TE
科技回声
首页24小时热榜最新最佳问答展示工作
GitHubTwitter
首页

科技回声

基于 Next.js 构建的科技新闻平台,提供全球科技新闻和讨论内容。

GitHubTwitter

首页

首页最新最佳问答展示工作

资源链接

HackerNews API原版 HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 科技回声. 版权所有。

Ask HN: Mechanic on-demand to evaluate a used car

5 点作者 edgefield将近 4 年前
Would you pay $125 to have a professional and certified mechanic evaluate a used car on-site with or without you present?<p>This would be a substitute for bringing a used car to a repair shop for a pre-sale inspection and would allow you to consider cars beyond your local area.<p>Thanks in advance for any feedback!

5 条评论

Dah00n将近 4 年前
I&#x27;m not from the US but I have used kinda similar services before. Two kinds somewhat similar:<p>One is a service where the seller delivers all their cars to a local vehicle inspection service that goes through a checklist and any later faults in a part that was tested is under extended warranty. I&#x27;m not much of a fan since who the customer of the vehicle inspection site is can be argued both ways.<p>The other service is where the car gets delivered by the seller to a vehicle inspection site that is owned by a motoring association that the buyer is a member of (like ADAC in Germany for example). This service I have a high amount of trust in since they are &quot;on my side&quot;, paid by me and will sometimes take dealers that misbehave to court (sort of like the EFF).<p>A service somewhere in the middle of these two I&#x27;m not sure I would trust. If I hire a local mechanic to look at a car for me how do I know he doesn&#x27;t have a deal with the local seller? If he doesn&#x27;t spot a fault will he pay to fix it when it breaks? if not, what am I buying?<p>In short: No, I would not use such a service unless it is backed by a trustworthy motoring association that is squarely on my side and who will go to court for or with me if needed.
LinuxBender将近 4 年前
If this mechanic is getting video from inside the cylinders with a borescope, doing compression tests on all cylinders, pulling diagnostics from the OBD interface, checking seals and joints, checking that emissions would pass in my state <i>at least via OBD</i> and signing their name on a form then I certainly would. ... especially on cars that pulling the plugs requires removing the fuel rails. I would also expect them to take it for a rough ride and see how it handles. Avoiding traveling cross country just to find that the vehicle is a pile of junk is worth much more than $125 in my opinion, assuming this system can&#x27;t be gamed and assuming they are doing the above checks.
injb将近 4 年前
People do this all the time. There are companies that specialize in it. I&#x27;ve often had cars inspected remotely, but always by having the seller bring it to a specialist shop.<p>My experience with this kind of thing has been that it&#x27;s hit and miss. It all depends on the person doing the inspection. Are you trying to do this as a startup? If I was convinced that the person really knew what they were doing, took lots of great pictures, scanned codes (including manufacturer specific codes), checked every panel with a paint meter etc. then I&#x27;d use it.
PragmaticPulp将近 4 年前
No, because on-site evaluations without access to a lift or all of the shop&#x27;s tools aren&#x27;t very thorough. It amounts to a visual inspection, which I can do myself.<p>It might be useful if I&#x27;m buying a car remotely and I need someone on the ground to look at it, though.
zeeshanqureshi将近 4 年前
I&#x27;m not sure if I&#x27;m the right audience&#x2F;user to answer your question but here&#x27;s an offshoot thought: Wouldn&#x27;t there be some value in building something like what you are suggesting but for electric vehicles only?