TE
科技回声
首页24小时热榜最新最佳问答展示工作
GitHubTwitter
首页

科技回声

基于 Next.js 构建的科技新闻平台,提供全球科技新闻和讨论内容。

GitHubTwitter

首页

首页最新最佳问答展示工作

资源链接

HackerNews API原版 HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 科技回声. 版权所有。

Radio was the original overhyped technology

31 点作者 maguay将近 4 年前

11 条评论

ZeroGravitas将近 4 年前
I&#x27;m a bit confused by this piece.<p>A lot of it echoes the book &quot;The Victorian Internet&quot; that digs up historical nuggets from the early days of the telegraph that sound like the birth of the internet. (e.g. people running away and marrying people they fell in love with even though they&#x27;d only ever had text&#x2F;Morse communication with them)<p>But it seems that they&#x27;re interpreting &quot;radio&quot; in the modern sense, and so not counting TV, mobile phones, Bluetooth, WiFi, wireless charging etc. which the originators may not have guessed at, but wouldn&#x27;t have abitrarily placed a boundary on their hopes based on categories not yet invented. Radio, in that bigger sense is a very vital thing, even if it&#x27;s &quot;normal&quot; to most of us.
评论 #28072857 未加载
评论 #28072927 未加载
garyrob将近 4 年前
I&#x27;m 65. When I was a kid I built a crystal radio, which inspired my grandfather to tell me about the early days of radio. He said he and his friends used to compete with each other to build radios that could receive stations from the farthest away. It was a real hacker culture!
评论 #28073875 未加载
评论 #28072654 未加载
评论 #28072836 未加载
gumby将近 4 年前
A lovely concrete expression of this phenomenon: a popular toy wagon from the 1920s (still sold today) is called the ”radio flyer”. It is a red wagon with big rubber wheels and was so popular that a red wagon in its shape became the canonical or generic image for such a toy.<p>“Radio” was so modern and so exciting (as was the idea of flight) that its name was used talismanically as were “cyber” or “iXXX” a couple of decades ago. I mean, I can understand why zooming down a hill might make a kid think of flying, but radio? Simply modern and cool.<p>Same reason for the name “Motorola” — radios in cars is super cool.
评论 #28081581 未加载
caslon将近 4 年前
Radio wasn&#x27;t overhyped, it was overlegislated. We aren&#x27;t allowed to use a <i>lot</i> of the spectrum, and what little we as citizens are allowed we are unable to secure. Radio was legislated into uselessness. We could have had a lot more a lot faster if we were able to make use of it.
评论 #28072995 未加载
评论 #28073752 未加载
评论 #28072804 未加载
评论 #28072973 未加载
tuukkah将近 4 年前
&quot;Radio? Like 5G but less bandwidth, like TV but just sound.&quot; It lives on in (almost) all the wireless communication technologies of today, and broadcast radio channels as a cultural and business phenomenon have just added a video stream, the signal may be digital and relayed by satellites or over the internet. If there was hype about either of the two, it was unrealism about how long it would take for some of the applications to become mainstream.
评论 #28072865 未加载
aurizon将近 4 年前
Radio was initially fairly cumbersome, so in WW1 it was restricted but was not a long range threat - still all of Europe feared the spy sending data to another spy in another country After WW1 Europe stayed locked down with draconian laws limiting private radios. At this time they relied on fenced borders - radio made them crap their pants. They had a Spy-Vs-Spy mind set, still it was manageable, long range stuff was large in terms of antennas etc. The USA relied in the Atlantic ocean - small transmitters did not have the range and large ones were easy to find and hard to hide. The net USA result was radio amateurs, crystal sets etc were not limited apart from the licence. So radio grew enormously in the USA, thousands of independent radio stations and millions of radio receivers. In Europe radio transmitters were government owned, BBC etc, so it grew a little but nothing like the USA. Rest of Europe more or less similar. By 1939 = WW2 all in europe were in the middle ages, more or less, in terms of radio at all levels. At universities etc, research took place, but wide dissemination and adoption was interdicted by this oppressive milieu. Thus the USA gained on the UK&#x2F;Europe after WW1 and by the time WW2 happened it was far ahead. During WW2 radio was locked down again, but the USA has by far the largest pool of amateur radio people - who all knew Morse Code.
simonblack将近 4 年前
<i>13 days later, the illusion shattered, as a German U-boat’s torpedo sank the Lusitania and brought America into the war.</i><p>Not quite correct. There was such a thing as &#x27;The Zimmerman Telegram&#x27;.<p>There were two years (half the length of WW1) between the sinking of the Lusitania in 1915 and the US declaration of war in 1917.
antisol将近 4 年前
I might have read this article. The only thing stopping me was:<p>blockquote { margin-left: -10%; }
nabla9将近 4 年前
It was not overhyped. Radio was incredibly important.<p>All those worries mentioned in the article were correct and actualized. The switch into radio was bigger change than moving to TV later.<p>Every coup, takeover or occupation started with gaining control of radio stations. Stalin was obsessed with radio.<p>Radio was central medium of informing, coordinating, controlling and influencing people. Orson Welles&#x27;s War of the Worlds Radio Broadcast caused widespread panic.
评论 #28074029 未加载
aaron695将近 4 年前
&quot;Radio was the original overhyped technology&quot;<p><i>What?</i><p>&gt; Fake news became the new worry. .... wrote National Broadcasting Co.’s Dr. James Angell in 1939.<p>Nazi&#x27;s used radio successfully, they created cheap radios to do it - <a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;daily.jstor.org&#x2F;an-affordable-radio-brought-nazi-propaganda-home&#x2F;" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;daily.jstor.org&#x2F;an-affordable-radio-brought-nazi-pro...</a><p>Rwanda and the extermination of &#x27;cockroaches&#x27; on RTLM in 1994<p>Radio literally raised our IQs, I don&#x27;t mean educated us, it changed the structure of our brains. (It also educated us)<p>For the rich it moved to TV, but for the poor it&#x27;s only the internet that might replace radios power.<p>As a side note, the radio guided ship was about torpedoes, which actually never happened, it was developed in WW2 but not used, it went to wires which is interesting. But radio controlled bombs where used in WW2 which is pretty close to a torpedo.
seddin将近 4 年前
Why reading this post felt so weird? Like it was written by some AI.