TE
科技回声
首页24小时热榜最新最佳问答展示工作
GitHubTwitter
首页

科技回声

基于 Next.js 构建的科技新闻平台,提供全球科技新闻和讨论内容。

GitHubTwitter

首页

首页最新最佳问答展示工作

资源链接

HackerNews API原版 HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 科技回声. 版权所有。

A new take on remote/hybrid standups

44 点作者 Ali_Jiwani超过 4 年前

12 条评论

casion超过 4 年前
&gt; Reframe the purpose of the standup so its not purely about work but about catching up and hanging out as well.<p>I like to chat after work, if I have time. I like to joke, laugh, have idle chatter with co-workers if&#x2F;when we pair on things. (especially during deploys or compile cycles)<p>I do not want to be forced to schedule &quot;social time&quot;. Social activity is fluid for me, and I can &#x27;fake it&#x27; if necessary, but needing to fake it 4&#x2F;5 days is just silly.<p>I&#x27;m not a cave-dweller either. I was an educator (teenagers, then graduate level), I&#x27;ve spoken at dozens of conferences, I run two active local clubs.<p>If a company forced &quot;rallies&quot; on me, I would unequivocally leave.
评论 #26244477 未加载
评论 #26251014 未加载
echohack5超过 4 年前
I&#x27;ve done every conceivable version of &quot;agile&quot; and &quot;standups&quot; over the years. The best shape, and the best teams that I&#x27;ve worked on do:<p>1. Standup - 10-15m (face time) Monday &#x2F; Wednesday 2. Async (Slack channel text) Tuesday &#x2F; Thursday 3. Planning - 30m-1h (face time) Friday 4. A rotating &quot;lead&quot; or &quot;on-call&quot; or &quot;captain&quot; for the week who organizes these things and interfaces with other team&#x27;s standups<p>This, in combination with your work queue (ticketing &#x2F; kanban board &#x2F; issues &#x2F; etc) is the most streamlined approach I&#x27;ve seen that works. You can certainly add more ceremonies, but I find the constant retrospectives of other systems too negative and depressing, and too much of a distraction.<p>&quot;Rally&quot; is not a new take on standups, it&#x27;s just scrum with a friendly coat of paint on top IMO. One thing that rubs me the wrong way about &quot;Rally&quot; in particular is the forced-socialization ideas. When I&#x27;m at work, I&#x27;m at work. Sometimes, there&#x27;s people at work that I&#x27;m not friends with, but I am going to work with them because I&#x27;m a professional and I get the job done. Don&#x27;t force people to be friendly. It&#x27;s kind of toxic, and forces people to hide their opinions and play politics more than is necessary.
评论 #26247415 未加载
评论 #26250384 未加载
hw超过 4 年前
Standups are normally short, and meant to be short so people don&#x27;t ramble on and everyone can go back to their work. I hate standups because it&#x27;s mostly treated as an agile &#x27;ceremony&#x27;, and that there are better ways to relieve blockers a.k.a communication via Slack or Teams or other means.<p>Taking 30-60 minutes to do a Rally is, forgive me for being skeptical, worse than a traditional standup in that it takes up more time, and requires everyone to buy in to the idea and that your team comprises of only extroverts - something that a traditional standup already has a problem with.
评论 #26250404 未加载
lowbloodsugar超过 4 年前
I thought this was from Rally, the company that makes Scrum software (now owned by Broadcom it appears), instead of from Rally, the company that makes Scrum software. Can&#x27;t believe you&#x27;re not walking into a trademark war with a much larger company.
评论 #26250423 未加载
cvburgess超过 4 年前
We dont use Rally, but my team has essentially always done this and its been very healthy for us. Even on rough days, people join standup and its like catching up with your friends after a long day at work, except they all _get_ what you do and they can constructively work together to &quot;unstuck&quot; whoever needs it.<p>If your scrum is about tickets and not about people, I think you&#x27;re missing the point of &quot;keeping the team in sync&quot;.
评论 #26250447 未加载
whimsica1超过 4 年前
This remind me of Remotion. I have no comments about the Standup vs. Rally. How this is solving a problem for me is that I no longer needs to create zoom call for every meeting, and it seems to be less resource heavy than Google Meets during screenshare.<p>1. Screen sharing does not work without enabling webcam first.<p>2. Room options are not presented in the room, I had to go back to lobby (e.g. change settings)<p>3. Video resolution is better than Discord free-tier, though the bandwidth&#x2F;speed seems slow.<p>4. How can I invite someone online to my table or room?<p>5. When I&#x27;m out of room or stopped camera, chrome is still occupying my webcam &#x2F; my macbook cam light is still on.<p>6. I was hoping there is option to keep room always open.<p>Awesome work; Keep it up!
评论 #26250407 未加载
kdamken超过 4 年前
This sounds like such a nightmare. Why would anyone subject their team to this?<p>“You know how stand ups can feel like a waste of time? What if we made them waste even more time? Managers will love it.”
Ali_Jiwani超过 4 年前
I am curious about your thoughts on this approach to standups. Excusing the self promo of calling it a Rally, do you think adding in some time before or after your standup has been useful to bring your teams together? Do you think adding more people to a dedicated meeting with multiple breakout functions like Rally is a useful way to improve cross company collaboration? Are the problems of connecting and cross collaborating real problems your remote teams are facing?
chas19超过 4 年前
Interesting concept - a solution that could compliment daily stand-ups- maybe a suitable solution for &quot;show and tells&quot;?
评论 #26259433 未加载
ghaff超过 4 年前
Having a <i>daily</i> team meeting for mostly unnecessary purposes sounds awful. I admittedly don&#x27;t primarily do development and don&#x27;t have daily standups anyway. Once a week team meetings at mutually convenient time--I work across multiple timezones--that can spend some time on what people are up to outside of work are fine. But that&#x27;s about the limit.
评论 #26247286 未加载
vinni2超过 4 年前
I wonder how small startups in early phase do it. Anyone has experience?
wackydummy超过 4 年前
Nice!