TE
科技回声
首页24小时热榜最新最佳问答展示工作
GitHubTwitter
首页

科技回声

基于 Next.js 构建的科技新闻平台,提供全球科技新闻和讨论内容。

GitHubTwitter

首页

首页最新最佳问答展示工作

资源链接

HackerNews API原版 HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 科技回声. 版权所有。

I am the healthiest person I know, and I got cancer

612 点作者 codetiger大约 3 年前

69 条评论

jll29大约 3 年前
First of all, I&#x27;m sorry to learn the author got cancer; I wish her all the best and continued strength.<p>Many contributors have already made good suggestions how to reduce the risk of getting cancer, or how to deal with it; but I found most posts quite _technical_.<p>Speaking in general terms, cancer is not a disease like a common cold. The human body sooner or later is bound to decay, which pretty much starts once one is fully grown, and mutations get less often corrected by the wonderful repair processes our bodies are equipped with. Occasionally, mutations lead to uncontrolled growth of malign tissue, some incidents of which are bound to lead to death, others not.<p>And while it is absolutely a good idea to life healthily and to take care of one&#x27;s physical and emotional well-being, one should also never deny that we are all mortals, and cancer as well as traditional diseases can and eventually will wipe any individual out. I am at peace with that, for we need to make space for the next generation (only adding people to planet earth would not be sustainable, as resources are scarce - imagine nobody would ever die). Being on this planet for a limited time period makes it more important to make the right choices, because we have only one life.<p>Because it is a statistical process, we can forecast how many are affected, but not which individual, and everyone can try to minimize one&#x27;s chances to be affected, but this does not mean they will live forever. And it&#x27;s not just cancer, there are many ways one may pick the unlucky straw: it is not widely known, but the number of people who die from a heath attack in their 20s is significant. Make the best of every minute you have, and live it as if it were your last.
评论 #30600171 未加载
评论 #30599223 未加载
评论 #30599453 未加载
评论 #30601852 未加载
评论 #30599063 未加载
评论 #30607471 未加载
评论 #30600097 未加载
评论 #30607320 未加载
评论 #30600660 未加载
评论 #30609265 未加载
评论 #30608630 未加载
评论 #30599667 未加载
评论 #30599113 未加载
catchclose8919大约 3 年前
This is one of the things where it matters more <i>how healthy&#x2F;unpolluted your environment is</i>.<p>I&#x27;d dare to say that a not-so-phisically-active moderate-smoker living in a less polluted environment has <i>way lower</i> cancer risk than a bio-vegan athlete buddhist monk living in a polluted industrial hellhole.<p>I&#x27;d wish we lived in a world where we could <i>actually address chemical, air-particulate +&#x2F;- microplastics</i> pollution seriously, and stuff like PFOAs that are still used round, without having it be totally overshadowed and drowned in noise by the &quot;fight climate change&quot; crowd or the &quot;extinction rebellion&quot; nutcases.<p>...like in, I&#x27;d rather have a petrol&#x2F;gas plant to replace a local COAL power plant FAST, than a nuclear alternative that would take 20 years to get funding and have the delayed-as-usual building process finalized. And I&#x27;d rather have all the hydro and windpower we can built asap, and we can figure out later if we really care about the western-golden-lyre-bird or whatever going extinct because of dams or windmills. In the end, tbh, I&#x27;ve come to terms with a +5&#x2F;7 C deg global warming (100y timeframe) happening, but <i>not with me or loved ones dying 20 years earlier of cancer because of chemical and particulate air pollution or god-knows-what from the latest untested and unidentified pan or sportswear coating!</i>
评论 #30598850 未加载
评论 #30599241 未加载
评论 #30598562 未加载
评论 #30598458 未加载
评论 #30598619 未加载
评论 #30598746 未加载
评论 #30598696 未加载
评论 #30600705 未加载
评论 #30599007 未加载
评论 #30598725 未加载
评论 #30600345 未加载
评论 #30600031 未加载
评论 #30601159 未加载
评论 #30602717 未加载
评论 #30599323 未加载
评论 #30598761 未加载
评论 #30600971 未加载
评论 #30601641 未加载
评论 #30598532 未加载
epistasis大约 3 年前
Individually, a person can reduce their cancer risk with a few things like not smoking, and avoiding sunburns, etc. but that does not eliminate the risk of cancer. It&#x27;s not a disease that primarily comes from unhealthy living.<p>That said, there is a toooon of cancer that we can prevent as a society though better public health messaging and better environmental laws, such as creating housing and cities that ban cars, so that we are not continually exposed to pm25 risks.
评论 #30597536 未加载
评论 #30597524 未加载
评论 #30598450 未加载
评论 #30597479 未加载
评论 #30597407 未加载
评论 #30598135 未加载
评论 #30597656 未加载
评论 #30597964 未加载
评论 #30597380 未加载
评论 #30598440 未加载
评论 #30597328 未加载
评论 #30598025 未加载
评论 #30598576 未加载
评论 #30597507 未加载
评论 #30597710 未加载
评论 #30598844 未加载
lars512大约 3 年前
When a cancer like this hits, there&#x27;s a surprising amount of victim-blaming that goes on. People&#x27;s fear of random events like this make them look for reasons why it hit you but could never happen to them, so they scour your personal choices for any sign of recklessness.<p>I love that the author of this kicked it off by saying she&#x27;s the healthiest person she knows. It short-circuits the victim blaming and lets you see it as the unfortunate random event it is.
评论 #30601825 未加载
franciscop大约 3 年前
There is some research that links flight attendants to higher rates of cancer, especially breast cancer and skin cancer:<p><a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.cancer.org&#x2F;latest-news&#x2F;study-examines-cancer-rates-among-flight-attendants.html" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.cancer.org&#x2F;latest-news&#x2F;study-examines-cancer-rat...</a><p>It seems that the title claims this person was healthy, but apparently also in a higher-risk occupation. Cannot say how much the occupation influence things, looking at the article probably very little, but I think it&#x27;s relevant to mention it.
评论 #30597842 未加载
评论 #30603648 未加载
deergomoo大约 3 年前
I was diagnosed with lymphoma at 24. While chemo isn’t fun (and if I ever have another lumbar puncture in my life it’ll be too soon), the mental side was much harder than the physical for me.<p>I needed inpatient treatment, so from probably August until just before Christmas I was mostly in hospital, with the occasional week or two break. By the end I was having people bring me McDonald’s most days, because the idea of another bland hospital meal was incredibly depressing—which sounds silly writing it out, but it really started getting to me.<p>Interrupted sleep and reduced privacy on the ward starts to wear you down too—the times where my immune system was as its lowest and I was moved to private side rooms were actually a big improvement for me, it got lonely but being able to put some music on and having my own bathroom helped a lot.<p>Not sure what my point was with this but 0&#x2F;10 would not recommend.
评论 #30599499 未加载
评论 #30603668 未加载
评论 #30603629 未加载
cracrecry大约 3 年前
In our modern societies there are lots of cancer risk involved that (most) people can not see.<p>For example using a microwave with microscopic cracks in the glass and staying nearby. All the diesel particles and exhaust car fumes and tire dust in the cities. The terrible air quality near maritime ports because of the bad quality ships do with ultra cheap fuels.<p>The extermination of gut microbiota with the use of pesticides and the use of artificial sweeteners.<p>Genetically engineered food that is flooded in pesticides(engineered so the plant can withstand them).<p>The excess use of liquid oils and refined sugars that were never consumed by humans and that are correlated with cancer and cardiovascular disease.<p>The excess use of the fridge and premade foods making essential nutrients go away as the food freezes, so you eat but starve.<p>Contraceptive pills that are hormone bombs in your body.<p>Chemical products like benzene that industries like energy extraction&#x27;s leak on aquifers and Perfluorooctanoic acid you could generate just burning a teflon pan you forget to put oil or butter in(or using the 3d printer with exotic materials).<p>All of those risk can be extreme but most people just can&#x27;t see it. I have seen people burn out a teflon pan and not understand that they have to trow it away immediately. I have seen people handling benzene like water.<p>You can believe that you are eating healthy because you eat lots of vegetables but if those are flooded in pesticides, then it is not so healthy.
评论 #30598275 未加载
评论 #30598703 未加载
评论 #30598332 未加载
评论 #30598351 未加载
评论 #30598349 未加载
评论 #30598344 未加载
评论 #30598290 未加载
评论 #30598535 未加载
评论 #30600164 未加载
评论 #30598390 未加载
评论 #30598336 未加载
评论 #30598346 未加载
评论 #30598316 未加载
lormayna大约 3 年前
As usual correlation don&#x27;t imply causation. My uncle was a professional national level runner, he was the healtier person that I know: he ran several kilometers every day, ate correctly, no drinking, no smoking, sleep at least 8 hours&#x2F;day, etc. He died from cardiovascular problems.<p>This not means that a correct and healty lifestyle is not going to reduce the risk, but it&#x27;s not the only factor.
评论 #30607784 未加载
评论 #30598730 未加载
评论 #30598071 未加载
评论 #30597858 未加载
codetiger大约 3 年前
Found this link on LinkedIn and felt like sharing to more readers. One of the best Cancer stories I read recently. Very informative!
评论 #30597490 未加载
shmde大约 3 年前
Seema is the wife of the founder of one of the biggest online stock brokerage firm called Zerodha.
评论 #30598077 未加载
评论 #30597929 未加载
评论 #30602535 未加载
yon1237大约 3 年前
So many interesting comments around defining a healthy lifestyle. We often look at health in general terms - i.e. how things work on average. This works really well to find generic risk factors, like smoking, excessive drinking, pollution, etc. These things are bad for everyone.<p>Our bodies are super complex and there is huge variability between individuals. We label certain foods with specific as good and bad, but we know that there is large individual variability in the glycemic response to the same foods. So how can we know if we are eating healthy? I think future of health will need to be more individualized - I need to figure out what is healthy for me, and it&#x27;s likely to be different for you.<p>I know there are a wide range of products that try to help with this from DNA testing to glucose monitoring. A lot isn&#x27;t really viable for the masses due to various factors like price, more research needed, etc. But it makes sense to me that if we better understand our individual bodies and take action that we can reduce (but probably not eliminate) certain risks - like cancer, dementia, etc.
AlexAffe大约 3 年前
She mentions a diet rich in Protein. Even Supplements like Whey Protein Shakes. I wonder how that extra growth fuel contributes to cancer cell growth. At the very instance kf cell division, there is a small chance of the cell going &#x27;rogue&#x27;, becoming a cancer cell. In all of our bodies, all of the time. Thankfully the chance is pretty slim, but when I train a lot and eat a lot of protein, then I will have a much higher frequency of cell division. It&#x27;s what I always wonder when I drink my whey protein after workout, being almost 40. Can my body handle all the growth right?
评论 #30598300 未加载
评论 #30598800 未加载
评论 #30598313 未加载
NiceWayToDoIT大约 3 年前
&gt; &quot;All the money in the world can’t buy you perfect health, and it is crazy how many just ignore it. Small changes to diet and physical activity can go a long way in improving health.&quot;<p>This is so confusing for me, with the sense of helplessness, so she saying small change to diet or physical activity, and that she was healthiest person in world but still got sick, so what is the point than ?!<p>I mean you can do everything and still get sick, and some people drink, smoke eat junk food and never get sick, so what gives?<p>I mean more or less it looks like lottery with different probabilities, you can do all good and still pull unlucky card, or you do all bad and you still have health lucky card.<p>I guess, for me most depressing is how little we know about the cancer and things that causing it...
评论 #30598425 未加载
评论 #30598417 未加载
评论 #30598409 未加载
评论 #30598401 未加载
评论 #30598848 未加载
评论 #30598413 未加载
refurb大约 3 年前
I recall a study that estimated ~2&#x2F;3rds of all cancers are due to uncontrollable factors outside of lifestyle choices - genetics, random mutations, etc.
评论 #30597353 未加载
评论 #30597493 未加载
评论 #30597300 未加载
ChrisMarshallNY大约 3 年前
That&#x27;s an inspiring story!<p>I suspect that she&#x27;ll do fine, but she&#x27;s quite young, to have gotten it. When you are young, they tend to treat it quite aggressively.<p>I live on Long Island, NY <i>(AKA &quot;Cancer Central&quot;)</i>. Before I moved up here, I had never known anyone that has had cancer.<p>The last 30 years (since moving up here), I have had at least one friend&#x2F;acquaintance a year, that has dealt with some form of cancer. Most have survived; a few have not. I have one chap that just got done with the &quot;Uncle Fester&quot; routine. It looks like he&#x27;ll be OK. I know of at least three other women that are dealing with breast cancer, right now.<p>Long Island is a big fat Superfund site. It became an industrial site during WWII, and pretty much had no environmental controls. I suspect that continued for a long time, afterwards.<p>The plus side, is that we have the best cancer treatment centers in the world, here.
DantesKite大约 3 年前
I remember reading once that if humans didn’t die of old age, on average something like 99% of all people would get cancer by the time they were ~2,000 years old.
评论 #30597520 未加载
cleancasey5564大约 3 年前
I have no proof to offer, exceptthe report of a video I did watch myself. In 1974 a Dr made a study on animal protein and cancer. In mice test subject in a laboratory he found cancer cells in the mice needed animal protein as food to survive and grow. Versus plant protein as food which they did not grow. I have looked for this study to no avail. I am a vegan now. This is my only post here, as I only read. The ladies story compelled me to share whether it was received or not. I fully believe the government would never let a cure be known unless it was pills and expensive. Good luck. All cancer Dr&#x27;s put you on a high protein diet of animal flesh. Maybe not all but it is recognized as a path forward.
11235813213455大约 3 年前
I think healthy&#x2F;unhealthy is not just about &quot;very healthy diet, good fitness routine, good sleep, low stress, and no other health issues&quot;<p>It&#x27;s actually also about regularly stressing your body with things like cold&#x2F;hot exposure (using natural elements&#x2F;seasons), for example a pragmatic daily fitness (for example commuting with a bike) instead of a more &#x27;artificial&#x27; fitness in a gym, an organic diet foraged yourself (with enough knowledge of course) instead of bought from shops, getting sometimes sick and recovering, reinforcing immunity
评论 #30598097 未加载
评论 #30597769 未加载
评论 #30598244 未加载
评论 #30598343 未加载
teekert大约 3 年前
One can put oneself in a low risk population by making healthy choices, but that population still has a probability of getting cancer associated with it. The risk can be inherent (you can be very healthy but with brca mutations a women will have something like an 85% probability of having breast cancer by age 45 I believe). You may also live near a gen-x dumping factory and not be aware of it, and then there is just the dumb bad luck of having errors during DNA replication and subsequently in the DNA repair mechanisms.
Aulig大约 3 年前
I looked into this revently, from what I can tell, no study could show a reduction in deaths from doing mammograms. This is because they detect many cancers that would go away on their own thus unnecessarily exposing you to chemotherapy which brings other health risks. A good starting point on this topic is this video: <a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;youtu.be&#x2F;_sg14En-Z7A" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;youtu.be&#x2F;_sg14En-Z7A</a> (I was doubtful at first, but everything he says is backed up by studies)
rishikeshs大约 3 年前
Does anyone have any insights on the importance of fasting or excessive calorie intake?<p>I think I read somewhere that we are not supposed to eat this much and should feel the hunger.<p>Can this be a reason?
评论 #30672163 未加载
评论 #30599423 未加载
nojs大约 3 年前
&gt; I have been getting a full-body health check-up done regularly for many years.<p>I’m curious how this works in other countries, because in mine doctors don’t really do “full body checkups”. You’d might get a few specific tests if you knew what to ask for, but doctors really do not do any kind of regular comprehensive exams sufficient to detect early cancer like this. If you insisted, you’re likely to just be treated like a hypochondriac unfortunately.
评论 #30599059 未加载
Borrible大约 3 年前
Whatever healthy living for a young Indian middle class woman may be, breast cancer is correlated to multiple factors to varying degrees. But a lot of those women suffering from breast cancer have to die because it is still underdiagnosed in India. And that has probably more to do with culture, social characteristics, and the socioeconomics of India.<p>What always amazes me is the surprise of people who think that they can never get hit, because they have done everything &#x27;right&#x27;.<p>Just like people who don&#x27;t realize how lucky they were to have been born in a certain place at a certain time.<p><a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;onlinelibrary.wiley.com&#x2F;doi&#x2F;10.1111&#x2F;ajco.12661" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;onlinelibrary.wiley.com&#x2F;doi&#x2F;10.1111&#x2F;ajco.12661</a><p><a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.firstpost.com&#x2F;health&#x2F;breast-cancer-in-india-is-underdiagnosed-people-dont-know-what-to-look-for-8913911.html" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.firstpost.com&#x2F;health&#x2F;breast-cancer-in-india-is-u...</a><p><a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.webmd.com&#x2F;cancer&#x2F;guide&#x2F;cancer-incidence-age" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.webmd.com&#x2F;cancer&#x2F;guide&#x2F;cancer-incidence-age</a>
IG_Semmelweiss大约 3 年前
Seems relecant to put here.<p>Intermittent fasting has been proven to significantly lower the risk of breast cancer in particular. There was a landmark study less than 2 years ago that hit the top page of HN.<p>&quot;Intermittent fasting once a week for 4 seeks cuts risk of breast cancer by ~40% &quot;<p>The jury is still deliberating whether it also lowers the risk of other forms of cancer.<p>Hopefullt it does!
评论 #30598834 未加载
评论 #30597987 未加载
nikolay大约 3 年前
&quot;Healthiest&quot; is very subjective. For example, people still believe low-fat diets are healthier and that saturated fats are evil and PUFAs are not (although people like Ray Peat call them &quot;toxic at any dosage&quot;). Excessive exercise is another proof that toxicity is all about the dose - because a sedentary lifestyle is possibly unhealthy, people wrongly conclude that working the hell out is any better.<p>Also, the environment does a huge toll - you can have the healthiest lifestyle in Los Angeles, but you still inhale one of the most polluted air. Also, you drive a new car, which intoxicates you, and reverses your lifestyle efforts manyfold!<p>Many consider eating kale to be healthy... and they drink kale juice, eat raw kale, not realizing how goitrogenic kale actually is.<p>So, when I hear &quot;I live a healthy lifestyle&quot;, I really interpret it usually as &quot;I suffer from orthorexia&quot;.
Decabytes大约 3 年前
I work in the healthcare sector and the good news is that the standard of care amongst cancer patients continues to go up. There is a lot of time, money, and brain power that goes into this every year. It&#x27;s one of the few things that people around me agree is terrible no matter your background&#x2F;political affiliation and I am excited to see its advancements in the years to come.<p>That said, some people do get unlucky and get it early, but that doesn&#x27;t mean you shouldn&#x27;t take care of yourself. Living a healthier lifestyle reduces your risk not just of cancer, but other health concerns as well, and also improves your recovery times when you do get sick. But make no mistake, even if humans lived 1000 years and had no other illnesses, Cancer could still happen. Just the free radicals in the oxygen you breath is enough given enough time
rstoj大约 3 年前
Early-onset breast cancer is most likely genetic, so the only thing that could&#x27;ve been done is to catch it earlier by having enhanced monitoring.<p>Hopefully we&#x27;ll learn more about the underlying genetics and have better risk assessment tests in the future to catch these earlier.
dsign大约 3 年前
I have read a lot of comments about reducing risks, which is a reasonable and practical approach. But given than almost all of us are going to die of one health condition or another, I think it is reasonable to budget and architect our society around&#x2F;against that fact. Like, having a medical research tax apart from ordinary income tax, and of course with different accounting and governance.<p>And it is not about funding healthcare (which is what politicians talk about in their speeches), but about funding medical research, which is a different matter altogether. A country can have universal healthcare and zero medical research, for example. Then again, I think that this distinction would be lost on most people.
rayzmundo26大约 3 年前
Whats the heathy diet she refers to? Sugar intake? Carb intake ?<p>She seems in physically great shape but has this been attained by eating food all day, not giving the body time to rest. Would time restricted eating have helped?<p>All bodies are different, but having tried various diets over the years , fasting or time restricted eating seems to give me the best benefits, I look at lot younger than my age(45).<p>I see a lot of long distance athletes in my own country(Ireland) the same age as myself that look aged, is this because of the copious amounts of high carb food that they eat to sustain their energy. Also have seen a lot of cases of heart attacks recently in these so called fit people. Sorry a bit blunt there
mdtrooper大约 3 年前
But there are a lot reasons (it is bad news but it is the science):<p>- you are living in a country (or place in your country) with enviroment that it increases the % cancer. I don&#x27;t talk about the human or no-natural things, I am talking about the natural things such as radon gas from granite...<p>- some cancers are from a tiny bug in the code our DNA (sometimes the code bug is from a infection of virus)<p>And at the moment you can check all the things (the science are working to find or clear more of them...but it is the far future or near) that they begins a cancer.
irjustin大约 3 年前
From a personal perspective, I feel that opening sentence.<p>Genetics has had me have high blood pressure since I was 25, left handed, prostate, lung cancer in family.<p>I put effort into low salt diets, exercise, monitoring, some small drugs, yet I know a lot of people who are significantly less healthy will outlive me. From time to time - I feel the pang of bitterness at that notion.<p>It is 100% recognized, my overall disposition in life is _extremely_ privileged. It&#x27;s still a feeling nonetheless.
评论 #30597788 未加载
评论 #30597931 未加载
acconrad大约 3 年前
That sucks but I wouldn&#x27;t beat myself up over a diagnosis over something like that. It&#x27;s largely genetic.<p>My dad is a Vietnam vet in his 70s who drinks, smokes, and has way too much coffee. And he&#x27;s fought 2 tours in Vietnam, 3 bouts of cancer, and a whole other host of issues.<p>Some people can&#x27;t be killed. Others get cancer in their 20s. You do the best that you can and try not to beat yourself up if you get an unlucky draw.
heyhihello大约 3 年前
Seeing this and “Regrets of the Dying” both on the front-page definitely adds cause for some reflection in life at the moment.
biglebowski大约 3 年前
Cancer is not a taboo in India, why would it be? I have lived in 6 different states of India and have heard&#x2F;seen relatives&#x2F;friends&#x2F;people openly talk about having breast cancer, lung cancer, having cancer treatments etc. I really don&#x27;t understand why she repeatedly mentions that in her, otherwise, insightful post.
antman大约 3 年前
Does anyone here looked into what checkups need to do yearly? I looked around, and each doctor seems to give different advice
评论 #30597522 未加载
评论 #30598729 未加载
tartoran大约 3 年前
I feel that currently I pull the lucky health lottery ticket on a constant basis since I am healthy but cannot afford a health insurrance in the US. Every time I hear of a cancer story I am horrified and reminded of how lucky I am but aware that my luck could run out at any moment. And how many of us there are…
RappingBoomer大约 3 年前
genetics and random chance are huge factors
micromacrofoot大约 3 年前
It&#x27;s all about risk, and a lot of risk factors are still somewhat unknown. I think about cancer like rolling dice, we all roll by the nature of existing.<p>A smoker might be rolling a 6-sided die with cancer on one side.<p>An athlete is still rolling a die with cancer on one side, but it&#x27;s more likely a 100-sided die.
james4k大约 3 年前
There is so much we&#x27;re still learning about what &quot;healthy&quot; even means, like dairy consumption seemingly being a high risk factor for a number of diseases. Breast cancer, diabetes, Parkinson&#x27;s, to just name those I&#x27;m aware of. Not a doctor.
xupybd大约 3 年前
I had a mole removed yesterday. It was picked up in my yearly mole map.<p>It&#x27;s cost me thousands over the years if you add it all up but it might have just saved my life.<p>If like me, you live near the ozone hole get a mole map. It could save your life.
frontman1988大约 3 年前
&gt; As cliché as it may sound, health really is wealth. All the money in the world can’t buy you perfect health<p>Sometimes I feel mortality and health issues are a good reality check for the super rich who think their money can buy everything in the capitalist world.<p>Cancer is often random, just like how it was random that she married a guy who went on to become a billionaire. You can&#x27;t have everything in life.
评论 #30598090 未加载
mjmj大约 3 年前
Would be curious if she did genetic testing and was BRCA or BRCA2. That increase your odds of all cause cancers quite a bit. You can live a seemly pristine lifestyle and your genetics will still get you.
bacro大约 3 年前
Could this be the case where she was not as healthy as she thought? I mean, we do not know if there was some vitamin &#x2F; mineral deficiency or the diet for that matter that she was following exactly.
rags2riches大约 3 年前
People do all sorts of things to &quot;be healthy&quot;. That&#x27;s great, if they are doing it to have a better life. But I get the impression some are doing it in an attempt to overcome death.
评论 #30597677 未加载
siwatanejo大约 3 年前
Link failing because of some TLS&#x2F;SSL issue on my side.
评论 #30597342 未加载
max_大约 3 年前
&gt; Today, cancer is curable, unless it is too late before it is spotted.<p>How valid is this? And what exactly is &quot;spotting it early&quot;? Stage one?
jack_pp大约 3 年前
I eat healthy because when I don&#x27;t, I feel like shit. not because I&#x27;m afraid I&#x27;ll get sick if I don&#x27;t eat healthy.
评论 #30598873 未加载
irpapakons大约 3 年前
One thing I was shocked to realise is that breast cancer affects 1 in 7 (14%) of women worldwide. That&#x27;s so high.
midjji大约 3 年前
Not your fault, most cancers, and in particular breastcancer are entirely unaffected by all forms of healthy living.
personjerry大约 3 年前
It&#x27;s like poker. You can play optimally and still lose. You&#x27;re just maximizing the odds in your favour.
lambda_dn大约 3 年前
I know plenty of people who smoked&#x2F;drank alcohol frequently (not alcoholic), never exercised and ate a &quot;bad diet&quot; and lived to 70&#x2F;80 and others who &quot;lived a healthy lifestyle&quot; who dropped dead&#x2F;died &lt; 70.<p>I think genetics&#x2F;randomness&#x2F;accidents&#x2F;homicide&#x2F;genocide&#x2F;suicide etc are 95% the cause of mortality. Drugs&#x2F;booze&#x2F;smoking&#x2F;obesity are much smaller than people think.
rudecomment大约 3 年前
Got to die of something, no matter how healthy you think you are in life.
simpthrown8id大约 3 年前
I sympothize with the poster but the headline is potentially misleading.<p>I don&#x27;t think the article really qualifies her status as a healthy lifestyle individual. I&#x27;m sure she may think she leads a very healthy lifestyle but there are a lot of misconceptions out there, when it comes to health. What exacerbates it is, once people learn that some things are not healthy, they switch to alternatives without understanding that the alternatives their going to are just as bad.<p>I know I&#x27;m going to get downvoted severly for what I&#x27;m going to post, but the truth must come out. These are all things which people generally believe are healthy but there is ample evidence out there and talk to nutritionistal scientists and they&#x27;ll tell you, the following are not necessarily healthy:<p>- eating dairy and meat (both of these can be quite carcinogenic, lots of research proves this) - even fat free dairy, even fat free meat -&gt; check out the china study, it&#x27;s quite comprehensive and enlightening, study the blue zones<p>- excercising, running more than 20 miles per week is actually detrimental to your health (surprising i know)<p>- eating more than 2 meals a day<p>- the list of foods that market themselves as healthy but are not, is extremely long: certain cereals, to granola bars, etc<p>- non dairy creamers - sorry, but these things are loaded with partially hydrogenated oils, aka trans fats. trans fats are so bad, they&#x27;ve been made illegal but companies can get away with putting them in products by printing 0g of trans fat on the label becuase they&#x27;re allowed to round down from 0.5g to 0. You might not think that&#x27;s a big deal but they make the serving size super small, so 0.5 easily becomes 1 to 2g. even 2g of trans fat is enough to make a health difference.<p>- high protein diet can speed up MTOR production, IGF-1 levels and increase cancer risk. research has shown it&#x27;s only the over 65 yr crowd that really need high protein diets for good health because their IGF-1 levels are already to low.<p>- Oils are NOT good for you, EVEEEN if their canola oil, extra virgin olive oil. All those mediterarean diets that show better health outcomes, do so &quot;inspite of olive oil&quot;, not because of it. Scientists have observed the impact of olive oil up close, and they will tell you, you&#x27;re endothelial cells which line your arteries do NOT like Olive oil or any other kind of oil running through your system.<p>- Not to mention, most people vastly underestimate their junk food intake because it&#x27;s density is so much greater. I mean, if you eat 1&#x2F;4 of your plate with cookies, your diet isn&#x27;t 25% junk. it&#x27;s actually more like 90% because cookies 12 times more calorie dense than vegetables and fruits.<p>- A salad with ranch dressing on it, you&#x27;d think would be healthy but look: the 2 TBS of ranch are 240 cals and the salad is like 20 cals, so your meal is mostly just oil and sugar. And yes, it&#x27;s the calorie which is the unit of account: nutrition researchers use it, and your stomach uses it to determine your fullness (satiety is yet another completely misunderstood concept )<p>- It is VERY EASY to underestimate the amount of saturated fat you&#x27;re consuming. The WHO recommends no more than 5% of your diet from Saturated fats which is about 11g. it&#x27;s not commonly known but super provable from the USDA&#x27;s own database, that saturated fats are present even in healthy foods but it&#x27;s the right amount. even, in your rolled oats, and your spinach and your veggies there&#x27;s some saturated fat, but it&#x27;s not much. but you&#x27;re already getting 5g a day just from the super healthy foods, so it&#x27;s very easy to go over that 11g limit.
评论 #30601684 未加载
trockbort大约 3 年前
It&#x27;s weird everybody&#x27;s on the PFAS-bad train but nobody wants to touch that fluoride itself is being injected into the water supply and being drunk by millions of people daily for their entire lives, &quot;for their health&quot;.
sunjester大约 3 年前
Can&#x27;t the Cancer cells be activated by just about anything?
loudtieblahblah大约 3 年前
She must&#x27;ve listened to the pro-PUFA crowd on Hacker News.
barrenko大约 3 年前
No description of lifestyle or diet before cancer in the text.
评论 #30597791 未加载
评论 #30597562 未加载
aosmith大约 3 年前
You&#x27;re not alone, good luck you got this!
headsoup大约 3 年前
She doesn&#x27;t actually say what she did to be healthy in the first place. That would help understand or perhaps point out areas of caution.
uwagar大约 3 年前
meat eaters seem to get cancer more
kashif大约 3 年前
seed oil and sugar are big contributors - haven&#x27;t met anyone who avoids both
emrahcom大约 3 年前
Jason Fung, The Cancer Code
S_A_P大约 3 年前
I’m 45 and I’m just now half way through my last chemo treatment for colon cancer. I would not say I’m you for cancer but definitely on the younger end of the spectrum for this type of cancer. I probably wouldn’t have gotten the colonoscopy that found the cancer had I not been lucky enough for the cancer to cause an infection where gut bacteria passed through my colon and made me extremely sick. I treated that with antibiotics and got a colonoscopy.<p>Results were that it was stage 3 c as I had 4 lymph nodes affected. The first step was surgery and about 12”&#x2F;30cm of my colon was removed right where it meets the small intestine. This was the most difficult surgery I have been through and happens during the delta surge last summer. That means I couldn’t have visitors for the week I was in recovery.<p>Next up was surgery for a port after 3 weeks of healing. That went in my right shoulder near my collar bone with an iv line to my jugular. Once that healed started the chemo…<p>I didn’t take to chemo very well at first and I had a severe reaction to one of the drugs and landed in the hospital again for a few days. They could not figure out what was really happening but I basically had severe chest pain and jaw pain. They suspected heart&#x2F;cardio problems and did a cardiac cath which came back normal thankfully. The fix was to reduce the dose of that particular drug by half. As time wore on the other drug in the cocktail started causing neuropathy in my fingers, feet and teeth&#x2F;gums. Picture your finger tips always asleep. That can last for up 2 years but in some cases is permanent.<p>Now that I’m on the other side of the diagnosis and treatment I still have the post treatment scan. Typically colon cancer makes its was up to the lungs and brain if left unchecked. I get that scan mid April. To me that is the scariest part. I think it would be a huge gut punch to find out that it spread even after surgery and chemo.<p>As for life post treatment there are adjustments I have had to make: While I used to like spicy food my colon has decided that spice is a laxative now and usually sends me to the restroom within 2 hours. I have to plan my coffee intake with meetings. I have some days when things seem normal and the others when I’m going to the rest room 4-6 times per day.<p>In my 30s I was in marathon shape until I severely broke my foot at 38. I have slowly gotten out of shape since. I think this was a bit of a lifestyle reminder for me so the plan is get back in shape and check my diet.<p>I have quit alcohol for treatment so I’m going on about 9 months with no drinking. I don’t know if I will continue abstaining or not. I am certain that had I not had that infection I wouldn’t have gotten a colonoscopy. I think that’s the takeaway for me. Get your colons checked folks. Age 40 is the new recommendation my doc has mentioned.
draw_down大约 3 年前
Maybe our ideas about what “health” is need some work.
评论 #30597659 未加载
评论 #30597794 未加载
ComradePhil大约 3 年前
Here&#x27;s an alternate explanation:<p>Maybe cancer is way to common and keeps being formed in the human body... but also the body gets rid of it by itself. This is why most people who have cancer never find out about it.<p>The few people who are always going for &quot;regular screenings&quot; are the only ones who find out about it and get &quot;treatment&quot; when it was completely unnecessary.<p>Here&#x27;s another alternate explanation:<p>Maybe what is marketed as &quot;healthy&quot; by the food industry by funding scientific research and selecting results favorable to them is not really healthy.
评论 #30599708 未加载
评论 #30598058 未加载
raffraffraff大约 3 年前
Doesn&#x27;t work?
seeekr大约 3 年前
As far as I can tell, cancer comes from worrying and mostly constant tension in your body.
评论 #30597982 未加载
评论 #30598728 未加载
dschuetz大约 3 年前
&quot;I am the healthiest person I know&quot; so others might disagree? Such self-centered perception of &quot;being healthy&quot; is one of the reasons people fool themselves while actually having a healthy <i>lifestyle</i> instead of being actually healthy. Any exercise also has an impact on health, it can be not just &quot;healthy&quot; but also unhealthy at the same time, at the expense of overall health. Also, cancer does not discriminate lifestyles. It&#x27;s chance. There is always risk. &quot;I am healthy&quot;-people only fool themselves that it cannot happen to them.
mise_en_place大约 3 年前
It was the same for my father, and even the doctor’s mother whom I regularly see. I wonder if these issues are caused by the immune system becoming lax over time.<p>For example, I know one of the treatments for arthritis is Humira, a monoclonal antibody that suppresses TNF-A (tumor necrosis alpha). It could be the immune system suppresses TNF and this causes the perfect environment for cancers to remain latent.<p>There should be markers for a “pre-cancer” chronic condition. In multiple myeloma (what my father had) there is a clinical definition of “smoldering” myeloma which I understand to be a pre-cancerous condition. There ought to be more of those