TE
科技回声
首页24小时热榜最新最佳问答展示工作
GitHubTwitter
首页

科技回声

基于 Next.js 构建的科技新闻平台,提供全球科技新闻和讨论内容。

GitHubTwitter

首页

首页最新最佳问答展示工作

资源链接

HackerNews API原版 HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 科技回声. 版权所有。

We don’t need nearly as much protein as we consume

56 点作者 hiddencache超过 3 年前

15 条评论

wombatmobile超过 3 年前
TFA curiously asks questions about what the body really needs, in order to investigate a processed food category from an industry that spends billions on advertising and technology designed to make people eat more than they need for only one reason - to generate profits for manufacturers.<p>What the body really needs is not processed foods, which are loaded with salt, sugar, and fat [0, 1]. Processed foods are what the world&#x27;s largest food corporations need you to buy in order to generate profits that feed their businesses.<p>What the body needs is fresh foods - fruits, vegetables, grains, pulses, nuts and meat.<p>[0] <a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.penguin.com.au&#x2F;books&#x2F;salt-sugar-fat-9781448133871" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.penguin.com.au&#x2F;books&#x2F;salt-sugar-fat-978144813387...</a><p>[1] <a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.youtube.com&#x2F;watch?v=eATmXufOvIk" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.youtube.com&#x2F;watch?v=eATmXufOvIk</a>
评论 #28433636 未加载
评论 #28433614 未加载
评论 #28433606 未加载
yawaworht1978超过 3 年前
Required Protein intake depends on many other factors. Carbs are protein preserving. If someone does a lot of weight lifting and or really hard cardio and is on a low carb diet, they will have an elevated protein requirement, else the body will simply consume its own proteins, aka muscle and tendon tissue, you don&#x27;t want that. For the average Joe with a sitting job and zero sports activity and a regular no care diet, yeah, they don&#x27;t need 2lbs of red meat every other day.<p>But protein is the macro nutritient which is least likely to get you fat, too much fat, you will gain fat if you don&#x27;t work out and are in a calorie surplus, same for carbs. Too much protein is hard to achieve consistently and will give you flatulence, but not much else.<p>Too many scenarios and factors to sum up all in a one size fits all statement.<p>If someone is trying to lose weight, protein intake should be bit higher, to preserve the muscle tissue.
评论 #28433513 未加载
评论 #28433529 未加载
评论 #28433483 未加载
评论 #28433538 未加载
briga超过 3 年前
Maybe not to lose weight, but as far as I know the primary goal of most people who take protein supplements is to gain muscle. From my understanding this is literally impossible if you don&#x27;t consume enough protein. So the question of how much should you be consuming based really depends on your training level, goals, diet, etc.<p>&gt; A 2014 analysis of 36 papers found that protein supplements have no impact on lean mass and muscle strength during the first few weeks of resistance training in untrained individuals.<p>Seems like any difference you would see with a couple few weeks of training would be a rounding error? In my experience, any noticeable differences in muscle mass require months of training.
评论 #28433448 未加载
strken超过 3 年前
I was reading <a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;mennohenselmans.com&#x2F;protein-is-not-more-satiating-than-carbs-and-fats&#x2F;" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;mennohenselmans.com&#x2F;protein-is-not-more-satiating-th...</a> yesterday, trying to understand the role of protein in satiation.<p>It makes the case that roughly 15% of calories is what we should be eating, which is the proportion in the average diet. The basis for this is the protein leverage hypothesis, which states that when protein falls below roughly 15% of our diet, we overeat to compensate. 15% of daily calories corresponds to 1.2g&#x2F;kg&#x2F;d, substantially more than the suggested 0.75g&#x2F;kg&#x2F;d from the BBC article.<p>I&#x27;m not sure that it&#x27;s correct to say we eat too much protein for our level of exercise. It seems like it might be more accurate to say we exercise too little for our natural level of protein consumption.
lambdaba超过 3 年前
This isn&#x27;t really about protein, just how ultra-processed, high-carb candy bars are masquerading as protein. Good quality protein is necessary and healthy, and as we age we actually need more of it, not less.
评论 #28433374 未加载
评论 #28433402 未加载
评论 #28433460 未加载
kortex超过 3 年前
&gt; Fortunately, it’s difficult to have too much protein. While we do have an upper limit of protein intake, it’s “virtually impossible” to reach, says Tipton. “There are concerns among some dieticians that a high protein diet can hurt the kidneys and bones, but evidence in otherwise healthy people is minimal.<p>That&#x27;s all I really need to know. Of the big 3 macros, I &quot;trust&quot; carbs the least, then fat, then protein. There&#x27;s bad carbs - sugars and simple starches, and bad fats - trans fats and long saturated fats, with cholesterol being iffy, but are there &quot;bad proteins&quot; outside of their associated fats?
评论 #28433803 未加载
Ambolia超过 3 年前
I wouldn&#x27;t trust mainstream nutrition advice coming out from any country with a &gt;20% obesity rate. So maybe from Japan, China, Thailand, Indonesia or Buthan. But not from the UK.
评论 #28433992 未加载
评论 #28433977 未加载
mattgreenrocks超过 3 年前
I&#x27;ve always eaten a lot of meat, and had cognitive dissonance about headlines like this. If I didn&#x27;t eat much meat in a given day, I&#x27;d just feel like garbage. When I did keto, it wasn&#x27;t a super difficult adjustment for me after the first week (which sucks for almost everyone). It felt closer to how I always wanted to be, to be honest, though I think keto is a little too into fat.<p>Well, I learned recently I have low B12 levels via a blood test. B12 is found in meats, fish, and dairy. We&#x27;ll see if supplementation reduces my carnivore desires.<p>Just a single data point but it seemed salient for the discussion.
bobobob420超过 3 年前
I agree with this article. As someone who has been weightlifting since I was in high school, most people are obsessed with protein for the wrong reasons. The truth is you only need to eat slightly above normal protein intake, and the part most people don’t understand is you need to increase carbs for muscle growth. Without the increase in carbs you will not be able to put on a large mass of muscles.
the-dude超过 3 年前
You don&#x27;t need nearly as much nutritional advice as we publish. But hey, <i>clicks</i>.
kvgr超过 3 年前
Protein bars are bullcrap, but try to write somewhere that you should eat protein equivalent of 0.5kg of meat to maximize our muscle potential.
Darmody超过 3 年前
I have tried different diets. Nutrient dense carbohydrates, healthy fats and high protein works the best for me.<p>According to some studies I should be fat or my muscles would grow as if I Was eating half the protein which is not the case.
adflux超过 3 年前
So I thought carbs were bad? Oh no, it was fat right? Or sugar, or meat, or...<p>This article is a convoluted joke, just like the rest of the nutritional science field. In few other fields can you find so many contradictory theories. Mainly due to the poor research methodologies.
评论 #28433373 未加载
评论 #28433421 未加载
geofft超过 3 年前
These two paragraphs are very confusing:<p>&gt; <i>In the early 20th Century, Arctic explorer Vilhjalmur Stefansson spent a collective five years eating just meat. This meant that his diet consisted of around 80% fat and 20% protein. Twenty years later, he did the same as part of a year-long experiment at the New York City’s Bellevue Hospital in 1928.</i><p>&gt; <i>Stefansson wanted to disprove those who argued that humans cannot survive if they only eat meat. But unfortunately for him, in both settings he very quickly became ill when he was eating lean meats without any fat. He developed &quot;protein poisoning”, nicknamed “rabbit starvation”. His symptoms disappeared after he lowered his protein intake and he raised his fat intake. In fact, after returning to New York City and to a typical US diet with more normal levels of protein, he reportedly found his health deteriorating and returned to a low-carb, high fat, and high protein diet until his death aged 83.</i><p>This doesn&#x27;t seem like an anecdote about <i>too much protein</i>, it seems like an anecdote about <i>too little fat</i>. Wikipedia&#x27;s article <a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;en.wikipedia.org&#x2F;wiki&#x2F;Protein_poisoning" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;en.wikipedia.org&#x2F;wiki&#x2F;Protein_poisoning</a> confirms that this is the right interpretation, and mentions (as this article does, later) that there is no point at which you can get poisoned by too much protein consumption, as long as you are also consuming enough fat.<p>Wikipedia goes into more detail about the experiment at Bellevue. The two types of diets he was on were a) all meat, with fat and b) all lean meat (analogous to eating solely rabbits, which are naturally lean and have little fat, hence the name). Diet A was fine; diet B was not.<p>The article&#x27;s phrasing &quot;a typical US diet with more normal levels of protein&quot; implies that the levels were <i>higher</i> than his previous diet, which caused him problems again. It seems pretty implausible for the standard US diet of the &#x27;20s and &#x27;30s to be higher-protein than either of these all-meat diets! And the article does mention he returned to a &quot;high protein&quot; diet. It seems like the more reasonable reading is that the important part was that his diet was &quot;low-carb, high fat,&quot; which the typical US diet was and is not.
throwaway59553超过 3 年前
How is the title accurate, when in the middle of the article there&#x27;s this:<p>&quot;Most experts agree with Tipton that protein is best consumed in food instead of supplements. But there are some exceptions, such as athletes who find it difficult to hit their daily protein targets, points out Graeme Close, professor of human physiology at Liverpool John Moores University. “I believe most need more than the recommended daily allowance, and there’s good evidence to support this,” he says. In this case, he says, a shake can be useful.<p>Another demographic who can benefit from extra protein? The elderly. That’s because as we age, we need more protein to retain muscle mass. But we also tend to eat less protein as we get older because our taste-buds begin to prefer sweet over savoury.&quot;<p>In my opinion there is no such thing as too much protein. You should have an estimate of how much calories you burn each day and eat accordingly. Supplements, like shakes, are just easier to consume since they&#x27;re liquids, and some people have low appetite.<p>Most people should eat more protein and vegetables, but ditch any refined sugars, oils, processed food, and cook their meals instead of eating garbage snacks.
评论 #28433453 未加载