TE
科技回声
首页24小时热榜最新最佳问答展示工作
GitHubTwitter
首页

科技回声

基于 Next.js 构建的科技新闻平台,提供全球科技新闻和讨论内容。

GitHubTwitter

首页

首页最新最佳问答展示工作

资源链接

HackerNews API原版 HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 科技回声. 版权所有。

Ask HN: Anyone having issues with job applicant fraud?

257 点作者 lgsilver超过 2 年前
In the past month we've seen a dramatic, seemingly coordinated, increase in engineering applicants whose resumés and backgrounds appear qualified, but who refuse to use their cameras during Zoom interviews and who often can't answer specific questions about their backgrounds. We've wasted a significant amount of time on comms and interviews with over a dozen of these candidates. Anyone else experiencing anything similar?

65 条评论

iaaan超过 2 年前
Earlier this year, I interviewed this guy who gave me really strange vibes. He would stall for a good 15-20 seconds after each question I asked... and then spit out a perfectly worded answer. I google&#x27;d some specific, peculiar phrases I remembered him saying after the interview and found that the phrases came straight out of places like the Kubernetes documentation, word for word. He was googling my questions and then reading the documentation aloud to me.<p>His resume said he&#x27;d worked for a company called &quot;Data Service Group&quot; (<a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;dataservicegroup.com&#x2F;" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;dataservicegroup.com&#x2F;</a>) for the last 5 years or so. Their website contains this sentence: &quot;Over the past decade, our customers succeeded by leveraging Intellectsoft&#x27;s process of building, motivating.&quot;<p>Wait... Intellectsoft isn&#x27;t the name of this company. Did these &quot;Data Service Group&quot; people steal Intellectsoft&#x27;s website?<p>Turns out, if you Google the quoted sentence above, you get TONS of websites for other fake companies that all contain that sentence:<p><a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.google.com&#x2F;search?q=%22Over+the+past+decade%2C+our+customers+succeeded+by+leveraging+Intellectsoft%27s+process+of+building%2C+motivating.%22" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.google.com&#x2F;search?q=%22Over+the+past+decade%2C+o...</a><p>I&#x27;m still not really sure what was going on with that as we politely rejected him and never heard from him again.<p>If you look up the company on LinkedIn, it appears to be made up of hundreds of immigrant DevOps engineers: <a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.linkedin.com&#x2F;company&#x2F;data-service-group&#x2F;" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.linkedin.com&#x2F;company&#x2F;data-service-group&#x2F;</a>
评论 #32672816 未加载
评论 #32673623 未加载
评论 #32673530 未加载
评论 #32670460 未加载
评论 #32670500 未加载
评论 #32670456 未加载
评论 #32671032 未加载
评论 #32669938 未加载
评论 #32671768 未加载
评论 #32670282 未加载
评论 #32669887 未加载
评论 #32675542 未加载
评论 #32672825 未加载
__d超过 2 年前
Early 2010&#x27;s, Wall St software tech vendor: I had a candidate show up for an interview, in person, go through the preliminaries and then sit down in a meeting room for the detailed questions.<p>As we got into it, the candidate often asked me to repeat the question. I was happy to do so, but after a few times, I was already taking care to speak slowly and clearly, and it was still happening a lot.<p>Then I noticed a quiet murmuring sound after I&#x27;d asked a question. It was like .. a TV on in the next room or something. I ignored it at first, assuming it was someone else in the next room, but then it seemed like it was only happening after I&#x27;d asked a question, and before the candidate answered.<p>I was now pretty suspicious, but confused: what was going on? The candidate was flubbing the interview anyway -- their understanding was pretty shallow and they didn&#x27;t appear at all confident in the material, so I wrapped up the interview, and showed them out.<p>As we were walking to the door, I stood beside them for the first time. And that&#x27;s when I saw the earpiece: the candidate had a hearing aid-like earpiece in, with a wire running into their collar.<p>I was basically too surprised to do anything, and by this point we were at the elevator, so I just let them leave.<p>The way I figured it, afterwards, was that they had someone on a radio who they thought would help them with the interview. But either the radio was noisy or they just needed more time for the answer, so asking me to repeat the question was for the benefit of their remote assistant. If they&#x27;d been better at it, even had I seen the earpiece, I&#x27;d have assumed it was just a hearing aid. Fortunately, even with the remote assistance, they didn&#x27;t pass.<p>Never happened again, but I can tell you I casually check everyone I&#x27;ve interviewed since for earpieces.
评论 #32669642 未加载
评论 #32669828 未加载
评论 #32673408 未加载
评论 #32671017 未加载
评论 #32672439 未加载
atrettel超过 2 年前
The FBI and other US federal agencies have attributed similar tactics to North Koreans looking to infiltrate particular industries [1-3].<p>[1] <a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.businessinsider.com&#x2F;north-korean-crypto-job-candidates-scammers-recruiters-2022-5" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.businessinsider.com&#x2F;north-korean-crypto-job-cand...</a><p>[2] <a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.theregister.com&#x2F;2022&#x2F;05&#x2F;17&#x2F;fbi_korea_freelancers&#x2F;" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.theregister.com&#x2F;2022&#x2F;05&#x2F;17&#x2F;fbi_korea_freelancers...</a><p>[3] <a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.wired.com&#x2F;story&#x2F;north-korean-it-scammer-alert&#x2F;" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.wired.com&#x2F;story&#x2F;north-korean-it-scammer-alert&#x2F;</a>
评论 #32671040 未加载
评论 #32669144 未加载
评论 #32676909 未加载
评论 #32672154 未加载
bb88超过 2 年前
It&#x27;s a problem here too. Even if they use their camera, it doesn&#x27;t mean they don&#x27;t have someone feeding them answers to questions. Phone interviews are even more sketchy since the person who may be answering the questions is a completely different person who shows up on day 1.<p>We had one person we hired as a contractor, but then her voice changed on the phone, and started calling people by their last names in chat. It looked like it was someone that subcontracted another who then quit, and the first was trying to hold onto the contract as long as possible.<p>Another answered complex questions during the interview, but after the start they knew nothing.<p>A third contractor I knew was trying to do two jobs at the same time. Unfortunately while he was supposed to be working for one company he was making public github commits for the second. He was shown the door that day.<p>Tangentially, another contractor &quot;lost&quot; two macbooks assigned to him. Apparently right after travelling to Colorado after they legalized weed.
评论 #32669245 未加载
评论 #32669173 未加载
评论 #32671200 未加载
评论 #32671304 未加载
ericol超过 2 年前
Some time ago (~6 months) my company was looking to hire a programmer.<p>We don&#x27;t have a established process for this as it was some years since we hired a coder, but then we are in the industry (hiring) so published a couple of adverts here and there and we got the thing rolling.<p>Most of the applicants were seriously under qualified, and my colleagues had to go through a lot of rubbish in the form of CVs in order to find suitable candidates.<p>But a few of them were good enough to at least make it to the interview step, and off the invitations went.<p>One of&#x27;em candidates - Let&#x27;s call him &quot;Rajeed&quot; - promptly accepted the meeting, and due to the small amount of people that made it that far - let me remind you, first interview - my colleagues were slightly excited, but at the same time also weary as our experience with coders from India is far from stellar.<p>You can imagine my colleagues surprise when they opened the Zoom session and Rajeed was nowhere to be found. Instead, there were two person of whom we knew nothing about - apparently they were running some sort of coding shop - and when my colleagues asked for Rajeed they just said &quot;Oh, it&#x27;s OK, it&#x27;s OK. You can talk to us.&quot;<p>For obvious reasons the meeting didn&#x27;t last long.<p>We ended up hiring a coder from Poland that, even thought he was decent, was miles ahead of the rest of the candidates.
评论 #32672667 未加载
评论 #32671500 未加载
plebianRube超过 2 年前
Yes. In a fairly large public company I worked at, I remember a DBA on contract got fired because he knew absolutely nothing.<p>But only a few weeks later he was back, in the same building, but using a different name on a different floor working as a Senior Software Architect.<p>He got caught because someone in the DB department recognized him, called him by his old name and they pretended they never new him.
评论 #32669582 未加载
评论 #32669881 未加载
评论 #32669930 未加载
评论 #32669779 未加载
kube-system超过 2 年前
About 5 years ago at a previous company we had someone who interviewed well, and then the person who showed up was totally not the same quality person we had talked to previously. I guess the placement strategy at some low quality placement agencies is to just put someone good on the interview and hope the hiring company doesn&#x27;t notice.<p>I haven&#x27;t seen it recently, but I am now in a position where we have good recruiters who filter people before I ever see them.
评论 #32669254 未加载
xupybd超过 2 年前
Ug... as someone that one day would like to work remote this is infuriating.<p>Anyone who is doing this, you&#x27;re destroying trust and making life hard for the rest of us.
评论 #32674097 未加载
评论 #32670471 未加载
评论 #32669302 未加载
评论 #32669010 未加载
jamestimmins超过 2 年前
Once worked at a 3rd party coding interview company as an interviewer, and we had a bunch of grad students from a college who were all clearly cheating. They solved the problem from the top of the page down (rather than organically, as someone would when doing actual programming) in a very specific way.<p>The company didn&#x27;t want to disqualify those candidates, since we couldn&#x27;t prove cheating, but it was pretty fascinating to witness.
评论 #32669267 未加载
评论 #32669237 未加载
评论 #32669038 未加载
snapetom超过 2 年前
Yes. I just had an odd Interview a couple of weeks ago. We were looking for a contractor and interviewed someone. The location he gave was the middle of nowhere, British Columbia.<p>Turns out though, I don’t live that far away from there. I can see his window was full of heavy, dark clouds. However, there was a heat wave going on and there wasn’t a cloud for hundreds of miles.<p>“Huh. Odd that we’re so close, it’s almost 90 down here and it look like it’s about to pour rain up where you are…” I said.
评论 #32672861 未加载
评论 #32669548 未加载
b800h超过 2 年前
Interesting that this has increased recently from the perspective of OP, but it has always been the case, and it&#x27;s an annoying timesink.<p>My favourite example of this was a interviewee for a post working on Oracle data warehouses. A colleague ran the guy&#x27;s CV under my nose before the interview - it was strange - it kept on changing tense, and contained a bit too much random technical information about Oracle&#x27;s tooling.<p>I Googled a random phrase, and discovered that 50% of the CV was directly lifted from the Oracle manual for their ETL and DW product.<p>The point is that despite being comically bad, he&#x27;ll have interviewed somewhere else, got the job thanks to a clueless hiring manager, and have spent three months learning the product before getting canned (optimistically).<p>The last time I saw a boom in this behaviour was in 2007.
评论 #32672765 未加载
s1k3s超过 2 年前
Ask HN: Anyone having issues with job description fraud?<p>The job market is a market. Nobody owes you anything. In most job fields the buyer has the leverage over the seller so the buyers will go out of their way to press that leverage (low pay, low benefits, impossible demands etc). It just happens that in a few fields the seller has the advantage so they&#x27;re doing the same thing to you. My point is you have to accept it and move on, because things like this happen all the time and won&#x27;t ever stop.
评论 #32674270 未加载
评论 #32673970 未加载
评论 #32675807 未加载
Spooky23超过 2 年前
It used to happen alot with contract bodyshops, even in person.<p>Usually you’d get weird looking resumes from someone based out of New Jersey or Arizona. In most cases the employees were Indian and would phone screen well. When the person landed, usually they were green staff who would basically send their work back to a more senior person or team who would do the work elsewhere overnight.<p>With remote, there’s definitely more fraud in this space, from people lying about where they are, stealing information and just grifting.
patrakov超过 2 年前
One of my clients (where screening CVs was one of my duties) had a different kind of fraud.<p>On a particular week, we received a lot of CVs for a DevOps position. They shared a few common characteristics: were sent through Indeed, allegedly from Indians who emigrated to the USA, talked about skills and duties but not achievements, and were longer than one would normally write. Additionally, they used too-low-level phrases that one would never use in the CVs, like, e.g. when describing their experience with Ansible, &quot;use the &#x27;file&#x27; module to copy files to and from remote systems&quot;. I.e. phrases that would appear in a course curriculum, but not in a proper CV.<p>The final red flag for me was a phrase repeated word for word in two CVs allegedly from different people.<p>I don&#x27;t really know how to react properly to this, in order to avoid lawsuits for rejecting candidates based on nationality and other kinds of discrimination (ans I was specifically instructed about discrimination-based lawsuits as a very real risk, something that happened before). So I just told about the problem to the head of HR, marked all CVs received through Indeed on that week as highly suspect (even those that a casual reader would mark as OK), and let him deal with it. I don&#x27;t know what exactly he did.
评论 #32676048 未加载
paxys超过 2 年前
This is exactly why the technical interview process is what it is. No point wasting time asking about backgrounds and describing past projects (all of it can be easily faked). Make them write code in front of you live as part of the screening round.
评论 #32672896 未加载
评论 #32669000 未加载
评论 #32668950 未加载
评论 #32673373 未加载
评论 #32669398 未加载
评论 #32669622 未加载
jmcgough超过 2 年前
Someone I know hired an experienced programmer from Indian who interviewed well. When his first day started, he seemed extremely junior - needed basic things explained to him like command line usage. One of the people who interviewed him saw him on camera and told the EM he was pretty sure it was a different guy. The EM confronted him and he admitted it, so they let him go.<p>Makes me wonder what % of the time this actually works and no one is willing to fire them, or if it&#x27;s just worth the salary of collecting a month of pay before you&#x27;re found out.
评论 #32669629 未加载
SkipperCat超过 2 年前
One thing that is really fascinating after reading many of the comments here is how hard people try to leap over the fence into the job-world of tech. Sure, if you have the experience or education, it&#x27;s not that hard. But if you never had the opportunity to learn it or work it, a tech job may as far away as Elysium.<p>Conversely, anyone with a laptop and an Internet connection can learn most tech topics. With the right amount of self study, personal project work and focus, you can acquire the skills needed to land an entry level job and then work your way up.<p>Maybe it just boils down to the fact that there are always people who try to short cut the path to senior dev salaries.
评论 #32677096 未加载
atdrummond超过 2 年前
We had an issue with a candidate who was attempting to use our access to processing networks to facilitate financial crime. It was a coordinated state actor tactic.<p>Happy to share more info with founders over email or IM; I don’t want to publicly draw the ire of those who attempted this.
评论 #32669349 未加载
评论 #32669773 未加载
giobox超过 2 年前
Not only have I seen this several times, I&#x27;ve also encountered multiple instances of &quot;over-employed&quot; software engineers, who are doing 2-3 full time salaried positions from home, at the same time. This is surprisingly easy to get away with unnoticed in the US tax system, as you get a separate W2 from each employer. It&#x27;s genuinely a lot more difficult to do this in some other countries. There&#x27;s even this service now offered to let employers try to catch this:<p>&gt; <a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;theworknumber.com&#x2F;" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;theworknumber.com&#x2F;</a>
评论 #32670092 未加载
评论 #32670563 未加载
nprateem超过 2 年前
Just give them a simple screening coding challenge like copying a file to s3, then if their code looks OK ask them to justify their decisions, eg error handling, testing, etc. Tell them not to spend more than 1 hour on it. Google won&#x27;t help much.<p>I&#x27;ve had people use IDEs to auto create empty test cases, hard code file paths etc. No point wasting time on an interview and anyone competent will smash it.
评论 #32675300 未加载
askafriend超过 2 年前
Simple - just auto-reject anyone who refuses to use a camera or answer specifics.
评论 #32669045 未加载
评论 #32674594 未加载
geoffbp超过 2 年前
Yes we’re having problems along those lines. We don’t proceed with interviews unless video is available<p>- Multiple candidates with the same resume<p>- Resume doesn’t include full name, location or LinkedIn<p>- Candidate blatantly lies during interview<p>- Candidate is observed copying answers from the web, unable to explain how it works<p>- Language barrier issues<p>- Candidate applying for a senior role can’t solve simple problem<p>- Job hopping every 6 months or 1 year
评论 #32671423 未加载
pmccarren超过 2 年前
Shameless plug - I&#x27;ve been building the startup Wedge[0]. In addition to helping prevent application fraud, I deeply believe applicants are _people_ and have more to share beyond a resume.<p>We enable companies to asynchronously collect a short series of video responses from an applicant either at application time or later in the process.<p>[0]<a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.wedgehr.com&#x2F;product" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.wedgehr.com&#x2F;product</a>
评论 #32675231 未加载
Consultant32452超过 2 年前
I worked at a BigCo for 5 years. 3&#x2F;4 of our department was offshore and we generally did not interview them. It was more like our offshore vendor filled seats when they were empty and we would occasionally fire them.<p>One of the offshore folks was amazing so we offered him an on-shore position and moved him here. He told us insane horror stories about how the offshore team worked. Basically 1-2 people did all the work for everyone to turn in. The managers were in on it and sometimes were one of the few competent people who did the work. As he described it, it was corruption from top to bottom. We were paying for 10-15 workers but really getting 1-3.
clcaev超过 2 年前
I had an unsolicited email offer to pay $5k upfront cash to use my github profile to solicit and perform work, plus monthly percentage of their earnings. I presumed it was spam, but they had done significant research as they knew the projects I participated in, and so on.
评论 #32672744 未加载
评论 #32669646 未加载
评论 #32671584 未加载
edgyquant超过 2 年前
I was hired as the engineering lead earlier this year at a company. It was packed full of “senior” engineers who wrote nested loops, each screen was a monolithic program with no abstractions etc. as I let them go we hired two more (we have a consultant that hired me and has been interviewing them) who were the exact same. Senior engineer, 15 years experience, etc.<p>Yes all of them appear to work a couple hours of day and I’d wager they get 3-4 jobs and work a few hours a day on each
评论 #32670061 未加载
macksd超过 2 年前
Curious where the candidates are being sourced from - my hunch is that whatever source they&#x27;re coming from is suddenly being exploited by such people for some reason. I&#x27;ve seen a general increase over the last 1-2 years (so, post-COVID) of candidates who exhibit similar behavior, but it hasn&#x27;t been the majority of the candidates. I&#x27;ve just chalked it up to remote work being more normal and some people actually being able to get away with this for some time: Googling their way into a few months of employment before being found out for good.
remote_phone超过 2 年前
My friend has personally interviewed 3 people in the last 2 months who were lip synching answers. One was a woman who was trying to lip sync to a man’s voice. It’s really insane what’s going on right now.
rexreed超过 2 年前
The increase in remote jobs, remote interviewing, automated interviewing, and use of AI systems for interviewing is directly correlated with people gaming the system. There really is very little good substitute for in-person interviewing. Or at least if you are committed to a fully remote experience, then you&#x27;ll have to accept a greater likelihood of fraud, deception, and misbehavior as part of the tradeoff between in-person and remote and manage those expectations.
ivanvanderbyl超过 2 年前
Every part of this rings true. We interviewed a guy for a front-end position, on his resume he mentioned react and svelte with 3 years of experience with both and was open for contact work. We exchanged a few emails and set up a call. Then it got weird.<p>On his resume his name was Daniel, but when he joined the zoom call he introduced himself as Andrew. Moreover the photo on his LinkedIn was of Asian appearance but this guy had a very White American accent. I asked him to turn his video on and he fumbled around for a bit and then said his camera was broken, so giving him the benefit of the doubt I jumped into asking him about his experience with svelte. He asked asked me what svelte was, I thought that was weird given it was one of the buzzwords on his resume, but 20 seconds later he all of a sudden knew what svelte was.<p>I reminded him that in our email exchange he said he had worked with svelte for 3 years and I&#x27;d like to hear more about what he had built. He told me, and no joke, he had worked in the same office as some guys who had used svelte.
评论 #32678682 未加载
strongpigeon超过 2 年前
Slightly tangential, but I wonder how long before you have people using deepfakes to look and sound like someone else on camera to perpetrate this kind of fraud. It seems like all of the pieces are mostly there.
评论 #32669305 未加载
评论 #32669071 未加载
评论 #32672756 未加载
mouzogu超过 2 年前
&gt; We&#x27;ve wasted a significant amount of time on comms and interviews with over a dozen of these candidates.<p>this is what happens when you filter people based on keywords. they game the system.
评论 #32677962 未加载
philipkglass超过 2 年前
I have been involved in hiring for years. I saw this happen for the first time a month ago. It makes me wonder if some Discord&#x2F;Slack&#x2F;Telegram group has recently been organized around this dubious &quot;life hack&quot; strategy.
评论 #32669379 未加载
评论 #32673334 未加载
pkrotich超过 2 年前
Perhaps in-person interview requirement would help eliminate such fake candidates? But I know it&#x27;s not very practical in the remote work age and maybe it explains why you&#x27;re seeing drastic increase.<p>While not as bad as fake candidates, professional interviewers who interview really well but cannot deliver a lick on the job are also very problematic. Once hired someome who sounded perfect for the role (even in person) - relocated him - but months into the job they couldn&#x27;t deliver.<p>That said, I just hired someone without meeting them in person (just Zoom call) and they&#x27;re pretty good thus far! I guess you just have to be lucky.
erdos4d超过 2 年前
This sounds like what I wanted to do once I realized how insanely easy remote work was. I do my wife&#x27;s code for her dev job and it honestly works out to like 2 hours a week for me. She spends maybe 10 hours in meetings, so it totally makes sense to put 3 or 4 front people in positions to handle the meetings and just funnel the work back to me. Sounds like they are doing a bait and switch strategy though. You should just give them a coding test and see if they actually have a senior dev behind these guys. If so, quit pestering the front person who takes your order and be happy with the finished product.
评论 #32736511 未加载
评论 #32671000 未加载
i_like_robots超过 2 年前
Yes.<p>Prior to my current company I think I&#x27;d only met two candidates face-to-face who had sent misleading CVs (one of whom memorably tried to tell me MooTools was a new Linux based operating system.)<p>But so far this year I&#x27;ve cut short half a dozen interviews once it became clear the candidate was hopeless, despite having good CVs. In some cases they seemed to struggle to even to use their own computer.<p>And in the last 12 months we&#x27;ve also cut ties with somebody who joined during lockdown after it became clear that they&#x27;d falsified details of their background and experience.
levi_n超过 2 年前
Anecdotal datapoint to add to the heap: a friend had someone show up to their first day of 100% remote work who was decidedly NOT the person that they interviewed. Obviously that was also their last day.
badrabbit超过 2 年前
For engineering, screen them with a verbal technical questionaire over zoom with camera before the actual interview. This would replace the &quot;phone screen&quot;.
评论 #32682130 未加载
dcarr178超过 2 年前
I run software engineering for a 100% remote company with ~35 developers on 5 continents. In April 2022 I interviewed a senior Python developer from Austin Texas - camera on, full pair-programming exercise, etc. 3 interviews, the guy was awesome. We hired him and assigned him to a development team. A month later I hear from the team that the guy sucks, doesn&#x27;t know how to program, thick accent, and says his camera is broken even though we just shipped him a brand new machine. We set up a sting operation, forced him to present&#x2F;share his screen over zoom, and recorded the call. It was some random person in India connecting via a VPN in Dallas to mask the origin of his network calls. In the screenshare recording you could see him quickly switch to a chat window and ask someone else how to answer the question. We fired him and only lost 1 month of salary + a very nice laptop we&#x27;ll never see again. I learned a valuable management lesson from that one. I bet at a larger company this guy could have flown under the radar for a lot longer than 1 month.
s1k3s超过 2 年前
I&#x27;m not saying this isn&#x27;t happening, but I want to mention that I often refuse to do stuff that my interviewers ask me to. Reasons being any of: I consider it useless for the evaluation, I consider it doesn&#x27;t correctly asses my expertise, I consider it would put me in a bad situation etc. Of course, I can do all this because the market allows me to do it.
评论 #32669125 未加载
评论 #32669108 未加载
fsckboy超过 2 年前
It seems like good interview questions (for all candidates) could be &quot;how should we stop interview and employment fraud, what are your ideas?&quot; You want candidates who are clever at analyzing a new problem, and it puts the issue on the table in a cooperative way.
评论 #32672650 未加载
giantg2超过 2 年前
We had third party recruiters sit&#x2F;listen in on interviews with their clients. Those recruiters would then use that knowledge to feed answers to the next candidate, usually during the interview.
评论 #32682178 未加载
sys_64738超过 2 年前
Once had a Ph.D. who wasn&#x27;t until somebody checked up and referred the issue to HR who did the background check. This was using an old-school in person interviewing method.
评论 #32669150 未加载
dijondreams超过 2 年前
Yup am seeing this weekly now when hiring. Pretty sure these are just companies who are employing cheap foreign labor and acquiring higher paying American jobs. Wage arbitrage?
somehnacct3757超过 2 年前
I had someone interview for a job and then a different person showed up to orientation. Locked their accounts immediately and nobody show up the next day. Fired.<p>When does this work?
dom96超过 2 年前
You hear these stories so much but what I don&#x27;t get is how these people get past the HireRight checks, do the companies this happens to just not use HireRight?
tomt00001超过 2 年前
I&#x27;m in the situation of apply for jobs and feels like I&#x27;m screened out of everything because my resume doesn&#x27;t have exact matches for every buzzword. I don&#x27;t really want to buzzword pad but kind of feels like I need to do that.<p>I got 25 years of varied experience(network admin, server admin, cloud stuff, scripting, etl and actual development) and now feels like being a jack of all trades is screwing me :)
robtani超过 2 年前
I know this is going to be controversial comment and I&#x27;m sad to say it... But quite frankly, I can safely say that just about every Indian developer that applied to my jobs and made it passed the initial filters STILL turned out to be a scammer of sorts. Either fake skills background listed; they must be getting away with it at least to some degree if I&#x27;m coming across it at this scale!!
neilv超过 2 年前
This sounds like fraud, and possibly organized crime.<p>I don&#x27;t know whether an AG&#x27;s office would be interested in hearing about it, but you could try calling.
ByersReason超过 2 年前
Yes, I had a candidate turn up for a physical interview who clearly was not the person on the phone screen.
b20000超过 2 年前
i thought leetcode interviews was all you needed, and, screw senior people with actual experience?
评论 #32672700 未加载
t_mann超过 2 年前
I&#x27;ve always wondered how those recruiting studies where they send out a lot of fake resumes that differ only on one attribute play out for the other side. That was my first thought, but your experience might also be something different.
tillcarlos超过 2 年前
I had a candidate like this. 7 years of Ruby, but didn’t know keyword parameters.<p>On the CV there were some companies with dubious consulting websites, super generic. I emailed them, no reply.<p>If I wouldn’t have given him a live coding test I wouldn’t have known.
Aperocky超过 2 年前
You guys conduct interviews without even seeing the face of candidates?
mv4超过 2 年前
I screened a candidate last month who insisted on keeping the camera off. Gave perfectly worded answers. Several things were off, e.g. not knowing certain industry acronyms etc.
Madmallard超过 2 年前
How many of these are candidates trying to game the interview into a remote dev position to sell the work to high experience cheap remote labor options in 3rd world countries?
bubblethink超过 2 年前
There was a darknet diaries episode about something like this. Can&#x27;t remember what the conclusion was (something about NK espionage ?).
donsupreme超过 2 年前
what exactly is the endgame?
评论 #32668814 未加载
评论 #32668809 未加载
评论 #32668958 未加载
评论 #32668960 未加载
评论 #32669030 未加载
hankchinaski超过 2 年前
I have also experienced the same with recruiters and companies. Who should I be appealing to?
Kinnard超过 2 年前
Don&#x27;t hire remotely. Fly them out. Like a pre-COVID YC Interview.
评论 #32670919 未加载
boltzmann-brain超过 2 年前
Let me give you a perspective of why people might legitimately not want to do camera during interviews.<p>A little about me: I&#x27;ve started doing remote work 15 years ago - long, long before the modern remote push. I&#x27;ve been coding for 30 years; I started with 8 bit micros; I can probably work with any technology and any deep problem you throw at me; I&#x27;ve led and launched projects worth billions of dollars. I prefer to work remotely because I hate commuting and open plan.<p>I&#x27;ve started denying camera interviews for a while now. I still do voice, but no camera, for the following reasons:<p>1. It impacts not just my earnings, but whether I&#x27;ll be considered in the first place. There&#x27;s a lot of sexism and racism happening in tech.<p>Sexism: if you&#x27;re presenting as female, or presenting as male but don&#x27;t look like Jim Halpert from the office, you can get looked at differently, which happened to me. This applies to people who are older, people who have visible tattoos or piercings, people who have blue hair, scars, etc.<p>Racism: you only need to look at other replies here with people talking about how bad eg Indian developers are. This extends to people of other skin color as well. In Europe there is a huge amount of racism against white Europeans from eastern Europe and from the Balkans and Europeans from Latin countries; in Asia there is racism against people ethnically from other Asian countries; in America there&#x27;s racism against pretty much everyone; etc. This is endemic. One look at someone&#x27;s face can be enough to disqualify them at a company that has this problem.<p>Ageism doesn&#x27;t even need to be explained.<p>Based on the three points above, by demanding camera interviews you betray yourself as a company which doesn&#x27;t have the issue of systemic bias against minorities figured out yet.<p>Incidental information leaks: The background - the location where you are - is important as well. Is the person located in their bedroom with a single bed? Probably a flat share, pay them less, they&#x27;ll take it. Are they in their garden? Hmm, they are probably worth what they ask for. Is it dark outside whereas it&#x27;s light where you are? Uh oh, remote work with someone who&#x27;s not in your time zone! Better start worrying!<p>Especially the last one is egregious. Dev work is mostly solitary, asynchronous work; most of the time there&#x27;s a lot of overlap even between eastern Europe and west coast US which is plenty of time for meetings and pair programming if necessary. People who insist on such things are usually inexperienced with remote work. Misconceptions like these destroy opportunities that can work out very well otherwise. I&#x27;ve had people make comments about &quot;oh it&#x27;s light out over there&quot; many times in my career and it&#x27;s always lead to a no-hire.<p>2. Issues that remote work solves can be brought to light in an ugly manner. For example, maybe the person feels they are not attractive, and are just generally shy around people in person - something that a lot of technical people share; their performance in front of a camera will be worse. Being shy when physically around other people perfectly fine for remote work. Maybe the person has special needs. Maybe they have to use an oxygen tank, or are missing an eye, or teeth, or a hand, or are sitting in a wheel chair, or are obese. Maybe the tapestry on their wall falling off and they haven&#x27;t had money to fix it due to an economic downturn or because someone in the family had cancer so that&#x27;s where the money went. None of this is stuff that the employer needs to know - but they are things that none the less can impact the recruitment and later career by a lot.<p>3. I experience fewer of the issues brought up in 1 and 2 than most others; however, I still deny camera interviews to see what will happen. Being this worried about job applicant fraud betrays that you likely can&#x27;t afford it. Job applicant fraud is a little time off your hands and a little money as well. That fraudulent applicant wasted maybe 3 hours through interviews across people in your company, and maybe up to $10k wasted money. If you can&#x27;t factor this into your business, it means to me - an experienced developer who has plenty of choice - that you can&#x27;t afford me at all, and that working for you, should it happen, will be precarious. I&#x27;ll probably skip over you. It is my experience that the most resilient companies - and ones that are well established already - absolutely don&#x27;t care about seeing your face on camera.<p>Additional wasted time after the hire is mostly on your hands: either it&#x27;s a complete bait and switch (smart person interviewed, substituted by someone unsuited) - and that&#x27;s something you figure out on the first day - or it&#x27;s someone who&#x27;s never been good enough, and you weren&#x27;t a good enough interviewer to figure this out in the several hours you&#x27;ve spent with them; at that point you&#x27;ll probably take a few weeks to figure out that they&#x27;re not great at their job, but that&#x27;s on you.<p>--------<p>TLDR: a camera interview is purely a disadvantage to minorities and people who aren&#x27;t well off by leaking things that are for good reason illegal to ask about; a job interview where this is demanded or implied betrays the company is standing on a shaky foundation.
评论 #32680501 未加载
评论 #32678336 未加载
throwaway787544超过 2 年前
Been happening for a decade, it ebbs and flows.
durnygbur超过 2 年前
You look for a fraud in every real human professional directly applying, so that now all you&#x27;re left with are real frauds. Sorry, not sorry.
samstave超过 2 年前
I may have just experienced identity theft by an indian company claming to hire me.<p>I am convinced of it now.
评论 #32670187 未加载
exnot超过 2 年前
I&#x27;ve had plenty of issues with job ad fraud. My last three jobs have been completely oversold and misdescribed in the ads and interviews. I think it&#x27;s only fair that applicants retaliate with the same ammunition.