TE
科技回声
首页24小时热榜最新最佳问答展示工作
GitHubTwitter
首页

科技回声

基于 Next.js 构建的科技新闻平台,提供全球科技新闻和讨论内容。

GitHubTwitter

首页

首页最新最佳问答展示工作

资源链接

HackerNews API原版 HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 科技回声. 版权所有。

Cryptocurrency is akin to ‘Ponzi scheme’

39 点作者 SquibblesRedux大约 3 年前

9 条评论

spaceisballer大约 3 年前
It’s more of a greater fool scheme or basically a MLM. You need people to buy in to raise the value, then get all these people hyping it etc etc. NFTs seem to have perfected what crypto started, give you FOMO and make you buy overvalued 0s and 1s.<p>I think crypto is deplorable purely on the amount of electricity it consumes. It’s pretty clear it offers a solution to a problem that doesn’t exist, unless that problem all along was give a subset of tech people a way to get rich off fools.
评论 #30372830 未加载
评论 #30368199 未加载
评论 #30368215 未加载
评论 #30368356 未加载
评论 #30368701 未加载
harry8大约 3 年前
A good way of thinking about such arguments to get you some new insight into your own thinking about it is:<p>&quot;How does this argument about BTC[1] apply to gold?&quot;<p>Eg is gold a ponzi scheme? &quot;Dug up, refined, buried again somewhere like fort knox with a very small use other than as a store of value. (eg some electronics). Whether you decide yes it&#x27;s ponzi or no it&#x27;s not, then look at what other difference there is or isn&#x27;t between gold and btc to justify the conclusion if that conclusion differs.<p>Or maybe like me you still haven&#x27;t reached any conclusion about crypto-currencies beyond noting there are a lot of hucksters out there - just like in any goldrush.<p>[1] yes you can use some other cryptocurrency as your example and some other precious metal or stone such as diamonds or whatever if that is more useful to your thinking.
评论 #30376314 未加载
评论 #30368228 未加载
themodelplumber大约 3 年前
&gt; they have no intrinsic value<p>It&#x27;s funny how much weight is placed on this word &quot;intrinsic&quot;, as if we need to penetrate down to some singular identity layer of a thing to be comfortable assigning it value as a store of anything.<p>Exactly what that layer is supposed to look like is always somehow described with gobs of words that easily map onto other things that people have already valued for millenia.<p>You might as well just ask, &quot;is it popular with some people&quot;? If the answer is yes, it&#x27;s probably a carrier of human interest to some degree, regardless of whatever snooty value systems may be applied to that, so you can likely buy it low and sell it high with a slightly-educated squint at a moving average chart.<p>(I noticed that people really like to think they are good at assigning value to things, so perhaps this comes down to some core human fear...certainly the typical concern about future outcomes also applies, in which we learn that people have apparently never heard of contingency planning and calculated risk...both of which may be even more useful than intrinsic-whatever subjectivity)
评论 #30368913 未加载
评论 #30367620 未加载
trixie_大约 3 年前
Please understand what a Ponzi scheme is.<p>A Ponzi scheme is where the con artist tricks you into thinking you bought an asset when really they just pocketed most of the money, giving you back a little bit and calling an &#x27;investment return&#x27;<p>No matter whether you think Bitcoin has real &#x27;value&#x27; or not, that has nothing to do with a ponzi scheme. You can buy Bitcoin and hold it yourself without a middle man.<p>It&#x27;s no different than holding stocks or gold, you can buy&#x2F;sell the full asset at anytime. There&#x27;s no middle man preventing you from selling the full asset and take &#x27;interest payments&#x27; instead.
评论 #30370106 未加载
ctocoder大约 3 年前
What makes a Ponzi scheme, a scheme is; a guaranteed profit. Crypto profit is not guaranteed at any time, the criteria is not met thus is not a Ponzi scheme.
评论 #30368726 未加载
评论 #30367838 未加载
评论 #30367836 未加载
anm89大约 3 年前
Wow this is a really unique take, good job tech crunch. I&#x27;ve never heard anyone make this claim before.<p>Hey did you guys know one time tulips got really over priced too?
Day1大约 3 年前
1 btc is worth more than a car and people are still calling it a ponzi scheme. I find that very amusing for some reason.
评论 #30368851 未加载
fattybob大约 3 年前
Doesn’t that also apply to most currencies?
tonetheman大约 3 年前
Clearly they meant to say &quot;Cryptocurrency is a Ponzi scheme.&quot;