TE
科技回声
首页24小时热榜最新最佳问答展示工作
GitHubTwitter
首页

科技回声

基于 Next.js 构建的科技新闻平台,提供全球科技新闻和讨论内容。

GitHubTwitter

首页

首页最新最佳问答展示工作

资源链接

HackerNews API原版 HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 科技回声. 版权所有。

Indian Government's Volunteer Programme to Report 'Anti-National' Content

55 点作者 keskadale大约 4 年前

5 条评论

desi_ninja大约 4 年前
Edit : sorry I am on mobile.<p>I am against any restriction on free speech but this one has some context. the farmer protests are happening in two states of India only which had a history of violent separatist terrorist movement (khalistanis). when this farmer protest started, it started getting a lot of attention in international media , NYT, WaPo which are usually critical of India. Canadian PM also put out a statement. the farm bills have their issues but they are more liberal and pro-environment. Canada criticizes India on global forums for not doing these reforms and when India does these reforms, Canada PM puts out a statement against the bill. it is entirely 180. Rihana and Greta start tweeting about it. Germany has a farmer protest happening too but no coverage. because the main reason is link to khalistani propaganda to spread. they don&#x27;t care about farmers. they want to re-ignite the fire of Khalistani separatist movement. the farmers didn&#x27;t do a good job of separating themselves from this organisations. The toolkit linked by Greta was created by a Khalistani supporting group. these are NOT speculation. search for poetic justic india and SJI. so govt is rightly looking for anti national content because it has been there for months.<p>More edit : Really ask yourself. Why a farmer protest within a country is so much advertised all over the world ? There is no serious violence by the govt . Ppl are getting space to do protests too. It is not just farmer movement, it is a launchpad for fanning anti india sentiments. Indian embassies have been attacked, superbowl ads have been shown at some places, massive rallies on US - Canada cities. Twitter celebrities are posting on it. Really ? Is this really only about farmers. Can they really list the 3 farmer laws and their problems ? The answer is NO. They haven&#x27;t bothered to read the bills. They are expecting a bloodbath in India and the govt is smart enough to not do it even when India had its own Capitol riot style attack where a religious flag was flurred on Red fort and khalistani flags were raised, hurting the symbol of Indian republic.<p>Kind of long livestreamed video but explains it well : <a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.youtube.com&#x2F;watch?v=MZHCiIFfc1Q" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.youtube.com&#x2F;watch?v=MZHCiIFfc1Q</a>
2Gkashmiri大约 4 年前
As someone who has to deal with this sort of censorship employed &quot;against me&quot; online by the dictator, who wants no one to criticize his actions, the government and everyone subservient to his whims, it doesn&#x27;t even sound like 1984 anymore. Big brother was supposed to be an exercise in what &quot;not to do&quot; or am I thinking wrongly? Instead, these people are using it as a playbook of what to do next.<p>The HN crowd will not really understand how &quot;misuse of social media&quot; means criticism of government that has landed thousands in jail with no recourse. You are treated the same as a terrorist who might have blown a plane or committed mass murder or a rapist.<p>I have always tried use a different handle online, avoid services that require a phone number, I dont post my photo or have a YouTube channel &#x2F; whatsapp&#x2F;telegram.<p>Just the day before, in a crowded street in the middle of a city capital with a population of 1 mil+, the army organised a sudden &quot;cordon&quot; when EVERY CIVILIAN was forced to stand in a queue, remove any &quot;traditional winter clothing&quot; that might hide a weapon and stand in line for over 2 hours while each person was frisked and made to prove their identity (ID cards, etc) while the whole thing was recorded by them.<p>Whatsapp&#x2F;Facebook Admins are ordered to report to the police to get their groups &quot;registered&quot; or else face criminal prosecution.<p>I dont want sympathies. No kashmiri does. Just the idea that the attrocities committed by India and Pakistan need to be put out and known because these people sugarcoat their versions so brilliantly.<p>I have a cartoonist friend who is regularly banned from social media because pages get &quot;forced to delete content&quot; and all because he draws stuff critical of government.<p>I see no light at the end of the tunnel for India or Pakistan also for that matter. They simply have dug their own graves
jgjot-singh大约 4 年前
The context and timing of this is what matters.<p>India is currently hosting the largest protest in human history. It was sparked by three ordinances which sought to regulate farming, by re-structuring how farmers may grow and sell their crops. The bills were passed with such haste and indifference towards the sentiments of opposing members in parliament, that something seemed very off right from the start.<p>And then farmers in Punjab began to accuse the government of siding with corporate interests (namely two billionaires, Adani and Ambani, and their various companies) and handing over an already exploited agricultural market to the corporate sector to be further exploited for profit. It was at this point, when after two months of heavy protests in Punjab, which the government did not directly respond to, and carried on non-chalantly with propaganda creation, that the anger began to spill over, and farmers began marching towards the capital, Delhi, forcing a reaction from the government.<p>That forced exchange between the farmers and government has led to a fascinating turn of events.<p>On one side, the farmers who have not even had a unified voice within India, let alone internationally, have gradually been given international attention and platforms to openly express themselves via social media.<p>On the other side, the Modi administration, which has far reaching influence and connections, while being directly called out to respond to the very valid points raised against them, chose to go with a strategy of playing ignorant and deflection, all the while ramping up propaganda to malign their accusers.<p>The main problem faced by the government is that while they keep trying to pin distinct groups as being a rogue anti-national &#x27;elements&#x27; who have sparked protests for their own benefits, the protest sites have only kept on increasing in numbers as well as in diversity, rendering the government narrative as more and more disconnected over time.<p>And all of this has been continously documented by an impressive counter-movement to pro govt media, made up of daring freelance journalists using social media, many of whom have been arrested and detained without cause.<p>So while Indian democracy is being exposed, the Modi administration, despite mass protests spreading across the country, has only continued to pump out the same forms of propaganda and divisive speeches which have grown rather stale with Indians.<p>I&#x27;ve been paying close attention to the situation since late November, and it&#x27;s been fascinating to see how Delhi&#x27;s IT cell has been working in overdrive to restore trust in government sources of information by any means, resorting to anything from spamming flat out lies, to publishing photoshopped imagery, to mass reporting activist Twitter accounts to get them banned.<p>And all the while, on-the-ground social media journalism continues gain more and more public trust, eroding away the need for conventional sources of information.<p>The public&#x27;s trust in pro government media outlets has gradually degraded to the point where reporters of those networks are being quizzed and questioned by citizens on sight regarding the ongoing protests, thereby completely nullifying the network&#x27;s freedom to create and influence narratives in the ways they would like to (and have been used to).<p>Their reporters are also being heckled and harassed, and one reporter for Zee news (one of the biggest news stations) actually ended up quitting while live on the air, after protesters began to question whether his loyalty lay with the government or the people of India.<p>I think the current situation in India is testament to the idea that the so called information age may have run it&#x27;s course, and we are now entering into an era where information is so abundant that the demand is centered around the quality of information and it&#x27;s relativity to our own experienced reality, rather than perceived, because our perception can and has been influenced,through brute force if nothing else, to our own detriment.<p>So now the trustworthiness of a particular source of information is becoming far more important than the quantity of information provided by it.
评论 #26261921 未加载
评论 #26261126 未加载
bobbydreamer大约 4 年前
30-40 yrs back in south india, there used to be newspapers and weekly magazines talking about politics without saying who they were talking about like the name wouldnt be mentioned but there would be a little clue, they won&#x27;t even mention is it a local issue or state or nation or world. The readers who were buying these magazines on weekly basis knows who they were refering to. Things were pretty much cryptic. We are reading everything in tech. A simple daily changing ceasars crypt would confuse people. I think that&#x27;s gonna happen soon.
infinite_beam大约 4 年前
pertinent news article : <a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;thewire.in&#x2F;rights&#x2F;cyber-whispers-home-ministry-volunteer-programme-surveillance-internet-right" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;thewire.in&#x2F;rights&#x2F;cyber-whispers-home-ministry-volun...</a>
评论 #26260590 未加载