载
vessenes超过 4 年前
Oooh, this is so exciting.<p>I went down the bridged chat rabbit hole earlier this year when I realized I had to be checking signal, telegram, WhatsApp, WeChat, iMessage and multiple emails to be on top of communication. I stopped when I realized how difficult WhatsApp and WeChat were going to be, though.<p>I want to pay for this, right now. Ideally double if it will help you launch. :)
评论 #25854748 未加载
scrollaway超过 4 年前
Holy crap, this is inspiring. The blog post (<a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;medium.com&#x2F;@ericmigi&#x2F;the-universal-communication-bus-42dfb9a141ad" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;medium.com&#x2F;@ericmigi&#x2F;the-universal-communication-bus...</a>) really says it all.<p>I&#x27;ve sent you an email. It&#x27;s great to see the problem being addressed the right way.
kuter超过 4 年前
Some of the supported messaging apps doesn&#x27;t allow automation or provide APIs. I appreciate the work that went into supporting those. But I don&#x27;t think it would be possible to have consistent support for some of those chat apps. Things like API changes or just getting you server ips banned would disrupt service.
mrweasel超过 4 年前
How does it work? Most of those protocols are’t exactly open.<p>Also please add support for Google Chat.
da_big_ghey超过 4 年前
I use weechat for this and it works fine. Slack, Discord, Signal, etc. all bridge fine (though Signal is a bit messy). And of course, IRC. The one thing I haven&#x27;t figured out how to connect is MS Teams, and it doesn&#x27;t look like this service offers it anyway; is there a reason to use it?
评论 #25853185 未加载
评论 #25850359 未加载
uoflcards22超过 4 年前
How do I get started? I put in my email like 10 minutes ago and have received nothing...
评论 #25849821 未加载
gkfasdfasdf超过 4 年前
I thought WhatsApp banned thirdparty apps some time ago? How does this work exactly?
评论 #25848987 未加载
bfors超过 4 年前
If I had a social life I&#x27;d be really excited about this
recursive超过 4 年前
There&#x27;s a list of logos for supported chat networks. But it doesn&#x27;t give the names. I recognize about half of them, but it would be nice if they were written in words somewhere.
评论 #25850776 未加载
halfjew22超过 4 年前
&gt;How in the world did you get iMessage to work on Android and Windows?<p>&gt;This was a tough one to figure out! Beeper has two ways of enabling Android, Windows and Linux users to use iMessage: we send each user a Jailbroken iPhone with the Beeper app installed which bridges to iMessage, or if they have a Mac that is always connected to the internet, they can install the Beeper Mac app which acts as a bridge.<p>Can you elaborate? Surely this is satire or I&#x27;m missing something super obvious.
dilly_li超过 4 年前
&quot;Beeper has two ways of enabling Android, Windows and Linux users to use iMessage: we send each user a Jailbroken iPhone with the Beeper app installed which bridges to iMessage, or if they have a Mac that is always connected to the internet, they can install the Beeper Mac app which acts as a bridge.&quot;<p>This answers my question! One iPhone for each Beeper user, no wonder the $10 monthly fee!
评论 #25854807 未加载
easyascake超过 4 年前
Went to their website, filled out the form, assumed I was signing up for a beta. Then...nothing happened. No automated emails, &quot;you&#x27;re in the beta!&quot; notifications, nothing. Reached out to them on twitter, nothing. So I&#x27;m not sure what&#x27;s going on, but from where I&#x27;m standing right now it looks like I gave my email to a service for no reason...
alaenix超过 4 年前
Wonderful promise ! I&#x27;m really thinking that I need an app like that one but how to justify the price ? I&#x27;m ready to pay for that kind of service but it&#x27;s seems too expensive to me. How an app like this can cost you 10$ per month and in comparison an app like Procreate (best drawing app on iPad) cost you only 10$ (not per month or year, just 10$).
3np超过 4 年前
Great to see the progress! I really hope you can grow sustainable and profitable while facilitating Matrix. Kudos!<p>Tulir&#x27;s been doing fantastic work, but it does seem that to ~80%, all the significant bridge maintenance&#x2F;development for public IM networks is a one-man show... Makes me a bit concerned that such a key piece of the Matrix ecosystem (and IMO a crucial component for eventual success) is underfunded, neglected and relying on a single person. Keeping things working with potentially hostile changes in undocumented or unsupported APIs is not trivial.<p>Also, how does your roadmap for new protocols look (if you have any)?<p>I&#x27;d love to promote this, but without LINE it&#x27;s pretty much uninteresting&#x2F;useless here in Japan, Korea, and Taiwan. I heard it&#x27;s also one of the top IM apps in other countries, like Thailand.
评论 #25854590 未加载
maelito超过 4 年前
&gt; Interesting, please tell me this is based on matrix<p>&gt; Oh, the matrix logo among others, good thing at least<p>&gt; YES !
e-clinton超过 4 年前
iMessage integration is interesting but I can’t imagine it will last. Not sure what type of wizardry you guys pulled but a cease and desist is likely on its way. Either way, congrats. Really hope it works out as this is very much needed.
visarga超过 4 年前
Are paying users messages visible to Beeper? If so, then it&#x27;s just another risk.
miguelrochefort超过 4 年前
Any plans for VoIP SMS support?<p>A few years ago, I moved my phone number to VoIP.ms to save about $50&#x2F;month on my cellphone bill ($70 &#x2F;month for calls, texts and data vs $20&#x2F;month for only data). VoIP.ms costs me roughly $2&#x2F;month. With the pandemic, I cancelled my cellphone plan and make all phone calls on WiFi.<p>However, SMS are still a pain to deal with. About 2-3 people in my life still send them, and many apps still use them for authentication&#x2F;verification.<p>Adding SMS support would make Beeper a lot more appealing, and might encourage people to move to VoIP (a service you might charge for when you inevitably work on audio&#x2F;video bridges).
whycombagator超过 4 年前
I thought I’d seen this before[0]<p>Also:<p>&gt; I make no claims to this being production level reliability. It&#x27;s very much beta software. Very beta<p>@erohead does this quote from you 6 months ago still hold true?[1]<p>This is a software I’d definitely use &amp; pay for if it was polished&#x2F;worked.<p>I quickly looked at the GitLab source and couldn’t find the code for the iMessage bridge. How does that integration work?<p>[0] <a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;news.ycombinator.com&#x2F;item?id=23693371" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;news.ycombinator.com&#x2F;item?id=23693371</a><p>[1] <a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;news.ycombinator.com&#x2F;item?id=23694933" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;news.ycombinator.com&#x2F;item?id=23694933</a>
评论 #25849040 未加载
properdine超过 4 年前
What&#x27;s the story on data retention and privacy? Are there servers you store data on and it downloads from? Do you back up messages?<p>Perhaps this is implicit from Matrix protocol but I didn&#x27;t see a clear call out on the site.
wnscooke超过 4 年前
It’s cool, the tech behind it all, but I’m in the process of closing my WhatsApp account, so I don’t need a bridge. For some reason my initial reaction was joy that this could be a WhatsApp replacement, somehow. And at the moment, I like keeping my other chat apps in their own app window, for keeping track of what I’m doing In them. I could see myself accidentally responding to the wrong person if everything is in one app. So again, it’s cool what with the tech, and OS, but, as I think about it... am I really going to use it?
asiando超过 4 年前
I spent a lot of time and effort merging my chat clients in the Meebo era and afterwards with XMPP proxies and I tried to keep friends from messaging me in 3 apps at once.<p>I gave up and that&#x27;s fine. I have at least 4 messaging apps on my phone and I still prefer that over debugging a proxy. A missed message causes real-world problems, so it&#x27;s important not to mess with the delicate balance that IM already carries.<p>If the benefit is easier archival and search, give me a solution to that that works in the background rather than a real-time proxy.
farukuzun超过 4 年前
It looks great, I would definetely subscribe <i>but</i> trusting a third-party with my IM data something I&#x27;m not comfortable with. Fundamentally, deploying a Matrix homeserver in the <i>cloud</i> is the same thing. Homeserver requires a public ip address or domain name, it&#x27;s really hard to set up one at home.<p>I don&#x27;t have enough information about Matrix protocol but, a raspberry pi image, or Dockerfile doesn&#x27;t need IP or Domain, uses hosts file to trick the homeserver maybe, just supports bridges, would be perfect.
yur3i__超过 4 年前
The main appeal of this to me is the whatsapp part. If I can reliably self host this and get rid of whatsapp on my phone, replacing it with an open source app then that&#x27;s awesome
habosa超过 4 年前
This looks super cool! Obligatory WUPHF link: <a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;youtu.be&#x2F;8wfG8ngFvPk?t=9" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;youtu.be&#x2F;8wfG8ngFvPk?t=9</a>
bichiliad超过 4 年前
I&#x27;ve been really excited for something like this, and seeing that it&#x27;s built on top of Matrix is also exciting. One of my biggest gripes as of late is how hard it is to, for example, limit your time on Instagram without cutting yourself off from Instagram&#x27;s chat. I can tell my friends to send me texts as much as I want, but there&#x27;s always a message or two in Instagram that I don&#x27;t see until a day or two later than I want to.
评论 #25848821 未加载
ronyfadel超过 4 年前
A significant part of my SO’s business (interior architect) is based on introductory chats with clients on different platforms (namely Instagram, WhatsApp, iMessage).<p>Did you guys solve custom features such as “replies to a specific message” (all platforms), or “stickers” (WhatsApp&#x2F;iMessage).<p>The last thing I want to do is to go check my phone every time I receive a sticker from a client, to get more context; it would beat the purpose of Beeper.
codebutler超过 4 年前
Looks awesome, I&#x27;m looking forward to trying it out! A couple questions: 1) Is the desktop app electron or native? 2) Is the Mac iMessage bridge open-source?<p>Thanks!
评论 #25849469 未加载
chenster超过 4 年前
Not &quot;All Your Chats&quot;. Franz is doing this already. It has a free version with limited features. The down side is it is a CPU hog. It doesn&#x27;t support WeChat, neither is your Beeper. That really sucks. It is probably due to WeChat&#x27;s closed API that they never really wanted any 3rd party to interface with it. Not sure if anything you can do about it.
评论 #25863488 未加载
Kaze404超过 4 年前
I wrote some code for this project a while ago and was fascinated by how well it works. I&#x27;m glad to see it finally being released :)
dmcc7897超过 4 年前
I have signed up and will happily pay for this the very second I receive an invite. This is exactly what I need.<p>The UI appears to be top notch, too.
johnisgood超过 4 年前
How does encryption work across the bridges? Is this written down anywhere? Signal, Telegram&#x27;s Secret Chat, etc.
评论 #25863511 未加载
jcul超过 4 年前
This looks great.<p>I&#x27;m just in the middle of trying to set up a home server using dendrite to do exactly this (mainly for fun).<p>This looks really well done and polished though.<p>It&#x27;s great to see services like this using matrix as it can only mean positive feedback for the protocol &#x2F; server code.<p>Is it using synapse or dendrite (or something else) for the server?
评论 #25852583 未加载
jonplackett超过 4 年前
1) Is this actually live or just a concept. All I get a a survey when signing up<p>2) This seems like a security nightmare. Is it?
dundercoder超过 4 年前
I was just looking yesterday for a unified chat client, specifically for slack and discord. Looks interesting.
electriclove超过 4 年前
Reconsider your pricing strategy. $19 for the year will get you TONS of signups (if scaling is not an issue).
ironmagma超过 4 年前
I would like to see this but for notifications. One cannot trust websites to have actual notifications anymore instead of stupid re-engagement pushes, and logging in to the various apps is a chore designed to be addictive. We need a no-nonsense platform for aggregating those.
lukegraham超过 4 年前
How does Beeper avoid Instagram deciding that &quot;your account has been compromised&quot; and forcing you to change passwords? Unsurprisingly, Instagram seems to not be a fan of &quot;illegitimate behaviour&quot; (like bots &#x2F; 3rd party clients).
deallocator超过 4 年前
I see that they allow you to search through your messages across all platforms. How do they achieve that, unless they&#x27;re somehow storing all my messages in their backend (which I&#x27;m not really a fan of if that&#x27;d be the case)
评论 #25859275 未加载
aabbccsmith超过 4 年前
I wouldn&#x27;t use this for Discord, as it requires you to insert a user token (aka self botting – which is against the terms of service). Bar that, the app looks quite promising, but I would be wary of what they are offering.
ggrelet超过 4 年前
I submitted my infos to Nova.chat (same form) a while ago. Do I need to do it again?
评论 #25850177 未加载
foolinaround超过 4 年前
A suggestion for the beeper folks -- offer any 2 integrations for free, and then another tier for 2 more integrations, etc.<p>Maybe the free tier has google ads -- these folks are already seeing these most likely and wont mind?
The_Amp_Walrus超过 4 年前
Beeper people: I filled out your Airtable form... how do I give you money?
css超过 4 年前
I used to use an app for this called IM+ in the early days of iOS, looks like they&#x27;re still around: <a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.plus.im" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.plus.im</a>
poisonborz超过 4 年前
This is awesome, but do I see correctly - based on the screenshots- that only basic chat is possible? I wouldn&#x27;t expect calls or video, but things like sending gifs, location, etc.
2Gkashmiri超过 4 年前
can you give us a ballpark figues of how much of a vps is needed to get started? you have given an ansible script and all but minimum specs would be nice along with users it can handle
评论 #25849077 未加载
krisgenre超过 4 年前
Not sure how many know&#x2F;remember Digsby? It worked pretty well on Windows, got acquired by Tagged, open sourced, promise of Linux client and then disappeared.<p>Hopefully Beeper will survive.
technick超过 4 年前
They lost me at $10 a month. I would be interested at $5 a month, but $10... I&#x27;m just going to go without or even consider setting up my own thing with Matrix.
soheil超过 4 年前
What happens if I have an iPhone and want to send&#x2F;receive text (not iMessage)? Is this officially supported or text messaging only works if you have an Android?
jnsie超过 4 年前
This looks really neat. Would love to know more about how iMessage is integrated and get thoughts on the likelihood of Apple blocking it in the future. But kudos!
polishdude20超过 4 年前
Does this solve the whole security issues with WhatsApp and such? It seems like just a proxy so it&#x27;s not any more secure than the apps it accesses right?
khimaros超过 4 年前
this is a really cool project, and a great curation effort. there are ansible scripts which they recommend for self-hosting: <a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;github.com&#x2F;spantaleev&#x2F;matrix-docker-ansible-deploy" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;github.com&#x2F;spantaleev&#x2F;matrix-docker-ansible-deploy</a> -- most of the bridges (mirrored to their GitLab org) appear to be unmodified from upstream.
评论 #25848783 未加载
smusamashah超过 4 年前
How does it compare with pidgin?<p><a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.pidgin.im&#x2F;plugins&#x2F;" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.pidgin.im&#x2F;plugins&#x2F;</a>
评论 #25872567 未加载
jmarinez超过 4 年前
Beeper bridges with WhatsApp. Does it mean that one can bypass the upcoming Facebook data sharing requirement by just using the Beeper client?
评论 #25850200 未加载
fileyfood500超过 4 年前
Will this support Amazon Chime and Microsoft teams?
评论 #25876347 未加载
sarthakjshetty超过 4 年前
Another quick question, the webpage looks a lot like Mighty&#x27;s. Is it designed by the same folks or is it like a design language?
saltybytes超过 4 年前
Isn&#x27;t Beeper similar to Franz [0]?<p>[0] <a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;meetfranz.com&#x2F;" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;meetfranz.com&#x2F;</a>
评论 #25854192 未加载
bambax超过 4 年前
This looks awesome but $10&#x2F;month&#x2F;user is too high. Can one register somewhere and be notified if the price changes?
worldmerge超过 4 年前
Because you&#x27;re using APIs, if I stop paying I won&#x27;t lose my messages right? They&#x27;ll still be in my other apps?
underlines超过 4 年前
trillian, Messenger Plus, Franz, WhatsApp Plus.<p>they all eventually die out. Either they use unofficial hooks or just the web app of the service.<p>:(<p>also: i am living in Thailand and here everybody uses LINE Messenger. they removed the webclient and the platform is not famous enough outside of SEA for any western multimessenger dev to reverse engineer and hook.
maneesh超过 4 年前
I just signed up and filled the form. It redirects to the home page. How do I find the link to download?
monkeynotes超过 4 年前
Does this support RCS flavours of SMS?
squiggy22超过 4 年前
Does this provide any additional privacy benefits over using say the native apps for said networks?
ggm超过 4 年前
PSI is dead, all hail Adium.<p>Adium is dead, all hail Beeper.<p>Is that it?
评论 #25854794 未加载
recursivedoubts超过 4 年前
Please, someone do this for email.
评论 #25848818 未加载
评论 #25848846 未加载
评论 #25848828 未加载
TheKarateKid超过 4 年前
What&#x27;s old is new again. Anyone remember Trillian?<p>AOL, MSN, ICQ, Yahoo messenger all in one client!
wiggler00m超过 4 年前
Where can I read more about Beeper&#x27;s privacy and encryption?
soheil超过 4 年前
If there is an iMessage bridge that would be considered a zero-day exploit. There is no official or un-office API for iMessage outside the Apple ecosystem and this is part of security measures by Apple to ensure privacy.
评论 #25850623 未加载
评论 #25850279 未加载
评论 #25851610 未加载
EGreg超过 4 年前
Wait wait -- how is Beeper able to use WhatsApp API?<p>I thought it was closed!
olah_1超过 4 年前
If Matrix &#x2F; Element had a better UX, it wouldn’t need “bridges” as the best selling point.<p>I use other messengers because I find their features to be better. If I preferred Matrix, I would use that without the need for bridges.
评论 #25854215 未加载
评论 #25861528 未加载
xx4xx4超过 4 年前
i hope the company supports parity purchasing power for the 3rd world countries... idk maybe $5 a month.. it would be very helpful..
jaimex2超过 4 年前
If the price comes down I&#x27;d be very keen.
agluszak超过 4 年前
How does the integration with facebook work?
vladojsem超过 4 年前
i can imagine this can work well for different way how to contact tech support. are people using it for that use case?
soheil超过 4 年前
Interesting that &quot;eroheard&quot; comment seems to be pinned to the top of this thread. Is this a new feature by HN and only available to YC company founders?
评论 #25850322 未加载
CosmicShadow超过 4 年前
I keep thinking that&#x27;s the PayPal logo
bkovacev超过 4 年前
Is there a plan for supporting Viber?
WorldPeas超过 4 年前
For those that don&#x27;t use a macintosh(or don&#x27;t care about imessage), ferdi is a great free alternative
评论 #25854243 未加载
maikhoepfel超过 4 年前
I very much welcome this, it would enable a smooth transition away from centralized, for-profit clients.<p>But am I missing something? Is this open for public? There&#x27;s a questionnaire after clicking signup, and then one gets redirected to the homepage again. No emails.<p>The privacy policy hardly looks encouraging. The hosted version is only tempting if they&#x27;ll comply with GDPR.
hemmert超过 4 年前
Awesome, Eric! Keep it up!
dkman94超过 4 年前
Is this the wuphf rebrand?
评论 #25852772 未加载
ops3936超过 4 年前
do you have plans of making outside calls or sending sms?
thatgerhard超过 4 年前
I like the idea, but the signup is awful, just give me a download link..
pryelluw超过 4 年前
wuphf.com ?
评论 #25849678 未加载
BFatts超过 4 年前
Trillian!
neycoda超过 4 年前
All your chat are belong to us
DeerSpotter超过 4 年前
ALL YOUR CHATS BELONG TO US
评论 #25859851 未加载
dbancajas超过 4 年前
no viber support?
maverik超过 4 年前
awesome product!
yters超过 4 年前
Why isn&#x27;t there a single app to aggregate and integrate all social media and messaging and email and voice chat platforms? Then it doesn&#x27;t matter which ones come and go, and people don&#x27;t need to worry about the plethora of ways to communicate..
评论 #25849759 未加载
评论 #25849915 未加载
heroHACK17超过 4 年前
WUPHF.com 2.0
gcblkjaidfj超过 4 年前
you are only enabling marketers and spammers.<p>No user will ever use this in the way you are advertising here.
评论 #25852364 未加载
评论 #25850310 未加载
noxer超过 4 年前
10$&#x2F;month is absurd
评论 #25852302 未加载
hypfer超过 4 年前
It&#x27;s mind-boggling, how many of these &quot;All your Chats in one App&quot;-Apps exist.<p>Maybe start building an &quot;All your All your Chats in One App-Apps in one App&quot;-App?