TE
科技回声
首页24小时热榜最新最佳问答展示工作
GitHubTwitter
首页

科技回声

基于 Next.js 构建的科技新闻平台,提供全球科技新闻和讨论内容。

GitHubTwitter

首页

首页最新最佳问答展示工作

资源链接

HackerNews API原版 HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 科技回声. 版权所有。

Ontario teachers' unions slam province for considering permanent online learning

34 点作者 AndrewBissell大约 4 年前

5 条评论

ipaddr大约 4 年前
The union is afraid of losing jobs. For the 30% doing better removing the choice will reduce their chance of success. Many kids did better without the distractions of the hallway rat race.<p>It could cost some teacher jobs in time if the best teacher and course becomes standard and broadcast to all.<p>What we are not talking about is the online model. The one used during covid where the teacher acted like a babysister and made sure she could see all eyes on all cameras for 6 hours a day needs to be examined. The lessons learned for many successful homeschooling families is structure and schedule should be flexible. We tried to import the best 1900 offered on how to structure a classroom to a group of 2100 century kids and wondered why they weren&#x27;t engaged staring at their teacher through zoom. It is not like we weren&#x27;t asking why kids are not as engaged in the classroom before covid. We had a huge rise in add.<p>The answer for many kids is going to be online education with the missing experiencial component where learning involves exploring, knowledge driven education. We need different types of teachers who will challenge students outside of the classroom. We need flexible local groups of students who can socialize and learn and explore together.<p>One size can&#x27;t fit all anymore.
评论 #27107247 未加载
client4大约 4 年前
I&#x27;d argue it&#x27;s reasonable for core concepts to be taught online, but things like etiquette, social interaction, etc. slbe taught in person. For instance this allows kids sitting next to each other to learn different levels of math according to their ability, and then go tag with their buddies.
评论 #27093776 未加载
评论 #27093573 未加载
评论 #27093606 未加载
评论 #27094883 未加载
评论 #27093664 未加载
Aerroon大约 4 年前
I&#x27;ve been occasionally tutoring my nephew for the past few years. Based on that I&#x27;m pretty skeptical of online learning for kids.<p>A lot of exercises and tasks are never done, because it&#x27;s much easier to pretend that you&#x27;re studying online than it is in person. It leads to less experience with the exercises. This isn&#x27;t all that bad in subjects like History or Literature, because if you miss out on ancient Rome then you simply don&#x27;t know about ancient Rome. However if you miss out on mathematics or chemistry, then it&#x27;s going to affect you down the line. What you learn a year from now is most likely built upon what you&#x27;re learning today. It makes learning future topics harder.<p>Online learning for kids might work, but I think it needs to come with a change of teaching materials. Printed out workbooks and exercises from textbooks written into your notebooks don&#x27;t work well with online learning. Teachers don&#x27;t really have a good way of getting kids to consistently do the exercises they need to do. Teachers only have so much time.<p>I&#x27;m not in Canada though. Perhaps the situation is better over there.
latch大约 4 年前
As it&#x27;s described in the article, neither side is presenting a compelling case. The government isn&#x27;t saying what problem it&#x27;s trying to solve, the teacher&#x27;s union isn&#x27;t saying why it&#x27;s bad (1).<p>I went through the Ontario school system, and I hated it. Unless it has changed drastically, high school seemed particularly ineffective, being both too broad and aimed at post-secondary university-level education. Of note was the lack of education for skilled workers, which, predictably, there&#x27;s a shortage of now. I went through the 5 year program, which was particularly awful (decades ago they aligned it with (all?) other provinces and made it 4 years).<p>Personalized education through technology, at least as a supplement to on-site education, is already here. Ensuring that all children have access to it, by making it government funded, seems like an awful thing to be up and arms about.<p>(1) They do claim that this will be a problem because of the digital divide, but the gap between poor and rich students (putting it simply) is well known, and growing, so how exactly would this make it worse?
评论 #27093802 未加载
wizzard大约 4 年前
By cutting &quot;option&quot; off of the end of the title you have made this sound more alarmist.
评论 #27098447 未加载