TE
科技回声
首页24小时热榜最新最佳问答展示工作
GitHubTwitter
首页

科技回声

基于 Next.js 构建的科技新闻平台,提供全球科技新闻和讨论内容。

GitHubTwitter

首页

首页最新最佳问答展示工作

资源链接

HackerNews API原版 HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 科技回声. 版权所有。

Is natural immunity stronger than vaccinated immunity?

15 点作者 loveistheanswer大约 4 年前
According to the data[1], which is of course limited like all the data on covid, there has only been 72 cases of confirmed reinfection out of more than 150,000,000 infections across the world.<p>Meanwhile, in the US, there has been thousands of break through cases of fully vaccinated people in a much shorter time scale.<p>Why are so many scientists and doctors asserting, or implying that vaccine immunity is stronger and longer lasting than natural immunity when the data indicates otherwise?<p>Note: this is a genuine question and I&#x27;d be more than happy for someone to point out what I seem to be missing. Please do not shame me or attack me, thank you.<p>[1]https:&#x2F;&#x2F;bnonews.com&#x2F;index.php&#x2F;2020&#x2F;08&#x2F;covid-19-reinfection-tracker&#x2F;

6 条评论

bart_spoon大约 4 年前
There are a few issues here. First note more importantly note that the barrier for &quot;confirmed reinfection&quot; here is far, far more strict here than the barrier for &quot;confirmed cases in vaccinated individuals&quot;.<p>A &quot;confirmed reinfection&quot; for someone who previously had Covid requires them to have gotten sick, tested positive, have the virus sequenced, then later get sick, test positive, get the virus sequenced again, and have the sequences demonstrate that the infections were caused by distinct virus variants. This is because it is often impossible to tell if someone who appears to be reinfected is suffering from a relapse but never cleared the virus, is suffering from &quot;long Covid&quot;, or otherwise falsely tested negative without fully recovering. The number of suspected reinfections is orders of magnitude higher than 72, simply because we don&#x27;t sequence most positive cases, and even if we did, the chance of being infected by different variants is relatively low. Even in your tracker, it has a &quot;suspected cases&quot; for reinfections at nearly 40,000, which is likely a large estimate simply based on reporting gaps.<p>On the other hand, to be confirmed as a case after vaccination, you simply have to have been vaccinated, and then test positive. The bar here is far lower, so of course there will be more observed cases.<p>Lastly, immunity isn&#x27;t some black box. We understand many of the biological components involved in how the immune system fights infection, in the form of IgA antibodies, IgG antibodies, T-cells, B-cells, etc. There have been numerous studies done over the last 6 months demonstrating that the presence of these immunity components is far higher for vaccinated individuals than those who simply have natural immunity.
评论 #27111332 未加载
dm03514大约 4 年前
<a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.medpagetoday.com&#x2F;blogs&#x2F;marty-makary&#x2F;92434" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.medpagetoday.com&#x2F;blogs&#x2F;marty-makary&#x2F;92434</a>
sloaken大约 4 年前
In most cases I would agree. But that is just my opinion. It gets down to the numbers. How much immunity is given by a given vaccine, verses how possible is it to be re infected with the disease naturally.<p>For myself, I do not expect the flu shot to keep me from getting the flu, I only expect it to make it less sever. Without a shot I am usually down for a solid 2 weeks, because of side effect. With a shot it is usually no more than 3 days. Typically these days I get 2 flu shots, and have rarely had the flu.<p>Once I have the flu in a session I do not ever recall getting it again. I would say about half the time I get a flu shot I catch the flu.<p>What will be interesting in the end is weather a particular vaccine protects against the variants of COVID better than having had the actual bug. And if having a particular variant, protects you against more variants.
giantg2大约 4 年前
The vaccines are not designed, nor claimed, to offer immunity. The effectiveness of these vaccines are measured based on their prevention of severe symptoms. That number is about 91%, give or take 5% based on specific vaccine.
phreeza大约 4 年前
&gt; Why are so many scientists and doctors asserting, or implying that vaccine immunity is stronger and longer lasting than natural immunity when the data indicates otherwise?<p>Do they? I don&#x27;t think I have ever heard this claim.
jimy990大约 4 年前
natural immunity is always a prove to the first line of defense against diseases.