TE
科技回声
首页24小时热榜最新最佳问答展示工作
GitHubTwitter
首页

科技回声

基于 Next.js 构建的科技新闻平台,提供全球科技新闻和讨论内容。

GitHubTwitter

首页

首页最新最佳问答展示工作

资源链接

HackerNews API原版 HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 科技回声. 版权所有。

Why are there so many bad bosses?

45 点作者 arunmp大约 3 年前

16 条评论

mcv大约 3 年前
The idea of management being the only road for advancement has always seemed extremely self-destructive to me. I recently quit my job as a senior developer at a company because they wouldn&#x27;t even pay me one of the upper pay scales for developers, because a requirement for that was that I&#x27;d have to take some sort of organisational responsibility outside my team. The fact that I did a lot of organisation and steering inside my team, which was considered one of the best performing teams there, didn&#x27;t matter.<p>My dad has also always refused managerial responsibilities, but he was very much appreciated at his company. He said he had nobody below him and only one person above him, and he made more money than his boss (until his boss was replaced and the new boss gave himself a raise so he made more). My dad did get responsibility for all sorts of projects, just not for the people on those projects. And he has always remained very hands-on, sometimes replacing an entire team on his own.<p>It&#x27;s basically what I want, but a lot of companies are apparently structured too rigidly to allow this.
评论 #30554175 未加载
评论 #30555013 未加载
评论 #30556042 未加载
评论 #30554204 未加载
thenerdhead大约 3 年前
I hate to be that guy, but I believe that many line managers &amp; middle managers aren&#x27;t honestly needed in knowledge work at a certain level of self-managing ICs with a common vision. It&#x27;s increasingly rare to find &quot;good&quot; managers among the bad. The good ones tend to find new jobs or get promoted and continue to climb the ladder. The bad ones? They also get promotions to take over the good ones jobs and they stay around forever.<p>They get in the way majority of the time. They try to make decisions for their own self interests rather than empowering their teams to make the best ones possible. They don&#x27;t say no to things, but rather use it as yet another opportunity for a &quot;quick win&quot;. They get offended easily and have fragile egos with blunt feedback. Literally the opposite of every characteristics of a &quot;good manager&quot;.<p>Many people in these roles are classic examples of narcissism and nepotism. Nobody has ever humbled them before or questioned their confidence that can easily be seen as an authority figure in most developer teams. I&#x27;m sad to be saying this, but I don&#x27;t think many developers stand their own ground against these types of people and they should. Teams should be able to vote out their bad managers because it is so apparent on certain teams that there&#x27;s a bad manager.<p>Even with decent managers on a team, you still hardly get anything meaningful done. You can spend years on things that have little to no impact externally, but will be praised internally because of the &quot;hard work&quot; done even at the cost of morale and questioning ICs saying &quot;why are we still doing this?&quot;. Good managers should see through this bullshit and get the team to self-direct course by talking to everyone and getting a sentiment for a new common vision.<p>Bonus: Steve Jobs thinking most managers are bozos - <a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.youtube.com&#x2F;watch?v=rQKis2Cfpeo" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.youtube.com&#x2F;watch?v=rQKis2Cfpeo</a>
评论 #30558845 未加载
评论 #30556857 未加载
karmakaze大约 3 年前
This hits close to home:<p>&gt; JOHNSON: For me, this is where the idea of splitting out those levels of seniority — so maybe you don’t become the manager, but you become a technical expert and you are paid and rewarded for that — is something that helps with the incentives. What I would say on that, though, is often we have this dual-career track of, “Okay, you can be a manager, or you can be a technical specialist.” But even though you might get a quote-unquote promotion and be paid more, the technical specialists still might be excluded from high-level conversations. [...]<p>Being an IC, I usually find out about a technical direction that arose out of management discussions and by the time I hear about it it&#x27;s usually too far along to change course of, and have to watch it play out. At best it&#x27;s a learning experience, that can refine the next attempt. Other times it&#x27;s a rabbit-hole with no light at the end of the tunnel. Fortunately this usually happens on other projects, but sometimes I join a project mid-way and there&#x27;s redesign that happens along the way, or banked for v2. This is a symptom of a top-down style of company management. A more technically managed company with former engineers all the way to the CEO are less likely to be this way. Unfortunately as even those companies grow, and more layers of management are added, not every link in the chains can be so-minded and there&#x27;s a disconnect.
评论 #30556761 未加载
matt_s大约 3 年前
Its because all you hear are the negative stories. As an EM my job is to shield the team from BS, give them what they need to get work done, stay out of their way and not to complain to them either about the BS that is circulating.<p>To an employee, a good manager kinda makes it feel like everything would be fine with the manager not there. And a good team could probably operate without a manager for a while. Until it comes time to write reviews or do other HR related things like filtering resumes, etc.
评论 #30556836 未加载
fargle大约 3 年前
think for a minute: great engineers - i mean really great engineers - how many do you know? it&#x27;s pretty rare right? it&#x27;s an awesome thing and a scarce resource. think about how many you can mention. if you&#x27;ve been around it&#x27;s not zero or one (yes of course you), but a handful. in my case 20-30. i feel lucky to say that.<p>now - how many great engineering managers have you come across? i mean really great, not just OK. not just barely acceptable. great - you&#x27;d want to work for. you&#x27;d quit if they left level great. in my case 2-3.<p>you think engineering is hard? engineering management is the rarest skill there is
评论 #30551839 未加载
评论 #30553726 未加载
评论 #30551325 未加载
badrabbit大约 3 年前
Managers of technical teams should be required to demonstrate a good understanding of what the team does and a good understanding of how similar teams are managed as a matter of best practice. You can&#x27;t do it your own way or according to your fragile personality.<p>Above all else, they must be nice and demonstrate a large capacity for empathy.<p>At the end of the day, their job is to get their team to efficiently get work done. Regardless of method used, fear,micromanagement and threats as a proverbial stick with your salary serving as the carrot, that never works.<p>Anyone can manage, but a good manager must be a leader. They must have the capacity to inspire their workers to want to excel in their work. For certain team types (like retail, manual labor, call centers,etc...) you can get away with a nasty task master yelling &quot;the beatings will continue until morale improves&quot; because your workers perform repetitive and simple tasks with critical thinking and creativity not being part of the job.<p>Lastly, I hope everyone tries to introspect and find out who you are and if you would make a good manager&#x2F;leader. I have, and I am confident I will make a terrible manager (one of the many reasons being I would simply hate it!). I can&#x27;t help thinking with the bad managers I have had to work with: Do they really lack self-awareness that much? Is their management not able to see their mess?<p>A theory I have is: There are two types of manangers, the first type will make excellent top or bottom level management, the second kind are great middle managers. I can&#x27;t help wonder if some of the bad managers I have run into would make good middle managers and they&#x27;re put there until a position opens up or something.
mcntsh大约 3 年前
Since I became an engineering manager myself, I find myself looking back with more sympathy to my past managers. Engineers are difficult people to manage.
评论 #30555883 未加载
评论 #30556590 未加载
评论 #30553599 未加载
mensetmanusman大约 3 年前
Society is still grappling with this new world where being technical and good at it matters as much as, and in many cases, more than knowing people (business) or rules (law).<p>I.e. business&#x2F;law&#x2F;finance used to run the world for centuries, suddenly technology talent is valued, but the old power structure doesn’t know how to keep these people a peg below where they ‘belong’. Spending more money, and being the ‘boss’ of people will be ‘valued’ by the ōld-ˈɡärd more than technology chops for many years to come.<p>Forcing people who want to have more of an impact and be paid more into ‘boss’ like rolls is a causality of this old power structure being challenged.
评论 #30556520 未加载
plumefar大约 3 年前
Maybe the right question is: how do you become a great boss?<p>Getting promoted to an EM position is one thing. Getting good at it is... very hard, and requires new skills. There&#x27;s very little in your day to day job as an engineer that prepares you to become a good EM.<p>One can both be a bad EM and become a good one.<p>The key questions are:<p>- Does the person have a growth mindset?<p>- Is the environment helping the new EM grow?
zcw100大约 3 年前
You&#x27;re asking the wrong question. You should be asking why do I think so many bosses are bad and who are the people who agree or disagree with that assessment. What&#x27;s a bad boss for you might be the perfect boss for someone else and that someone else is probably the person in charge who hired them.<p>It&#x27;s like a prisoner asking, &quot;Why are there so many bad prison guards?. They tell me where to go and what to do. If I get out of line they use increasingly coercive tactics to bring me back into line and if it gets too bad they ostracize me and put me into a box.&quot;<p>That prison guard is probably going to get an award for prison guard of the month and a small bonus. Bad for you, good for someone else.
hyperman1大约 3 年前
Because the feedback loops are broken, is probably part of the answer.<p>A bad engineer simply does not deliver. In a way, the product provides feedback to the engineer by not working.<p>But providing feedback to a bad manager from below rarely ends well. So people work around them.
allisdust大约 3 年前
Because stepping on others to climb the corporate ladder is encouraged in most of the companies. People like that are seen as ambitious, competitive while people who display empathy are seen as weak and unreliable. So at every level the filtering happens to pass up the least empathetic candidate possible. This eventually results in mostly soulless middle management and leadership who continue to hold the same culture together.
eternityforest大约 3 年前
Power tripping money grabbers like... power and money. Bosses have those.<p>Jerks are motivated to climb the ranks and willing to climb over you.
christianvozar大约 3 年前
The Army and Navy also realized specialized, highly-skilled, and educated soldiers were needed. Not to command troops but to fly very expensive machines. They are the Warrant Officers (CO1 -&gt; CW5) and get paid well and the respect of those that command without the burden of commanding large amounts of troops.
badrabbit大约 3 年前
Getting a 502 here. HN hug-of-death?
ukraineally大约 3 年前
&gt;502 Bad Gateway<p>I&#x27;m originally from the Detroit area. Naturally you have lots of factory mentality. Wherein workers will not work unless you&#x27;re standing behind them whipping them. Largely speaking unions got very strong because these middle managers live and die by metrics they themselves dont control and can become brutal to their workers. Like for a long time you couldn&#x27;t go to the washroom while at work. So what would people do? They took a dump right there on the job.<p>Somehow this is how managers are trained; and this is how you&#x27;re expected to operate as a manager. Doesnt matter if you&#x27;re white collar or any other collar. Your manager is expected and actively trained to micromanage you as often as possible. Your manager will come by hourly or so and look at or ask you what you&#x27;re working on. They&#x27;ll often input how you&#x27;re doing it wrong... even if they have absolutely no chance of knowing how to do it properly. The bikeshedding becomes extreme. It mostly demotivates people to be responsible for everything and often 1 person ends up responsible for everything and that person takes all the heat from the manager.